Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are you obese?

182 replies

Beautybunny · 29/10/2021 07:28

I have been following a fab thread regarding others not being obese. Lots of posters that are obese have commented that the strategies other have don't work for them. I have tried many diets, acupuncture, fasting, diet pills etc. In my adult life I have been a size 8 and a size 22. Food and wine are my comfort in unhappy times. I have a nutrition qualification and am a very competent cook. I was also a vegetarian for years. I like my veg. Never had a weight problem until I had my children. Their births were followed by a harrowing law suit and then a bereavement. I have lost weight on and off in the last twenty years but generally I have been fat and getting fatter as I now take steriods for RA. I also have an under active thyroid. I find slimming groups difficult as the logic can be a bit bonkers (mashed banana is a syn etc). I also work away so the personal trainer approach is not convenient. Has anyone used a good therapist /weight loss guru? I know my weight is my amour against attack, it started in my childhood. If I have a shitty employer I put on weight, conversely I had a great one in 2016/17 and lost two stone naturally. I would love any suggestions.

OP posts:
Beautybunny · 01/11/2021 08:19

Well ladies I have opened the Facebook page. Let me know if you would like to join. It is a private closed group. It is just a chat form so we can support each other. Your comments over the weekend have really helped me. I have 'mindfully' eaten for the last three days and haven't been on the booze either.

OP posts:
frumpety · 01/11/2021 06:39

@KatherineofGaunt

I've started CBT for depression and it's making me realise that by sitting around, I'm depressing myself because things don't get done, or I get stressed because I "haven't had time" to get things done. When I'm actual fact a large part of my day involves sitting and eating.

This is so me ! except the eating bit, I have stopped eating to excess, just need to work on the sitting Smile I don't know about you, but when I was depressed I found it difficult to focus and find a routine, so it felt like I was constantly firefighting, everything last minute or missed, if I missed stuff then I felt guilty, constantly feeling like I was letting everyone down.

Fernhilde · 31/10/2021 20:48

Hi I would be interested in joining the fb group if allowed please

KatherineofGaunt · 31/10/2021 19:05

The one time I got to my lowest ever adult weight, I was doing WW with a friend and ended up being one of the volunteers helping out every week. The leader then quit and I put everything back on and more.

So I know losing weight with someone really helps, but I don't think doing WW is the answer. I've been so lost ever since then, almost a decade ago.

AlphabetAerobics · 31/10/2021 10:23

Jeez, I loved Risperidone - felt invincible and happy.

Went to my meds review 6 weeks later and the panel looked on horrified as I rabbited on high as a kite and not caring I’d put on 2 stone in just a few weeks.

They took me off it and I put the gummy bears down…

Beautybunny · 31/10/2021 10:19

Good morning, I am almost there with the Facebook group. Hopefully it will be helpful.
I had an epiphany last night and realised that bullying man= fat to me.
My husband is lovely but because of my seniority in business I usually report to a man. Most of them have been barstards. I am too clever for my own good so they belittle me and try to keep me in my plac, I might take their job!
I have had three lovely lady bosses and each time I have worked for such a person I have lost loads of weight. Conversely with the guys I eat to survive as opposed to saying feck off leave me alone. Enlightening.

OP posts:
Thornrose · 31/10/2021 09:38

HerRoyalWitchyness thank you, I'll mention this to her. I might write it down and remind her to ask at her next meds review.

Loodally · 31/10/2021 09:37

I would love to join your facebook group please.

Reading this thread has been enlightening, I too am attempting to love myself with food, due to never having felt loved in real life - abusive childhood etc.
I'm not sure how I stop doing that but I really need to try. I hate the way I look right now and any confidence I had has gone completely.

Thornrose · 31/10/2021 09:36

@LadyOfLittleLeisure she is on Risperidone. She has had meds reviews but they don't seem to want to get her off it!

She has capacity so I don't get a say or attend her medical appointments. The plan was always to start to reduce them when she has a long period of stability. That never seems to happen.

She has autism and went through a MH crisis was put on meds and never got off them.

Her thyroid must be having an impact too. Sadly the Risperidone also contributes to the thyroid issues, it's such a vicious circle for her.

RobinPenguins · 31/10/2021 09:16

@Driposaurus

Can I just say it’s been so good reading everyone else’s comments. I know this is painful but… I don’t feel alone. And so much of the obesity conversation i perceive to be “you must be stupid to be so fat” that I have always, always thought that of myself, despite what other people would regard as external evidence (career, “in control”, highly organised sort of person) to the contrary.

I just feel so so stupid that every day I can’t stop myself making stupid choices about food.

This resonates a lot with me too. I’m well educated, I’ve got a good career, I have no “excuse” for being obese and that’s a big part of the self loathing.
Beautybunny · 31/10/2021 09:00

@KatherineofGaunt

I feel some sort of counselling would help me too. I have plenty to do at home but like you I read magazines or chat to friends.

Interestingly this thread will not attract thousands of replies because it is not a MN demographic. However it did attract more than the flip thread of why aren't you obese.
?
If it has helped someone that is great. It has helped me. I asked my best friend if she thought I was 'padding up' against male bullies and she said yes! I will use this thought when I start my therapy.

OP posts:
HerRoyalWitchyness · 31/10/2021 08:59

. I found aripiprizole didn't make me gain weight but quetiapine was terrible for it. Maybe she could have a medication review?

I agree with this. I've tried quetiapine and olanzipine, both made me gain weight. Since going on aripiprazole I've lost 18lb

KatherineofGaunt · 31/10/2021 08:42

@Beautybunny True what you say about spending money on diet things. I first went to WW when I was about 14, I think. I had problems, even then. I danced two nights a week, played hockey, was doing GCSE PE, cycling to school... So I was plenty active. But the food I ate was so bad. I've been on and off WW, SW, MFP premium, diet tablets, diet drinks, Slim Fast...

