Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Penelope jackson guilty of murder

407 replies

Thomasina79 · 29/10/2021 16:51

I’ve been following this news item with interest. She is the woman who stabbed her violent and coercive and bullying husband to death after 20 years of torment. She denied murder, but admitted manslaughter.

Am I being unreasonable in thinking the jury should have not found her guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter. Murder carries a life sentence in prison and I cannot see that that there is anything to gain by locking her away.

OP posts:
StarfishDish · 30/10/2021 08:48

@99victoria

About 120 women a year in the UK killed by men. You never even hear about them. One case of a woman killing a man and it makes HEADLINE news on the TV! Sums up what our society thinks of women :(
@99victoria You hear about it all of the time!
Cronezone · 30/10/2021 08:47

In my experience abuse is not always so black and white, for me it would come as a result arguing back, afterwards I would be accused of 'provoking', but as the weaker sex physically i would always back down and be afraid. After years of this happening you do begin to fantasise about what it would be like to fight back. Her words struck a deep chord with me, 'he was an aggressive bully and I just couldn't take it any more'. I have also been through the court system as a victim of violent crime and my attacker was found not guilty by a jury. I am sure this case must strike fear into the hearts of many women currently being abused.

LizzieSiddal · 30/10/2021 08:44

50Sades I hadn’t read the stuff about her childhood, and it was The Times I read she said in court she felt she drive her third husband to suicide.

I do agree that people are complex and also feel that these two people were both abusive and actually quite awful people.

50ShadesOfCatholic · 30/10/2021 08:40

@LizzieSiddal

That's an overreach. The DM did a full blown misogynistic character assassination on the woman knowing that she could never have the means to sue. Doesn't make it true.

And only at the very end did they drop in that the husband's own brother descibed him as arrogant and argumentative and that his own daughter was NC. Also that it was his third marriage.

And only then did they also reveal that Sally Jackson was abandoned by her parents as a baby, did not see them again until she was 12, and raised in group homes. Went on to have two children by age 18. A very difficult and sad childhood and undoubtedly massively contributing factors to this tragedy.

Point is, it's rarely as black and white as onlookers may wish to believe. People are rarely all bad or all good, they are complex and damage runs deep.

Chocolatewheatos · 30/10/2021 08:22

@PlanDeRaccordement

I’m actually glad the verdict was murder.

It’s obvious that she intended to kill him and he was no threat to her when she went back, snatched the phone out of his hand after he’d called 999 for help, told the police not to send an ambulance and calmly stabbed him some more. She stated to police that she was fully aware of what she’d done and if she’d done it right, it would be murder instead of attempted murder. Etc etc.

There was more evidence that she was coercive and bullying than he was according to character witnesses. So I think that whole angle of the defence was poorly thought out.

Thank god someone else has said this. It would be appalling that a woman can just claim to have been abused with no evidence and get off on murder. She stabbed him again while he was on the phone to 999. If the sexes were reversed would anyone have sympathy for a man in that situation?

She doesn't seem in the slightest bit upset at any part of the situation, she seems pretty chuffed with herself

FourteenSixteenTwentyTwo · 30/10/2021 08:13

This is a side tangent, and not necessarily about this case, but I find the ‘lack of evidence about domestic abuse’ comments really troubling.

I don’t think I’m unique in this, but no one person could attest to abuse from my ex as it was always behind closed doors. In fact I’m fairly certain some probably don’t believe that he could have done it. I remember finally telling a couple of my friends after an incident and one of them made a joke how she would probably do something similar if she had to live with me. I didn’t talk about it again until I was ready to leave.

I’m also amazed that a knife to a throat several years ago is discounted as ‘historic’ without a single thought that just because it hasn’t been witnessed since, doesn’t mean it’s not still going on.

I don’t think it’s up to anyone else to suggest this is not murder if that’s what the jury agreed, but nor does a judgement (or even the action of murder) mean domestic abuse did not occur.

londonrach · 30/10/2021 07:48

Totally the right verdict. She kept stabbing him when he called 999. Weather or not he was the abuser or she was or bit of both is unknown. He is dead so can't give his side. She was vvvv cold and clinical and sounded proud she killed him. I feel vvv sorry for their poor daughter. She's pregnant so terrible timing for her.

mountbattenbergcake · 30/10/2021 07:15

@saraclara

It continues to be really disturbing that many mumsnetters simply cannot let themselves believe that a woman can be capable of cold blooded murder. The desperation to blame her victim for no other reason than that he was male, is stunning. The spurious comparisons between her sentence and that of men whose cases were entirely different are just so illogical.

