Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there's a stigma over having a third child?

282 replies

Beachloveramy · 30/10/2021 03:20

Please tell me I'm not alone.

I already have a 14 year old I had quite young and a three year old (with my husband) and I'm 3 months pregnant with our third child.

As I've slowly told people about the pregnancy I've received a lot of comments such as "you're pregnant again?!"

Now, I don't exactly feel as if I've been popping them out, there are fairly big age gaps between my children. Myself and my husband do also both work full time and support our own family but for some reason I can't be completely excited about this baby as there seems to be a stigma associated.

I'm I being paranoid or are woman judged for having more than two children?

OP posts:
ShepherdMoons · 30/10/2021 07:33

I know a lot of friends with three or more children! I haven’t come across a stigma. I just feel total admiration for anyone with three or four children! I have one and it’s bloody hard work!

THOSEcobwebsareDECOR · 30/10/2021 07:33

I think 3 is still considered 'normal' We have 6. I noticed a difference in peoples reactions from 4 onwards. But really i couldn't give a shit.

DukeofEarlGrey · 30/10/2021 07:27

@tiggerwhocamefortea

Ah the environmentally sanctimonious who base being childfree decisions around environmental concerns - they ought to ponder who exactly it will be paying for their pensions one day 🤔
I’m not childfree for this reason (I would love to have a child) but either way am planning to pay for my own retirement. In the meantime, I pay higher rate tax that contributes to state schooling and many other services that benefit children. And am very happy to do so as part of a community.
carpetbugs · 30/10/2021 07:27

We should plan for an aging population and cope with the tax shortfall of the future in whatever way we can (taxing business properly would go a bloody long way towards this) rather than try and have more kids, because at the rate we're going the planet will be screwed before those kids reach retirement anyway. Once again, we're sacrificing our kids' future to ensure our own comfort.

We aren't having enough kids though in the west, & not enough is being done to manage the ageing population. That scares me more tbh.

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/apr/20/britain-falling-birthrate-covid-pandemic-conservatives-removed-support-for-parents

DukeofEarlGrey · 30/10/2021 07:23

I don’t judge people for the number of children they have but the link between population growth and climate change is pretty unequivocal. It’s a different point from the economic one and not mitigated by things like ‘better opportunities for women’. Climate change eclipses these things as an imperative so we shouldn’t in any way diminish the discussion about it.

There’s more info here about the population growth factor:

populationmatters.org/climate-change

ParmigianoReggiano · 30/10/2021 07:23

@tiggerwhocamefortea

Ah the environmentally sanctimonious who base being childfree decisions around environmental concerns - they ought to ponder who exactly it will be paying for their pensions one day 🤔
No one will be - chances are there won't be a state pension by then!
ThirdElephant · 30/10/2021 07:12

I feel like the 'oh, the environment thing doesn't matter because of the overall fertility rate in the West' comment kind of misses the point.

  1. A child born in a developed country like the UK will have a larger environmental footprint than one born elsewhere.
  2. We don't actually, as a planet, want to increase or even maintain the number of people living in countries like ours. Economically we do, but tbh the problem is that we're continually and consistently putting money ahead of the health of the planet. Needing future taxpayers in the mid-term is not enough of a reason to increase pressure on the planet in the long term by having more kids. We should plan for an aging population and cope with the tax shortfall of the future in whatever way we can (taxing business properly would go a bloody long way towards this) rather than try and have more kids, because at the rate we're going the planet will be screwed before those kids reach retirement anyway. Once again, we're sacrificing our kids' future to ensure our own comfort.
eurochick · 30/10/2021 07:12

Call it environmental sanctimony if you want but it is true that having (any) children is the worst thing you can do environmentally. Many people feel that replacing themselves is justifiable but adding to the global tally of overpopulation is not.

Pottedpalm · 30/10/2021 07:07

I don’t judge people with three, four or more children, if they can afford to care for them. I’m not particularly interested. I have friends with no children up to six children.

tiggerwhocamefortea · 30/10/2021 07:04

Ah the environmentally sanctimonious who base being childfree decisions around environmental concerns - they ought to ponder who exactly it will be paying for their pensions one day 🤔

Santastuckincustoms · 30/10/2021 07:03

The only thing I think, as a mum of a very demanding 2 yo, is why would you want to go back there again! But fair enough if you enjoy the punishment Wink

carpetbugs · 30/10/2021 07:03

Unless and until China, India, Australia et al start seriously amending their behaviours, and we ALL make day to day adjustments, whether I have 1 or 10 children really isn't going to change the trajectory.....

