Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are you obese?

182 replies

Beautybunny · 29/10/2021 07:28

I have been following a fab thread regarding others not being obese. Lots of posters that are obese have commented that the strategies other have don't work for them. I have tried many diets, acupuncture, fasting, diet pills etc. In my adult life I have been a size 8 and a size 22. Food and wine are my comfort in unhappy times. I have a nutrition qualification and am a very competent cook. I was also a vegetarian for years. I like my veg. Never had a weight problem until I had my children. Their births were followed by a harrowing law suit and then a bereavement. I have lost weight on and off in the last twenty years but generally I have been fat and getting fatter as I now take steriods for RA. I also have an under active thyroid. I find slimming groups difficult as the logic can be a bit bonkers (mashed banana is a syn etc). I also work away so the personal trainer approach is not convenient. Has anyone used a good therapist /weight loss guru? I know my weight is my amour against attack, it started in my childhood. If I have a shitty employer I put on weight, conversely I had a great one in 2016/17 and lost two stone naturally. I would love any suggestions.

OP posts:
GTAlogic · 29/10/2021 12:39

I'm not now: I'm slowly losing the weight and am now 2lb under the obese range. Woo-hoo!
I was obese because I was eating massive portions, loads of chocolate and am a boredom eater.
I am losing it because I took some medication that took away my appetite and then felt like I didn't need to eat as much to feel full. I'm also doing other things when I'm bored.

bordersroaming · 29/10/2021 12:27

Yes, I have a good genetic tolerance to alcohol unfortunately!

Sunshinedrops85 · 29/10/2021 12:25

*the

Sunshinedrops85 · 29/10/2021 12:25

I comfort eat when stressed.

Used to go gym 6 days a week pre covid. Haven't got back into he swing of it again.

hamstersarse · 29/10/2021 12:25

This is a really nice podcast about food addition / emotional eating. In depth and considerate.

thisjungianlife.com/episode-31-food-addiction/

Beautybunny · 29/10/2021 12:18

Genes? Habits I think, although boozing has been proven to be part of a DNA pattern.
My brothers are slim, my sister and I fat. My parents loved food. Dad obese in old age, mum always until she developed cancer. A little extra money? Feast time. Horrible situation? come round to eat. Both War babies. I cook for my friends and family. My children luckily are slim. Son athelite, daughter dieted off excess weight and has an app! I think am lonely too as many people have said.

OP posts:
shouldistop · 29/10/2021 12:11

@EmotionalSupportBear well done on your weight loss!

bordersroaming · 29/10/2021 12:07

You do realise that saying "genes , both parents are overweight " is concerning

People say genes as an excuse to themselves
And yes genes will have a role
But unless you also want to say that genetically poor people are very different to rich people you have to accept that genes is only a small part of the picture

From observation, it's not genes but the bad habits of your parents that is inherited

That can be portion size, daily menus , how much oil you typically put in a pan, use of food for comfort , treats and rewards

EmotionalSupportBear · 29/10/2021 11:57

genes (both parents are overweight)
hormones (pcos)
health (i'm disabled and asthmatic, swimming is only safe exercise and i don't currently feel safe going swimming)
diet/lifestyle (links into health issues.. kids have speciality diets, so i rarely have the spoons to cook a 3rd meal for myself, so pick/eat convenience food)
insomnia (well known factor in weight gain, i get less than 5hrs sleep on average)

i am losing weight though, doing intermittent fasting and down 10kg so far :)

knackeredcat · 29/10/2021 11:54

Perimenopause, crap genes, crap metabolism (borderline hypothyroid), meds, fatigue from neurodiverse related masking and trying to pass as "normal", CPTSD (so probably impaired adrenals), can't be arsed-ness, secretly glad of increasing invisibility.

I'm not a huge eater but I do like wine and chocolate - I've cut down on both. I've completely ditched bread, etc. and cut down on as many carbs as I can. Yay, konjac noodles...

I have managed to lose nearly 2 stone over the past few months through meal replacements (2 x vegan protein shakes a day) but it will probably go back on as has happened all my life. I've lost up to 5 stone before through being prescribed Xenical, almost starving myself and very punishing exercise regimes that I don't have time or energy for now. Plus even if I did I'm not sure they'd be as effective at this age.

Classicblunder · 29/10/2021 11:52

I like food (not processed food particularly, my weaknesses are things like cheese) and alcohol and I don't enjoy exercise. I keep my BMI to 28-31 through conscious effort.

CounsellorTroi · 29/10/2021 11:51

I am overweight, BMI 27.9. I was a healthy weight until my thyroid started to malfunction. I lost 2st doing Weightwatchers 7 years ago but have put it all back. I eat a healthy diet, am a member of a gym, do spin classes, rowing, weights machines and swim regularly. I do like my wine, but watch my intake.

Beautybunny · 29/10/2021 11:50

@tiredanddangerous

My mother took me to slimming clubs too. I was a 14 and 5'10". I had been a very skinny kid but my older brother use to contaminate my food so I didn't eat much. Size 12 when I met my husband. I realised I had married too quickly so I stopped eating. I went down to a 8. Very skinny. I then met someone else but I went back to my husband as my mother shamed me into it. My weight shot up. My husband is big too. I didn't really know him and tbh I probably married to get away from home. Decades later I grew to love him but we have had so much trauma I just eat to feel better. My GP doesn't help. Thinks, educated, good job, why can't you stop overeating? Tbh I don't know why. I use to be a shagger before I met the husband, perhaps that is the answer, except I am so body embrassed!

OP posts:
wouldyoudothistoo · 29/10/2021 11:41

Trauma in childhood (developmental trauma of childhood/CPTSD) being diagnosis, I learnt eating made me feel safe and happy - at 30 I regret it as I’m now 22 stone .

I’ve also got PCOS, dyspraxia, and I’m very, very unhappy and lonely - so it’s all a vicious cycle .

Nachostress · 29/10/2021 11:38

I'm not obese now but I have been (fluctuating weight like a lot of people I guess) Mine was comfort eating, in a way that meant my weight gradually crept up over the years. The difference is always when I've got the time/money to do hobbies that make me happy. Without that, I sit on the sofa of an evening and think about what I can eat to make my day better.
I don't have the higher appetite issue that a lot of people have so I'm lucky in that regard I think.

Gymohithoughtyousaidgin · 29/10/2021 11:36

@Beautybunny

I have been following a fab thread regarding others not being obese. Lots of posters that are obese have commented that the strategies other have don't work for them. I have tried many diets, acupuncture, fasting, diet pills etc. In my adult life I have been a size 8 and a size 22. Food and wine are my comfort in unhappy times. I have a nutrition qualification and am a very competent cook. I was also a vegetarian for years. I like my veg. Never had a weight problem until I had my children. Their births were followed by a harrowing law suit and then a bereavement. I have lost weight on and off in the last twenty years but generally I have been fat and getting fatter as I now take steriods for RA. I also have an under active thyroid. I find slimming groups difficult as the logic can be a bit bonkers (mashed banana is a syn etc). I also work away so the personal trainer approach is not convenient. Has anyone used a good therapist /weight loss guru? I know my weight is my amour against attack, it started in my childhood. If I have a shitty employer I put on weight, conversely I had a great one in 2016/17 and lost two stone naturally. I would love any suggestions.
You need to change your psychological approach/relationship to food. If your using it as a comfort or to fill a gap or boredom/habit etc it's a habit you need to learn to change. I agree that all these diet groups are not sustainable long term and don't work for every one. Weight loss is just simy calories in vs calories out. Exercise is important too but diet more so. You say you know what foods to eat which is a great start. I use my fitness pal to track my meals as it allows me to work out my macros and stay within my limits. I also go to the gym 3 times a week but if your away alot you could try and do YouTube workout videos at your home/hôtel etc instead. Losing weight isn't easy and it takes alot of time and dedication. I'm not obese naturally however I had my second child 5 months ago and had put on a considerable amount of weight so have been working hard to lose it. It's a long journey but you can do it op. I plan all my meals, bulk cook and eat well Monday to Friday. I so relax at weekends and do my best not to over do it with cheat meals but it does happen on occasion. There are also some days when I am so drained that il grab a jar of Nutella and a spoon.... 🥄😂. There are lots of people on here to offer support when you need it and I hope it goes well for you! :) x
Fernhilde · 29/10/2021 10:56

Decades of Binge Eating Disorder and no treatment available in my region.

tiredanddangerous · 29/10/2021 10:44

It's such a complex issue and I've never managed to unravel it.

I was an unhappy child with parents who weren't around much (worked long hours) and very low self esteem. I would get home from school and raid the snack cupboard then make myself a microwave meal for dinner, followed by a big bowl of ice cream for pudding. Comfort eating I guess. I would eat and eat whilst sobbing.

I was twice the size of the other children when I started school at 5 though so presumably was only eating what my parents fed me at that point. No 4/5 year old can be blamed for being obese, can they?

I'm also autistic and I think that makes things more complicated. I can't bear the feeling of hunger. It feels physically painful and makes me feel sick. I also get a pounding headache.

My mum had a fucked up relationship with food and was always on some diet or another. She took me along to weight watchers in my teens and at other times let me do stupid meal replacement diets with her. That also can't have helped, although I'm sure she thought she was helping.

I'm in my forties now and a good six stone overweight. Food is my comfort and my punishment. I don't think I deserve to look better and have nice things. I have tried and tried over the years not I don't think I will ever be able to fix myself.

Beautybunny · 29/10/2021 10:39

@LindaEllen

Greedy bastard is funny!
I am a scoffer. I can scoff celery!!

I do love food. Curry and nectarines are my favourite. Can be low cal. Its the other bits that effect me. Food props. More hugs and I probably wouldn't eat so much. A bit of praise too.

OP posts:
Franticbutterfly · 29/10/2021 10:39

That's an interesting question. I am
Naturally a very stocky person (particularly on the top half) and despite being very active and fit (I exercise several times per week) if I eat what I think is a normal amount I gain weight. My mum also carries extra weight and is not a huge eater at all (although doesn't move much). I, on the other hand love to cook and bake (although I've not been baking much as I'm trying to lose weight atm). I also love snacks which has got me to the weight I am now. Well that an a lot of emotional ups and downs over the years.

The solution for me is to exercise quite hard most days, keep active and moving a lot during the day, and aim to eat about 1700kcal a day with lots of veg. It's coming off slowly but is manageable. I may have to pick up the kettlebells again to boost my weight loss as it has slowed a bit.

I always joke that if there was a famine I'd be the last one standing, I feel like my body doesn't need food in the same way as other people's does, I can water fast for 3 days quite easily. I have also developed a bit of an unhealthy way of looking at food. It makes me feel guilt when I eat. So that probably hasn't helped.

Beautybunny · 29/10/2021 10:32

@Rotundpig
I am sorry you are having such a hard time. I am 8 stone overweight. I buy fabulous clothes but I still look like an apple with legs!
My job is stressful but I changed careers to the charity sector and they were no better. I thought they would be nice, outsiders not welcome! I now work for a beauty company again and we do have some big girls but I hate being big. I want to swim and not feel people are staring. I want to buy clothes in stores and not order off line. I have a weird obsession with clothes as my mother made me wear my sisters hand me downs. I have thought about weight loss surgery but have just heard of an unsuccessful case. The lady is still unhappy and can't eat more than 4 mouthfuls. Also skin tucks are now needed.

OP posts:
LindaEllen · 29/10/2021 10:31

Because I have a sedentary desk job with ridiculous hours, a sedentary hobby two evenings a week (so I don't exercise enough) and I'm a greedy bastard on top of it.

Sometimes when DP is out I feel out of control because I just cannot stop myself eating. It's horrible.

Driposaurus · 29/10/2021 10:24

I stress eat.
I love cooking and baking.
I am a feeder.
I was always overweight, even as a young child. My (overweight/obese) parents’ solution was to keep scales in the kitchen and weigh us every week, make us do a rosemary Conley exercise tape weekly but (and this blows my mind) we were still encouraged to eat our whole plates and serve huge portions of ice cream every day as dessert. All the women in my mums family are big.

Now I eat healthy meals but turn to chocolate when I need to feel better about myself m, can’t leave an empty plate. I hate myself even as I’m doing it as I know I’m doing terrible things to myself.

Hippywannabe · 29/10/2021 10:23

@Beautybunny don't cry!
It can be done, it isn't easy and a lifetime of thinking about it sits on our shoulders all the time. I feel that burden more than the physical weight sometimes.
Doing the plan I am on now has made me feel free of that (most of the time).
Being obese is more mental than physical in my opinion x

Rebuildingconfidence · 29/10/2021 10:18

I'm obese because I eat too much and very unhealthily. It's also genetic, my dad's side of the family, who I take after, gain weight easily.

I use food to deal with stress, anxiety, and low mood. I eat a lot of cheese, crisps, crackers, etc, so a lot of snacking on crap.

In the last few months I have started focusing on getting more sleep as tiredness is a huge trigger for me to overeat. I am sleeping better now but the weight isn't going down.

I am in denial about how bad my diet is but I don't know how to change it.