Several witnesses stood up and said that she was the abuser, but him. But that's just glossed over.

Oh, and she was only found guilty of murder because the judge was a man. That was a good one.

Spurious comparisons?

Anthony Williams was sentenced to just 5 years even though he admitted he ‘choked the living daylights’ out of his wife because he ‘just flipped’.

Jackson also said she just flipped.

Society is much too forgiving of men, and too quick to subscribe to the trope of the hen pecked husband.

Remember the courts still allow for crimes of passion aka ‘loss of control’ as mitigation for murder, and again, these are mostly carried out by men but women are not given the same leniency. There is a higher bar for women.

mountbattenbergcake · 30/10/2021 07:09

@LizzieSiddal

She was married 4 times. Her 3rd husband killed himself and she admitted in court that she’d driven him to suicide. It’s emerged that whilst he was abroad she had his two dogs put down! She sounds an absolutely horrid woman. Yes, her 4th may have been abusive but she she sounds abusive too.
Any source for this?

The papers said he committed suicide because of her affair with the victim. That doesn’t mean she drove him to suicide.

And funny how you don’t say the victim drove his own son to suicide, even though the son left a note saying he didn’t want to be like his dad.

mountbattenbergcake · 30/10/2021 07:06

“Asked if he ever saw Mr Jackson hurt the defendant, Mr Potterton replied: 'No, he once or twice raised his hand in frustration and on no account did I envisage he would do anything, and he never did.'”

If he can raise his hand to her in public, God knows what he did in private.

mountbattenbergcake · 30/10/2021 07:05

The prosecution said Mr Quinlan “was not controlling, as his wife went regularly to the gym and would go shopping with friends.”

They have zero understanding of coercive control.

itsgettingwierd · 30/10/2021 04:40

@saraclara

No-one wants to believe that 'someone like us' (even if it's as global as 'any woman' is capable of such a thing. I dare say most men feel that way too, when they read about abuse and murder carried out by those of their sex (which is of course much more frequent).

But we can't let it make us incapable of objectivity and reason. And this seems to be what's happening with some posters. They don't want to believe it, so they refuse to see it.
I'm still stunned by the poster who assumed that the judge was incapable of advising the jury impartially because he's a man. I mean...c'mon.

True
x2boys · 30/10/2021 02:42

On stabbing *

x2boys · 30/10/2021 02:41

@Suzanne999

I thought more manslaughter than murder —- she snapped, picked up a knife. It doesn’t sound as if she planned to kill him that night. Having once been married to an abusive man ( I walked) there were many times I wished he’d die.. Not nice, I’m not proud of it but living with a man who mentally abuses week after week is horrendous.
You didn't see her telling the police that she hoped they were to late to save him or that when he dialled 999 she put the phone down on him and carried instabbinf him ? not sure how that is manslaughter,you can't just decide it's not murder based on your own personal circumstances.
PlanDeRaccordement · 30/10/2021 00:50

@99victoria

About 120 women a year in the UK killed by men. You never even hear about them. One case of a woman killing a man and it makes HEADLINE news on the TV! Sums up what our society thinks of women :(
So you’ve never heard of these women? Agnes Wanjiru Sarah Everard Bibaa Henry and Nicole Smallman Sabina Nessa
TaraR2020 · 30/10/2021 00:32

This was such a tragic case, awful thing to happen and I agree with one the early pps who pointed out we can't possibly know enough about it to form conclusive opinions.

However, when the subject is one that affects the lives of so many, its natural that discussion will take place.

Personally, I think there's been enough research to show that people in shock often behave and talk in ways like she did in the video. We can't know, really, how much shock and disassociation played in her initial reaction to her attack on him but we should acknowledge that some women may well behave in this way when in a disassociation state because they've snapped after years of abuse.

We're also told that she behaved in a deliberately provocative manner. Now some relationships become toxic because the initial victim doesn't know how to stand up for themselves except by adopting aggressive and abusive behaviour too.

We can't know if this was the case here, but we can acknowledge that it happens in some relationships. What does seem clear is that they had a toxic relationship in which there seems to have been abuse on both sides. I've known men be the victims of awful dv by women and just because the balance of numbers swings the other way doesn't mean they should be denied justice or protection.

