Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be concerned about this re nursery?

35 replies

Hmmm21 · 28/10/2021 22:10

My son is due to start at his first nursery in a couple of weeks.

He's been signed up for around the past 6 months and I have been received email updates, like typical parent newsletter types, from the nursery since then even though he's not started yet.

Since he's been signed up I have had loads of emails to say different staff members are leaving and welcoming new ones, one being the nursery manager and various nursery workers.

I have started to feel really uncomfortable about the amount of staff that seem to be leaving in such a short space of time after having received yet another email today notifying me of another staff member leaving.

AIBU? I can't quite place my finger on it but part of me thinks is this just a really rubbish place to work? And if so, how good can it be for the children if staff members seem to be leaving in droves.

It's a really highly rated nursery in our area and a few friends have had children there before who loved it (none there currently though) but I'd go so far as to say there probably isn't any of the same staff there anyway now for friends experiences to really be relevant.

Am I just overreacting? I will happily accept if I am! Smile

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MissChanandlerBong81 · 29/10/2021 15:55

I think YANBU to be concerned because it could indicate a problem but equally it could be benign. Our nursery is a small nursery and it lost two members of staff last year after having no staff departures for nearly 6 years. They were two older ladies who decided to take early retirement because they were very concerned about catching Covid/taking it home (this was pre-vaccinations). Which is understandable but also not an indication of a problem at the nursery! So maybe just ask the question.

chocolatecerealcampingbrekkie · 29/10/2021 12:11

@EbbandTheWanderingHearts

I have worked in my current nursery for less than a year and have handed in my notice. Main reason is the huge amount of babies in the unit. 37 +. It takes 2 members of staff over an hour to do each batch of nappy changes. I have 8 key children with up to 6 in on one day. I don't get to spend much time with them as just the basic maintenance of feeding, nappies, getting babies to sleep takes most of the time. Coupled with unqualified staff than can't do meal dish ups or be left unattended, just adds to the pressure. I'm moving to a small nursery where I feel I can provide much better care. I feel bad for the children I'm leaving behind but the nursery is still advertising for more children. I know it's all about profit but I don't think it should be at the expense of the quality of care. I was in my previous job for 5 years so it's not due to me being flaky.
I have e peri ended this in the past too.
Toottooot · 29/10/2021 11:34

I’m in Scotland and this happened at the nursery my child attends very recently. Nursery sent an email to all parents explaining that due to an increase in nursery places for 3 year olds in local authority nurseries they were loosing staff to the local authorities. Who could blame them - im assuming school nurseries operate on much shorter opening hours and follow school holiday patterns.

EbbandTheWanderingHearts · 29/10/2021 11:23

I have worked in my current nursery for less than a year and have handed in my notice. Main reason is the huge amount of babies in the unit. 37 +. It takes 2 members of staff over an hour to do each batch of nappy changes. I have 8 key children with up to 6 in on one day. I don't get to spend much time with them as just the basic maintenance of feeding, nappies, getting babies to sleep takes most of the time. Coupled with unqualified staff than can't do meal dish ups or be left unattended, just adds to the pressure. I'm moving to a small nursery where I feel I can provide much better care. I feel bad for the children I'm leaving behind but the nursery is still advertising for more children. I know it's all about profit but I don't think it should be at the expense of the quality of care. I was in my previous job for 5 years so it's not due to me being flaky.

chocolatecerealcampingbrekkie · 29/10/2021 11:04

It's just common with nurseries I'm afraid. The work is hard but pay and respect are low. There is usually a high staff turn over and in my experience a lot of workers leave permanently once they have their own dc or a better paid job comes along.

IamJuliaJohnson · 29/10/2021 07:54

This happened at our nursery. It was to do with a change of management. Broadly, old manager left, new manager came in. I got on well with new manager, really great change as a parent, but staff were unhappy and left in high numbers including key members of leadership team. Staff at the nursery were then, overall, less experienced and tbh it did show especially in the preschool - DS2 had terrible preparation for school (hampered by the pandemic but I think the staff in the room would have been unable to replace the early years teacher status staff they replaced). New manager left under a cloud and actually old manager came back part time. I have no idea what’s happening now, but I suspect these things are like schools where it takes a while for the nursery to settle and regain its position. If you are able to choose another nursery you should consider it.

Rosebel · 29/10/2021 07:48

High staff turnover is never a good sign and I wouldn't want to send my child there either.
I'd do as you suggested. Start him there but visit lots of others and get him on the waiting list. Or can you or your partner dely returning to work until another space becomes available.?
You might find that the staff turnover settles down but if it doesn't at least you know he won't be there too long.

girlmom21 · 29/10/2021 07:07

A lot of the staff at our nursery were working in the nursery whilst training for other jobs.

Nurseries have lots of bank staff too.

whatswithtodaytoday · 29/10/2021 07:05

Try Googling the nursery name. There are few places online I've found parent and staff reviews of our nursery - just keep going down the rabbit hole and see what you can find.

Normally it would concern me but there might be a good reason for it.

UnsolicitedDickPic · 29/10/2021 07:00

@marykitty

At my DS nursery we experience a huge Staff turnover during the first covid months (which was also when he started nursery...Confused) I was honestly really worried for a while, then situation stabilized again after few months and since 1 year there is no change, and DS is happy. For us it was a combination of people not coming back after maternity leave, people going in anticipated maternity leave, vulnerable people going into anticipated retirement etc all within few weeks Hmm
I was going to say this. My DDs nursery had the same staff for years and then, due to COVID and some going on maternity leave and not coming back, several of them left all in one go. The situation has levelled out there now, but that might be a reason at your nursery.

