Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

weird text from lady on facebook marketplace. Now I don't know if I was U?

262 replies

Sneezecakesmama · 28/10/2021 18:34

I couldn't find my umbrella so decided on buying one off FB marketplace.
Found a nice Joules one for £15 and asked to buy it.
At 09.12 am had the conversation via messenger and agreed to buy. She said it would be on the doorstep and put the money through the letterbox. Fine by me.

I asked what time was convenient and she replied no later than 12.15 as she was going out and gave me the address. I said I would be there at 12.
At 11am I found my umbrella (DH had it) so messaged her at 11.12 am to apologise and say I didn't need it after all, but thank you very much.
She replied
Is this a joke I have changed my plans plus taken item off eBay!!!?
I am fuming Angry reported and informed police as you have our address plus our plans!! Very odd

It was literally 2 hours so why take it off eBay? She hadn't changed her plans and why that level of aggression?

Was I really being as unreasonable as she says? Genuinely confused!

OP posts:
MrsDThomas · 29/10/2021 07:40

YANBU. She sounds pretty unhinged. Its always best to meet at a neutral place. I do this unless i know the person.

And threatening to inform the police shows she’s an odd cookie.

PetriDisher · 29/10/2021 07:36

Sofiegiraffe At very high level - in England to create a legally binding contract you need offer, acceptance, consideration (which can simply take the form of exchange of promises - 'I'll pay you £1'/ 'I'll give you this item') and intention to create legal relations (a pretty low bar and subject to certain presumptions depending on whether, for example, the context of the other three elements was in a domestic familial setting (presumption against) or - like a FBM setting - a commercial context (presumption for)). Those elements can be present verbally or in any written form. Writing is not required for a contract, it just makes its existence and the terms of it easier to establish if one part seems to enforce later.

It's very easy to create a legally binding contract in a way people would think of as 'casually'. Certain terms may be explicit or implied (e.g. about quality), and misrepresentation can affect your obligations but if you have created a contract and there is no legal 'out' identified, you have created obligations for yourself.

In reality is anyone likely to try to enforce those obligations against you for something agreed for sale in FBM for £5, or even suffer compensateable loss if you back out it? Probably not. And there will be plenty of nuance in every situation that could affect the analysis of the basic principles.

If anyone find themselves in an uncertain legal situation around contracts and sale of goods they should seek proper legal advice rather than relying on any basic internet outlines of general principles by me or anyone else.

But my basic point is, please don't state your personal moral reasoning and opinion as though it were actually the law, because it may mislead people.

shivbo2014 · 29/10/2021 07:32

You didnt do anything wrong, people are allowed to change their mind. Her problem for taking it off ebay, obviously you don't do that unless the item has sold and been collected. I've had people change their mind on items they were going to buy, it wouldn't occur to me to be annoyed. Its just one of those things.

Sofiegiraffe · 29/10/2021 07:22

You also have her address and this would concern me too.there are some weirdos on these sites

Why do people keep saying this? OP would have had the seller's address regardless of the sale completing or not. How does OP changing her mind about the purchase increase the risk to the seller in terms of awareness of her home location? OP would have still known it after collecting the brolly (had she done so)Confused

Andwander · 29/10/2021 07:14

It is not very odd at all.I can totally sympathise with the seller.There is nothing so annoying then timewasters on Ebay and FB.You also have her address and this would concern me too.there are some weirdos on these sites.I would have bought the brolly.the seller has obviously made an effort to give you your bought item and you totally disreslected her effort.

Sofiegiraffe · 29/10/2021 07:05

@PetriDisher

Sofiegiraffe You have completely misunderstood the law of contract, what does and does not constitute a legally binding one (spoiler - one can absolutely be created via FB Messenger, or indeed verbally) and what happens to that contract in the event of misrepresentation, faulty goods or one person "changing their mind". I don't propose to set out a full correction because it would be long and is not the point of this thread, but I just wanted to put that marker down for anyone who might think your post is accurate advice - it is not.

