Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Penelope jackson guilty of murder

407 replies

Thomasina79 · 29/10/2021 16:51

I’ve been following this news item with interest. She is the woman who stabbed her violent and coercive and bullying husband to death after 20 years of torment. She denied murder, but admitted manslaughter.

Am I being unreasonable in thinking the jury should have not found her guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter. Murder carries a life sentence in prison and I cannot see that that there is anything to gain by locking her away.

OP posts:
50ShadesOfCatholic · 29/10/2021 18:49

@ssd

The footage of her discussing stabbing him afterwards was awful, really chilling. If this had been a man stabbing a woman no one would question the guilty verdict.
I agree it was disturbing footage but to me that is someone trying to manage an unthinkable situation. There is nothing "normal" about it. You can sense the officers willing her to stay silent, to stop her incriminating herself.

Hearing her speak reminded me so much of a woman I once interviewed.
She'd been subject to the most unthinkable child abuse, utterly chilling. She had a strange, detached way of talking about terrible events with an almost jokey demeanour.

I do think that severely traumatised people can appear almost cold and unfeeling, they've developed coping strategies that do not align with outsiders' notions of how they should behave. And I think TV has a big part to play in that hardly any shows portray victims realistically.

A tragedy all round, not least because this couple clearly had many years of misery. What a waste of lives.

letsmakethishappen · 29/10/2021 18:47

I know it’s very hard to leave abusive relationships but she was wealthy etc could have rang the police , we just don’t go around killing people

Theluggage15 · 29/10/2021 18:47

Sounds far more likely she was the abuser in the relationship from the evidence and what the judge said. Glad her lies were shown up and feel very sorry for that poor man’s family. Perhaps the police will take another look at the death of her third husband.

SlugRose · 29/10/2021 18:45

@TheAntiGardener

I think there needs to be a loss of control too on the part of the abused person, not just the fact of the abuse. There have been cases previously that have focused on this.
Yes I think that's it.
PlanDeRaccordement · 29/10/2021 18:45

@TheAntiGardener

Depressing there are women on here who don’t seem to believe that being abused can lead to the abuser lashing out and even killing. That DV victims are only victims if they behave nicely. Thankfully, the law is more progressive on this point, even if it wasn’t applicable or unconvincing in this particular case.

I have no clue what went on here, but it’s pretty well established that abused people can snap and hurt their abusers. They aren’t ‘crying abuse’ if they use that to defend themselves.

For me it’s not that. It’s the fact that more witnesses attested that David was not abusive.

One daughter claimed David had been violent 3x over 20yrs ago. But the other two children...her sister and older brother who also grew up in same household said no violence had ever happened.

SausageSizzle · 29/10/2021 18:45

If someone murdered someone in cold blood, in their right mind and 'in control' as you say, would they really be making jokes about pyjamas? It's an absolutely bizarre thing to be doing.

Yes, these are the actions of someone who has very clearly lost it.

As in the Anthony Williams case, apparently.

Yet he got 5 years.

And no abuse there as a mitigating factor.

RudestLittleMadam · 29/10/2021 18:44

@OverTheRubicon

Anyone who came on here to say that their husband was once violently abusive - keeping in mind that he had held a knife to her throat - would be told that (a) a tragic child loss is still not an excuse and (b) that men are not likely to be violent just 3 times and never again.

She may still be a nasty person. But I am horrified by the headlines in the Times and elsewhere saying that sure he'd been violently abusive but only a long time ago, and that because her daughter hadn't seen it since, it must not have happened. Surely more likely that it always happened, it was just that his son's suicide had made him stressed enough to forget to hide it.

I agree with everything you’ve said, all of it.
grapewine · 29/10/2021 18:44

@Zwellers

Seriously. This thread wouldn't be here if the otherway round. The double standard is shocking. This woman was psycho who stabbed her husband whilst he was on the phone to 999 and showed no remorse, and has years worth of people saying she bullied him.
Quite. I hope they throw away the key.
OverTheRubicon · 29/10/2021 18:43

[quote PlanDeRaccordement]@SausageSizzle
I think stabbing him in the bedroom, then going and writing a note about murdering him, then when hearing him in the kitchen calling 999 going to him, snatching the phone out of his hand and stabbing him while the 999 emergency services are still on the line pretty much doesn’t show a lack of control. The recordings and footage show a woman very much in control so much so she is calmly making jokes about her M&S pjs.[/quote]
If someone murdered someone in cold blood, in their right mind and 'in control' as you say, would they really be making jokes about pyjamas? It's an absolutely bizarre thing to be doing.

Mrsjayy · 29/10/2021 18:43

I think her lack of "guilt" at the time off arrest and maybe continued yes I did it has made her look cold blooded ,and didn't helpshe loked like a woman at the end of her tether as a pp said, * hope she appeals.

SausageSizzle · 29/10/2021 18:41

In the Anthony Williams case, he chased his wife around the house 'choking the living daylights' out of her so violently that he broke her neck 5 times.

He said he began strangling her after she told him to “get over it” when he expressed his concerns.

He said he chased his wife downstairs and again grabbed her by her throat as she tried to unlock the front door to escape, saying he found himself “throttling her to death”.

