Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

weird text from lady on facebook marketplace. Now I don't know if I was U?

262 replies

Sneezecakesmama · 28/10/2021 18:34

I couldn't find my umbrella so decided on buying one off FB marketplace.
Found a nice Joules one for £15 and asked to buy it.
At 09.12 am had the conversation via messenger and agreed to buy. She said it would be on the doorstep and put the money through the letterbox. Fine by me.

I asked what time was convenient and she replied no later than 12.15 as she was going out and gave me the address. I said I would be there at 12.
At 11am I found my umbrella (DH had it) so messaged her at 11.12 am to apologise and say I didn't need it after all, but thank you very much.
She replied
Is this a joke I have changed my plans plus taken item off eBay!!!?
I am fuming Angry reported and informed police as you have our address plus our plans!! Very odd

It was literally 2 hours so why take it off eBay? She hadn't changed her plans and why that level of aggression?

Was I really being as unreasonable as she says? Genuinely confused!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tal45 · 30/10/2021 15:51

You should have looked properly for your umbrella in the first place so you didn't end up wasting her time. People do this sort of thing all the time which is why she is so pissed off.

Shasha17 · 30/10/2021 15:48

I'd be angry with you too and would just have bought it having already arranged it

FreshFancyFrogglette · 30/10/2021 15:30

Well you cant take the umbrella to the shop and exchange it for food, so potentially going hungry for a day whilst she tries to find another buyer... Or anything else that she has committed to with the assumption she would have £15 to pay for it.

Sofiegiraffe · 30/10/2021 11:47

@LaetitiaASD
Very sensible posts, with which I fully agree.

LaetitiaASD · 30/10/2021 11:18

And another thing... when selling on facebook or anywhere else there are three types of "deal" -

Deals that never happen

Deals where you get money in exchange for the item

The bad deals - the ones where you end up without the money or the item

If you have so few bad deals that you have the time and energy to get upset with the deals that don't happen then you're winning.

LaetitiaASD · 30/10/2021 11:14

@FreshFancyFrogglette

Exactly *@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll* the fact that people can't comprehend why shes upset is surprising to me.

Imagine loosing your last £15 on the way to the shop, that's what it feels like.

But she still has the umbrella worth £15 so what exactly has she lost other than a small bit of time? A small bit of time that could easily have been lost as a result of the umbrella selling on facebook and ebay and leaving seller as the one having to renege on a deal.
LaetitiaASD · 30/10/2021 11:12

@Luckingfovely

You committed to buy it, you should have bought it. You're totally in the wrong. Yeah, her message wasn't exactly mature and the police thing is obviously stupid, but she's right to be fuming.
In theory yes, but back in the real world people change their mind or can't get transport all the time, and change buying plans as a result.

Annoying to take something off ebay and then find it isn't sold, but then again she has no obligation to list in multiple places, and she could easily have committed to sell to OP and then found it sold on ebay as well and then she'd have been the one having to pull out of one of the sales.

The seller is rightfully a bit annoyed, but the reaction was completely OTT, it happens all the time and the seller was a bit crazy.

Sofiegiraffe · 29/10/2021 14:11

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

This is a false analogy as no "refund" was requested by OP - no monies were yet exchanged. She changed her mind - it's allowed.

Sofiegiraffe - You took only one of my two paragraphs and responded to it in isolation - if you took note of the whole comment, you will see the full analogy that I was suggesting.

Yes I read your entire comment. You are talking about a refund - you say what if her DP had found the brolly after monies had been exchanged and OP had then decided she wanted a refund, right? Well, I stand by my comment - that's a false comparison. She didn't want a refund as monies were never exchanged. Unless I am missing something else of what you mean?

FreshFancyFrogglette · 29/10/2021 13:24

Exactly @WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll the fact that people can't comprehend why shes upset is surprising to me.

Imagine loosing your last £15 on the way to the shop, that's what it feels like.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/10/2021 13:16

Blimey, how do people have the energy to give this much of a fuck about a £15 brolly.

Yes it's irritating being messed around but it's an umbrella. Not a 4K prized bull.

Do you think the same about other (potentially) poor people 'banging on' about the removal of their 'only £20' weekly UC uplift?

There are rich people out there who would be totally unable to understand somebody caring about a theoretical £4K bull - as it's 'hardly a £60M Van Gogh, is it'.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/10/2021 13:11

This is a false analogy as no "refund" was requested by OP - no monies were yet exchanged. She changed her mind - it's allowed.

Sofiegiraffe - You took only one of my two paragraphs and responded to it in isolation - if you took note of the whole comment, you will see the full analogy that I was suggesting.

