Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy a small property to rent out - would you? Have you? How have you found it?

108 replies

opalplumstead · 29/10/2021 13:02

I am currently about to apply for a buy to let interest only mortgage to buy a small house to let out.

I have had the mortgage illustration and it will cost me about £280 a month, (I already have a repayment mortgage for the house that I live in that is £600 a month).

I have had a rent estimate done and the estate agent thinks that the approximate rent would be £600-700 pcm.

I am new to all this - I only bought my own house 6 years ago! Is it worth doing? Or is it more hassle than it is worth? And any other advice or words of wisdom would be amazing.

TIA

OP posts:
maxelly · 29/10/2021 13:59

Yes you'd be better off asking or browsing through old threads on money matters or property and DIY, AIBU is good for opinions 😂 but not so much sensitive level headed advice. Look at some 'what should I do with my inheritance' threads for example, as buy to let is an option which often comes up and the pros and cons are well debated. My own personal view is that it really depends on your circumstances and can be a good option for an 'average' person looking to invest £25-30k, that has an existing moderate income from employment, minimal or no other savings and a basic occupational pension, an existing residential mortgage in the same or similar area as the planned BTL and no particular interest or skills in property management/refurbishment, there are much easier, safer and more tax efficient ways to invest your money. But there are people/circumstances where it's a good choice... Am happy to expand if you want to know more but it's all there in previous threads, it's a topic that comes up quite a lot...

lastqueenofscotland · 29/10/2021 13:59

you won’t get balanced replies from MN about landlords!
Do you have an FA? Ask them to go over the tax implications with you with a fine toothed comb.
If you aren’t an experienced landlord you’ll need to get it managed really which will be 10/11% so say £65pcm out of an already small profit of £300 add in repairs, certificates etc realistically looking spread out over the year about £100 profit a month?

It’s far too high risk for that sort of reward imo.

Blossomtoes · 29/10/2021 13:59

Honestly you would be completely mad to take on extra debt to do this at a time when interest rates are rising.

This. And as a result, don’t rely on capital growth. A lot of people are going to fall into mortgage arrears in the next few years and I predict property prices falling as a consequence.

catsareme14 · 29/10/2021 13:58

I had a rental , bad experiences even though the agency checked references. I would never do it again .

minimecantrollerskate · 29/10/2021 13:52

OP, you asked in the wrong place, you would be better off asking in Property.

There is a high demand for rental property at the moment, so it would not be a daft decision and property should always increase in value bar a few exceptions.

You need to look at the overall picture. You would get the rent each month, less agents fees if you use one. You need proper Landlords insurance and the property must have EPC and electrical certificate and smoke alarms and carbon monoxide detectors. If you don't use an agent then you will need to protect the deposit yourself.

I would use an agent certainly to find a tenant and do all the proper checks and credit referencing etc even if you don't want to use one ongoing.

You will need to do a tax return to declare the income. Interest can't be set against the rent any more, but you can claim a tax credit of 20% if you have paid tax elsewhere, and you need to factor in tax that might be due, plus accountancy fees (shop around). I would have the rents paid into a separate bank account and pay all expenses out of it and then leave the balance to cover tax and repairs. You will also need to pay utilities if the property is empty between tenants.

You are also responsible for all repairs and maintenance so if the cooker breaks down you repair/buy a new one etc.

You will need to pay stamp duty on the purchase as you already own a house.

and be aware that interest rates are only going to go one way which is up, so fix your rate for as long as you can, and consider whether it is still affordable if the rate goes up.

Have a look on local estate agents websites for fees, or ring round a few and ask what their fees and commissions are, how often they do inspections etc.

Cosyblankets · 29/10/2021 13:50

You won't get a balanced opinion on here as many posters are of the opinion that landlords are the devil.
I've recently done this. Take financial advice and look for the best deal. You're paying more than I am for a similar return.
We have shelled out a fair bit on boiler and electrics etc so that we know it's all new. We did all the decorating ourselves but it was all day every day for a couple of months.
Our tenants do not want to buy for their own personal reasons so we are not depriving any families before all the haters start.
We used an agent to do all the background checks, credit references etc and then we took over. We have all the safety certificates and we know a plumber and an electrician that we can trust
We've taken out landlord insurance with legal protection.
We learnt quite a bit from doing it up. We learnt that things always cost more than you think, we learnt that sometimes it's easier to rip out than work with what you've got.
Shop around for the best deal on interest rates and broker fees. Even if you're using an agent go and do the viewings yourself. There was one in particular who would have passed the checks on paper but there was a few things they said at the viewing that stood out to me as they would be hard work as an individual. So I turned them down.
Would we do it again? It's early days and we'd need to work round our jobs when that allows but yes we would. In the same area. And definitely not a new build because they're not as well built

whiteroseredrose · 29/10/2021 13:50

Can I also throw in increasing interest rates?

