Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Penelope jackson guilty of murder

407 replies

Thomasina79 · 29/10/2021 16:51

I’ve been following this news item with interest. She is the woman who stabbed her violent and coercive and bullying husband to death after 20 years of torment. She denied murder, but admitted manslaughter.

Am I being unreasonable in thinking the jury should have not found her guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter. Murder carries a life sentence in prison and I cannot see that that there is anything to gain by locking her away.

OP posts:
12548ehe9fnfobms · 29/10/2021 20:19

This thread goes part way to explaining why men with violent wives are unable to talk about it, society finds it hard to accept that women can be this violent & abusive to men.
There are more victims in these situations as often children are witnesses. They grow up in violent homes with no understanding outside the home of what they are dealing with, not just when the violence spills over, but on a daily basis.

mountbattenbergcake · 29/10/2021 20:17

@Puzzledandpissedoff

I find it very scary how people make up their own narrative and write it as fact in criminal cases

It always happens though; in a way it's another example of "I think they did/meant such-and-such ... so they must have done ... so they did"

Seems that courtroom must have been pretty packed, what with so many people who are sure they know what happened ...

No, just willing to believe eye witness statements from their daughter, her search history and the police records of her calling the police on him.
LittleDandelionClock · 29/10/2021 20:17

but we are talking about an elderly couple it not easy to just get up and go.

I think what this woman did is abhorrent, and she deserves the murder charge, but I agree with this. It really grates on me when some people say on here 'just LEAVE,' even when the woman is in her late 50s/early 60s... Like she is just a spring chicken, and can just start her life over, forge a new career, and find a wonderful new man.

Ain't gonna happen.

What man is a 60-year-old woman going to get? Not a handsome, fun-loving, go-getting 40 year old man who will want to travel, get involved in new hobbies, give her great sex, and will rarely complain or moan about anything. A 60 year old woman is not what a man like this is looking for! He is looking for a woman in her mid 30s or younger.

The only thing a 60 y.o. woman will get the is the same grumpy moaning whiny boring old fecker with multiple health ailments that she wants to get away from so badly...

Went off on a tangent there, but even so, I agree with a pp that no matter how hard it, leaving has still got to be a better option than murdering your husband! No matter how abusive he (allegedly) is/was.

@darbs

I think she was guilty of murder. Reading her history too I think the police body camera caught the real Penny Jackson.

Agree!

@ssd don't worry, I think despite a few apologists on here, the vast majority of people agree that she deserved the murder charge and conviction, and she IS a callous murderer.

PurpleOkapi · 29/10/2021 20:17

Self-defence is different. He was the aggressor throughout their marriage.

If she'd stabbed him in a confrontation he'd initiated as the aggressor, the case would have been very different. That's not what she did.

mountbattenbergcake · 29/10/2021 20:16

@PurpleOkapi

If my husband locked me in the conservatory, I'd "brandish" whatever was at hand trying to get out, too.

She locked him in the conservatory BECAUSE he was brandishing a poker. Jesus.

Her search history doesn't establish that she believed she was abused, just that she was looking for a place to leave. Even if it did, her subjective belief that she was abused doesn't prove that it was true.

No, she was looking for a DOMESTIC VIOLENCE REFUGE.

More importantly, this was all several years ago. There's a big difference between killing someone because you're angry that they abused you in the past, and killing them because you reasonably perceive a threat to your life in the moment. The former is murder. The latter generally isn't.

She was looking for the DV refuge in DECEMBER 2020.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 29/10/2021 20:16

I find it very scary how people make up their own narrative and write it as fact in criminal cases

It always happens though; in a way it's another example of "I think they did/meant such-and-such ... so they must have done ... so they did"

Seems that courtroom must have been pretty packed, what with so many people who are sure they know what happened ...

mountbattenbergcake · 29/10/2021 20:15

@x2boys

Well she reapetedly stabbed him and said she wanted to kill him so if had survived ,she was also violent ,once violent always violent according to your rules *@mountbattebergcake*
Self-defence is different. He was the aggressor throughout their marriage.
PurpleOkapi · 29/10/2021 20:14

@mountbattenbergcake

Their daughter:

"observed three violent incidents, one in which he held a knife to Jackson’s throat."

"In December the couple’s toxic relationship is said to have worsened when a row over a remote control resulted in her calling the police after she locked her husband in the conservatory, where he was brandishing a poker. Her computer’s search history showed she researched domestic violence refuges later that evening."

How is this not proof of an abusive marriage - witnesses, proof of police complaint and her search history from years ago?

All she's guilty of is appearing 'lucid'.

If my husband locked me in the conservatory, I'd "brandish" whatever was at hand trying to get out, too. Her search history doesn't establish that she believed she was abused, just that she was looking for a place to leave. Even if it did, her subjective belief that she was abused doesn't prove that it was true.