Sofiegiraffe · 29/10/2021 12:14

@spudjulia ok then 😂😂

spudjulia · 29/10/2021 12:12

[quote Sofiegiraffe]@spudjulia

Firstly, I disagree that I made any "personal attacks" - I made a comment on what I felt a person's tone was towards me, and I'm entitled to that opinion.

Secondly, the issue has been resolved between that poster and I - your input is unnecessary.

Thirdly, I honestly, genuinely do not care how I "look coming out of this". It has about as much relevance to my life as what a random stranger on the bus that just went past by house thinks of me. Smile[/quote]
You made personal comments about the poster that had nothing to do with the point of the thread. And while you are completely entitled to having an opinion on the nature and tone of another poster, and indeed entitled to behave however you like, readers are also entitled to form an opinion of you based on your behaviour. Quite ironic that you're telling me my 'input' is unnecessary, when you have made personal comments that derailed the thread. Strangely, I don't come to you for permission or acceptance about what and when I post. And my post was not really intended for your benefit; there's so much crap on MN that I try to point out when I believe posters have been reasonable and helpful, which I think @PetriDisher has been. If you wanted to take anything from my post, great. If you wanted to dig yourself even deeper, fine. No skin off my nose.

Andwander · 29/10/2021 12:03

@shivbo2014.you would not last long on ebay.ebay is tough on timewasters and buyers who fuck up a sale because they change their mindAngry

Sofiegiraffe · 29/10/2021 11:29

Apologies to the OP for the unnecessary derail. Thanks

Sofiegiraffe · 29/10/2021 11:27

@spudjulia

Firstly, I disagree that I made any "personal attacks" - I made a comment on what I felt a person's tone was towards me, and I'm entitled to that opinion.

Secondly, the issue has been resolved between that poster and I - your input is unnecessary.

Thirdly, I honestly, genuinely do not care how I "look coming out of this". It has about as much relevance to my life as what a random stranger on the bus that just went past by house thinks of me. Smile

spudjulia · 29/10/2021 10:31

[quote Sofiegiraffe]@PetriDisher
It's not actually your knowledge I have an issue with, it's your apparent superiority complex and the way you "correct" me as though you're such a better person than I am. You're not. No matter how much you talk down to me. [/quote]
Petridisher has been very polite considering your hesitance to accept that you were wrong and your personal attacks once you had nowhere left to go. Your initial response should have been along the lines of "hands up, I've no clue about contract law, it was just my best guess. Probably best to ask an expert". You would have come out of this looking much better.

Scirocco · 29/10/2021 10:20

Once you agreed to buy it, you really should have followed through. It wasn't a huge amount of money and it was for an item which would realistically have been useful so it wouldn't have been a waste for you. It's bad etiquette to withdraw from a purchase once it's been agreed.

The police thing is probably just to warn you away if you're a criminal - people use the same/similar approach as your actions could appear, in order to get an address and a clear window of opportunity to access a probably empty property. I don't think the police would actually be interested in you at all unless someone broke into the seller's house during the relevant timeframe.

gillsareforfish · 29/10/2021 10:17

Ooops sorry wrong thread

yikesanotherbooboo · 29/10/2021 10:17

Obviously the police won't be interested but you behaved dishonourably. You agreed to buy it . If you didn't need it you could have sold it on or given it away. The environmental point is disingenuous .

gillsareforfish · 29/10/2021 10:13

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 29/10/2021 10:10

[quote Sofiegiraffe]@PetriDisher
It's not actually your knowledge I have an issue with, it's your apparent superiority complex and the way you "correct" me as though you're such a better person than I am. You're not. No matter how much you talk down to me. [/quote]
@Sofiegiraffe

I think PetriDisher was reasonable, measured and avoided making it personal.

....how would you rather be told you're mistaken?

MintyGreenDream · 29/10/2021 10:05

You were being a classic fb timewaster

PetriDisher · 29/10/2021 10:05

sofiegiraffe I'm sorry I've come across that way. I'm not correcting what you said because I think I'm a better person than you (being right or wrong about the law says absolutely nothing about someone as a person in my opinion), but because it was incorrect information on a public forum. That's it.

I don't suppose I can wish you well or a nice day without coming across as patronising, either, but to the extent I can, there it is!

Sofiegiraffe · 29/10/2021 09:59

@PetriDisher
It's not actually your knowledge I have an issue with, it's your apparent superiority complex and the way you "correct" me as though you're such a better person than I am. You're not. No matter how much you talk down to me.