Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to know how they know he has less than 2 weeks to live? NHS Euthanasia?

64 replies

EOLQ · 29/10/2021 00:09

Evening all.

We've been told today my dad has less than 2 weeks to live.

He has a rare neuro-degenerative condition that's been worsening for a number of years. So while we've known it's coming and is what he's wanted for the last couple of years hearing this news today was still a shock.

But what myself and family can't quite figure out is what caused today to be the day we were told it's so close to the end.

As to me he seems similar to a couple of weeks ago. Maybe even a bit brighter than some of the worse days.

Anyone with end of life knowledge able to help me out?

He has had a lot of fluid on his lungs which has worsened a lot the last week or two. He doesn't for have the strength or muscle capacity to clear it. But is on a medication (a patch behind his ear) which has really helped that.

So is the fluid, even though it's being managed a sign?

He has a bad UTI which won't respond to ABs. Is that the reason?

Or - today he was fitted with a syringe driver to have his morphine and now midazolam (?) administered 24/7.

So I guess I'm wondering do they know once that medication starts so does the clock? A family member said to me that it's the NHS version of euthanasia.

But can that really be the case?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Paperyfish · 29/10/2021 13:42

I’m so sorry about your dad. Mine died three years ago today. He also had a rare neurological condition. His was PSP.
He had a water infection ( one of many) and was getting antibiotics but they weren’t doing much. He got a driver for pain with the stuff to reduce secretions too. The 24 hospice staff turned up. He looked the same or a little better to me, but some how they knew this was it. It was about a Week for him. He passed very gently with us all around him.

EOLQ · 29/10/2021 12:57

Thanks all.

Just to clear something.

The family member who said what they did said it in a hopeful tone. There's been no questioning of what's been given or advised by the various doctors etc.

They know it was dads wish anyway and I think maybe the thought he'll be done suffering soon is comforting them (while of course also breaking their heart.)

There's been no accusation that anyone involved has ever done anything other than do whatever they can to make this easier for everyone involved. Most of all dad.

So please don't think they're angry or upset at the treatment he's getting. Quite the opposite.

No one is angry or disappointed in anything that's been done.

OP posts:
whitehorsesdonotlie · 29/10/2021 11:53

Of course it's not euthanasia! It's giving a terminally ill patient the means to control the amount of pain they are in. What does your FM think should happen instead?

It sounds as if you could do with speaking to your dad's consultant, as they should be able to answer your questions and clear up any misunderstandings.

Sending you best wishes, and peace to your dad.

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 29/10/2021 11:52

My sympathies that you are going through this OP. It is hard for us left behind & watching & waiting.

I'm interested to hear all the stories of people perking up - the Guardian ran an article earlier this year on the phenomenon of 'terminal lucidity'
www.theguardian.com/society/2021/feb/23/the-clouds-cleared-what-terminal-lucidity-teaches-us-about-life-death-and-dementia

Crispyturtle · 29/10/2021 11:48

My MiL died earlier this year after a lengthy illness. She also developed fluid on the lungs and this seemed to be the thing that the HcPs caring for her felt showed the end was near. She too was immobile and unable to clear the fluid herself. She was given 24-48 hours but lasted four days. She was also on a syringe driver and we all thank god she was, her passing was peaceful and gentle and although she stopped communicating she could clearly understand and respond to voices and smiled when she hear her grandchildren. She is so missed but as a family we thank god that the HCPs recognised her condition, communicated that clearly to us so we could respond appropriately (ie drop everything to be with her) and provided all the pain relief she needed to make her death such a positive experience for all. I hope you and your family are able to experience the same for your father.

Corkit · 29/10/2021 11:48

So much helpful information on this thread and lots I wish I'd known when going through this with DGP's. I hope it's helped you too OP, thinking of you and your family Flowers

NeverAnyMilk · 29/10/2021 11:41

Isn’t it based on worse case scenario, medics have seen hundreds of people in the same situation presenting the same symptoms and the majority would have died within 2 weeks
Is like end of care when a nurse can tell the patient will die within a few hours so calls immediate family to be with the person. Did that at 3am to my mother when stepdad had lung cancer and he died at 6am

Staryflight445 · 29/10/2021 11:30

‘ NHS version of euthanasia’

This is so damaging, please educate your family member. Because of people that think like this, lots of people end up dying in pain when they refuse to let their dying relative be given such medicines. The meds make the patient comfortable, they don’t kill the patient or speed up their death.

I’m sorry to hear about your dad.

Pinkfairylights · 29/10/2021 11:00

Sending you love and strength OP Flowers

My lovely Dad died of cancer at home last year. In his last week he barely spoke, apart from an agitated half hour when he tried to get out of bed to 'go home'.

