Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shocked at how terrible the NHS is nowadays

342 replies

ConfusedBoobs · 29/10/2021 19:13

I had a mammogram a month ago that showed I have calcifications that they don't think are cancer but they won't know for sure until after I've had a biopsy. Today I found out that the biopsy can't be prioritised as urgent and so will still be another month away. AIBU to think it's terrible to leave people in limbo like this?

OP posts:
MamsellMarie · 30/10/2021 07:42

I really don't think people should wait for what could be a diagnosis of cancer, however unlikely it might be, the mental stress is terrible, it's not easy carrying on as normal with the thought that you could be in for debilitating treatment with long term consequences or a much shortened lifespan, and how that plays out for your loved ones.

Don't mean to be hysterical but it's all very well to say 'you'll be fine' when in fact the OP doesn't know that and nor does ayone else.

I think the Gov can't do anything aabout the mess the nhs is in without screams of panic about privatising the NHS when privatising to an insurance system is actually the way to go but we can't get to that because of screaming headlines and the Tories risking losing most of their seats due to the hysteria (there was similar over the 'dementia' tax). Nothing is going to improve until the parties unite to come up wiht a solution.

Drinkyourweaklemondrink · 30/10/2021 07:25

I am so sorry you are going through this at the moment. It's not acceptable. They are blaming it all on covid but I personally have been on the NHS waiting list for endometriosis surgery since February 2019

Thewiseoneincognito · 30/10/2021 07:23

Whilst the option does seem logical, not everyone can afford Private, why should they have to when we already pay for the NHS with our taxes and NI? As others have said the worse this situation gets (and it will due to Covid) the more it plays into the hands of those who wish to ultimately Privatise the system.

I hope you get some resolution soon OP, I truly do.

Pixxie7 · 30/10/2021 07:18

The nhs is in a crisis at the moment it has been abused for years through people’s unrealistic expectations. If people thought more about how they use it rather than expecting it to solve all their problems. I am sorry you are going through this but there are people far worse off.

Knownbyanothername · 30/10/2021 07:17

A quick google tells me there are around 250 vacancies in Scotland alone for NHS managers- most of those jobs offering a salary of 40-60k. That’s plus an employer contribution to a pension of around 14% each year. No doubt England will be similar
This is taxpayers money. Are people still happy for more money to ploughed in without reform?
And yes I know NHS Scotland is different from England but both are failing.

Superfoodie123 · 30/10/2021 07:10

I've had to go private as I dont want to live my life in sickness and NHS has let me down for years. A lot of people come to its defence but I honestly feel scared when my self or a family member needs its care. Such a shame.

Knownbyanothername · 30/10/2021 06:53

The NHS employs 1.4million people! That is a massive percentage of the working population of the uk. It’s not just underfunded but horribly inefficient. There are multiple layers of middle management which are simply not needed. Just throwing more money at it is not the solution- it needs a complete overhaul.
Something has to be done about the GP system. This business of telephone appointments before being seen is a waste of everyone’s time because you end up using 2 appointment slots for each case needing seen, one for the call and one to actually be seen. How is that an efficient way of working? Massive overhaul is needed.

notanothertakeaway · 30/10/2021 06:47

Sorry for those who have had bad experiences

I recently went to the GP for a non urgent issue. I had two appointnents, and some hospital tests and the test results back, all within a week. I couldn't have asked for better

Starfish1021 · 30/10/2021 06:29

I do hope those that voted for the Tories are all getting what they voted for.

This with bells on

Gwlondon · 30/10/2021 06:26

To be honest there is always waiting. We always had rationed healthcare it’s just we are noticing it at the moment.

I don’t believe the tories want to destroy the NHS - why would they? Doesn’t make sense as they will need it. It might be they are younger and don’t have as many reasons to use it yet. Cameron knew about the NHS because of his son yet he still got vilified.

I had a bad experience in June with a phone consultation with a locum GP. Went for a smear recently, the nurse doing my smear ordered me another blood test that was missing, booked me in with a healthcare assistant and the GP. Between the 3 of them they made up for the bad experience a few months ago. It’s the sort of condition that should have been face to face through the pandemic but wasn’t. But I think that’s the problem sometimes the nhs is too reliant on staff doing extra to cover for colleagues who don’t do enough.

Hang in there OP.

knitnerd90 · 30/10/2021 06:20

Yes, the UK needs to pay more and it's needed to pay more for decades. That's precisely the issue. But turning everything into NHS vs. USA has obscured that debate for a long time. The NHS does not compare favourably for outcomes for many cancers.

