Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shocked at how terrible the NHS is nowadays

342 replies

ConfusedBoobs · 29/10/2021 19:13

I had a mammogram a month ago that showed I have calcifications that they don't think are cancer but they won't know for sure until after I've had a biopsy. Today I found out that the biopsy can't be prioritised as urgent and so will still be another month away. AIBU to think it's terrible to leave people in limbo like this?

OP posts:
julieca · 31/10/2021 18:33

@knitnerd90 what our government wants is a for-profit insurance scheme.
But any insurance scheme would mean setting up a whole new layer of bureaucracy to administer it. I also don't want some people getting lesser healthcare because all they can afford is a lower standard policy.

FitAt50 · 31/10/2021 17:21

I'm a manager within the NHS and its a total mess. Too many non-clinical staff who don't actually add any value. Locums earning £100,000s more than nhs doctors. Huge long term sickness and non of it is managed properly. Really needs a massive overhall but the nhs is scared to many people and too scared to do it.

Newnamefor2021 · 31/10/2021 17:11

Sorry you're going through this OP.

Yes it's a mess.

My son is on a waiting list that we have been told Is 3 years!

I've been waiting on surgery for my hearing of 3 years now, I got to top of the list and then Covid happened. I will likely lose all my hearing before I ever see that surgery. Which is obviously terrifying.

Additionally, I've been bleeding everyday since 1st august 2020. I am waiting in surgery to investigate and ablation as I bleed so heavy some days I faint and can't get off the toilet or (on slightly better days) leave the house. I've been waiting on that urgent 13 months. I was told they don't think it's cancer but they won't know anything for sure until they actually see. But my age etc makes it unlikely.

I have no idea what the answer is. Obviously I understand that my cases are not urgent, it's unlikely I will die and other people will, so I'm not a priory, but it's still frustrating when my quality of life diminishes and you struggle daily with your health.

Wish you all the best OP. Hope you get seen soon, must be such an anxious time. I had a higher ca screen with this bleeding and waiting weeks for a scan, which was normal but an anxious wait.

knitnerd90 · 31/10/2021 16:55

Insurance based systems are not synonymous with for-profit. The German system is quite complicated, but the sickness funds are not for-profit. Germans are very very happy with their system which offers amazing choice and service.

In Israel, the basic level of services is defined by the government and paid for through the health tax. You must choose one of the 4 health funds, which are non profits. Doctors visits and hospital treatment are free. You can then pay for one of two levels of supplemental services which are priced by age. A 30 year old would pay about 50 shekel a month, or about £12.

There's all sorts of ways to run a health system. The NHS isn't the only fair way.

julieca · 31/10/2021 16:01

Except we don't pay high taxes.

dotoallasyouwouldbedoneby · 31/10/2021 16:00

@julieca

And you have to compare negligence payouts compared to a well funded system. I know there is negligence that should not happen. But I also know in the US medical insurance for Drs is very expensive due to negligence payouts. Some will happen even in the best system. So what level is standard across countries with good health systems?
The effect in the USA is that doctors over test for everything just in case they miss something and then get sued. The NHS tends to under test/wait till you have severe symptoms. There is probably a happy medium somewhere in the EU. In the USA medical professionals also have to pay out for professional insurance against claims. It is not a model I would want. The Dutch system seems to work quite well. Although I don't like their emphasis on drug-free birth. You can't really expect people to pay high taxes and then have to wait months/years for basic care in the NHS.
julieca · 31/10/2021 15:07

And you have to compare negligence payouts compared to a well funded system. I know there is negligence that should not happen. But I also know in the US medical insurance for Drs is very expensive due to negligence payouts. Some will happen even in the best system. So what level is standard across countries with good health systems?

julieca · 31/10/2021 15:01

@BigWoollyJumpers Which EU system? There are many.
I want taxation to fund an improved NHS. Insurance schemes need lots of government regulation not to disadvantage people with pre-existing conditions and spend money selling insurance and managing policies. They also generate profits for shareholders. That money could be better spent on medical treatments.
The most vulnerable people already have the poorest access to healthcare. I don't support anything that enhances that disadvantage. Healthcare should not just be for middle-class people.

We have been told for decades that privatisation solves issues with public services. We see over and over again that is not the case. There has been scandal after scandal. Group 4 and its many scandals in delivering public services. Priory group and the recent scandal of undertrained low wage staff way out of their depth with seriously mentally ill people.
I do expect that the service for middle-class people would improve under your plans and lots on MN would be happy. They don't really care about all of those who don't have the same level of power and would be in a much worse situation.

dotoallasyouwouldbedoneby · 31/10/2021 15:01

@Knownbyanothername

You’re missing the point *@julieca*. The current system isn’t working. Throwing more money at it isn’t the solution. No one is suggesting abandoning the poor but something has to change.The rich have always been able to afford private care so they would continue to do that anyway. If negligence payouts are nearly as much as the annual budget for the NHS then something is very very wrong.
I am old enough to remember that there didn't used to be negligence payouts at all; as there was something called 'Crown Immunity'; now that was scary. Removed by the Tories in 1990s I think.
Knownbyanothername · 31/10/2021 14:57

You’re missing the point @julieca. The current system isn’t working. Throwing more money at it isn’t the solution. No one is suggesting abandoning the poor but something has to change.The rich have always been able to afford private care so they would continue to do that anyway. If negligence payouts are nearly as much as the annual budget for the NHS then something is very very wrong.

