Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Penelope jackson guilty of murder

407 replies

Thomasina79 · 29/10/2021 16:51

I’ve been following this news item with interest. She is the woman who stabbed her violent and coercive and bullying husband to death after 20 years of torment. She denied murder, but admitted manslaughter.

Am I being unreasonable in thinking the jury should have not found her guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter. Murder carries a life sentence in prison and I cannot see that that there is anything to gain by locking her away.

OP posts:
PlanDeRaccordement · 30/10/2021 11:09

Well said @saraclara

prh47bridge · 30/10/2021 11:01

@itsgettingwierd

Did Penelope go for diminished responsibility? Did she have psychological assessment before trial?

One would assume she would have had some psychoanalysis arranged by her defence if she claimed loss of control? Did any psychologists give evidence? For the defence or prosecution? The prosecution can ask for separate witness reports if they dispute the original or to raise questions to ask about the original report.

No, she went for loss of control which is a different defence. As far as I can see, no psychological evidence was presented.

One of the elements needed for a loss of control defence to succeed is that a person of the accused's age and sex, with a normal degree of tolerance and self-restraint, might have reacted in the same way or a similar way in the same circumstances. Evidence of psychological issues would undermine that as it would suggest that a person with normal tolerance and self-restraint would not have acted as she did.

If she had run a defence of diminished responsibility, there would definitely have been psychological evidence. With a defence of loss of control, the last thing the defence would want is evidence that she was not of sound mind.

PlanDeRaccordement · 30/10/2021 10:58

[quote mountbattenbergcake]@Felix125

They will be other incidents of of women killing men - they just do not make headline news for some reason.

93% of murderes in the UK are men.[/quote]
Of adults. If you look at murder of babies/ children you parents..very different.

CounsellorTroi · 30/10/2021 10:47

@saraclara

Agreed 💯. So many handmaidens on this thread.

FFS. What have we come to if acknowledging that a woman might well be guilty of killing in cold blood, makes one a handmaiden?

I'm sick of this all women are innocent, all men are guilty syndrome. It's far from the case, and when simply applying logic and reason to an issue is seen as 'pandering to the menz' we're pretty much doomed. And as I said earlier, playing to the 'women are irrational' trope.

It was much the same on the Ioan Gruffudd thread. Most people saying he was a cheating scumbag despite no one actually knowing and defending his wife’s online abuse of him.
SlugRose · 30/10/2021 10:45

And as I said earlier, playing to the 'women are irrational' trope. yes, in a weird way it is insulting to assume that a woman can't intentionally kill someone.

SlugRose · 30/10/2021 10:44

We weren't there. We don't know. The jury have more of an idea than us and have decided that yes she intended to kill him. It doesn't matter why. She could be a victim too or she could not. I can't just say oh my partner was cruel and abusive 5 years ago so I decided to stab him and expect to get away with it. There has to be more to it than that.

saraclara · 30/10/2021 10:39

Agreed 💯. So many handmaidens on this thread.

FFS. What have we come to if acknowledging that a woman might well be guilty of killing in cold blood, makes one a handmaiden?

I'm sick of this all women are innocent, all men are guilty syndrome. It's far from the case, and when simply applying logic and reason to an issue is seen as 'pandering to the menz' we're pretty much doomed. And as I said earlier, playing to the 'women are irrational' trope.

MuslinsRLife · 30/10/2021 10:15

@wheresmymojo thats an absolutely shocking thing to say. This is real life, not a TV program. How you could laugh at that I don’t know.

I’m sick of mumsnet & the ‘all menz are bad’ brigade. This woman is a sick murderer & has been sentenced within the law. If you think you know better than the jury & judge you need to give your head a wobble, oh & watch the video of her on camera!

itsgettingwierd · 30/10/2021 10:11

Did Penelope go for diminished responsibility? Did she have psychological assessment before trial?

One would assume she would have had some psychoanalysis arranged by her defence if she claimed loss of control? Did any psychologists give evidence? For the defence or prosecution? The prosecution can ask for separate witness reports if they dispute the original or to raise questions to ask about the original report.

