Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shocked at how terrible the NHS is nowadays

342 replies

ConfusedBoobs · 29/10/2021 19:13

I had a mammogram a month ago that showed I have calcifications that they don't think are cancer but they won't know for sure until after I've had a biopsy. Today I found out that the biopsy can't be prioritised as urgent and so will still be another month away. AIBU to think it's terrible to leave people in limbo like this?

OP posts:
Igfdyjxzyjkv · 01/11/2021 11:07

So @julieca tell us what your recipe would be? How much more NI should people pay? Because it’s fine to say more money, but how much?

julieca · 01/11/2021 10:43

Also the idea that insurance stops people abusing the system is laughable. For people, having to pay £15 co-pay to visit a GP for whom £15 is nothing, they will still go at a drop of a hat with nothing.
And if you make A and E free then people will just go there instead and queue for much longer. If you don't make A and E free, then more people will die.

Bunsnbobbins · 01/11/2021 10:40

It’s breaking because those in charge of the country are breaking it on purpose so they can justify handing it over to private firms.

I’m sorry you’re going through this.

julieca · 01/11/2021 10:38

I have relatives in America who have the same illness I have. My aunt my age - late fifties, is already dead as she couldn't afford proper treatment and because of the many exclusions in available insurance policies.
The focus of the Tories is always that people are abusing services. In reality they are a tiny number. There are far more people reluctant to bother their Dr with the bit of bleeding from their bum, or who delay going to hospital until they are close to death.
I have been at a hospital clinic and seen the nurses call a Dr down for an elderly man to do an emergency admittance as he was really ill and just waited for his scheduled appointment. I have taken my DP to the GP surgery and been sent straight to hospital as an urgent case.
Your recipe will kill more people while meaning more money for well off people.

julieca · 01/11/2021 10:35

Yes its a choice not to pay for ambulance insurance. So shall I pay my heating bill or buy ambulance insurance? And my child is knocked over by a car!! No ambulance insurance. Bundle them into a car to get to hospital. I might paralyse them by moving them, but I have no choice.

These are the kind of choices insurance creates. No issue at all for the many very well off people in MN. For ordinary families though it can mean one small step away from disaster.

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 01/11/2021 10:30

@Knownbyanothername

So not fully free at point of service then…
How isn’t it? I don’t have to pay for ambo insurance, it’s a choice. Plenty of people get ambulances and never pay, it’s just a slightly different set up than the UK, and one which stops most people abusing the service. I reckon that’s a good thing, ymmv.
julieca · 01/11/2021 10:28

@Igfdyjxzyjkv No only the very poorest would receive free care. Those getting £73 a week benefits to live on. Virtually everyone would pay. And nearly all the poorest would pay more than at present either through premiums or co-pay or both. That is how insurance schemes work. The premiums would be sky high if all those who were poor didn't have to pay. It won't happen. In some areas, a quarter of people are officially in poverty. That means they struggle to pay bills and food.
You want everyone struggling as food, fuel and transport costs rise, to have an additional expense, all so that well off people pay less for better health care and some rich people make money.
It makes no sense that adding another layer of bureaucracy at minimum to sell insurance and collect co-pays and take people to court for non-payment, would be seen as efficient use of money. And probably some money going to shareholders as well. And this is supposed to be efficiency?

Igfdyjxzyjkv · 01/11/2021 10:18

@julieca

Everyone has to pay more via tax for the NHS. A percentage rise would be fair. Insurance schemes mean the better off will pay less for medical care than they do now and the poor will pay much more.The poor will be subsidising the well off who tend to have better health. Because if you have poor health or are disabled you are more likely to only manage a low paying job or part-time hours. I don't want a world where the poor subsidise the rich.
The poor would be subsidised/receive free care. People who can pay will pay and have more choice. I really can’t see what is wrong with this. The system will become more efficient and work better for everyone.
julieca · 01/11/2021 10:15

Everyone has to pay more via tax for the NHS. A percentage rise would be fair.
Insurance schemes mean the better off will pay less for medical care than they do now and the poor will pay much more.The poor will be subsidising the well off who tend to have better health. Because if you have poor health or are disabled you are more likely to only manage a low paying job or part-time hours.
I don't want a world where the poor subsidise the rich.

