Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Penelope jackson guilty of murder

407 replies

Thomasina79 · 29/10/2021 16:51

I’ve been following this news item with interest. She is the woman who stabbed her violent and coercive and bullying husband to death after 20 years of torment. She denied murder, but admitted manslaughter.

Am I being unreasonable in thinking the jury should have not found her guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter. Murder carries a life sentence in prison and I cannot see that that there is anything to gain by locking her away.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
prh47bridge · 04/11/2021 23:22

‘Loss of control’ focuses on that moment in time, not the years that led up to it

That isn't entirely true. The trigger doesn't have to happen immediately before the loss of control. However, I agree that there are problems around the way the courts have interpreted the relevant legislation, which often seems to be the opposite of what parliament intended.

We are now much more aware of the impact of long term abuse on the mind

That has been used successfully to mount a diminished responsibility defence.

SheikhMaraca · 04/11/2021 22:07

@prh47bridge

I do think the law needs updating in this area to more accurately reflect the social mores of our post #MeToo era. Much of the legal authority was decided at a time when we viewed VAWG very differently than we do today.

It is actually loss of control rather than provocation these days. The current law was set in 2009 - perhaps more recently than you think.

The rate of social change has always outstripped the pace of change in the law, this is precisely the point.

‘Loss of control’ focuses on that moment in time, not the years that led up to it. We are now much more aware of the impact of long term abuse on the mind.

It reminds me of all the years we spent thinking that a woman who doesn’t fight back during a rape somehow consented. Now that we know better, we have different attitudes towards the offence of rape and consent in general.

Even 2009 is a lifetime ago in terms of social development, but I agree is is practically yesterday as far as the law is concerned.

I’m not sure what the answer is though, it’s a difficult one for sure.

prh47bridge · 04/11/2021 19:12

I do think the law needs updating in this area to more accurately reflect the social mores of our post #MeToo era. Much of the legal authority was decided at a time when we viewed VAWG very differently than we do today.

It is actually loss of control rather than provocation these days. The current law was set in 2009 - perhaps more recently than you think.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 04/11/2021 18:43

The judge sat through the whole case. We didn't. Here are his sentencing remarks. t.co/wrPjqhUfEL?amp=1