Please do point out how a verbal exchange or FB message creates a legal obligation to buy??

spudjulia · 29/10/2021 07:01

Having wasted a significant proportion of my morning snoozing time reading this thread, I'm pretty sure that agreeing to drive for an hour to get a second hand umbrella (presumably in the rain) because you couldn't find yours, then finding yours and cancelling on the seller, then making a post about them on a public forum to ridicule them, whilst claiming not to even be bothered, by the seller or by anyone who disagrees with you, is more unreasonable than being irritated because you've been messed around by a FB buyer and sending them a private message to express that.

50ShadesOfCatholic · 29/10/2021 06:55

You should have just bought it but yeah her response was ott.

THisbackwithavengeance · 29/10/2021 06:51

I get that she has been mildly inconvenienced. Although given that she was out at the time you were supposed to call suggests that she didn't have to wait in for you or anything like that so I would suggest that the inconvenience was very minimum. At least you messaged her; most people would just have not turned up.

As for suggestions that the OP shouldve bought the item anyway out of kindness or altruism, why should she? It's a financial transaction not a charitable donation.

I worry about the mental health of people who claim to be "fuming" after such a minor inconvenience. How do such people cope when real bad things happen to them?

If you sell on second hand platforms like FB and Ebay, you have to accept that there will be a certain amount of inconvenience, mad buyers and pisstakers and adopt a zen approach. Her reaction was actually ridiculous and I hope the police told her to piss off.

garlictwist · 29/10/2021 06:46

YABU to spend £15 on a second hand umbrella

strawberrydonuts · 29/10/2021 06:43

The police aren't going to care at all but I can see why she was annoyed.

Once you'd agreed you should have just gone ahead with the purchase.

ElftonWednesday · 29/10/2021 06:34

YANBU, you are entitled to change your mind about a purchase and you let her know. A lot of people would have just not bothered to turn up and she would be left wondering. She sounds unhinged. Ignore.

Pancakeorcrepe · 29/10/2021 06:33

YABU and she’s not the weird one here. I would have just still bought the umbrella.
What you did was annoying and selfish.

YouJustFoldItIn · 29/10/2021 06:31

I don't understand why either of you would go to all this trouble over a second hand umbrella when you could have nipped into an supermarket and picked one up cheaply and easily. I have no idea how much a new Joules umbrella would usually cost but 15 quid seems a lot to me for a second hand brolly, plus Ebay postage. Confused

She's bonkers to report you to the police. I bet they had a good old chuckle at that.

Nowt so queer as folk.

PetriDisher · 29/10/2021 06:28

Sofiegiraffe You have completely misunderstood the law of contract, what does and does not constitute a legally binding one (spoiler - one can absolutely be created via FB Messenger, or indeed verbally) and what happens to that contract in the event of misrepresentation, faulty goods or one person "changing their mind". I don't propose to set out a full correction because it would be long and is not the point of this thread, but I just wanted to put that marker down for anyone who might think your post is accurate advice - it is not.

lottiegarbanzo · 29/10/2021 06:26

That is a truly excellent point PetriDisher

PetriDisher · 29/10/2021 06:19

It seems to me that you are suffering from a particularly modern twist on self-absorbtion.

It seems that you simply can't grasp that your actions have negatively impacted someone else or, if you can, you don't really care. After all, the situation suits you fine - you found your umbrella - so what's the problem, really?

The "other people do worse" defence is particularly ridiculous - that one will let you excuse yourself for just about anything short of murder!

Reneging on your bargain is one (very annoying) thing, but to do it and then profess to not be bothered about the inconvenience (and possibly worry) you've caused someone and hold them up for ridicule and censure - as you've done on this thread - is another.

