Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Close Relative with Newborn Not Allowing Visitors Except Hired Help

64 replies

Pumpkin544 · 29/10/2021 01:44

I was searching the threads for some answers. I’m a mum of 4 older kids and some of these Covid/risk/visitors threads have really chimed with a situation I’m experiencing. A close family member has recently had a baby and having gone through the pregnancy with some challenges and anxiety and decided against getting vaccinated during, they are being ultra cautious about any contact with family. I do respect this decision but am hurt by the fact that they have decided to hire their birth coach to help out with the baby. I think I’m most upset by the fact that I am very aware that having school age kids makes one quite a “dirty” Covid prospect at the moment and I accept this, however this person also has school-age children and all the risk factors I feel I am being kept at bay for and yet this person is allowed to play a full part of the family at the moment, even though no close relatives are allowed to visit. Can you help me understand this? For the background, I’m a mum with 4 older kids and certainly not demanding cuddles or close contact. Masks etc would be fine, but the inclusion of a third party is feeling a bit like exclusion to my side of the family.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Sceptre86 · 02/11/2021 18:33

It is up to the parents. I think it is overkill but there you go. I have an 8 week old baby and family have been to visit. Some have done lfts before others haven't. I expect them to hand sanitise when they arrive and use common sense so if they don't feel well,don't come. Otherwise life goes on, we have a child in primary school and another on pre school so the risk of catching covid is already there.
I'm not overly anxious though and am vaccinated.

Thedogscollar · 02/11/2021 09:38

[quote ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba]@Thedogscollar

the whole first post is just "me me me", I'm upset, I'm this, I'm that".

but what her friend decided to do is nothing to do with OP.
she asked to help her understand, so if she can understand it's not about her but about what her friend wants then job done.

is that better?[/quote]
You could have said that to the OP but instead you thought you were being funny but turns out you are actually just rude.

Calmestofallthechickens · 30/10/2021 11:13

I sympathise with you - it’s not easy, you want to be supportive, involved, and you feel like she’s favouring a stranger/employee over you. That’s understandable and it’s valid.

What’s also valid is her doing whatever she needs to to get through the absolute insanity of having a baby in a pandemic. I had my second child last year and it was all just mad, everything was so scary and unknown and I seriously considered having her at home to avoid hospital - I’ve not really had any issues in the past with anxiety or anything like that but the continuous low level panic for months and months is like nothing else I’ve ever experienced. And this was my second - I knew how I would handle birth and a newborn and feeding - so it must be even worse for first time mums.

So I guess what I’m saying is cut her some slack, don’t take it personally because she probably wouldn’t be like this if she had a baby outside of an apocalypse movie, just let her know you’re available for whatever support she needs.

tofuschnitzel · 30/10/2021 11:00

@JudgeJ "And hopefully this precious family member will understand if, in the future, she is seeking some help from the OP if she is told No!"

The baby is not a bargaining chip. How utterly selfish to imply you wouldn't help if asked, just because you didn't get to see the baby when you wanted to. This time is about helping the parents establish themselves in their new role, to figure out how it all works as a family of X.

OP, I understand your questions, and I think it's great that you've asked for help to understand this. It's actually brought up some memories for me that I'd prefer not to think about. I had my twins in May this year. In my MIL's need to "help", I was left feeling like she didn't even want me in the room with my babies. She was very insistent, even though I was and still am struggling with my mental health as a new mum. I felt like the incubator, and as I'd done my bit I was expected to step aside. I didn't want to leave my babies before I was ready to, I needed help to facilitate me staying with them. That could have been making cups of tea for me, making sure I ate something, help with putting washing on or cooking us a meal. She did none of that, I ended up making her tea! Everyone wants to hold the baby, but I can do that, it's all the other things I needed help with. Only my sisters understood that, which I am so grateful for. Establishing the bond as parents is so important, and should be paramount. And it was infuriating that my MIL would insist she was there to help, but wouldn't do anything apart from hold a baby.

Just give them space. Let them know you are there to help if and when needed. Ask if you can make them a meal and drop it off. Be there for them, but give them space.

Derbee · 30/10/2021 10:48

[quote ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba]@Thedogscollar

the whole first post is just "me me me", I'm upset, I'm this, I'm that".

but what her friend decided to do is nothing to do with OP.
she asked to help her understand, so if she can understand it's not about her but about what her friend wants then job done.

is that better?[/quote]
No, it’s not better. It’s still pointless and unhelpful

SunscreenCentral · 30/10/2021 01:39

Parts of the UK seem to be absolutely riddled with Covid. Under those circumstances I'd be limiting contact as much as possible too. No question. Sorry OP

ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 30/10/2021 01:28

@Thedogscollar

the whole first post is just "me me me", I'm upset, I'm this, I'm that".

but what her friend decided to do is nothing to do with OP.
she asked to help her understand, so if she can understand it's not about her but about what her friend wants then job done.

is that better?