Felix125 · 30/10/2021 10:11

[quote mountbattenbergcake]@Felix125

They will be other incidents of of women killing men - they just do not make headline news for some reason.

93% of murderes in the UK are men.[/quote]
I completely agree

Men are by far (93%) the major issue here.

rwalker · 30/10/2021 10:09

I found the interview and footage of her chilling .

ancientgran · 30/10/2021 09:56

@FourteenSixteenTwentyTwo

This is a side tangent, and not necessarily about this case, but I find the ‘lack of evidence about domestic abuse’ comments really troubling.

I don’t think I’m unique in this, but no one person could attest to abuse from my ex as it was always behind closed doors. In fact I’m fairly certain some probably don’t believe that he could have done it. I remember finally telling a couple of my friends after an incident and one of them made a joke how she would probably do something similar if she had to live with me. I didn’t talk about it again until I was ready to leave.

I’m also amazed that a knife to a throat several years ago is discounted as ‘historic’ without a single thought that just because it hasn’t been witnessed since, doesn’t mean it’s not still going on.

I don’t think it’s up to anyone else to suggest this is not murder if that’s what the jury agreed, but nor does a judgement (or even the action of murder) mean domestic abuse did not occur.

It goes both ways though and I think it is even less likely that there would be evidence of him being abused by her. No one knows what really goes on behind closed doors.

I'm pretty sure no one would believe my exDIL abused my son, she is so sweet so thoughtful so kind, so blonde and pretty. He is a big rugby playing bloke, no one would imagine he would be attacked in a bar or on the street and take it so who is going to believe he wouldn't hit back at a woman or even be the aggressor. Apart from the fact I know him and believe him my GC knew how to phone me and when she started I would get a phone call, child wouldn't speak but I'd hear what was going on. It was a cry for help and I would jump in the car to remove child from the situation. I'd arrive and see the state son was in and she'd look at me and deny everything. She was so convincing and I think that was because when she flipped she didn't even know what she did so when she denied it she was telling the truth as she believed it.

It is very very difficult to know the rights and wrongs. Even with the knife was that him on the point of flipping from the abuse but managing to stop? Or was that him being a violent bully?

I agree with you that we don't know if domestic abuse occurred or who was the abuser.

prh47bridge · 30/10/2021 09:55

None of us can know the reality of what happened in that marriage. Was he abusive? Was she abusive? None of us can know for sure. The jury was better placed than any of us but even they don't know for sure. Even if he did abuse her throughout the marriage as she claimed, that isn't an automatic "get out of jail free" card on a murder charge. Her defence was loss of control. For this to succeed, she needed to prove that she lost control, that there was a qualifying trigger and that a person of her age and sex, with a normal degree of tolerance and self-restraint, might have reacted in the same way or a similar way in the same circumstances. The qualifying trigger must be a fear of serious violence (which appears to be what she attempted to claim) and/or things said and/or done which "constituted circumstances of an extremely grave character" and caused her to have a justifiable sense of being seriously wronged. The judge allowed this defence to go to the jury, so clearly the defence had done enough to raise this as an issue. However, the jury rejected it, so clearly they thought the prosecution had proved beyond reasonable doubt that it was not loss of control.

A number of posters have compared this case with that of Anthony Williams. His case was rather different in that he ran a defence of diminished responsibility. There was expert evidence from a psychologist to supported his defence and there was also evidence of strange behaviour in the weeks leading up to the killing. There was no suggestion of domestic abuse in this case. Apart from the fact he was charged with murder and pleaded guilty to manslaughter, it has little in common with this case.

Note that I am not saying either jury was correct in their verdict. It is quite possible that one or both juries were wrong. But they heard all the evidence before making their decision. We only have the bits of evidence that the press chose to report - 5-minute summaries of cases that lasted for days.