On Marie Curie's website there's a brilliant short film that helped me prepare for changes during his last few days.

Keep talking to him. Xx

MakeMineALarge1 · 29/10/2021 10:54

@GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER

Re the food and drink refusal* (happened with an aunt of mine) some doctor put it very well:

‘They are not dying because they are not eating and drinking. They are not eating and drinking because they are dying.’

But from all I hear, relatives often still get very upset and want tube or PEG feeding, because they think the medics are callously trying to starve their loved one to death.

*she was still offered both regularly, but would just close her mouth and turn her head away.

I agree with this Dr 100% they aren't eating and drinking and as such don't need it, because they are dying, their body is shutting down, its a process.
comfortablyfrumpy · 29/10/2021 10:43

Hi I'm sorry you're all going through this.

When my Mum was nearing the end, she'd been up and down for a quite a long while. She was also affected by fluid on lungs, different cause but same effect. I had a feeling she was starting to really go downhill, but I don't think my Dad or the rest of the family had realised.

Slightly different situation in that she was at home, with us and carers doing everything, community nurses popping in when needed.

Community nurse who flagged up that she thought it was now time, was absolutely right - and she put things into motion very quickly so that Mum could have morphine etc etc if needed.

Thing is, they've seen this time and time before so they know what to look for, and they know when to step in and say that this is going to happen.

We all felt hugely supported, and it meant Mum got all the care she needed and was able to slip away peacefully just a few days later.

Virtual hugs to you and your family.

CharlotteUnaNatalieThompson · 29/10/2021 10:41

The post I quoted didn't work - the book is "With the end in mind" by Kathryn Mannix

With the End in Mind: Dying, Death and Wisdom in an Age of Denial www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0752X79CK/ref=cm_sw_r_apan_glt_EJSR363YTKAFG0Y6D06H?tag=mumsnetforu03-21

Practicebeingpatient · 29/10/2021 10:40

My dad was in a coma for about a month before he died from cancer. Mum was caring for him at home with twice daily visits from MacMillan nurses to do the things mum couldn't manage.

Three days before he died mum and I were having a takeaway pizza in his bedroom when he woke up and asked for some. He ate a slice, drank a glass of wine and then lay down again. He was a very fit, sporty man who watched his diet and barely drank so it's ironic that his last words were to ask for pizza and wine! We were so hopeful that it was a good sign but it was obviously the last minute perking up people have described. It's still a very happy memory though.

CharlotteUnaNatalieThompson · 29/10/2021 10:39

@sillysmiles

Hopefully his passing is peaceful.

]]

I listened to this book as an audiobook after the passing of a close family and found it interesting and reassuring in a way.

I was just going to post recommending this book. I read it while my best friend was dying of cancer and found it extremely comforting. The author explains very clearly about the symptoms of dying, and explains clearly why although they can appear distressing to those watching, they are not to the person dying. It's beautifully written. You'll probably find it pretty painful to read, but if you can bear it I think it will bring you a lot of comfort.

Sending love to you and your family and wishing for a peaceful passing for your lovely Dad x

whynotwhatknot · 29/10/2021 10:34

bless you all its so hard you dont want to let go of course but you dont want them to suffer

they said my mum had 18 months and she died in 6-they dont know for sure but seeing as they see it alot it seems this is end of life care

love to you

HeyBlaby · 29/10/2021 10:26

I work in EOL care, we don't euthanise patients, ever, it's illegal. If someone is in pain (for example) we can give analgesia and titrate the dose up until effective, but we can only act on symptoms, EOL drugs are strong and a side effect of this is they can shorten life further, but it is that and a good death (as much as it can be) or a drawn out death with no symptom control.

Yes the fluid build up is usually a sign that someone is very poorly and may well be what sparked the conversation.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 29/10/2021 10:24

Re the food and drink refusal* (happened with an aunt of mine) some doctor put it very well:

‘They are not dying because they are not eating and drinking. They are not eating and drinking because they are dying.’

But from all I hear, relatives often still get very upset and want tube or PEG feeding, because they think the medics are callously trying to starve their loved one to death.

*she was still offered both regularly, but would just close her mouth and turn her head away.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 29/10/2021 10:24

What I didn't realise is that death is a process as well as an event, so the process starts quite a long time before you actually go into active dying; basically the normal functions (such as fighting off infections and clearing lungs) are not there any more, and the body will essentially run down over time. That's usually when the palliative team step in and put in place their own protocols so no more active treatment, no more medications unless they are for pain relief/symptom relief- they let the body do what it's been often trying to do for a while, which is shut down. This can be distressing to the person, if their breathing/pain increases, which is why they then introduce medications to help with this.