***
R v Penelope Jackson
Sentencing Remarks

  1. David Jackson was 78 years of age when you murdered him. He was a kind, gentle and caring
man. He was a loving father and grandfather who had battled through a number of serious illnesses and yet was still enjoying a well-earned retirement, having spent many years serving his country in the armed forces. He had plans for the year ahead and no doubt well beyond. All that was brought to an end on the 13th of February when you chose to stab him to death. That was a vindictive and cruel act on your part.
  1. I have no doubt whatsoever that you wrote the confession note in advance of inflicting the
first wound to his chest. I have no doubt you were aiming for his heart. As he was on the telephone speaking to the 999 operator you stabbed him twice more. You chose to stab him in the abdomen because you wanted to ensure that he would die. The confession that you wrote was composed in anticipation of achieving that end. I have no doubt that you intended to kill your husband and that this was a premeditated murder. Your own confession recognised that fact as it suggested two possibilities – premeditation or selfdefence. Your actions had nothing to do with that latter concept.
  1. Having inflicted fatal injuries you then spent 18 minutes talking to the emergency services
during which time you refused all their pleas to go David Jackson’s aid. He was alive for much of that 18 minute period and would have been able to hear what you were saying. At one stage in response to an enquiry as to whether he was still alert you called out to him by way of enquiry, but did so in a mocking fashion and with no thought of helping him. At other points you even contemplated stabbing him again and said so. Your behaviour during that call evidences a shocking level of callousness on your part.
  1. So why does a 67 year old woman of good character choose to murder her partner of 28
years? Despite professing to still love him you sought in this trial to portray David Jackson as a monster. Whilst there were no doubt tensions in the marriage, points of friction that lockdown will have accentuated, I am quite sure that he was nothing like the person you claimed. You were both strong willed people. Different characters in the sense that you are out going and he was less so, but that would have been complementary to a degree. There had been violence back in 1998 at a time when your husband was, as your daughter Isabelle described, a broken man following the suicide of his son Gavin. Such behaviour then, even in the circumstances that it came to take place, was of course very wrong. But your husband received treatment for the depressive state he was in at that low point in his life, and other evidence makes clear that you found it in yourself to forgive him and thereafter the marriage continued through what must, at many points, have been very happy times.
  1. In the months leading up to the killing I have no doubt you were unhappy. The events of the
23rd of December, when your husband broke the glass of the conservatory door in an effort to leave the property, clearly had an impact upon you. The footage that you took of that argument represented a deliberate attempt on your part to goad and torment your husband. It did not support your claim that you lived in fear of him. After he left that night you contacted him and asked him to come back. There was then a very happy family Christmas with your daughter and son-in-law.
  1. I have no doubt you reached a stage when you wanted out of the marriage. You knew that
your daughter would support you if you elected to separate. There were many other options open to you other than killing the person with whom you had lived for all those years. By choosing to do so you took the life of another human being and that is a terrible thing to do. It represents a burden that you and all the other family members will have to bear for the rest of their lives. You didn’t just kill a man who you once loved but you also deprived many others of someone they loved as well. There was no justification for so doing. Their memory of him will always be tarnished by the manner of his death and the way you have sought to portray him after depriving him of his life. During your four days giving evidence I did not detect a shred of genuine remorse on your part for the terrible crime that you have committed.
  1. I have heard moving victim personal testimony that underlines the enormous damage that
you have done. The loss to those who loved David Jackson is deep and irreparable. The evidence from Isabelle Potterton exemplifies the conflict those who care for you feel in the context of the loss that you have caused them. The sentence I have to impose can do nothing to bring an end to their grieving.
  1. Your age, good character and lifetime of service as an accountant with the Ministry of
Defence afford you some mitigation of which I take full account.
  1. The sentence for murder is life imprisonment. I have to set a minimum term applying
Schedule 21 to the Sentencing Code. The starting point by reference to that is 15 years. The aggravating features that I have outlined require significant upward movement, but that must be tempered to a degree to reflect the available mitigation. 10. In my judgment the minimum term that you must serve in prison is 18 years, less the days you have spent on remand which number 256. That term represents the minimum period you will be required to serve. After it is served, there is no guarantee that you will be released at that time, or at any particular time thereafter. It will then be for the Parole Board to decide if you are fit to be released. You must also understand that if, and when, you are released you will remain subject to licence for the rest of your life and may therefore be liable to be recalled. 11. The statutory surcharge will be added to the record. ************************
LittleDandelionClock · 04/11/2021 18:21

[quote namechangerino]**@LittleDandelionClock I believe it was mentioned in the court case that the child was so used to not receiving any attention from her mother (I use that term loosely) that she had learnt not to cry. Which is even more heart breaking.[/quote]
Awwww, how sad. Sad

SheikhMaraca · 04/11/2021 12:25

@ScienceSensibility

There are a number of legal defences to murder, which would reduce the crime to manslaughter.

Provocation is one of the defences. Sounds like she was massively abused over so many years to constitute provocation?

This.

Provocation, and diminished responsibility are statutory (partial) defences to a charge of murder.

Partial, as they reduce the crime from that of murder to manslaughter. They contrast with self defence, which can remove all responsibility and is therefore a full defence to murder.

I think it was the return and then further stabbing that would have been the issue here, as there wasn’t really a sudden loss of control.

I seem to recall another case in which the poor wife was abused for many many years, and finally snapped and stabbed her H.nether fact that she had sharpened the knife beforehand was enough to sink her claim of provocation.

I do think the law needs updating in this area to more accurately reflect the social mores of our post #MeToo era. Much of the legal authority was decided at a time when we viewed VAWG very differently than we do today.

