Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shocked at how terrible the NHS is nowadays

342 replies

ConfusedBoobs · 29/10/2021 19:13

I had a mammogram a month ago that showed I have calcifications that they don't think are cancer but they won't know for sure until after I've had a biopsy. Today I found out that the biopsy can't be prioritised as urgent and so will still be another month away. AIBU to think it's terrible to leave people in limbo like this?

OP posts:
dotoallasyouwouldbedoneby · 30/10/2021 18:12

YANBU but I have got used to the the NHS being so slow that a delay of a month sounds short/quick to me. Best wishes Flowers

julieca · 30/10/2021 17:45

@BigWoollyJumpers Private providers already do the easy stuff. The NHS pays them to do it. That is what makes money. The NHS does the complex stuff that is not money-making.
And no rose-tinted glasses. I have a chronic condition. I can directly compare my medical treatment under Labour and under the Conservatives. Labour was much better.

julieca · 30/10/2021 17:43

@Igfdyjxzyjkv live within their means? You may be happy to have a world where people die if they cant afford an operation or children are left with lifelong injuries because their parents cant afford treatment, but most people arent.

knitnerd90 · 30/10/2021 17:24

The thing about going private is that it solves the problem for the individual user, but it does not actually solve systemic issues when used on a larger scale: in fact, when too many people do this, it makes the NHS worse. One of the core problems in the UK is a shortage of providers. Private health care was designed for low-volume, high value services; generally, doctors see fewer patients in the same amount of time. By making private provision attractive, doctors' time and energy can be drawn away from NHS work.

Labour actually did some very good things with increasing the number of medical school places, but they still relied on attracting doctors and nurses from abroad to plug the gap. The Conservatives didn't continue this level of investment, which was already struggling to catch up with the needs of the service. What scares me is that the shortages in personnel and investment take so long to reverse and there seems to be no prospect of a proper plan to do it.

Igfdyjxzyjkv · 30/10/2021 17:20

[quote julieca]@Igfdyjxzyjkv yep blame people for not paying for the dentist. It will be the same when people have to pay for medical care.
Well its your own fault you didn't pay to go to the GP when you got blood in your poo. Not our fault you now have terminal cancer.
I can see the MN threads now.
If only they stopped paying for Netflix and Sky they could afford to go to the GP.[/quote]
Why do we need to infantilise people? Why shouldn’t people live within their means?

Igfdyjxzyjkv · 30/10/2021 16:57

@ReadtheFT

You are so right OP, GPs are useless, miscomunication between hospitals, A&E takes the piss, full of inexperienced junior doctor that cant even take blood samples from children, referrals take forever when the GP finally decides to grace you with one. The worse health system in Europe, not to mention some non european countries too. But hey, its "free" 🤔 Good for those who can afford to go private, even tho still need to pass thru dreaded GP
No need to pass through GP - most private health insurance now includes private online GP, so you can completely avoid the inefficiency of the NHS (and I consider that I am freeing up an appointment for someone who cannot afford private)
BigWoollyJumpers · 30/10/2021 16:32

Then when Labour was in the NHS gradually got better and better

No it didn't. Rose tinted glasses etc.

The NHS now treats more people, with more conditions, and with more expensive treatments than at any time in its history. It is, and will forever be a bottomless pit. It therefore needs to decide what to concentrate on. It can and does treat high risk cases, difficult cases, and cases which need lots of additional support.

It doesn't need to treat to day to day simple operations. Many Orthopaedic cases, diagnostics, could and maybe should, be farmed out to private providers. It can still be free at the point of delivery, but as with every other European system, there is nothing wrong with contracting out to private services for treatments that can be done away from, for example, a major trauma centre.

HereComesTheSun12 · 30/10/2021 14:50

Ongoing issue that could become urgent any day with the only advice being go to casualty if X happens. GP mentioned surgery as a treatment option but this is best done not as an emergency as there's less risk of complications.

julieca · 30/10/2021 14:31

@HereComesTheSun12 I am sorry to hear that.
I have waited 6 weeks to see a consultant next week and had tests in the meantime. It is not an urgent issue. I am assuming your issue is very non urgent.

HereComesTheSun12 · 30/10/2021 14:25

53 weeks to see a specialist. Now on appointment number 4 (broken equipment, staff absence, poor management) and I still haven't got a treatment plan. The NHS is awful.

Feedingthebirds1 · 30/10/2021 13:07

Look at even a small reorganisation in a private firm and how much it costs to do well? It is very expensive.

