Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Penelope jackson guilty of murder

407 replies

Thomasina79 · 29/10/2021 16:51

I’ve been following this news item with interest. She is the woman who stabbed her violent and coercive and bullying husband to death after 20 years of torment. She denied murder, but admitted manslaughter.

Am I being unreasonable in thinking the jury should have not found her guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter. Murder carries a life sentence in prison and I cannot see that that there is anything to gain by locking her away.

OP posts:
CounsellorTroi · 30/10/2021 12:03

But I do believe that there'd be none of this hand wringing over her attitude and her earlier life experiences (and the lack of remorse wasn't just instant, it continued right up to the court case) had she been a man.

I agree with you. I also think no one would have been defending a man, whether being abused or not, who’d stabbed his wife once and then came back and did it again while she was calling 999, and saying he shouldn’t have been convicted of murder.

LexMitior · 30/10/2021 12:02

@CatsArePeople

She's guilty, ok. But a life sentence? Unlike men who get ridiculously short sentences.
Everyone who murders gets a life sentence - its the law. The difference is the minimum amount of time spent before you get considered for parole.

In this case, it was a lack of remorse and her conduct at the point of contact with the authorities which will have set this above the minimum point of 15 years.

TaraR2020 · 30/10/2021 12:02

But I do believe that there'd be none of this hand wringing over her attitude and her earlier life experiences (and the lack of remorse wasn't just instant, it continued right up to the court case) had she been a man

I agree with you there, @saraclara. As women who support other women, we need to own it when one commits a terrible crime against a man.

saraclara · 30/10/2021 11:59

[quote TaraR2020]@saraclara have you read my first post?

I'm not accepting any "justification for murder", what she did was abhorrent and I've stated more than once that whatever view you take about her, the outcome of the trial was the right one.

I'm simply acknowledging that it's a tragic thing to have happened and that if she was the victim of long term domestic abuse its tragic for her too.[/quote]
Fair enough. I was just going in your exchange with @mountbattenbergcake.

But I do believe that there'd be none of this hand wringing over her attitude and her earlier life experiences (and the lack of remorse wasn't just instant, it continued right up to the court case) had she been a man.

CatsArePeople · 30/10/2021 11:59

She's guilty, ok. But a life sentence? Unlike men who get ridiculously short sentences.

itsgettingwierd · 30/10/2021 11:55

[quote PlanDeRaccordement]For specific to England and Wales, 37% mothers and 63% fathers murdering their own children. It’s simply a fact that women can murder family members.
bmjpaedsopen.bmj.com/content/bmjpo/1/1/e000112/DC1/embed/inline-supplementary-material-1.pdf?download=true[/quote]
There's 3 cases very recently running.

One is mum and step mum, one mum and step dad and one is just mum (completed)

It's obviously anecdotal but there is evidence mums can be involved in the harm and deaths of their babies at quite an incidence.

TaraR2020 · 30/10/2021 11:52

@saraclara have you read my first post?

I'm not accepting any "justification for murder", what she did was abhorrent and I've stated more than once that whatever view you take about her, the outcome of the trial was the right one.

I'm simply acknowledging that it's a tragic thing to have happened and that if she was the victim of long term domestic abuse its tragic for her too.

itsgettingwierd · 30/10/2021 11:52

Thanks ph that makes sense. What a minefield!

LexMitior · 30/10/2021 11:48

I don't think this case is as complicated as some say - she did show intent to murder. She returned to stab him again after the initial assault. Conceivably he might have survived if she had not done that, but manslaughter wasn't possible, and it wasn't diminished responsibility in any way- no evidence admitted on that, and she didn't plead this, did she?

She is a murderer, and the actual evidence that she was abused was rather scant in court. The jury didn't believe her manslaughter case because there was no arguable basis. Its a very different case from Sally Challen where there was a lot of evidence that was not taken into account by the courts.

saraclara · 30/10/2021 11:41

@TaraR2020 @TheAntiGardener @mountbattenbergcake would you accept the same justification for murder if the defendant had been a man who killed his wife? Would you have accepted his complete lack of remorse in the same way?

iloveeverykindofcat · 30/10/2021 11:36

I don't think she gave the jury much choice but to find her guilty of murder. Whatever sympathy jurors do or don't have for the accused they still have to follow the law.

mountbattenbergcake · 30/10/2021 11:30

Agreed @TaraR2020

TaraR2020 · 30/10/2021 11:28

@TheAntiGardener thank you. Yes, I'm inclined to think her response was linked to relief and shock...How many of us have expressed extreme emotions when we've discovered we've been cheated on etc? (Of course we don't act on them!) When you watch true crime docs the murderers- many of whom are psychopathic - don't react like that.

I just hope that any mitigating factors are recognised and taken into account in an appeal, but I'm not convinced she'd even get a reduction in years. Whichever way you look at it, a prison sentence is the right outcome, however sad.

mountbattenbergcake · 30/10/2021 11:27

@PlanDeRaccordement

My point is female jurors are often harsher on women.