A sad case all round,

Delatron · 04/11/2021 12:06

It’s heartbreaking. The poor child was suffering from flu so would also maybe have been too sick to cry out. It should have been murder ( I know legally it’s not but it’s worse in my eyes). Leaving a child alone to die of flu and dehydration.

namechangerino · 03/11/2021 23:58

@LittleDandelionClock I believe it was mentioned in the court case that the child was so used to not receiving any attention from her mother (I use that term loosely) that she had learnt not to cry. Which is even more heart breaking.

prh47bridge · 02/11/2021 23:01

9 years seems a light sentence

The offence appears to have been gross negligence manslaughter. It is clearly high culpability but I don't think there is enough to push it into the very high culpability category in the sentencing guidelines. The starting point for sentencing was therefore 8 years and the sentence had to fall in the range 6-12 years. It looks to me like the judge went for the maximum possible sentence (12 years) with a 25% discount for pleading guilty.

LittleDandelionClock · 02/11/2021 19:02

@ancientgran I know right. Sad The little girl must have been so frightened and desperate. She STARVED to death while her mum 'partied' for 6 days. Sickening. Hmm

What a dreadful, painful death that little girl must have suffered. The only very slight consolation is that the little girl is suffering no more, and doesn't have to suffer having that awful callous woman for a 'mother' anymore.

I think the woman should have been up on a murder charge to be honest.

One thing baffled me slightly about this whole case though. Surely someone must have heard that little girls cries and screams? She must have been crying/wailing/sobbing for a long time. How come no-one heard her/noticed her? This baffles me.

ancientgran · 02/11/2021 18:49

[quote LittleDandelionClock]@Felix125

There was another case recently where a young mother left her toddler alone whilst she went out partying. The child basically starved to death. I'm not sure if that has been to court yet - but it would be interesting to see what the sentence is there.

She got 9 years in prison. (I think this is the women you are referring to... Verphy Kudi.) She left her toddler alone for 6 days whilst she went partying. The poor little girl died of starvation and dehydration.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-sussex-58102792

Verphy got away with a manslaughter charge. Hmm Probably be out in 4 and a half years! She should be sterilised. yes, that IS what I said. She doesn't deserve to ever EVER have another child[/quote]
That is truly horrific and 9 years seems a light sentence, haven't read the article so maybe there are other factors but that poor child.

LittleDandelionClock · 02/11/2021 15:04

@Felix125

There was another case recently where a young mother left her toddler alone whilst she went out partying. The child basically starved to death. I'm not sure if that has been to court yet - but it would be interesting to see what the sentence is there.

She got 9 years in prison. (I think this is the women you are referring to... Verphy Kudi.) She left her toddler alone for 6 days whilst she went partying. The poor little girl died of starvation and dehydration.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-sussex-58102792

Verphy got away with a manslaughter charge. Hmm Probably be out in 4 and a half years! She should be sterilised. yes, that IS what I said. She doesn't deserve to ever EVER have another child

Wherearemymarbles · 01/11/2021 17:26

Jury had the facts. We dont
I hope she dies in prison

Whammyyammy · 01/11/2021 16:50

Correct verdict imo

Franklin12 · 01/11/2021 16:48

This is an unusual one. She had been married 4 times and one husband killed himself. She sounded flippant as though she had just done something a little foolish but never mind...no harm done.

Now that there can be further reporting on the case as a whole I think they were right to find her guility. Not one of us heard the case personally but I think the result was the right one.

She left three other husbands and I am struggling to think why she didnt leave him if he was doing the things she claims.

ancientgran · 31/10/2021 12:48

@mountbattenbergcake

The only one who mentioned abuse over many years was the murderer, she'd used the policve in the past but with no charges being brought. Being a woman does not make it all true.

But that’s not true. Eye witnesses (their dd) saw him holding a knife to her throat years ago and even his son said he had seen him raise a hand to her (he didn’t see him hit her but it’s still a threat of violence).

