Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get friends kids second hand presents

135 replies

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 29/10/2021 12:45

I’m a big fan of buying second hand; try to get my kids presents and Christmas stockings from charity shops or free Facebook groups. I can afford new but don’t like buying new, mainly for environmental reasons.

I usually get my kids friends new presents but was thinking of getting them from charity shops this year, obviously would only do it if the present suits the kids, like one friends son loves trains and found a great Thomas puzzle in a charity shop.

What do people think about this?

AIBU- buy new if you can
YANBU- charity shop it

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
yourestandingonmyneck · 02/11/2021 09:06

My kids love charity shops. They love choosing toys for themselves and also for their friends.

They also love the fact that they can use their own "pennies" to buy their friends gifts as they are not as expensive as buying brand new in shops.

A group of us do this and are happy to do so, because we are all similarly minded about the environment.

But I agree it's difficult because some people have sneering attitudes towards it, but I really, really hope this is changing and I think it is.

During lockdown when the shops were shut, people tried to source what they needed on Gumtree / FB marketplace and from what I can see this has continued, which I am so happy to see.

Our local primary school fb page is full of parents posting "does anybody have a (toy/item of clothing etc) that they are selling before I buy new?" and I love seeing it. It's not about being cheap, it's about reducing consumption.

StarfishDish · 31/10/2021 18:57

@PurpleishDahlia

I'm thinking of mentioning charity shop books for baby daughter, I'm hoping they'll go for it.
@PurpleishDahlia We've asked for books this year for our baby daughter. However, somebody suggested a book voucher instead so you don't end up with the same books? :)
minimecantrollerskate · 31/10/2021 15:22

I have just sold loads of toiletries and makeup on Vinted, all brand new, but somebody will snap up a bargain for a Christmas present. Everyone is happy.

On the charity shop front , while I do love them, some of them are getting quite expensive. I queried a price this week, a Primark Harry Potter bag priced at £9.50. It was in excellent condition, but only cost £10 new. I queried it and they let DD have it for £4.50.

I didn't begrudge the charity the money, but DD only had so much to spend and that bag was a rip off. All her money went in charity shops that day on books mainly.

halloweenqwueeeen · 31/10/2021 10:42

@EmeraldShamrock yes I’ve heard that a lot about charity shops! Obviously I understand their goal is to raise as much money as possible but i wish they would be the help the less fortunate in our local community by allowing them access to lower priced items.

This is why I tend to donate to a local church playgroup instead, they have a clothing bank too and do amazing work with struggling families.

Tal45 · 31/10/2021 10:28

I buy secondhand presents for us and for family who are happy with that but I wouldn't for friends. Why not just give some money in a card instead?

EmeraldShamrock · 31/10/2021 10:16

It’s not for me to decide what’s good enough for other people, they make their own decisions and choices.

I like to donate to a local playgroup, or second choice would be a charity shop, I would only bin if it was broken.

I think it is fine to buy new toys if that is your preference, I do it at Christmas and Birthdays.
Someone has to do it.
The main thing is you recycled the toys.
I gave ours to neighbours less fortunate or the DC'S playschool.
I was really poor when DS was little he wasn't diagnosed but I had to stop working, I saw a remote batman toy in the window of a charity shop, it was priced at €40 no remote, missing pieces.
The item new was €50.
I wouldn't give or buy from them anymore.
I use free cycle to pass them on.
Didn't realise eco people used free cycle I assumed the items were going to someone in need otherwise I'd sell it

halloweenqwueeeen · 31/10/2021 08:41

[quote SleepingStandingUp]@halloweenqwueeeen so yes it's good enough for others, but not you. At least you're not binning it. I'm more horrified by pointless landfill.[/quote]
It’s not for me to decide what’s good enough for other people, they make their own decisions and choices.

I like to donate to a local playgroup, or second choice would be a charity shop, I would only bin if it was broken.

PurpleishDahlia · 31/10/2021 06:13

I'm thinking of mentioning charity shop books for baby daughter, I'm hoping they'll go for it.

PurpleishDahlia · 31/10/2021 06:12

I would be delighted if all my presents this year were second hand, but I can't suggest that to my husband's family, they'll think it's very odd.

45redballoons · 31/10/2021 06:07

Are people suggesting they'd throw the gift away purely for the fact it is secondhand?

Honestly, I'd be unlikely to be friends with someone like that. Obviously whatever you buy has to be in perfect condition and I'd have higher standards for a gift than my own children, but na, someone who thought like that wouldn't be for me.

I am trying to buy more second hand, especially when they are young and its just plastic and they don't have many preferences yet. When you buy new there is no guarantee they will play with it, I don't see why the risk is higher if it isn't.