More importantly, this was all several years ago. There's a big difference between killing someone because you're angry that they abused you in the past, and killing them because you reasonably perceive a threat to your life in the moment. The former is murder. The latter generally isn't.

Darbs76 · 29/10/2021 20:13

I think she was guilty of murder. Reading her history too I think the police body camera caught the real Penny Jackson.

prh47bridge · 29/10/2021 20:11

@mountbattenbergcake

But we also know that women more likely to falsely confess to crimes than men.

Yes, she killed him, but if she was a man, she would be guilty of manslaughter.

In all honesty, I doubt it. I think any defendant would have had difficulty running the defence of loss of control given the evidence. But it is, of course, possible that a different jury would have come up with a different verdict. After all, the verdict in this case was not unanimous.
PurpleOkapi · 29/10/2021 20:11

@Dojacatpaws

So the daughter said he had held a knife to her mums throat and given her a bloody nose in the past, but because it was years ago, was discounted, because apparently they were getting on now, what a joke
It's discounted because someone threatening your life years ago isn't a justification for killing them now.
x2boys · 29/10/2021 20:08

Well she reapetedly stabbed him and said she wanted to kill him so if had survived ,she was also violent ,once violent always violent according to your rules @mountbattebergcake

mountbattenbergcake · 29/10/2021 20:07

But we also know that women more likely to falsely confess to crimes than men.

Yes, she killed him, but if she was a man, she would be guilty of manslaughter.

Boood · 29/10/2021 20:05

Clearly, by her own admission, she intended to kill him, and she killed him. That’s murder.

That aside, there is not “little evidence” that he abused her. Their daughter, as a small child, witnessed him hold a knife to her throat. How inured to violence do you have to be to think that is minor? (And I’m talking about both the daughter and the posters on this thread.) I don’t believe that you go from that to being harmless.

mountbattenbergcake · 29/10/2021 20:03

@OverTheRubicon

Anyone who came on here to say that their husband was once violently abusive - keeping in mind that he had held a knife to her throat - would be told that (a) a tragic child loss is still not an excuse and (b) that men are not likely to be violent just 3 times and never again.

She may still be a nasty person. But I am horrified by the headlines in the Times and elsewhere saying that sure he'd been violently abusive but only a long time ago, and that because her daughter hadn't seen it since, it must not have happened. Surely more likely that it always happened, it was just that his son's suicide had made him stressed enough to forget to hide it.

Yep, once violent, always violent.
Penistoe · 29/10/2021 20:00

Surely more likely that it always happened, it was just that his son's suicide had made him stressed enough to forget to hide it

Agree with h this 100%

mountbattenbergcake · 29/10/2021 20:00

I mean - her search history from December was about DV refuges, just months before the killing.

mountbattenbergcake · 29/10/2021 19:58

@Dojacatpaws

So the daughter said he had held a knife to her mums throat and given her a bloody nose in the past, but because it was years ago, was discounted, because apparently they were getting on now, what a joke
Exactly.
mountbattenbergcake · 29/10/2021 19:58

Their daughter:

"observed three violent incidents, one in which he held a knife to Jackson’s throat."

"In December the couple’s toxic relationship is said to have worsened when a row over a remote control resulted in her calling the police after she locked her husband in the conservatory, where he was brandishing a poker. Her computer’s search history showed she researched domestic violence refuges later that evening."

How is this not proof of an abusive marriage - witnesses, proof of police complaint and her search history from years ago?

All she's guilty of is appearing 'lucid'.

Userguaranteed · 29/10/2021 19:58

If she'd done it at the time when he held the knife to her throat, it would be a different matter. It would be self defence.

Userguaranteed · 29/10/2021 19:56

You don't kill someone years later in cold blood and cite the reason being that they held a knife to your throat years ago. Then expect an 'Oh well. That'll show him! It's alright then'.

What the hell sort of reasoning is happening here?

Dojacatpaws · 29/10/2021 19:54

So the daughter said he had held a knife to her mums throat and given her a bloody nose in the past, but because it was years ago, was discounted, because apparently they were getting on now, what a joke

SlugRose · 29/10/2021 19:53

@PurpleOkapi

Even supposing she was abused, having understandable reasons for wanting someone dead isn't the same as not being guilty of murder when you stab them.
I think this is the point a lot of people miss. It's not a get out of jail card to say you were abused.
mbosnz · 29/10/2021 19:53

The burden of proof was on the prosecution. They met the threshold. Beyond all reasonable doubt. She can appeal.

prh47bridge · 29/10/2021 19:53

The judge is a man then? Typical.

The judge did not decide to find her guilty of murder. That was the jury. The jury had the option to find her not guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter. All the judge will have done is explain the law to the jury and set the sentence.

Manslaughter is only a defence if she didnt mean to kill him

That's not actually correct. She could have been convicted of voluntary manslaughter on the basis that she intended to kill him but had suffered an extreme loss of control. That is one of three circumstances when you can be convicted of manslaughter even though you intended to kill the victim.