And China introduced a 3 child policy

SunshineCake1 · 30/10/2021 07:03

There no stigma.

WTF475878237NC · 30/10/2021 07:02

People are a lot more aware of overpopulation and climate change now.

I think it's this too. Globally we're over populated and more people see the effects of this now.

carpetbugs · 30/10/2021 07:01

@BarbaraofSeville wasn't that poster comparing herself to people with dc not those without?

Panicmode1 · 30/10/2021 07:01

I wasn't judging the childfree (if you read my post, I referenced those with fewer children driving 4x4s and flying regularly, neither of which we do).

I'm aware 4 is environmentally damaging but we do all we can to minimise as much as possible.

Unless and until China, India, Australia et al start seriously amending their behaviours, and we ALL make day to day adjustments, whether I have 1 or 10 children really isn't going to change the trajectory.....

carpetbugs · 30/10/2021 07:00

@Goatinthegarden if one is concerned about the they’re the ones that are going to have to live in the mess we’ve made for them point I don't understand why you would have any at all.

Many women aren't having dc hence why the birth rate is so low so having a 3rd in the UK is not that a big a deal. People are living longer hence why we have an ageing population. This is actually something the government need to address & start planning for, the new health tax will not cut it.

Pleatherandlace · 30/10/2021 06:56

Ignore the environmental argument nonsense. Birth rate in the uk is 1.6 replacement level is 2.1. So we’re way below that. Also carbon consumption is wealth dependent not population size dependent. Also for all those people handwringing about the “state of the world” you are bringing children into never before have we had higher rates of literacy, vaccinations, life expectancy, wealth etc etc and Lower levels of violence, increased opportunities for women . There has literally never been a better time to be born than now.

BarbaraofSeville · 30/10/2021 06:51

Completely agree with the environmental sanctimony mentioned upthread. We walk everywhere we can, almost never fly as a family, recycle, hand down clothes etc. I think that as a family we are far less environmentally damaging than friends of mine with 1 or 2 children who fly abroad 3 or 4 times a year, drive large 4x4s etc. Populations in the West are declining, not replacing themselves

Newsflash, you're wrong. Having even one child is far more environmentally damaging than all the other things you mention.

Once you've had DC, you're so far ahead of the child free on environmental impact that you're a massive hypocrite for judging the child free for flying, driving, eating meat etc however often they do it.

www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/jul/12/want-to-fight-climate-change-have-fewer-children

Goatinthegarden · 30/10/2021 06:47

@blanketg

In the UK with the declining birth rate I don't personally think having 3 is that big a deal as many aren't having any.
One of the reasons (admittedly, not the only one) I’ve chosen to not have children is because of the environmental impact.

I’m not a saint when it comes to every choice I make regarding the environment, and I don’t begrudge anyone the right to have children. It seems a bit flippant to not at least consider the impact a third child might have on the planet though - they’re the ones that are going to have to live in the mess we’ve made for them.

speakout · 30/10/2021 06:46

I think it's the age gap.
If your kids were 5 and 2 I think you may get a different reaction.
Most people have children quite close together- having a 15 year old and a baby would not be a choice for everyone.
Potentially one child starting universityy while the youngest hasn't even started school.
It draws out the caring role of a parent- let's face it the mother over a very very long time.
Many wouldn't want that.

carpetbugs · 30/10/2021 06:45

The UK birth rate is 1.6 so we actually do need those immigrants that people hate.

polkadotclip · 30/10/2021 06:45

@Ericaequites

Three children is harder than two. Not many cars will hold three child seats unless you buy a people mover. Most holidays are set up for two adults and two children. It can be hard to give all your children individual time. If you and your husband each have a favorite, it can be hard when the third child feels left out. If you have three close together, childcare costs can make it economically difficult for both parents to work. I see more disadvantages than advantages, but am a third child much younger than the other two.
Most of the comments on here are predictable, but this one is flabbergasting.

Who has favourite children?

tiggerwhocamefortea · 30/10/2021 06:44

Countries need a birth rate of 2.1 to sustain population but in Europe the rate is as low as 1.59

According to the UN 2/3 of countries in Europe have introduced measures to increase fertility rates

If they aren't concerned at the highest level about how many children we should have I don't see why I should be - especially when I can pay for them without relaying on any form of benefits. Let them get on with restricting our lightbulbs and making us drive electric cars and leave my uterus alone

carpetbugs · 30/10/2021 06:43

Also might seem a bit strange to people given what we know now about the lives children born now are going to have

Surely this applies to all children though?