Igfdyjxzyjkv · 01/11/2021 10:12

@Hopeisallineed

‘This country needs to modernise not prop itself by expecting high earners to subsidise the majority.’ I don’t know where to start with this statement. 😳
You may disagree with it but these are the views of the people you would have pay more for the NHS. The people who earn higher incomes have very little tolerance for higher taxes when it would effectively cancel out their effort. If Labour is going to have a chance at any future election it needs to address this sense of unfairness.
julieca · 01/11/2021 09:58

We dont pay nearly as much as other countries for healthcare. Whether that is through taxes, or through more hidden costs such as insurance policies. In no other service would people pay a half or a quarter of other people, but expect the same service.

Hopeisallineed · 01/11/2021 09:54

‘This country needs to modernise not prop itself by expecting high earners to subsidise the majority.’
I don’t know where to start with this statement. 😳

Hopeisallineed · 01/11/2021 09:53

We don’t pay high tax in relation to many other countries ( that funnily enough have great standards of care).

TaraR2020 · 01/11/2021 09:17

@Igfdyjxzyjkv
While I don't disagree with the reality of the first part of your post, there is so much wrong with the final sentence that I don't know where to start

Igfdyjxzyjkv · 01/11/2021 08:51

If you increase taxes even more there will be a mass exodus of high earners. Brexit has killed the appeal of the UK and the pound. Those who are mobile will just get fed up with paying even more - living alongside council flats with luxury cars parked outside and sending their kids to nurseries where some are heavily subsidised affording them a better lifestyle than those who pay full fees. This country needs to modernise not prop itself by expecting high earners to subsidise the majority.

Igfdyjxzyjkv · 01/11/2021 08:47

@julieca

Except we don't pay high taxes.
Yes we do. And certainly too high for what we get.
Carriemac · 01/11/2021 08:00

The nhs is not a bottomless pit. It is an underfunded structure working on the goodwill of its staff. It needs investment and a cross party long term strategy for its management, not tweaking by every idiot health minister who can't read a brief.

oneglassandpuzzled · 01/11/2021 06:38

@ChocolateDeficitDisorder

Thank fuck I'm in Scotland and we've got a small hope keeping our NHS Tory free.

+1

Hope you’re not where my family lives—their regional hospital is appalling. Three family members have either died, had botched operations or had treatment given in error.
Yusanaim · 01/11/2021 06:21

It's 2 years for an 'urgent' hip replacement here, Scotland.

dotoallasyouwouldbedoneby · 01/11/2021 00:40

@ChocolateDeficitDisorder

Also not running perfectly in Scotland. I know someone who was told 2 year delay for gall bladder surgery, so he went private.

I'm surprised, I had my gallbladder out in Fife 3 years ago. I waited for 4 weeks after seeing the Consultant. My Mum was the year before me and had to wait 8 weeks.

I can understand things being slower now, but I've never know waiting lists for surgery to be as long that.

3 years ago was pre-covid.
ChocolateDeficitDisorder · 01/11/2021 00:17

Also not running perfectly in Scotland. I know someone who was told 2 year delay for gall bladder surgery, so he went private.

I'm surprised, I had my gallbladder out in Fife 3 years ago. I waited for 4 weeks after seeing the Consultant. My Mum was the year before me and had to wait 8 weeks.

I can understand things being slower now, but I've never know waiting lists for surgery to be as long that.

Knownbyanothername · 31/10/2021 21:56

Can you give some examples of how the corruption has directly resulted in losses to the NHS please?

julieca · 31/10/2021 20:25

@LyndaLaHughes

The NHS is falling apart because people keep voting for the Tories. If you want decent properly-funded public services- then stop voting for the people siphoning off as much public money as they can to their rich mates. When will people wake up and realise we have the most incompetent, corrupt and self-serving government in history.
THIS!! So much money has already been given by this government to their rich mates and party donors. The corruption is off the scale.
LyndaLaHughes · 31/10/2021 20:06

The NHS is falling apart because people keep voting for the Tories. If you want decent properly-funded public services- then stop voting for the people siphoning off as much public money as they can to their rich mates. When will people wake up and realise we have the most incompetent, corrupt and self-serving government in history.

julieca · 31/10/2021 18:36

I am sorry that some are having so many problems.
It is not a situation I recognise at all though. My father has had lots of tests and two operations in the last year. I have had tests and have a consultant appointment next week, all within 6 weeks for a non-urgent issue. My DP has had various tests and is waiting for a further test to see what type of operation would be best - a non-urgent medical situation. My work colleague was seen under 2 weeks cancer referral pathway and had tests, no cancer and operation to remove a cyst.