OTOH, if your gut is telling you it's weird then always go with that.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 29/10/2021 06:53

Are these people, at least in part, work experience/placement trainees going back to college?

ArthurTudor · 29/10/2021 06:40

Staff turnover at ours seems to get like this every now and again. I thought it was fairly common in nurseries? Maybe it depends on the area. I put it down to the wages being so low and responsibility quite high that after a while they seem to move on. Having said that the management is stable - I think that's very important.

MaverickSnoopy · 29/10/2021 06:37

My husband has worked in nurseries for well over a decade and tbh what you're describing sounds normal.

I'm sure there are some nurseries where this doesn't happen but nurseries can be toxic environments for staff. Low pay, poor work/life balance with high expectations due to ratios. Will never forget when one tried to Bradford score our child for illness (they didn't attend the nursery) because they felt my husband shouldn't have the time off to look after her (she had been rushed to hospital). So many more stories. The stress to our lives has been horrific - he has worked for 2 major chains and 1 smaller chain.

In my experience it usually goes in waves of people leaving. Usually one person leaves and it sets others off. However, at the moment with the pandemic, it is a huge time of uncertainty for nurseries. They are they chronically underfunded and a lot short staffed as a consequence, putting a lot on members of staff. I also have friends who work in various nurseries and am hearing the same from them. Lots of people leaving to work in supermarkets. Same pay, easier life. It's not just nurseries- I'm a Registered Childminder and Childminders are leaving the sector in droves as the childcare sector has been treated appallingly during the pandemic.

I'm sure there are nurseries out there where staff are very happy, the above comments do indicate that. In your shoes I would probably ask the nursery what their turnover had been for the last 2 years. Have you asked on any local Facebook groups about local nurseries and which people feel are best or worst?

CakesOfVersailles · 29/10/2021 06:36

It sorts of depends what the reasons are too. A kindergarten near me lost five staff members in a year but 2 were retiring after over 40 years in the early years sector, 2 were to maternity, and one was going back to uni for a higher qualification related to early years. Sometimes a good nursery can just have a spate of staff leaving.

But in general it is a concerning sign that would make me take a second look at the nursery.

underneaththeash · 29/10/2021 06:24

Do you live in London?
It was a huge problem with all the nurseries we attended (3 of them), the population tends to be transient abs it’s a low wage and with the extra costs of living in London, staff tended to leave once they had a better paying job.

All the nurseries we attended outside London had much better staff retention.

Megan2018 · 29/10/2021 06:17

I’d be concerned. DD has been at her nursery for a year and the staff changes have almost exclusively related to maternity leave (so a couple returning and a couple going on leave). One person has actually left and 2 trainees joined. They have a bank staff team who have covered some of the mat leave.
They do have 2 vacancies that they can’t seem to fill but that doesn’t seem connected to them as there are vacancies at all the local ones too (my facebook feed seems to spam me with all of them!).
Low turnover is one of the things I liked about it. I’d see how it is when you start but have a back up plan.

Freddiefox · 28/10/2021 23:41

Lots of nursery staff have decided that it’s not really worth the money and its easier to work in a shop, or similar.
The money is better and it’s less responsibility.
I think covid gave people a chance to re evaluate their lives.
Covid and lock down was also a hard work, and lots of staff now feel undervalued so are moving on.

drpaddington · 28/10/2021 23:39

I've worked in a nursery for years. I find that it goes through phases like this- staff will leave one after the other- then it settles down. We have had lots of staff leave over the last few months and I'd say nearly all of them did so because they weren't happy. Honestly, lots of the staff still there weren't happy either.

That's not always the case though, sometimes there are genuine reasons and it's not a reflection on the nursery or the care provided.

MoreThanAnOffDay · 28/10/2021 23:38

That would put me off

My dds pre school have had the same members for years. Not one change

Pleasegodgotosleep · 28/10/2021 23:26

In the current climate I wouldn't be worried about this. Many council run/state nurseries are heavily recruiting. Private nursery staff are moving for better conditions/holidays etc. It will all level out soon.

mynameiscalypso · 28/10/2021 23:06

I think it's a really tough time for nurseries to find staff at the moment. Quite a few of the overseas staff at DS' nursery decided to go home to their families when Covid struck too and they've struggled to replace them. That said, the core management team have remained the same so there is some continuity. It's tough though - I want the people who look after DS to be paid well and be happy with their working conditions. I do get the sense that that is the case with DS' nursery but I think you're right to be concerned.

MissCruellaDeVil · 28/10/2021 22:59

I would be concerned, high staff turnover in an education setting normally means it's an unpleasant place to work, and this reflects on the provision for children.

LittleRedYoshi · 28/10/2021 22:55

In the past - yes, this would have been a warning sign. But in the current environment, no - lots of childcare providers are seeing this right now - there have been news articles about it. It's one of the areas that's been hit by Brexit - there's fewer childcare staff around now, so those that are still here have their pick of jobs and are moving around to take advantage - hence high turnover.

myheartskippedabeat · 28/10/2021 22:53

Has one of them set up another setting and poached all the staff?
That happend near here afew years back

LizS16 · 28/10/2021 22:50

My daughter is at a nursery where this has just happened and I also started having alarm bells. There's completely new management after 5 members of staff left. We were told the reasons why and they all had genuine reasons so I decided to give it a month and then look at potentially moving. It turns out it was the best thing that could have happened as the new management team is super enthusiastic and have just done really well on their last OFSTED. It seems like a much happier place and my daughter is now really keen to go. Maybe it isn't always such a bad thing to have new staff in?!