I'd never advocate American style fees; as well as the cost the way they are done is very confusing. The UK has a higher proportion of healthcare costs paid via public sector than almost any other country, but the amounts (known as cost sharing) vary quite widely between countries. For example someone mentioned that in France a visit to a GP costs about 25€. That's what the health insurance allows as a normal fee. They pay 70% of that. You can pay the rest out of pocket, or you can take out supplementary insurance. If your income is below a certain amount, you receive what's called the CMU, which pays 100% of the normal fee. Some doctors choose to charge more than the scheduled fee, and you pay the gap between the normal fee and theirs--or some supplemental plans may pay it. For a whole host of chronic conditions, public insurance pays 70% (the French system is quite complicated).

Insurance doesn't necessarily mean a system like BUPA or the old American system (nowadays you can't be rejected for health reasons). In some countries everyone has to purchase insurance; it is subsidized and regulated, and everyone is accepted. The Netherlands does this, and Switzerland.

Meanwhile, Canadians are always shocked that in Britain you can jump the queue by paying, which is very limited in Canada (and to do it you have to give up being able to bill the province: no dual practices). But their system does not cover prescriptions or various things like outpatient physiotherapy.

itsgettingwierd · 30/10/2021 06:16

I got referred to gynae under urgent in April.

The consultant triaged it as routine.

Urgent was a 3 months wait and routine 38 weeks!

I spoke to GP who expedited it. They said when they see patients and deal with them under primary care for years and then decide it's urgent that's because it is!

I saw them this week after 6 months wait.

Booked in for hysterectomy/ I have no idea how long I'll wait for that! I'm scared to ask!

newstart1234 · 30/10/2021 05:53

The danish government pay the bill for the private provider - it’s totally free for the patient.

newstart1234 · 30/10/2021 05:52

Someone said the UK has the only free at the point of use system which is simply not true. Denmark has a free system for gps. But the gp gives a referral you then go to find a private provider that you like. Apart from some services like maternity which is like UK. Really inefficient compared to the UK nhs. You also pay for your prescriptions full price, again inefficient from financial perspective. The nhs has buying power that benefits us all. You pay higher taxes but I’ve never known a ‘waiting list’ for gp or other service. You just make an appointment at your convenience. Cancer survival rates are very good because of early diagnosis (which also is good for the purse strings).

The difference is people take responsibility because of cultural factors and don’t abuse the system like the nhs. Public health is excellent at preventing illness only possible because the government also takes responsibility seriously.

I think the nhs is the best system possible but it needs more money and responsible government and public.

Wingingthis · 30/10/2021 05:27

I’m so sorry. I’m in a similar position where I’ve been told my 18mo dd could have various non cancerous tumours snd have been waiting 2 weeks so far and not even got an appointment date 😔

NadiaVulvokov · 30/10/2021 05:21

Few years back I was three month wait for biopsy, three month wait for result. Thankfully it was negative but if it hadn’t been, the cancer is at least six months further on before you start treatment.

I agree the NHS is being thrown under the bus to pave the way for privatisation.

I also think there could be better ways to organise things, life example integrated centres where you self refer, the mammogram is looked at right away and then any further investigations (e.g. ultrasound/biopsy) are done right away amd you get the results immediately. It’s how it’s done in Iceland:
American woman in Iceland finds breast lump

Andwander · 30/10/2021 05:09

Go private,if you can.The NHS is kaputt,broken.I dont expect to ever see a GP ever again.I am thinking of getting private insurance.All the best for you,it must be so stressful time for you.

MintJulia · 30/10/2021 02:10

I'm sorry you're in that situation. It's horrid and stressful while you are waiting.

I don't know where you are OP but I was recalled for a biopsy on Sept 2nd, seen on Sept 3rd, results on Sept 16th and op on the 29th. They were brilliant.

Maybe they are seeing more worrying cases first. It sounds like it. Take some comfort from that.

I hope it all goes ok xx

onlychildhamster · 30/10/2021 02:01

@NCForthisxox my grandma is Singaporean, and she got a stroke. She had health insurance (my dad paid for her for years) but her month long stay in the hospital still cost us the equivalent of £5000 after insurance and all the subsidies. Its cheaper than America and maybe she would have gotten more subsidies if we didn't live in private housing (as subsidies are means-tested based on the type of housing you live in and your household income) but most singaporeans would expect to pay thousands out of pocket if they have a health condition; but we are lucky its not tens of thousands. There is a medical savings account that you have to make mandatory contributions to and mandatory insurance and also the government would pay for the truly poor people, but healthcare is something most Singaporeans budget for in a way that is alien to Britons.

@bunanarama it is very quick, my dad had an abscess operation and they arranged an operation on the same day (this was in a public hospital). My abscess operation on the NHS took 4 days despite being prioritized as 'urgent' and this was in 2017. I had 3 aunts and uncles who recovered from cancer using the public health system (including an aunt who was stage 3) so it is definitely fit for purpose

@julieca but 60% of Singaporeans don't pay any tax? It is friendly to rich people cos top rate of income tax is only 20% but at the same time, the middle class also don't pay tax. The Singapore government derives most of its income through sale of land (owns 90%) as land in Singapore is extremely expensive given the scarcity of land. 85% of Singaporeans also purchase their apartments from the government (92% home ownership rate) so there is a steady stream of income there. Most small countries wind up as tax havens because we need to attract foreign investment and the population is small enough that the government can afford to fund public services without charging high taxes.

Dhcfisssifjrsnxfjds · 30/10/2021 01:51

[quote julieca]@Dhcfisssifjrsnxfjds I and my family have been getting appointments and surgery. And you use private healthcare. What the hell do you know about using the NHS!!![/quote]
Why do you assume I don’t use the NHS? The waiting times have been utterly disgraceful.

Dhcfisssifjrsnxfjds · 30/10/2021 01:48

[quote Changechangychange]@Dhcfisssifjrsnxfjds why do you think the NHS is failing? Do you think the French system might also “fail” if its funding was halved? Would the Canadian system “fail” if its funding was cut to 25% of current spending? What would the German system be like with 1/3 of the doctors?

I personally don’t care how healthcare is funded. I’ve worked in both systems, they both have advantages and disadvantages (there are some very perverse incentives in the Canadian system due to the billing system).

No system will work if it is starved of funds, and chronically understaffed. Look at the number of ICU beds we have in the UK compared with other EU countries. Look how many specialists. That is the problem, not the specifics of how money is redistributed from taxpayer to healthcare system.[/quote]
It is failing because it does not provide adequate care. People will not pay more so another solution must be found.

Dhcfisssifjrsnxfjds · 30/10/2021 01:42

[quote julieca]@Dhcfisssifjrsnxfjds You dont understand things at all, your ignorance is showing. Saying a co pay system means health services are less likely to be abused.
I partly care for a relative who works with serious mental health problems. It is difficult to get him to go to the Dr anyway, co pay would make it way harder. My dad like many older men wont go to the Dr with new things and needs lots of persuading. Co pay would mean he would go less.
Personally, I go to the Dr when I need to, not for every tiny thing. I also have a serious health problem. I would just go to A and E for free treatment rather than co pay.
Co paying would be about rationing healthcare to those who can easily afford it.[/quote]
Your examples are not applicable to the vast majority of people

Cameleongirl · 30/10/2021 01:41

@julieca

I am getting at the fact you pay more for your healthcare and don't get appointments because you cant afford good insurance or afford the co pay. Insurance always has co pays.
The insurance my family has in the US doesn’t have copays, it has a high deductible for any type of appointment not covered by the insurance-so annual physicals for all of us, vaccinations, an annual mammogram and gyn visit for me, gyn for DD are completely covered. Anything else comes under the deductible until we reach a certain threshold.

I’m a huge fan of the type of universal healthcare offered by the NHS ( I grew up in the UK) but I will say that I make sure I’m getting everything I’m entitled to now that I’m paying for it-we never miss our annual physicals, I’d never skip my smear test or mammogram. We also certainly don’t abuse the system, e.g., do something daft like binge drink until We pass out, because we’ll be presented with a bill afterwards!

So having lived under two different systems, I personally think that a certain amount of accountability isn’t a bad thing-but I believe in universal healthcare.

Changechangychange · 30/10/2021 01:33

@Dhcfisssifjrsnxfjds why do you think the NHS is failing? Do you think the French system might also “fail” if its funding was halved? Would the Canadian system “fail” if its funding was cut to 25% of current spending? What would the German system be like with 1/3 of the doctors?

I personally don’t care how healthcare is funded. I’ve worked in both systems, they both have advantages and disadvantages (there are some very perverse incentives in the Canadian system due to the billing system).

No system will work if it is starved of funds, and chronically understaffed. Look at the number of ICU beds we have in the UK compared with other EU countries. Look how many specialists. That is the problem, not the specifics of how money is redistributed from taxpayer to healthcare system.

julieca · 30/10/2021 01:16

And all the public health campaigns about going to the GP with blood in your poo, for smears, etc all show that plenty of people don't go to the Dr for things they should. Those campaigns are run precisely because people are not going.

Swipe left for the next trending thread