On the wider point, there don't appear to be any statistics that tell us whether men are more likely to succeed with "loss of control" or "diminished responsibility" defences than women. There are only a handful of cases a year in which one of these defences is advanced and the accused are overwhelmingly men, so it would be difficult to get reliable statistics.

50ShadesOfCatholic · 30/10/2021 09:54

@Movinghouseatlast

That is so sad, I'm so sorry for what you and your mum have been through.

itsgettingwierd · 30/10/2021 09:51

Mount what has stats of rape cases got to do with Oenelope being found guilty of murder by the people who sat through the evidence Confused

x2boys · 30/10/2021 09:50

@dottypencilcase

I think it's the right verdict (because there doesn't appear to have been any finished responsibility) but my sympathies lie with Valerie. DV is a horrid beast that has a permanent impact on a person's psychology. I hope she appeals and gets a lesser sentence.
Valerie ??
itsgettingwierd · 30/10/2021 09:50

[quote mountbattenbergcake]@Felix125

They will be other incidents of of women killing men - they just do not make headline news for some reason.

93% of murderes in the UK are men.[/quote]
Thanks for that link.

It make very interesting reading.

Mostly that the highest number of people committing murders are make but also males are 73% of the total homicides. White British are less than 2/3rds.

The highest incidence in children under 1 and then 16-24yo.

But it also states that homicides of woman from partners/ex partners has decreased this year. That is something I'd like to explore further. How and why?

It's a huge document that you could take and spin most figures to any agenda you have. But there is certainly some data that makes some interesting questions arise.

Movinghouseatlast · 30/10/2021 09:49

My mum suffered mental abuse and coercive control from my dad throughout her married life. It was heartbreaking.

She used to tell me that she sometimes fantasised about killing him to make it stop. Had she done this I would have testified in court but my evidence would have been 10 years old- the last time I personally observed it rather than hearing about it.

The psychology of why women don't leave is complex. My mum hated my dad, her life was miserable but she 'felt sorry for him' and wouldn't throw him out. I saw her life just gradually drain away through misery and loneliness. My dad was evil and when he died I very calmly said I wished I could dance on his grave and was glad he died.

dottypencilcase · 30/10/2021 09:48

I think it's the right verdict (because there doesn't appear to have been any finished responsibility) but my sympathies lie with Valerie. DV is a horrid beast that has a permanent impact on a person's psychology. I hope she appeals and gets a lesser sentence.

x2boys · 30/10/2021 09:48

The irony @mountbattenbergcake 🙄
You are determined this women despite not knowing her is somehow the abused one ,I disagree , it's not all about your opinion

anon12345678901 · 30/10/2021 09:42

She murdered him so it's correct she's found guilty of murder. She went back to stab him some more and showed no remorse, she's a murderer. The judgement is correct.

mountbattenbergcake · 30/10/2021 09:42

@itsgettingwierd

But what happened in this judgment is best understood by those who were part of it.

This is something people need to remember.

You can't assign your own personal experiences to Penelopes because it sits better with you about how this panned out.

As pointed out very well earlier - we get to see bias reports. The facts came out in court. I'm court a jury of 8 woman and 4 men found her guilty of murder.

“Many studies suggest women are more likely to judge female rape complainants harshly and to acquit men accused of rape. In 2009, Irish academics who studied 108 rape trials found that male-dominated juries had the highest conviction rate. There was not a single conviction in the 17 cases which had female-dominated juries”

www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/women-under-represented-on-juries-in-serious-criminal-trials-1.3156886

mountbattenbergcake · 30/10/2021 09:39

*murderers

itsgettingwierd · 30/10/2021 09:39

But what happened in this judgment is best understood by those who were part of it.

This is something people need to remember.

You can't assign your own personal experiences to Penelopes because it sits better with you about how this panned out.

As pointed out very well earlier - we get to see bias reports. The facts came out in court. I'm court a jury of 8 woman and 4 men found her guilty of murder.

mountbattenbergcake · 30/10/2021 09:39

@Felix125

They will be other incidents of of women killing men - they just do not make headline news for some reason.

93% of murderes in the UK are men.