She was taken to hospital where she was pronounced dead, having suffered haemorrhaging in her eyes, face and mouth which were consistent with strangulation, as well as five neck fractures.

Yet only 5 years. Double standard or what?

Hard to avoid concluding that women's lives are seen as less valuable than men's and men's mental health issues are seen as more valid than those caused to women by domestic abuse.

x2boys · 29/10/2021 18:39

@TheAntiGardener

Depressing there are women on here who don’t seem to believe that being abused can lead to the abuser lashing out and even killing. That DV victims are only victims if they behave nicely. Thankfully, the law is more progressive on this point, even if it wasn’t applicable or unconvincing in this particular case.

I have no clue what went on here, but it’s pretty well established that abused people can snap and hurt their abusers. They aren’t ‘crying abuse’ if they use that to defend themselves.

As you say you have no idea what went on none of us do ,but I'm sure the jury had a fair idea .
Userguaranteed · 29/10/2021 18:38

@x2boys

Userguaranteed · 29/10/2021 18:38

Oh yes... the woman provoked the man. I'm sure we wouldn't say that either.

TheAntiGardener · 29/10/2021 18:37

Depressing there are women on here who don’t seem to believe that being abused can lead to the abuser lashing out and even killing. That DV victims are only victims if they behave nicely. Thankfully, the law is more progressive on this point, even if it wasn’t applicable or unconvincing in this particular case.

I have no clue what went on here, but it’s pretty well established that abused people can snap and hurt their abusers. They aren’t ‘crying abuse’ if they use that to defend themselves.

x2boys · 29/10/2021 18:36

@Userguaranteed

I wonder what we'd say if a man killed a woman who's abused him in the past and who he's also abused. Killed in cold blood. Said he hope it wasn't "attempted" murder or else he hadn't done the job well. Said he wished he'd stabbed her few more times. Said he wished the police/ambulance wouldn't try to save her. Only cared about his coat and slippers and said he was happy with what he did. Then cried in court for a few minutes and said he didn't know what he did and was sorry.

'Locking him up serves no purpose. Hope he wins his appeal'. I'm sure that wouldn't be said ever!

Of course we wouldn't ,we wouldn't somehow try and blame the wide either ,for getting murdered .
Puzzledandpissedoff · 29/10/2021 18:35

Very well put, midsomermurderess

I was surprised myself at the verdict, but then I wasn't there to hear all the evidence so I'm not going to join the chorus about "abusive men" since it doesn't seem relevant in this particular case

ssd · 29/10/2021 18:35

The footage of her discussing stabbing him afterwards was awful, really chilling.
If this had been a man stabbing a woman no one would question the guilty verdict.

Userguaranteed · 29/10/2021 18:33

I wonder what we'd say if a man killed a woman who's abused him in the past and who he's also abused. Killed in cold blood. Said he hope it wasn't "attempted" murder or else he hadn't done the job well. Said he wished he'd stabbed her few more times. Said he wished the police/ambulance wouldn't try to save her. Only cared about his coat and slippers and said he was happy with what he did. Then cried in court for a few minutes and said he didn't know what he did and was sorry.

'Locking him up serves no purpose. Hope he wins his appeal'. I'm sure that wouldn't be said ever!

SausageSizzle · 29/10/2021 18:33

This man was given 5 years for killing his wife in remarkably similar circumstances:

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/feb/18/anthony-williams-killed-wife-act-of-great-violence-jailed-for-five-years

And he wasn't a victim of abuse.

PlanDeRaccordement · 29/10/2021 18:32

@SausageSizzle
I think stabbing him in the bedroom, then going and writing a note about murdering him, then when hearing him in the kitchen calling 999 going to him, snatching the phone out of his hand and stabbing him while the 999 emergency services are still on the line pretty much doesn’t show a lack of control. The recordings and footage show a woman very much in control so much so she is calmly making jokes about her M&S pjs.

itsgettingwierd · 29/10/2021 18:29

@midsomermurderess

I don't think there is much merit in second guessing the jury's verdict. They had all the relevant evidence in front of them, they saw daily the accused's demeanour, they were given guidance by the judge as to what would justify either verdict. There is nothing to suggest that they didn't properly apply themselves to their duty. It doesn't really matter what outcome you would have chosen.
I think this is a great calm and very measured post.

It's very easy to build opinions based on what media choose to print on whatever bias they want the story told.

TheAntiGardener · 29/10/2021 18:28

I think there needs to be a loss of control too on the part of the abused person, not just the fact of the abuse. There have been cases previously that have focused on this.

Lockheart · 29/10/2021 18:28

@skippy67

I'm glad she got found guilty. 18 years isn't long enough.
Her sentence is for life, 18 years is the minimum term for incarceration. She will still be serving her sentence on license when she leaves prison.

She is also 66. She will be 84 before she is eligible to be released.

x2boys · 29/10/2021 18:26

@Pixxie7

She admitted murdering him so I don’t think the jury really had a choice, however I hope her sentence is appealed as locking her up serves no purpose in my view. Hopefully it will go on to be a landmark case and the eventual outcome will be more positive for anyone guilty of coercive abuse. However we need to be able to ensure that it doesn’t become an excuse for killing partners.
So you don't think she should have a custodial term for murdering someone?