Thedogscollar · 30/10/2021 01:11

@ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba

it's not about you

it's not about you

it's not about you

it's not about you

in summary: it's not about you

OP never said it was. She was merely asking a question.
Pumpkin544 · 30/10/2021 00:05

@IrishMamaMia Sounds very similar, thanks for sharing.

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 30/10/2021 00:00

Her baby, her choice. I didn’t want visitors for several weeks in non-Covid times.

Peach01 · 29/10/2021 23:58

Try not to take it personally. She hasn't yet been vaccinated and the newborn barely has an immune system. Seems sensible, not irrational. She's limiting visitors at the moment, not disowning everyone. One of my close family members didn't have visitors pre covid due to wanting time to adjust with the baby. It's their decision, whatever the reason is. Tbh it isn't really anyone else's place. It's her home and her baby. The irony in pp calling the mum precious. It's not a reflection on you or any other family member.

IrishMamaMia · 29/10/2021 23:39

This is a really interesting question and thread OP as I've gone through it recently with my in-laws. Our relationship can be tricky to navigate at the best of times and it can be hurtful to feel pushed away and brushed off when you yourself have been very amenable to them seeing your own newborn babies.
I've distanced myself for now and have found myself thinking they have been working from home and limiting contact due to covid and the pregnancy for lmost two years now, maybe this is their new post-covid normal?!

PumpkinsandTea · 29/10/2021 23:25

Honestly, some pfbs really do think they're the first & only ones to ever have a baby!!

JudgeJ · 29/10/2021 23:18

@Aquamarine1029

Can you help me understand this?

This isn't for you to "understand." Your family member doesn't have to justify to you, or anyone, why they are taking the precautions and steps they are taking. They are doing what is right for them. If you choose to take their decision personally, that's your responsibility.

And hopefully this precious family member will understand if, in the future, she is seeking some help from the OP if she is told No!
Randomness12 · 29/10/2021 18:57

I echo what the others are saying. I’m due a c-section in a couple of weeks and have just been given all the info from the hospital - it actually advises limiting contact to only medical/birth professionals for 2 weeks post-op due to the risk to mum and baby (vaccinated or not) and any childcare for older children. I’ll be sticking to that.

I am vaccinated but understand the transmission risk is not zero, and what with being in hospital, midwives, HVs, GP and breastfeeding support plus my DD being at a school my risk is already higher than I’d like. I need all of those people and interventions - I don’t need to increase that risk with 10 family members also arriving.

I can see it going down really poorly with my in-laws in particular but they’ll have to just get on with it. It’ll be the same for everyone and although I understand it’ll be difficult, it’s better to be safe than sorry.

Pumpkin544 · 29/10/2021 18:52

Thanks for the supportive messages MereDintofPandiculation, this is true. I’m not disrespecting anyone’s wishes, I had questions which many have provided helpful answers to. It’s a way of processing and in the spirit of sincerely trying to do that listening to other people’s experiences and explanations. Thanks all.

OP posts:
EdgeOfTheSky · 29/10/2021 18:24

She obviously has very high levels of anxiety, to the extent of having made the irrational (IMO) and contrary to medical advice decision not to get vaxxed during pregnancy.

Do not take this personally.

It’s not about you.

I would be more concerned about her level of anxiety than about feeling excluded.

And…people who take things personally are often those who are hardest to be with.

itsgettingwierd · 29/10/2021 18:18

@Twodogsandababy

My doula/birth coach came postpartum for six weeks after I had my baby and it was amazing. I felt totally comfortable with her because she had been there while I was giving birth and vulnerable, so I felt totally comfortable sitting on the sofa with my boob out/hobbling around because of my stitches. I answered the door in my pyjamas, didn’t worry about tidying up. My doula was the only person who came to visit who didn’t come to see ‘the baby’ - she came to see me. That is so important and special as a new mum. I absolutely love my little girl and am so proud of her but visitors can definitely make new mum’s feel like an afterthought when they are newly postpartum, even if they don’t mean to. My doula was amazing because she came in, made me a hot drink, got me anything I needed, made sure I ate something, did washing and light tidying. When my baby was happy to be held she would hold her and send me for a hot shower or a sleep. I trusted her completely to come and wake me or get me the minute my baby needed me which was what I wanted. She wasn’t there to ask gory questions about my birth, or make comments about how I was choosing to feed, or holding her too much, or how I was doing things wrong. She was a professional and that meant I totally relaxed around her and knew she would respect my wishes with my baby. She knew lots about babies and postpartum and gave me advice but only when I asked for it. She made me feel like a super mum.

I can be quite anxious and could never relax with visitors coming, even family I was close to. I felt like I had to tidy up, try and find “proper” clothes that fit me, get snacks out for everyone and then sit around and make people tea while people tried to hold my tiny baby who only really wanted her mummy and the boob. I did have visitors, but it was was exhausting no matter how much I loved them.