Absolutely. And I'm not arguing for a bodge job. I know how expensive it would be and how long it would take to do it properly. But in an ideal world, we would take the time and commit the money to achieve a long term solution that works for the NHS as it was created but in the 21st century.

Note the 'in an ideal world'. I know that what I posted originally is not going to happen. But if it could, think how much better things would be.

rwalker · 30/10/2021 13:05

Whilst we absolutely love to blame the tory funding in the current state you could throw money at the NHS all day long you might as well set fire to it.Waste is astronomical ask any NHS staff how much money wasted .

My friend is a rota coordinator for 2 hospitals after the lockdown they upped to consultant rate temp for 2 hour clinic to £650 from £500 to encourage the consultants to work more than 2 hours a day .
more clinics on patients getting seen.
They have now stopped the enhancement and taken it back down to £500 and they are refusing to work unless they get £650 again holding them to ransom .

Also locum doctors demanding extortion fees litteraly naming there price .
The money they are spending is eye watering

julieca · 30/10/2021 12:54

@Feedingthebirds1 I am older, I remember all the same arguments when Thatcher was in. Then when Labour was in the NHS gradually got better and better. Not perfect. But for my condition the treatment was very fast. And private health insurance numbers plummeted. There were articles about it in the press.
Starting from scratch sounds a nice idea. It would be horrendously expensive to do and would need to keep all existing staff on board and on side. Look at even a small reorganisation in a private firm and how much it costs to do well? It is very expensive. There is no way the government or taxpayers would pay for that. INstaed it would be a cheap bodge job with good pr.

ReadtheFT · 30/10/2021 12:47

You are so right OP, GPs are useless, miscomunication between hospitals, A&E takes the piss, full of inexperienced junior doctor that cant even take blood samples from children, referrals take forever when the GP finally decides to grace you with one. The worse health system in Europe, not to mention some non european countries too. But hey, its "free" 🤔
Good for those who can afford to go private, even tho still need to pass thru dreaded GP

Feedingthebirds1 · 30/10/2021 12:45

@Feedingthebirds1 yes the Tories said the exact same under Thatcher. Then when Labour got in suddenly the NHS got a lot better and the amount of people buying private health insurance plummeted.

Please will you find me the evidence for that? I am genuinely (not goadily) interested to read it and to see what was done differently.

However just because the Tories said it (and in 1979 when the Tories came in, there still wasn't anywhere near the treatments we have now) doesn't mean it's not true today. The evidence of inefficiency, of demand out stripping supply, is there for all to see. I'm definitely not a Tory apologist. Unlike the Tories I'm not shrugging my shoulders and saying 'so what can we do?'. I'm saying that we need to, as I said, go back to the first principles and design an NHS which combines the ideals of 1946 with the capability of 2021. That may include some or all of what Labour did when they were in power. But how can we find a long term solution if we don't first understand the extent of the problem?

ConfusedBoobs · 30/10/2021 12:33

And for those suggesting I go Private there are reasons I can't do that and not just for money reasons. I have quite a complex case and they would need to gather my notes/ scan results from 3 different hospitals and by the time all that is done I might as well wait for this appointment to come through.

OP posts:
DoraMaude · 30/10/2021 12:25

My personal experience has been good, even in recent months. I know thats not the same for everyone.

But we need to be paying more for healthcare, like they do in other European countries. We also need to stop the waste of resources. Prior to covid my GP practice used to list the number of missed appointments per month. It would be several hundred each month which is disgraceful.

julieca · 30/10/2021 12:24

@Feedingthebirds1 yes the Tories said the exact same under Thatcher. Then when Labour got in suddenly the NHS got a lot better and the amount of people buying private health insurance plummeted.
It is the same old Tory laws. It needs reform to allow us to give our rich friends more money.

Feedingthebirds1 · 30/10/2021 12:21

The NHS needs a complete rethink and overhaul. Following the NHS Act of 1946, and when the NHS actually came into being in 1948, things were very different to what they are now.

In 1948 penicillin was a new drug. Internal investigations were a few blood tests or an x-ray, and if you were staying in hospital you had an iron framed bed and a locker. Monitoring was taking your temperature twice a day. Because there was so relatively little on offer, hospitals were smaller and more manageable. The UK population in 1950 was 50m.

Compare that to now, when we have so many more drugs, operations, investigations, and a population of 68m. Anyone who watches hospital documentaries, or Holby, knows how much more there is to healthcare in 2021.