Your dad is in a safe place, and this is a natural process. They are just giving meds to relieve the pain and to stop restlessness/agitation- my husband became agitated at times and tried to throw himself from the bed, so the drugs against that were very helpful. In the end he didn't need much pain meds, so they won't always give what's allowed. They are not helping him die, they are allowing that natural process to occur, but without the pain and agitation that often accompanies it.

Hugs to you OP, this is a hard path for us to tread, and give your dad lots of hugs and talk to him at this time.,

Our experience of palliative care was nothing short of amazing and it would be wonderful if everyone had home hospice or hospice care, or just great palliative care in hospital- so many do not and to have it is a blessing Op even if it doesn't feel like that!

LindaEllen · 29/10/2021 10:16

@MobyDicksTinyCanoe

The perking up is really common......I remember a friend of my brother in laws who died really young from cancer. He'd been unconscious for days, family and friends were at his bedside waiting for him to die when he suddenly got up like nothing was wrong with him. Tried to use the bathroom and made himself something to eat.

It was heartbreaking and lovely all at the same time.

The main thing at the moment is that your dad isnt in any pain, it's in everyones interests that that's managed well.

Yeah, my friend's 17yo son died of cancer and a week before he died he was well enough - after spending most of his time mobile but very very tired - to go to Pizza Hut with his friends. They knew it was goodbye and so did he, but it was absolutely wonderful that he got the chance to do that. After that he went to bed and didn't get out of it again.
Biggiraffe · 29/10/2021 10:13

I good way of thinking about this stage of someone’s life is, symptom control gives a short death rather than shortening life, I hope that helps you understand what might be happening x

ParishSpinster · 29/10/2021 10:13

I'm so sorry OP

My MIL died this summer. She had alzheimers and in the end caught a chest infection that she didn't recover from. She had been on end of life care for a few weeks but one day the carers in her care home called DH to say that she only had a week or so left.

There are a number of markers or signs they look out for. Loss of swallow is one thing, another was lack of eating- she didn't need to eat anything for most of the last week which the nursing staff said was typical towards the end of life. Breathing changes as well, this was more towards the last few hours though.

Essentially, the experience of the medical and caring staff meant they knew signs to look out for and could make sure DH, SIL and FIL could spend time with MIL.

guestusername · 29/10/2021 10:07

I’m sorry for you OP at what you’re about to go through. Although it’s not the same, but my brother had cancer and it was very obvious that he was a couple of weeks away. He had two syringe drivers - one for pain relief and one for nausea and to help keep his chest clear. He actually spent most of the last two weeks sleeping but when he was awake he wasn’t really with it, which was a direct effect of all his meds. He had a very lucid period the day before he died. He was able to move around and speak coherently.

It is very common with end of life for the patient to be talking about needing to go somewhere. We were also watching for signs of the body gradually shutting down so weakness when the end was really close.

What you’re about to go through is very distressing for everyone. Please all take time to yourselves if you’re able, even if it’s just something as simple as taking a bath. You’ll be glad of the headspace.

Sorry, I got a bit carried away there. As time goes on there may be tweaks to his meds - new meds or different doses but it is all with one aim - to keep your dad as comfortable as possible

MakeMineALarge1 · 29/10/2021 10:06

@Disfordarkchocolate

Your family member is an idiot.

It sounds like you Dad is slowly shutting down and the care he is getting is making him for comfortable. This is what I would want for a loved one, care and comfort.

I agree, they are deliberately using inflammatory language to get a rise from you and to make you doubt and question the Dr - I am not not saying the NHS is above being questioned - this is good end of life care
Hobbesmanc · 29/10/2021 10:04

We didn't have a timescale for my mum battling a horrendous cancer at 59. But it was obvious that she was slipping away. But I'm glad people have shared about the pre death burst of energy. I've read many theories but none really make sense. But my beautiful adored mum had hardly spoken or opened her eyes for days. Then the evening she died she sat up and started talking- she asked for some music she loved and (and people find this hard to believe but its true) she asked for and drank a small glass of wine. She laughed and stroked our hands and heads as we all took turns on the bed (she died at home). This lasted about 45 minutes and is a memory I will treasure. She then dozed off and died an hour later.

I'm sorry you are losing your dad. I'm sure he knows how loved he is.

MakeMineALarge1 · 29/10/2021 10:04

@Jobseeker19

This tends to be what people are talking about rw:Ns euthanasia, but it doesn't sound like what us happening to your dad.
That paper was written in 2012! it is dated, even when the LCP (as it was known) fluids were never withheld!

What people don't understand is that when the body is dying and is in its final days, it slows down and pushing in fluids/food can do more harm and the body has to digest it etc, when all its wants to do is slow down.