BigWoollyJumpers · 31/10/2021 14:53

[quote julieca]@BigWoollyJumpers Yes I know you want co pay and private insurance with the NHS left just for the poorest. It will benefit rich people. Poor people will die younger. I know you don't care about that.[/quote]
No, I want an EU system. Are you suggesting that the EU has shit systems and leaves the poor dying in the streets? Don't be ridiculous.

julieca · 31/10/2021 14:51

@BigWoollyJumpers Yes I know you want co pay and private insurance with the NHS left just for the poorest. It will benefit rich people. Poor people will die younger. I know you don't care about that.

Knownbyanothername · 31/10/2021 14:50

I’d be happy to spend the money on a flu jab if that was what is expected of me. My point earlier was that there hasn’t been enough allocated for my age group(and that age group is entitled to a free jab). The system isn’t working.

BigWoollyJumpers · 31/10/2021 14:49

@torquewench

My friends 96 yo mum.has recently passed away in hospital (Aintree) as a result of infection caused through bedsores. How much of its hundreds of billions of pounds a year budget does the NHS throw at negligence claims?
Estimates published last year put the total cost of outstanding compensation claims at £83bn. NHS England's total budget in 2018-19 was £129bn

Almost the total annual budget Shock.

Knownbyanothername · 31/10/2021 14:46

Health expenditure per capita- check the table at the bottom. Canada does not spend 4x more than the uk

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_health_expenditure_per_capita

3luckystars · 31/10/2021 14:46

Well it’s interesting that spending £15 on a flu injection is not going down too well here, when it should be ‘free’.

BigWoollyJumpers · 31/10/2021 14:43

[quote julieca]@BigWoollyJumpers Canada pays 4x per patient on healthcare than we do. Across the EU it is double.
I work in the private sector. I can point out waste of money in the private sector as well. That happens. But you cant pay less than other countries for healthcare and expect the same outcomes.[/quote]
You have to be careful as these figures do not compare like for like. Most EU systems are part tax, part insurance, part co-pay based systems, and use private providers as well as state hospitals to provide care. The pot doesn't just come out of general taxation like it does in the UK, and they don't just use state funded hospitals. Also everyone gets a basic standard of care, but those who are more wealthy can pay extra and upgrade their care.

Yes, we need to pay more, but not necessarily exclusively through taxation, and to further accept that there will always be a two tier system for those who can afford it.

torquewench · 31/10/2021 14:25

My friends 96 yo mum.has recently passed away in hospital (Aintree) as a result of infection caused through bedsores. How much of its hundreds of billions of pounds a year budget does the NHS throw at negligence claims?

julieca · 31/10/2021 14:21

@BigWoollyJumpers Canada pays 4x per patient on healthcare than we do. Across the EU it is double.
I work in the private sector. I can point out waste of money in the private sector as well. That happens. But you cant pay less than other countries for healthcare and expect the same outcomes.

dotoallasyouwouldbedoneby · 31/10/2021 14:15

Quote RainbowbriteUK: Before the pandemic, I'd receive letters for appointments that had already passed. This happened a fair few times and then I would get referred back to my GP for 'missing' the appointment. I was very unwell.

Yes why doesn't the NHS use emails to contact patients with appointments? It would be far more efficient and cheaper; and the number of people without e-mail must be vanishingly small, so they can have a letter.

Knownbyanothername · 31/10/2021 14:14

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_care_in_Australia

And this is quite interesting

Knownbyanothername · 31/10/2021 14:07

So not fully free at point of service then…

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 31/10/2021 11:19

[quote Knownbyanothername]@julieca we are the only country in the whole world to provide free at the point of service. Does that mean all other countries have got it wrong? The NHS is not the shining beacon people think it is.[/quote]
Absolute rubbish! I am in Australia and can get a walk in free ( bulk billed) same day appointment at any time. My son was recently diagnosed with ADHD , and a treatment plan started within five days of his first appointment. Meanwhile my mum in the UK has been told she is best going private for some treatment she needs. I know which system I prefer. We do way about $100 a year for ambo service though.

BigWoollyJumpers · 31/10/2021 09:57

The NHS needs more money is a constant theme, and then you read this:

Trusts will be given a bronze, silver or gold award depending on their inclusive cultures in £220,000 taxpayer-funded Rainbow Badges project

On top of the already £500,000 over the last three years, contracted by NHSE, to Stonewall.

May I gently suggest, that although a worthy project, we have more pressing issues to spend money on?

ichundich · 31/10/2021 08:45

[quote julieca]@BananaBlue it makes no difference. What would happen though is insurance firms would cherry-pick easy patients. So middle-class healthy people probably would get quicker appointments and minor surgery and tests. Poorer people and those with complex health problems would wait longer than now.[/quote]
This is not true. Have a look at Germany, where everybody pays health insurance monthly based on their income and where health care is excellent.

@OP: I'm not a doctor, but possibly your biopsy is not considered urgent because microcalcifications can be an (early) symptom of bc, but quite often they mean other, harmless things.

www.breastcancer.org/symptoms/testing/types/mammograms/mamm_show/calcifications