Haven't major lenders just upped their rates a little? And if inflation increases the rates may go up more.

opalplumstead · 29/10/2021 13:49

Yes I am a bit worried about rising interest rates @ErrolTheDragon (and anyone else who has mentioned this). However

I do also worry about house prices potentially crashing with all the brexit stuff and just how volatile everything seems atm :(

I meant to say as well, I am putting down a £30k deposit its not all mortgage

OP posts:
BritInUS1 · 29/10/2021 13:49

I have a few properties and it's worth it for me, but you have to go in with your eyes open

Make sure you understand the tax implications
Make sure you have funds for repairs, if it's empty, if the rent doesn't get paid, etc

ErrolTheDragon · 29/10/2021 13:46

DH rented out his parents’ house for a few years, firstly while MiL was in a nursing home and then after she died. It was a lot of work (even with an agent), lots of expense - even with no mortgage to pay it really wasn’t a good ‘investment’ versus other things. And then he had a tenant from hell, the stress of dealing with him (together with inadequate agents) resulted in a heart problem.

Taking out a mortgage to let (especially interest only…. You’re not really ‘buying’, are you) seems like a risky move, especially as there are signs that the era of rock bottom interest rates may not last forever.

opalplumstead · 29/10/2021 13:43

Thanks for all the responses, really helpful.

I do understand and was expecting the landlord hate, I hated them passionately myself when I was renting!

OP posts:
Greenrubber · 29/10/2021 13:40

@Salmakia

Thats very unfair not everyone is out to make a quick buck

We are going to be letting our house out because we would take a major loss if we sold it
We need to move to the other end of the country and need to pay a property company to look after our let so once you take out the cost of them the mortage itself and money aside for any problems broken boiler for example your not left with much

Obviously they are paying your mortgage so in the long run you do well but not everyone can get on the ladder in the first place and believe it or not some people don't want to

DameCelia · 29/10/2021 13:37

TAX

Additional stamp duty when you buy.
Tax on rental income while you own it.
Capital gains tax when you sell.

Make sure you've factored all of those in.

Then compare the actual income you'd make against the value of overpaying your current mortgage by the same amount you'd spend on your btl.

(Btw for the avoidance of doubt I think you should pay all if the above)

Guacamole001 · 29/10/2021 13:32

I did it for a couple of years but some tenants moan about everything and the agents were crap.

PooWillyNameChange · 29/10/2021 13:31

I probably wouldn't.

We moved from our old house during the pandemic in a hurry due to job loss/change, not knowing if we would need to come back, and got tenants in the meantime. Our mortgage on it is about £600 pcm and we get rent of £1100 from two lovely doctors who haven't been any trouble, but compared to just investing the £600+ in stocks and shares each month there's a fair bit of admin throughout the year including self assessment and lots of costs. Once our current tenants decide to move on, now we know we won't be going back, we will sell.

If you're passionate about doing it, really want to be a landlord, can weather it being empty a few months and still pay the mortgage, don't mind getting a call in the middle of the night re. repairs (or paying an agent every month for management) then it's a model many use to invest but I'd make sure you're absolutely sure you understand CGT, income tax, listing/management costs, insurance, mortgage arrangement fees every X years, how much you need to set aside for repairs, and all the legal obligations such as electricity and gas testing. There are so many costs involved, it is often slim margins, plus the gov't are likely to increasingly make it harder as a business model to deter buy to lets.

LalalalalalaLand123 · 29/10/2021 13:29

If you do it, make sure you budget in all the associated costs of maintenance, unexpected repairs and appliance replacement, taxes, estate agent fees, etc etc. All these things can really add up. Get good insurance for things like boiler, repairs etc.

VanCleefArpels · 29/10/2021 13:28

I have 6 properties, have done fir some years so I have git the T shirt.