In both those examples he did control himself, if he hadn't he might have been on a murder charge. She didn't control herself, quite the opposite really as she came back for a second attack so she was on a murder charge.
Frigginintheriggin · 31/10/2021 08:26

We none of us know any of the actual details of their marriage. We weren't there, living in the house, every day.
In fact nobody who gave evidence was either. There were accounts from family and friends supporting and refuting the DV claim from both sides.
Whatever her motive to kill her husband that day , was heard in court and judged by a jury of her peers , which is our system in this country. She was represented by lawyers as is everyone's right in the UK.
At the end of the trial she was found guilty BEYOND REASONABLE DOUBT, that is how it works.
Her lawyers were unable to supply enough evidence to persuade the jury of her innocence or that the charge should be manslaughter.
She may well appeal.
All this speculation on here seems futile.
The families of these people have to live with the consequences of what happened every single day.
Its very sad for them.

mountbattenbergcake · 30/10/2021 17:58

@Helen0202

I 100% believe she should be locked away for life. I was best friends with her eldest daughter in the 90s when her husband "killed" himself. Even as a young teen I could see pure evil in her. If there was abuse I don't believe it was from him, ive seen it with my own eyes.
Pure evil? What’s this, Take a Break magazine?
itsgettingwierd · 30/10/2021 17:20

Thanks for correcting PH. I had read that but if it's being reported incorrectly it needs to be out there as it is. I did read the judge was quite scathing of him in his closing remarks.

KonTikki · 30/10/2021 15:40

Can't argue with that !

Helen0202 · 30/10/2021 15:30

I 100% believe she should be locked away for life. I was best friends with her eldest daughter in the 90s when her husband "killed" himself. Even as a young teen I could see pure evil in her.
If there was abuse I don't believe it was from him, ive seen it with my own eyes.

prh47bridge · 30/10/2021 15:29

@itsgettingwierd

A life sentence is mandatory for murder. Any man convicted of murder will also get a life sentence. The judge has no choice.

The judge has set the minimum term at 18 years which is a little above the starting point for this type of murder (15 years). A man who murdered someone and showed no remorse would be likely to get a similar sentence.

And the interesting case above of Peter who got diminished responsibility and a life sentence for manslaughter with DR.

The other man Anthony got 5 years with the same conviction.

I'd never really looked before at how varying sentences could be for the same conviction of crime. I guess that's where the judges opinion of the case comes in? But again - he has to base that opinion on facts presented to him/her and justify that?

Peter was not sentenced to life in prison, contrary to some reports. He was given a hybrid order under the Mental Health Act of life with a minimum term of 8 years.
DobbyTheHouseElk · 30/10/2021 15:28

I think because she wasn’t sorry she did it won’t have helped her case.

She wanted him dead. She hated him. He taunted her even as she was stabbing him that she was pathetic and not even stabbing him properly

This blew up because she served him “bubble and squeak” with lobster for a birthday dinner. He didn’t want the “bubble and squeak”.

itsgettingwierd · 30/10/2021 15:15

A life sentence is mandatory for murder. Any man convicted of murder will also get a life sentence. The judge has no choice.

The judge has set the minimum term at 18 years which is a little above the starting point for this type of murder (15 years). A man who murdered someone and showed no remorse would be likely to get a similar sentence.

And the interesting case above of Peter who got diminished responsibility and a life sentence for manslaughter with DR.

The other man Anthony got 5 years with the same conviction.

I'd never really looked before at how varying sentences could be for the same conviction of crime. I guess that's where the judges opinion of the case comes in? But again - he has to base that opinion on facts presented to him/her and justify that?

prh47bridge · 30/10/2021 15:04

There was another case recently where a young mother left her toddler alone whilst she went out partying. The child basically starved to death. I'm not sure if that has been to court yet - but it would be interesting to see what the sentence is there.

She was convicted of manslaughter and sentenced to 9 years.

She got 19 years. But the husband who murdered his wife recently, strangling her so hard his hands hurt, got 5 years after pleading dimished responsibility. I'm not convinced this is a fair sentence.

He was convicted of manslaughter, not murder, hence the difference in sentence. If Penelope Jackson had succeeded with her defence of loss of control, the starting point for sentencing would have been 8 years.