If I was you I would respect that this is how she feels, try and remember that huge hormonal crash and just how overwhelming everything feels with a new baby when it’s a struggle to even have a shower. I would offer to do helpful things - “would you like to leave some washing at the door and I’ll do it and bring it back for you”, drop a home cooked meal off, ask if she wants any food shopping delivered. Ask her how’s she feeling, ask if she needs anything. Tell her you understand how overwhelming and scary it can be. Tell her you love her, she’s beautiful and you are proud of her. I think in the early days it is the family’s job to nurture and love the mother so she can nurture and love her baby and find her feet in her new life as a mother and a nuclear family unit. Once she is secure and happy she will be much more open. Babies don’t spoil, you have all the time in the world to get to know this new little person. I promise your relative will always remember how you make her feel in this time, so do everything you can to make that a wonderful feeling.

That sounds so lovely and I get it.

I had ds when living abroad. Waaaayyyyy before covid times!

My parents were there when he was born but I spent most of that time in hospital! They were great though and my (ex) ILs are a whole other type of special.

I had a ex midwife expat living in my block. I loved her visiting. She kinda took in the role voluntarily but was never pushy. Would come round and make me tea and toast. Watch ds whilst I showered or slept. Answer questions professionally but as a friend.

It made such a difference as you say to have someone who wanted to take care of me so I could take care of my baby.

TheNarwhalBalloon · 29/10/2021 18:13

I'd see it this way : she's decided to limit visitors to reduce risk. And is trying to balance risk against benefit. You and other family members visiting at the moment probably benefits you more than anyone if we're honest. Whereas the doula visiting will hugely benefit the mum and baby. I can see why she's made this decision but I understand it's made you feel excluded. Her concerns are valid though and if she lets one family member visit she may feel pressured to letting a number of others come too.

MereDintofPandiculation · 29/10/2021 18:08

You’ll get to see the baby in the future. It’s the parents’ decision, so respect it. She is respecting it. That's an unwarranted criticism.

I suppose. she's limiting contact to one person, and better a hired outsider than picking one family member with all the jealousy that that can cause. What Holly's saying.

The criticism and implied criticism of OP is quite nasty to see. She's being respectful, she's not clamouring for a visit, but she's feeling hurt, and wants to understand, which is perfectly reasonable. And she's seeking that understanding by coming on here rather than pestering the new mum. So what is there to criticise?

Holly60 · 29/10/2021 18:01

[quote Pumpkin544]@Twodogsandababy
Thank you, very sensitive advice and lots of very helpful contributions on this thread. Thanks![/quote]
I can understand you being hurt and wanting to understand why they are doing this.

Could it be that they have decided that a) they need help, but b) they want to minimise risk to their new baby and mum whilst c) they want to be fair to all family members?

Therefore they are saying no to ALL family visits, whilst allowing the birth coach (?) to help out. They have already had contact with her through the birth etc, so probably has built a strong bond of trust, and she is only one person. She is probably vaccinated, under strict instructions to wash hands/change clothes etc. She still also probably be doing regular lateral flow tests. All things they can ask her to do as an employee.

If anxious, it’s often about feeling in control. It’s easier to feel in control when it is just one person, and they are avoiding a situation of having lots of family over by just saying no family, which at least is fair

megletthesecond · 29/10/2021 17:56

I don't blame her.
If I had my time again I'd choose paid help over family visits.

ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 29/10/2021 17:56

it's not about you

it's not about you

it's not about you

it's not about you

in summary: it's not about you

RoseAndGeranium · 29/10/2021 17:52

@FluffMagnet

Can I just say, from a paediatric ward full of bronchiolitis babies with siblings at nursery or school, your relatives fears about germs is not unfounded. Due to Covid restrictions, my husband is not allowed to visit his son, and I'm trying to deal with my post-CS body and a tiny newborn who cannot keep their oxygen levels up. Not where I was hoping to spend my son's second week of life, but sadly being a second baby, I couldn't keep him away from all the sicknesses DD keeps catching atm. My sister is due in December, and I have already warned her to keep people away if they have even a hint of a virus. Tbh I won't be visiting inside their house until their baby is older and stronger.
@FluffMagnet I could have written almost exactly this post two weeks ago. My daughter was 15 days old on admission after catching RSV from her older sibling who is at nursery. It was crushing watching her struggle to breathe, hour after hour, and so hard not being able to see my husband for support. I really feel for you. Just try to keep in mind that the doctors and nurses caring for your baby see hundreds of bronch babies and toddlers every year and they really know what they’re doing. Sending you Flowers and crossing my fingers you and your little one will be home soon.
Cuck00soup · 29/10/2021 17:49

@Yummiliscious

Herself and her baby would have been been better protected having been vaccinated during pregnancy. This is now standard medical advice. How many other expectant mothers is the birth coach visiting? Surely that’s more of a COVID risk factor.
This. Especially if the mother has school aged children herself.

To be honest from your posts I would be very worried about the Doula’s influence.

Swipe left for the next trending thread