I know I just need to easy better, but then I'm out and I'll grab a lovely latte and then usually have a muffin with it and suddenly I've bought a load of crap to eat at home, sitting in front of the computer or TV.

I've started CBT for depression and it's making me realise that by sitting around, I'm depressing myself because things don't get done, or I get stressed because I "haven't had time" to get things done. When I'm actual fact a large part of my day involves sitting and eating. So I'm trying to change my physical behaviour in the hope they improve the mind.

It's a relief to hear others struggle too, though I wouldn't wish my struggles on my worst enemy.

LadyOfLittleLeisure · 31/10/2021 08:33

@Thornrose I was super slim all my life and had to take antipsychotics for a short period and put on a stone a month Shock I've still, after years of being off them, not lost even half of it. They changed my body more than my pregnancies.

I don't know what your daughter is on but some antipsychotics are better than others for fewer weight gain side effects. I found aripiprizole didn't make me gain weight but quetiapine was terrible for it. Maybe she could have a medication review?

Beautybunny · 30/10/2021 21:05

@Driposaurus

Food addiction is the mother of all evils I think. As you have said many highly educated ladies have responded. I have had an interesting day. Went shopping and bought the food I like, fish, fruit and champers! My husband added in puddings but I don't touch them. I shall eat my fish this week and I am nursing a glass of fizz now. I don't usually buy what I want but today I did. I pay, I say. My daughter and son can get their own! It felt good.

OP posts:
Driposaurus · 30/10/2021 20:57

Can I just say it’s been so good reading everyone else’s comments. I know this is painful but… I don’t feel alone. And so much of the obesity conversation i perceive to be “you must be stupid to be so fat” that I have always, always thought that of myself, despite what other people would regard as external evidence (career, “in control”, highly organised sort of person) to the contrary.

I just feel so so stupid that every day I can’t stop myself making stupid choices about food.

Beautybunny · 30/10/2021 18:15

@Neverthecornflakegirl
And @BabyAlexander

It doesn't make sense really does it?
Big jobs, big money, still like the big scoff. Personally I think I would not work well with WLS so I haven't tried that. Hypnotherapy doesn't work on me, a much too active mind.

I have been designing a Facebook page this afternoon. I think it could be helpful however I have to out myself so I will send private messages when I am ready to go.

I use to think mumsnet was all lovely Boden and nappy cream. Ha, can be vicious even if you ask perfectly reasonable questions. Once you reach middle age we are supposed to have all the answers. Fat(no pun intended) chance of that.
In the words of Bridget Jones 'I choose Champers (vodka) and Chaka Kahn.'
I will be in touch.

OP posts:
HerRoyalWitchyness · 30/10/2021 17:59

I gained 7st in my last pregnancy due to not being able to walk and the only thing stopping the nausea was eating. Since then I developed binge eating disorder and I have a wide array of physical and mental health issues which make dealing with my weight very difficult, especially as a side effect of my tablets is weight gain, but if I don't take my medication ill end up in a mental health unit.

Neverthecornflakegirl · 30/10/2021 17:55

@BabyAlexander

RobinPenguins · 30/10/2021 17:08

I have no idea of a good group name but I’d be in! I need to stop my binge eating because it’s got out of control, I need accountability but I’m too ashamed to talk to anyone from real life about it.

BabyAlexander · 30/10/2021 17:00

@Neverthecornflakegirl

I don’t know what to call the group but I’m in!

I’m an intelligent, capable, measured middle aged woman but I am completely hobbled by my emotional eating which is a handy way of trauma blocking. I drive myself crazy - there’s the sensible version of me that has all the qualifications (I’m a sensible solicitor for goodness sake!) who knows I just simply have to stop eating in the way that I do and then there’s the sad, traumatised, lonely, bereft, grieving part of me that doesn’t care - that part just wants that moment of joy which comes from eating ever-escalating levels of crap. Even though that part knows the joy might be only a second or two and then the self-loathing starts. I haven’t looked at a full length mirror in over 5 years now - every year it’s been my New Year’s resolution to look in a mirror. Not achieved it yet.

Unmumsnetty hug to you all.

I could have written this, even down to the job. This is the one area of my life I have no control over. It consumes me.

A group? I'm in.

darkn · 30/10/2021 16:54

If you already know that wine makes you eat lots, then it’s kind of clear what you need to do to start

most of us know what's good and bad for us but stopping is the hard part.

Neverthecornflakegirl · 30/10/2021 16:47

And a big hug for @sunshinealligator - I am so sorry that happened to you

Neverthecornflakegirl · 30/10/2021 16:45

I don’t know what to call the group but I’m in!

I’m an intelligent, capable, measured middle aged woman but I am completely hobbled by my emotional eating which is a handy way of trauma blocking. I drive myself crazy - there’s the sensible version of me that has all the qualifications (I’m a sensible solicitor for goodness sake!) who knows I just simply have to stop eating in the way that I do and then there’s the sad, traumatised, lonely, bereft, grieving part of me that doesn’t care - that part just wants that moment of joy which comes from eating ever-escalating levels of crap. Even though that part knows the joy might be only a second or two and then the self-loathing starts. I haven’t looked at a full length mirror in over 5 years now - every year it’s been my New Year’s resolution to look in a mirror. Not achieved it yet.

Unmumsnetty hug to you all.

Beautybunny · 30/10/2021 14:20

So ladies let us have a name for our obese ladies support group (I get there are big chaps who are desparately unhappy) but personally I am not the person to facilitate the discussion with them.
Obeseies against the world? That sort of thing. I am sure we can one up with something.

OP posts: