Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shocked at how terrible the NHS is nowadays

342 replies

ConfusedBoobs · 29/10/2021 19:13

I had a mammogram a month ago that showed I have calcifications that they don't think are cancer but they won't know for sure until after I've had a biopsy. Today I found out that the biopsy can't be prioritised as urgent and so will still be another month away. AIBU to think it's terrible to leave people in limbo like this?

OP posts:
julieca · 29/10/2021 23:53

Taxation is the fairest way to pay. Poor people pay less, rich people pay more.

julieca · 29/10/2021 23:53

God this really worries me.
Paying for missing appointments sounds fine in theory. For anyone with mental health issues or pre senile dementia, it is a nightmare.
Paying £25 a GP appointment is a lot if you have to go a couple of times a week. Most serious conditions here are managed through GPs. This would get very expensive for the illest patients.

Dhcfisssifjrsnxfjds · 29/10/2021 23:51

Go private - I wish there was a way to stop paying for the NHS, it is utterly useless especially for diagnostics.

MountainDweller · 29/10/2021 23:46

Every time I read a thread like this, I'm so glad I'm not in the U.K. any more. The NHS is failing it's people but it's not the fault of its staff but of a government that refuses to fund it well and public who are resistant to paying in more.

A US system is not the only alternative - there are plenty of examples in Europe that are better than the UK's - but we pay more for them. There is the Australian model, which seems like a bit of Europe and a bit of US. But yes there would be issues with rich/poor areas - where I live in France is basically a medical desert because we are on the Swiss border and HCPs earn more in Switzerland, so they work there.

The French system is really good in many areas. 70% is paid for though taxation and you can chose to pay the other 30% yourself as you go or get a top-up insurance to cover the difference. But à GP visit costs €25, so not expensive. Many medications are pennies. The cost of insurance isn't high.

The Swiss system is great, but expensive, though poorer people get help to ensure they have basic health insurance. I access it through international insurance and it's worth every penny. My DH has special cross-border insurance. Between us we pay about £10,000 a year - I'm not sure how much he would pay in the U.K.. I have had 7 surgeries there, all booked on a day of my closing, mostly within a month of the consultation (a couple within a week!). Follow-up care is amazing. Now under a wonderful pain clinic where the staff are like a second family.

DH worked in Sweden for a year and again they pay more in taxes (taxation is high anyway) but healthcare is almost free at the point of delivery - for outpatient treatment certainly everything is free after the first €100 each year.

Missed appointments have to be paid for in many countries if you cancel with less than 24 (sometimes 48) hrs notice. Things like falling ill with Covid would be an exception. It's an incentive not to waste your HCP's time.

If the U.K. switched to private, the same staff would be providing the care in à hopefully more efficient manner - but undoubtedly extra staff and hospitals would be needed too - there is no quick fix.

OP i hope you get seen soon.

julieca · 29/10/2021 23:45

And if you are not earning? So rich people? Retired people?

Prokupatuscrakedatus · 29/10/2021 23:42

As far as finances are concerned: I am employed with a lower end wage paying into the German system (employers have to match the contributions, the % are the same for all earners, insurance is compulsory so insurers have to take you)
health: 8,05 % of the pre-tax income, that covers me and my dependant DC.
care: 1,5 %
pension: 9,3%
unemployment: 2,4%

worcestersauce29 · 29/10/2021 23:39

I work in the NHS and have done for many, many years. Those talking about emergency care delays...as far as I'm aware emergency ambulances aren't available privately and if they are where would they discharge on to? The majority (if not all) of private hospitals do not have the expertise, staff nor facilities to deal with true emergencies, quick treatment privately brill but if something goes wrong? BTW I also vote blue!

Knownbyanothername · 29/10/2021 23:33

healthandcare.scot/default.asp?page=story&story=1862

Knownbyanothername · 29/10/2021 23:31

@ChocolateDeficitDisorder
I’m fully aware of that, but the Scottish government has also done a good job of privatising parts of our Scottish NHS. No one wants to talk about that because it doesn’t fit the narrative of our wonderful free health service.

teezletangler · 29/10/2021 23:30

julieca we are the only country in the whole world to provide free at the point of service.

What? This is absolutely not true.

julieca · 29/10/2021 23:30

Honestly, an insurance-based scheme would be a nightmare for me. It would be very expensive. But I would also have to do all the admin for my parents and for a relative with serious mental health problems. And there is no way my relative would go for mental health treatment if they had to pay. They would end up sectioned and losing their job. It would have a major impact on my life.

Newbabynewhouse · 29/10/2021 23:26

Not going to lie I'm actually terrified of what's happening with NHS.. I think about it daily, things like what if I need to call an ambulance for a family member, will we be waiting 4 hours...? I'd rather pay more NI if it means saving Nhs or scrimping some money together and getting some good health insurance in place, but even then, if you need A and E, you have to go through NHS don't you? Scary times...not to mention covid...

ChocolateDeficitDisorder · 29/10/2021 23:25

@julieca we are the only country in the whole world to provide free at the point of service.

No, we have the Scottish NHS which is separate organisation to the English NHS and operates in a different country and under a different government.

PinkForgetMeNot · 29/10/2021 23:25

@ChocolateDeficitDisorder

All part of the Tory plan...steadily underfund the system and when enough people write posts like this about how 'terrible' the NHS is, they're going to start encouraging you to use the recommended 'alternatives'.

End result a few years down the line, no more NHS and an American style healthcare system that makes lots of billionaires even richer and regular people struggling to afford food and healthcare. Sick people will die for want of insurance/treatment they can't afford.

I do hope those that voted for the Tories are all getting what they voted for.

Exactly this.
julieca · 29/10/2021 23:22

@LondonLife3 that shocks me. My issues are gallbladder. It took me 6 weeks from initial call to GP surgery to consultants appointment, with a scan in between. I wonder if they would have brought it forward?

LondonLife3 · 29/10/2021 23:20

I recently had major gallbladder issues, I had my letter through to offer a consultation next July!! By next July the pain would have gotten worse and I dread to think the sick time I might have needed from work..
I’m just very lucky I have private medical that had me in and the operation done within 3 weeks..

julieca · 29/10/2021 23:18

@Knownbyanothername we have very high levels of inequality, far higher than many EU countries with good health services. That means we have lots of people not accessing dentistry because they cant afford the cost.
I have problems getting my DP to go to the GP anyway. No chance if there was a cost. For people like my dad with many appointments and tests even a small cost every time would soon be extortionate.

Why do you think the Tories want this system rather than increasing tax? They want it because poor people who tend to have worse health will pay more, while rich people will pay less. It is not about getting good healthcare.

Knownbyanothername · 29/10/2021 23:13

@julieca we are the only country in the whole world to provide free at the point of service. Does that mean all other countries have got it wrong? The NHS is not the shining beacon people think it is.

Porcupineintherough · 29/10/2021 23:05

Fil had a scan this week and has been called in for a biopsy 11 days later. That's because they think it is cancer, so be careful what you wish for.

julieca · 29/10/2021 23:03

@Knownbyanothername no, you increase tax, Charges at point of use would mean people like my dad would have died.

Cameleongirl · 29/10/2021 23:03

Not the point of your post, OP, but just to let you know that my mammogram last year revealed calcifications and they turned out to be harmless.

So don't stress too much, they're probably fine. Flowers

Knownbyanothername · 29/10/2021 23:01

healthandcare.scot/default.asp?page=story&story=1862

Sadly Scotland has privatised a fair amount of NHS services.

The only way is to make small charges at point of service, but keep it free for those on low incomes. The money has to come from somewhere. Even in Europe people pay out more for their health. Here we seem to think everyone else should pay for it.

julieca · 29/10/2021 23:00

A friend had a life threatening illness and her work provide private insurance. I was surprised she opted for NHS treatment. She said the care and outcomes were better under the NHS.
DP has a rare chronic illness. The only specialist consultant in England only does NHS work. You have to go abroad to go private.

DixonD · 29/10/2021 22:57

@Mumsgirls

The private system in USA is far better than anything here, but it is very expensive, so unless you are rich or have good employer cover, you are stuck Here we have made a holy cow of the NHS which now provides a very poor service. Meanwhile nhs consultants do private work on the side, for those with money or a rare excellent employer scheme. I have severe health problems and am so grateful that my employer covers me with as a work benefit. I would be in a right mess without it, but not fair
That’s grossly naive.
BewareTheBeardedDragon · 29/10/2021 22:56

It must be a postcode lottery because I've had brilliant experience of the NHS recently. I have had a few issues and had no problem speaking to a GP who sorted them quickly.
Ds has a non-urgent but nonetheless ongoing quality of life issue which I spoke to GP about, referral was made to specialist service, appt received less than a month later, and procedure he needs booked in for 2 weeks after the appt.
And the HCP he saw was so kind, patient and understanding of his sensitivities (ASD) and skill full. I can't praise them enough, in my area for these issues at least.