Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

weird text from lady on facebook marketplace. Now I don't know if I was U?

262 replies

Sneezecakesmama · 28/10/2021 18:34

I couldn't find my umbrella so decided on buying one off FB marketplace.
Found a nice Joules one for £15 and asked to buy it.
At 09.12 am had the conversation via messenger and agreed to buy. She said it would be on the doorstep and put the money through the letterbox. Fine by me.

I asked what time was convenient and she replied no later than 12.15 as she was going out and gave me the address. I said I would be there at 12.
At 11am I found my umbrella (DH had it) so messaged her at 11.12 am to apologise and say I didn't need it after all, but thank you very much.
She replied
Is this a joke I have changed my plans plus taken item off eBay!!!?
I am fuming Angry reported and informed police as you have our address plus our plans!! Very odd

It was literally 2 hours so why take it off eBay? She hadn't changed her plans and why that level of aggression?

Was I really being as unreasonable as she says? Genuinely confused!

OP posts:
Cheeserton · 29/10/2021 09:58

Total overreaction, but you should have kept your word and honoured the deal.

Sofiegiraffe · 29/10/2021 09:57

@PetriDisher

Sofiegiraffe Oh come on, we're all wrong sometimes - it happens to me all the time, I can promise you!

Anyway, back to the OP.

Patronising. Again.

Sofiegiraffe · 29/10/2021 09:57

just suggesting that you don't declare things like this that you think should be true as though they are concrete fact when they are not.

I didn't say anything was "concrete fact" ffs

PetriDisher · 29/10/2021 09:56

Sofiegiraffe Oh come on, we're all wrong sometimes - it happens to me all the time, I can promise you!

Anyway, back to the OP.

Sofiegiraffe · 29/10/2021 09:56

I had a longer response than this but I'm not trying to be a dick about it,

This is so unbelievably patronising.

Lavendersquare · 29/10/2021 09:56

@Sneezecakesmama I think you did the right thing in telling her you no longer needed the umbrella far worse to have just been a no show.

Some people who are selling stuff can be really tricky, I once ordered something from eBay that didn't arrive, the seller was really difficult and wouldn't send the tracking/proof of postage. When they eventually did it turned out they used my postcode with a random house number. I tracked down the parcel from the other end of the street but the seller was unapologetic and told me off for wasting her time because apparently any normal person would have checked with the whole street before bothering the seller.

Sofiegiraffe · 29/10/2021 09:54

I'm referring to the civil law as opposed to criminal law, of which contract law is a part. And so were you.

I was referring to criminal law. But I'm sure with how superior you are, you can tell me with certainty that I wasn't and you evidently know exactly what I was thinking when I typed.

Sofiegiraffe · 29/10/2021 09:51

Ok @PetriDisher you're clearly a superior person to me and I do hope you feel much better now.

🙄

PetriDisher · 29/10/2021 09:30

anxiousoverthinker I assume you are sofiegiraffe? I'm referring to the civil law as opposed to criminal law, of which contract law is a part. And so were you.

My objection was to you stating things like, "No one is obliged to follow through on a purchase of any item unless they have signed a legally binding contract. FB messenger is not such a contract" (incorrect on several counts and nothing to do with criminal law), "it's not a binding contract to swap messages saying you want an item" (it could well be if all elements of a contract are present, and this is nothing to do with criminal law) etc.

Binding contracts and legal obligations often have absolutely nothing to do with criminal law but they are still obligations a court will enforce and that can cause people to be on the wrong side of a judgment / costs order if they take internet posts like that at face value. I had a longer response than this but I'm not trying to be a dick about it, just suggesting that you don't declare things like this that you think should be true as though they are concrete fact when they are not.

General plea: People of the internet - never rely anything you read on internet forums about the law (including from me!) - get independent legal advice from a reputable, regulated source!

gingerbiscuits · 29/10/2021 09:22

🤣 People buying & selling on FB Marketplace can be SO weird! I advertised some stuff a few months ago & was told to go f*ck myself by a charming person when I politely messaged him back in response to his query to tell him that an item had literally just been sold but that I'd come back to him 1st if the person didn't turn up to collect it!! Some people are just batshit crazy!

Sofiegiraffe · 29/10/2021 08:53

Would the police actually do anything proactive about her concerns? Probably not.

Definitely not. They'd probably say "it seems she was just wanting to purchase a brolly and has now changed her mind. But we shall be on the look out for a brolly-less criminal staking out the local area for empty houses........." then do this Hmm and leave, probably annoyed at their time being wasted.

Vickles20 · 29/10/2021 08:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

anxiousoverthinker · 29/10/2021 08:48

@PetriDisher

So we are at cross purposes them, as opposed to me talking rubbish. I'm referring to criminal law whilst you appear to be referring to consumer law. Either way, the police aren't interested. Ridiculously over the top reaction.
And yes, seller is beyond paranoid to assume that. She's given her address out willingly online regardless so 🤷‍♀️, if you do that; you accept that another person knows where you live.

TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross · 29/10/2021 08:40

£15 and an hour’s drive for a second hand umbrella? Never mind the (undoubtedly twattish) decision to pull out of the deal at the last minute, YABU for that alone.

Nice try with the carbon footprint excuse though - as if you give the tiniest of shits about that 😂

PetriDisher · 29/10/2021 08:32

I'm truly sorry, I will learn the rules of the game and do better next time!

Whinge · 29/10/2021 08:30

See, I think going out and buying another umbrella you don't need because you've found yours would be weird.

It's no weirder than driving for an hour to buy an umbrella.

RicePleaseJan · 29/10/2021 08:29

I'm sorry, but are you new?

*I mean, you come on here, with your reasonable tone, your well-constructed sentences, knowing what you're talking about - what's your game, sunshine? It's exactly this sort of rationality and expertise that can cause irreparable damage to Mumsnet specifically and social media as a whole. Is that what you want? Is it?

It's a disgrace. Bloody tree-hugging c*ommie
Well said. Get out of here and come back when you can suggest the OP chases the seller down the street with a striped yet also floral brolly.

PetriDisher · 29/10/2021 08:28

sofiegiraffe Agreed, no crime!

Though I believe that the reason the seller threatened to contact the police was not because the OP pulled out of the sale as such, but because she was concerned that the OP was a scammer trying to find out when her house would be unoccupied.

Paranoid? Probably. Would the police actually do anything proactive about her concerns? Probably not. Did the seller actually call the police? Doubtful. But I don't think the part about the police was about the OP not ultimately buying the umbrella.

DecadentlyDecisive · 29/10/2021 08:27

@Pancakeorcrepe

YABU and she’s not the weird one here. I would have just still bought the umbrella. What you did was annoying and selfish.
Really?

See, I think going out and buying another umbrella you don't need because you've found yours would be weird.

OP did the right thing - at least she told the seller she was cancelling!!

DecadentlyDecisive · 29/10/2021 08:24

She sounds like a classic Mumsnetter to me!! Grin

I've had people cancel, I much prefer them to the one's that just don't turn up.

Block her on FB & leave her to froth.

PetriDisher · 29/10/2021 08:24

WalkingOnTheCracks This made me laugh! Thanks for the "reasonable" rather than "pious" which I can easily see me straying into!

BirdyBirdyTweetTweet · 29/10/2021 08:22

I think you were committed to buying. As nice as joules are, you could have bought a cheaper one elsewhere.

However, she did overreact.

Sofiegiraffe · 29/10/2021 08:21

@PetriDisher

Ok, I'll rephrase. There is no criminal law broken by changing your mind about a purchase before monies are exchanged and the involving of the police malarkey is ridiculous. If that were a legal issue the police would be being called every time someone got to the checkout in Tesco and said "sorry changed my mind about that item". That's what I meant. It's the seller's reference to the police that is ridiculously OTT.

Blondeshavemorefun · 29/10/2021 08:05

@callmeadoctor

Cant get past the fact that it would have been an hours drive, for an UMBRELLA!!!!!!!!!!
I missed that

An hour ?

Again drive to local poundshop for one for £1

WalkingOnTheCracks · 29/10/2021 07:57

@PetriDisher

Sofiegiraffe At very high level - in England to create a legally binding contract you need offer, acceptance, consideration (which can simply take the form of exchange of promises - 'I'll pay you £1'/ 'I'll give you this item') and intention to create legal relations (a pretty low bar and subject to certain presumptions depending on whether, for example, the context of the other three elements was in a domestic familial setting (presumption against) or - like a FBM setting - a commercial context (presumption for)). Those elements can be present verbally or in any written form. Writing is not required for a contract, it just makes its existence and the terms of it easier to establish if one part seems to enforce later.

It's very easy to create a legally binding contract in a way people would think of as 'casually'. Certain terms may be explicit or implied (e.g. about quality), and misrepresentation can affect your obligations but if you have created a contract and there is no legal 'out' identified, you have created obligations for yourself.

In reality is anyone likely to try to enforce those obligations against you for something agreed for sale in FBM for £5, or even suffer compensateable loss if you back out it? Probably not. And there will be plenty of nuance in every situation that could affect the analysis of the basic principles.

If anyone find themselves in an uncertain legal situation around contracts and sale of goods they should seek proper legal advice rather than relying on any basic internet outlines of general principles by me or anyone else.

But my basic point is, please don't state your personal moral reasoning and opinion as though it were actually the law, because it may mislead people.

I'm sorry, but are you new?

I mean, you come on here, with your reasonable tone, your well-constructed sentences, knowing what you're talking about - what's your game, sunshine? It's exactly this sort of rationality and expertise that can cause irreparable damage to Mumsnet specifically and social media as a whole. Is that what you want? Is it?

It's a disgrace. Bloody tree-hugging commie.