Being unable to prove abuse in court doesn't mean it didn't happen, so this could be an awful case in which an abused woman finally snapped, experiencing some sort of mental fugue state. Or it could be that she was the abuser who coldly murdered him. Or it could be that it was a highly toxic marriage in which a series of events led to her murdering him so horribly.

The jury found her guilty of murder and tbh, on the little we know, I don't see how they could have come to another conclusion.

That male violence against women goes unjustly unpunished, or lightly punished, is terrible and needs urgent addressing. Anything less than a life sentence for men who murder their partners in a temper or through claiming rough sex is abhorrent. But I think in this case we can't say anything other than justice has been served, however tragic the circumstances leading up to the crime may be.

It's hard to comprehend for some people that one of "our own" could have committed such a terrible crime, especially when we witness so many women denied justice and help when they're the victims of domestic violence, but if we deny that her guilt could even be a possibility then we are just as bad as all those men who claim Not All Men and deny their friend or colleague could possibly have raped that woman because He's-Such-A-Nice-Guy or a guilty verdict would Ruin-His-Life.

Their families will have to live with the reality of this terrible crime forever and probably with very little support. Their children must be going through hell.

prh47bridge · 30/10/2021 00:25

@99victoria

About 120 women a year in the UK killed by men. You never even hear about them. One case of a woman killing a man and it makes HEADLINE news on the TV! Sums up what our society thinks of women :(
About 25 men a year are killed by women in domestic homicides. This is definitely not the only case this year of a man being killed by a woman, but it is the only one I remember making the headlines. And, as Hont1986 points out, we have had a big news story this year about a man killing a woman.

There are roughly 600 homicides a year in England & Wales. Very few of them make headlines. Most homicides, domestic or otherwise, go under the radar regardless of the sex of the victim.

PurpleOkapi · 30/10/2021 00:21

@99victoria

About 120 women a year in the UK killed by men. You never even hear about them. One case of a woman killing a man and it makes HEADLINE news on the TV! Sums up what our society thinks of women :(
You hear about them all the time. But you're partially right: in general, the more unusual something is, the more coverage it will get. There's a reason "Man bites dog" makes headlines when "Dog bits man" doesn't, and it's not because of bias against either men or dogs.
Hont1986 · 30/10/2021 00:14

About 120 women a year in the UK killed by men. You never even hear about them. One case of a woman killing a man and it makes HEADLINE news on the TV!

The biggest news story this year was about a man killing a woman and it was headline news everywhere.

oviraptor21 · 29/10/2021 23:58

I found the video of her arrest incredibly alarming. Lucid and calm, asking for her coat - a psychopath. Guilty of murder, no question

Regardless of the outcome of this case I truly hope you are never on a jury if you come to that decision purely on the demeanour of the defendant at arrest.

saraclara · 29/10/2021 23:57

@99victoria

About 120 women a year in the UK killed by men. You never even hear about them. One case of a woman killing a man and it makes HEADLINE news on the TV! Sums up what our society thinks of women :(
No, it sums up how rare it is. Making your point for you.
99victoria · 29/10/2021 23:54

About 120 women a year in the UK killed by men. You never even hear about them. One case of a woman killing a man and it makes HEADLINE news on the TV! Sums up what our society thinks of women :(

saraclara · 29/10/2021 23:53

Murder really is the only suitable sentence, and if it had been a woman victim that’s what we would have demanded

Exactly. No way would we have accepted her defence had it come from a man, especially with all the witnesses citing the defendant being the abusive partner.

Abhannmor · 29/10/2021 23:51

@Dojacatpaws

Men and women are not physically equal in most cases, I tend to believe its usually the man who abuses
Yes but not in this case. She was taller , and heavier from the photographs. Also 13 years younger, while he was 78 years old with health issues. She was well able for him physically as evidenced by the fact she was able to lock him in the summer house. Over on Twitter the debate is less evenly balanced with people taking it as read he was an bullying abuser as opposed to a cranky old man with possible dementia. I'm afraid if you want to help women victims of domestic abuse this particular case is not exactly helpful.
Abhannmor · 29/10/2021 23:40

@LittleDandelionClock

I can see way more people on here agreeing that the woman is a dreadful person and definitely a murderer. I see very few people defending Penelope Jackson.
The poll is going the other way though ?