We all do things to inconvenience other people at times, but a decent person genuinely apologises for it, which involves understanding that you are in the wrong, saying so and accepting the other person's right to be annoyed with us. It doesn't involve a cursory "sorry" followed by outrage that the other person still thinks poorly of you and appealing to the masses to tell you you're not in the wrong.

By itself, this is a minor incident in the scheme of things, yes, but your "I'm the main character" attitude (of which I expect you're completely unaware given how common it is) has annoyed me, I'm afraid! And if everyone behaves like you (which, more and more, they are) it makes the world just that little bit of a worse, more mannerless, more difficult, place to be.

So yes, YABU!

lottiegarbanzo · 29/10/2021 05:55

I'm amazed she would leave it outside and trust a stranger to post the money through the door.

I'm amazed you would drive an hour to collect an umbrella. (I guess you mean half an hour each way, which isn't quite so crazy as an hour but still). Then to come over all pious about carbon footprints! (You must be able to laugh at yourself about that, it is an absurd stance).

Rollmopsrule · 29/10/2021 05:52

'I think I'm about as bothered as upsetting the strange woman grin'

If your so not bothered about the whole thing why have you posted it on Aibu?

TasteTheMeatNotTheHeat · 29/10/2021 05:42

Obviously it's ridiculous of her to say she's contacting the police but I can understand that she's annoyed. You wasted her time.

Onlinedilema · 29/10/2021 05:35

Am I the only person alive who has more than one brolly?

PinkSyCo · 29/10/2021 05:22

What a load of drama over a poxy umbrella. What sort of person pisses about searching for second hand umbrellas when you can buy a new one for a couple of quid? Also I’m guessing it was raining when you started looking for your brolly, so why did you not guess that your DH was using it? And when you did find out surely you could have gone ahead and bought the Joules one so that you and your DH could each have your very own umbrella.

Sofiegiraffe · 29/10/2021 04:49

I honestly don't understand this concept that she was obligated to buy because a message had been exchanged to that effect. Bear in mind she hasn't even physically seen the item yet. Imagine she turned up at the seller's house and it was faulty when she attempted to use it? Imagine it had appeared to be black in the photos but was in fact closer to dark blue in reality, and OP didn't want a dark blue brolly, she wanted black. Imagine there was a hole in it, disguised on the photos ... etc etc. So many reasons why a person might see the item and change their mind. Or of course, they might just change their mind regardless of any of the above - and that's OK. It is not a binding contract to swap messages saying you want the item.

As I said earlier in thread, I had a "buyer" turn up at my house after messaging me about a brand new unworn and still tagged in box pair of trainers that didn't fit my daughter. She drove over an hour to my house, asked on the doorstep to try them on (I obliged - only allowed her to try one of course in case she ran off 😳), and then proceeded to say "oh they don't fit, wrong size- I'm a size 4 and these are a 3". The size was very clearly listed in the advert and she had also asked me in the message exchange what size?! 🤦🏼‍♀️ Anyway... it was annoying, yes (also a bit amusing if I'm honest😂), but I was very pleased I hadn't removed them from sale yet. For this very reason - things can fall through.

So .... take home points: Grin

  1. No one is obliged to follow through on a purchase of any item unless they have signed a legally binding contract. FB messenger is not such a contact.
  1. Removing an item from sale before seller has completed purchase (i.e. monies exchanged) is a bad idea - wait until they have physically paid for and taken the item!
  1. If someone exercises their right to change their mind - don't be an arsehole and threaten them with the police. Just sigh and move on.

Think that covers it 😂

Sofiegiraffe · 29/10/2021 04:32

@Platax

It was literally 2 hours so why take it off eBay

Why wouldn't she take it off eBay once she had a firm agreement to sell?

For precisely the reason she is now fuming! In case it falls through!

Sofiegiraffe · 29/10/2021 04:31

@Eeiliethya

Blimey, how do people have the energy to give this much of a fuck about a £15 brolly.

Yes it's irritating being messed around but it's an umbrella. Not a 4K prized bull.

Grin