I agree though, it is good to check with parents so at least they know its OK to reciprocate.

allthegoodusernameshavegone · 31/10/2021 06:00

More people should have your attitude and both parents & children be grateful for any gifts given. A secondhand gift is a wonderful idea.

StTherese · 31/10/2021 05:50

I've donated lots of things to our local hospice charity shop, and DH has had a few 'rare' vinyl records from CS.
I wouldn't buy gifts from there - I find CS all have a certain smell that seems to permeate everything. (Not being judgey, I do have a very sensitive sense of smell.)

I do recycle/regift unwanted presents though. Particularly toiletry gift sets!

UnsuitableHat · 31/10/2021 05:47

Sounds fine to me - kids aren’t going to care. I’ve bought 2nd hand books for friends’ children a few times, because the book looked like something they’d really enjoy.

Tilltheend99 · 31/10/2021 05:43

YANBU as it’s good for the environment but I have a few relatives who do this and three times out of five I am given something hideous that I would never use so ends up back in the charity shop again. If you are just buying for kids it is probably easier as is much more kids stuff around.

Offmyfence · 31/10/2021 05:39

@BananaPB

I would talk to your friend. Personally I wouldn't mind second hand jigsaws but if you've spend 50p and I've spent £20 on a new item then I wouldn't be too impressed.
Why? If someone had bought a present that is ideal for your child, what has cost got to do with it?

I mean

DS loves Lego, friend sees a fabulous set in a charity shop (worth maybe £30 new), but it costs £5 in charity shop. She buys it DS loves it, the friend had benefited, the charity has benefited, the environment has benefited but you'd be pissed off because you'd spent more?

You'd rather a £20 gift that your DS would not necessarily enjoy as much, but it means friend has spent the same amount?

Really?

OP YANBU and it's not about cost, it's about thought. If the gift is one the child would like, then good on you. I'd not be bothered at all, wouldn't give it any head space!

NeverForgetYourDreams · 31/10/2021 05:38

[quote OnceuponaRainbow18]@halloweenqwueeeen

Why wouldn’t you? I couldn’t imagine buying everything new- expensive and terrible for the environment.[/quote]
If No one bought new then there would be nothing used for you to buy

I buy new. We aren't frivolous proper without expensive hobbies and so I do like to buy brand new stuff fir myself.

DockOTheBay · 31/10/2021 05:30

I don't give to them anymore and usually give to free cycle with a person whose in genuine need

How do you know someone in free cycle is in genuine need of something? I've had stuff from free cycle i could really have afforded but why would you pay if someone is offering it for free.

DockOTheBay · 31/10/2021 05:26

I just don’t like the idea of it, you don’t know what kind of life second hand items have had

Oh I know, those toys could have been... played with by another child 😱
/s

You can tell what kind of life they've had by their condition. If they're in good condition, they have been well looked after. What else could possibly have happened?

HappyDays40 · 31/10/2021 03:42

Id live you if you spent money in a charity shop for my son. My mum an dad did it fir his birthday a d bought him 50.00 worth of charity shop toys. He got new lego bat cave and about four other presents. I lovecthe fact that they did this.

Sometimeswinning · 31/10/2021 01:14

Personally I wouldn't mind second hand jigsaws but if you've spend 50p and I've spent £20 on a new item then I wouldn't be too impressed

You're kidding right?? What is wrong with these entitled parents??

EmeraldShamrock · 31/10/2021 00:45

In your situation I'd buy them vouchers for the cinema or a fancy burger bar, adventure day trips.
There's plenty of gifts without buying tat if money is not a problem.

SleepingStandingUp · 31/10/2021 00:24

@halloweenqwueeeen so yes it's good enough for others, but not you. At least you're not binning it. I'm more horrified by pointless landfill.

Yetano · 31/10/2021 00:10

I'd love this, but plenty of people would not.
I floated the idea one Christmas and it went down badly with some. I'd have a chat first.
It also depends on how good the charity shops in your area are. Near me they're amazing and I rarely buy anything new, but not all area are the same.

Notjustabrunette · 31/10/2021 00:06

I buy lots of second hand toys, and once my kids have out grown them I either return to the charity shop or pass on to friends. I’m totally open with everyone that I do this. I wouldn’t buy someone else a second hand gift though. You could always buy consumables like art and crafts materials or an experience voucher if the didn’t want to to buy something new.

EmeraldShamrock · 31/10/2021 00:03

The chance of finding them something they'll like is slim.
It also pushes the prices up for the people who can't afford to buy new.
Now that recycling and buying seconds is good for the environment the whole charity shop circle is broken.
It was a case of supporting the charity and the community, now charity shops price off eBay maximising profits.
I don't give to them anymore and usually give to free cycle with a person whose in genuine need in mind not someone who doesn't like buying new.