Do not do this unless you have considerable savings that would cover the worst possible scenario you could think of (perhaps boiler blowing up, causing an internal flood, you get my drift) PLUS the legal fees that you will need to shell out if you have to evict a tenant.

There is very little profit in the Lettings game now as you cannot deduct mortgage interest from your income for tax purposes, there is an increasingly long list of landlord requirements (quite rightly) and other costs are high. If you decide to manage the property yourself Sod’s law dictates that you will get a call about an essential repair when you are sitting in an airport departure lounge. If you pay an agent that’s another 10% cost off the rent. So make sure you have a reliable plumber, electrician, handyman, appliance repair person etc on hand.

I could bang on. The reason why I have property is to take advantage of capital growth not for income, and my portfolio is not mortgaged so I have high reserves.

Honestly you would be completely mad to take on extra debt to do this at a time when interest rates are rising.

hibbledibble · 29/10/2021 13:28

According to Mumsnet landlords are akin to puppy killers, so don't expect balanced replies here.

Personally, I would carefully consider the tax implications, and possible costs, including maintenance, tenants not paying rent and damage to the property.

Cupidity · 29/10/2021 13:22

Would you be able to easily afford to cover the mortgage repayments in case the house is unrented for several months? Or if the tenant doesn't pay? How long would you fix the interest for (bearing in mind that rates have been historically low, and likely to rise).

You'll need to save up some of the rent money to use as a slush fund, for redecorating, boiler replacements, fixing fence panels, general repairs, etc.

You can go via an agency, but they'll take a cut of the rental income.

Calculate the costs of annual landlord insurance, any ground rent & service charges, gas safety checks, electric checks, in a couple of years there will be new EPC rules coming in (property should be at least a band c), etc.

As long as you're confident that house prices will continue to stay stable/rise then an interest only mortgage might be the way to go, especially if you plan to pay off chunks before remortgaging.

PiglingBlonde · 29/10/2021 13:22

I wouldn't. The Government have been making noises for ages about removing S21 of the Housing Act 1988 and amend the grounds for repossessing the property to stop no fault evictions. It would still be possible to get rid of tenants who are damaging the property or not paying rent (on time or at all) but very much more difficult to evict tenants because the property could fetch more rent (for example).

assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/819270/A_New_Deal_for_Renting_Resetting_the_Balance_of_Rights_and_Responsibilities_between_Landlords_and_Tenants.pdf

I think it is very brave to invest in a BTL while this is settling - it is quite likely that a large number of people will decide to offload in quite a hurry if this goes through, which could damage the capital value of the property as well.

NailsNeedDoing · 29/10/2021 13:22

You will get ridiculous responses asking that on here, there are a lot of people on MN who seem to lose any sanity when it comes to talking about landlords/rental properties because they are too filled with hate.

I am a landlord but I use an agency to deal with everything. It makes life easier but the fees take a big chunk of the rent. Think about whether you’d want to manage yourself or have it done for you, and what exactly you want to achieve from it.

Do you want to make profit now, or would you see it as an investment that you won’t profit from for years?

If you’d be paying a mortgage, it would be unlikely to make you much, if any profit any time soon.

DampSquidGames · 29/10/2021 13:20

I did this and I rent the property to my DC, it’s working out well.

AwkwardPaws27 · 29/10/2021 13:17

You might be better off overpaying your own mortgage and clearing it early instead. You'll save money on interest and be mortgage free sooner.
What if your rental property needs repairs, maintenance, or is vacant for a while (or a tenant became unable to pay)? Would you be able to comfortably cover costs & pay both mortgages? I'm not sure how much of the income would be lost to letting agents & tax.

FakeFruitShoot · 29/10/2021 13:16

We could afford to do it but find it unethical.

Maybe it depends on where you live - possibly acceptable (to me, we all need to have our own sense of values and ethics which vary for everyone) in a student area or an area with quite a transient workforce. In our area, we'd basically be depriving a family who happened to have the misfortune to be setting up home together 10 years later than us from getting their own mortgage, by making them pay off ours instead. It'd pretty gross when you think about it.

whereisthekey · 29/10/2021 13:15

silly comments above. Plenty of people.want to rent and not buy and you need a good supply of rented housing with good landlords.
Just consider tax implications, maintenance costs and time, and additional stamp duty.
To make it worth while realistically you should be looking at repayment mortgage rather than interest only, unless u are picking up a house for next to nothing and charging huge rents somehow.