So for the NHS to function as we want it to, we need to go back to its first principles. If we want to have a service that provides the treatment people need, in an appropriate time frame and free at the point of delivery, and in the context of the care that is possible in the 21st century, then rather than giving it a few extra billion here and there it has to be redesigned from the ground up. And then we need to see what the cost of that service would be, and whether it is even within the bounds of possibility that it could be funded by taxation. And if not, then alternatives have to be considered.

The problem for the NHS today is that like Topsy it has growed and growed - " something that grew or increased by itself, without apparent design or intention" - and its original design may not be feasible for present circumstances.

ConfusedBoobs · 30/10/2021 12:20

Oh I do know it's not the NHS fault at all but it's the Government who has underfunded the NHS for years.

The Consultant had given me a M3 Mammogram grade which comes with about a 40% risk of cancer. I'm really unhappy that I'm left to wait when it seems so high. I understand it can't be as highly prioritised as someone with a higher risk of cancer though.

I am sorry that others have experienced such a difficult time with the NHS. I think it's such a postcode lottery and we really we need to think again about how we do things. Or what governments we elect.

OP posts:
Changechangychange · 30/10/2021 11:00

Ok - what we need is a BETTER system that is more efficient and makes sure that the vulnerable are not prevented from accessing health care because of their means. I don’t care how it is done but mindless defence of the current system is not going to get us there. In other systems that are hybrid public and private you can access primary care and get diagnostics, operations etc in reasonable clinical timeframes

And that costs more! Four times as much in the Canadian system, up to double in European countries and Australia. Which you say is unacceptable to you. You can’t have it both ways. Good, or dirt cheap, pick one.

julieca · 30/10/2021 10:51

Plus letting covid run through the population is putting strain on the NHS. We have nearly 9,000 people with covid in hospitals taking beds that in normal times would have been used by other patients.

julieca · 30/10/2021 10:50

@Igfdyjxzyjkv The two issues with the NHS are:

  1. Underfunding - it needs more money. For example women who have given birth should be in private rooms.
  2. More staff, there is a shortage of qualified medics. The only way to solve this is in the short term immigration and in long term planning and incentives for people to train in areas of shortage.

Anything else wont work. If we don't increase the number of qualified staff, we simply ration healthcare in another way. Probably through ability to pay.

julieca · 30/10/2021 10:48

[quote Changechangychange]@Igfdyjxzyjkv You said Australia had a better system and spend less on it. They don’t, they have a better system and spend more on it.

You said the NHS should be as good as private healthcare models, and yet cost less than it costs now, because people are sick of spending money on it. That is not physically possible - good healthcare is expensive.

The options are:

Better, more expensive system (whatever funding structure is used)

Status quo

Worse, cheaper system (which is what we seem to be moving towards)

Or the US system, which I think most people are clear we don’t want. We do need to ensure that isn’t brought in by stealth though - the issues with procurement contracts during the pandemic demonstrated that we have an entirely corrupt system of awarding contracts to politicians friends and donors.[/quote]
Yes all the better systems cost more.
Good healthcare costs. We are being sold a lie that we can have private insurance schemes and they wont cost more than now. Of course they will cost more. And there will be more bureaucracy and managers. It takes staff to sell and collect insurance payments and collect co pays and chase people for debts through courts.

Igfdyjxzyjkv · 30/10/2021 10:45

[quote Changechangychange]@Igfdyjxzyjkv You said Australia had a better system and spend less on it. They don’t, they have a better system and spend more on it.

You said the NHS should be as good as private healthcare models, and yet cost less than it costs now, because people are sick of spending money on it. That is not physically possible - good healthcare is expensive.

The options are:

Better, more expensive system (whatever funding structure is used)

Status quo

Worse, cheaper system (which is what we seem to be moving towards)

Or the US system, which I think most people are clear we don’t want. We do need to ensure that isn’t brought in by stealth though - the issues with procurement contracts during the pandemic demonstrated that we have an entirely corrupt system of awarding contracts to politicians friends and donors.[/quote]
Ok - what we need is a BETTER system that is more efficient and makes sure that the vulnerable are not prevented from accessing health care because of their means. I don’t care how it is done but mindless defence of the current system is not going to get us there. In other systems that are hybrid public and private you can access primary care and get diagnostics, operations etc in reasonable clinical timeframes. Here we are expected to develop serious illness before the system reacts.