In rape cases. Not relevant to murder cases.

If it holds for rape cases it likely holds for homicide too. Society has a much higher bar for women.

Look at the vilification of Kate McCann. Her husband was not vilified to the extent she was.

mountbattenbergcake · 30/10/2021 11:26

@x2boys

I said people need to stop minimising what's happened ,and making stories up in there head
Yep, trying to police the thread.
mountbattenbergcake · 30/10/2021 11:25

[quote PlanDeRaccordement]@mountbattenbergcake

The post was about murderers in the UK. Did not specify men/women.

I see you did not link your source. Mine is a systematic world wide review of 9,431 studies.

“Data from 33 countries distinguishing the perpetrators of parental homicides of children under the age of 18 years showed that mothers committed just over half of all parental homicides (median 54.7%, IQR 36.7–68.8); in high-income countries, the median percentage was 44.4% (IQR 36.7–66.7), in the East Asia and Pacific region, 64.6% (IQR 59.0–69.3), in the Americas, 15.4% (IQR 13.3–17.4), in Africa, 88.6% (IQR 71.1–100.0), in low-income and middle-income Europe, 60.4% (IQR 45.8–75.0) and in the Mediterranean region, 7.4% (IQR 0.0–14.8).”

From Child homicide perpetrators worldwide: a systematic review, British Medical Journal. bmjpaedsopen.bmj.com/content/1/1/e000112[/quote]
I didn’t include a source as was difficult to find clear UK only stats. But here is the one I quoted.

Your source says the majority of child murders in high income countries are committed by men.

And that there were issues gathering data for all the countries studied.

Chocolatewheatos · 30/10/2021 11:24

I love that people think she could be fairly pushed to stab him and then again while he was on the phone to 999 by him abusing her. But don't think, someone whose child had just committed suicide could be pushed to threaten their abusive partner with a knife which his daughter remembers happening when she was a child over 20 years ago. I can imagine an abusive partner could say some vile things after your child commits suicide to push you to want to kill them.

PlanDeRaccordement · 30/10/2021 11:20

My point is female jurors are often harsher on women.

In rape cases. Not relevant to murder cases.

PlanDeRaccordement · 30/10/2021 11:19

For specific to England and Wales, 37% mothers and 63% fathers murdering their own children. It’s simply a fact that women can murder family members.
bmjpaedsopen.bmj.com/content/bmjpo/1/1/e000112/DC1/embed/inline-supplementary-material-1.pdf?download=true

x2boys · 30/10/2021 11:17

I said people need to stop minimising what's happened ,and making stories up in there head

mountbattenbergcake · 30/10/2021 11:16

@itsgettingwierd

Mount what has stats of rape cases got to do with Oenelope being found guilty of murder by the people who sat through the evidence Confused
People kept referencing the 8 female jurors on this case as if that proved the verdict was right.

My point is female jurors are often harsher on women.

PlanDeRaccordement · 30/10/2021 11:14

@mountbattenbergcake

The post was about murderers in the UK. Did not specify men/women.

I see you did not link your source. Mine is a systematic world wide review of 9,431 studies.

“Data from 33 countries distinguishing the perpetrators of parental homicides of children under the age of 18 years showed that mothers committed just over half of all parental homicides (median 54.7%, IQR 36.7–68.8); in high-income countries, the median percentage was 44.4% (IQR 36.7–66.7), in the East Asia and Pacific region, 64.6% (IQR 59.0–69.3), in the Americas, 15.4% (IQR 13.3–17.4), in Africa, 88.6% (IQR 71.1–100.0), in low-income and middle-income Europe, 60.4% (IQR 45.8–75.0) and in the Mediterranean region, 7.4% (IQR 0.0–14.8).”

From Child homicide perpetrators worldwide: a systematic review, British Medical Journal. bmjpaedsopen.bmj.com/content/1/1/e000112

mountbattenbergcake · 30/10/2021 11:11

@x2boys

The irony *@mountbattenbergcake* 🙄 You are determined this women despite not knowing her is somehow the abused one ,I disagree , it's not all about your opinion
I’m not the one one saying people need to stop giving their opinions, that’s you.
Jamallama · 30/10/2021 11:10

None of us were there prior to the murder, during the murder or after the murder, nor were we in the court listening to the case, so none of us know the actual truth of the defining moment.
The jury found her guilty and the judge gave the sentence which he found fitting to the crime.
Everything else is pure speculation and hearsay.
The rumour mill is running rampant.

mountbattenbergcake · 30/10/2021 11:09

Of adults. If you look at murder of babies/ children you parents..very different.

Source? The only study UK study I found said:

“Overall, fathers were significantly more likely to kill their children than mothers, and were more likely to use violent methods of killing, have previous convictions for violent offences, perpetrate multiple killings, and have a history of substance misuse or dependence.”

Anyway, the thread was about men/women not kids.