Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to buy the house but only with the land?

108 replies

Sp3849 · 28/10/2021 18:08

So we went to view a house we loved. A rural farmhouse with small parcel of land however on viewing realised it has another parcel to the side of it with caravan on. Asked the agent who it belonged to and they were vague. So before we made an offer I knocked the farm next door. To mainly discuss the access track that runs over thier land and they told us that small parcel of land next to the house with caravan was actually owned by the house In question. The grandchildren of lady who had lived thier (now deceased) frequently partied there. We then went and had a nose and there were beer bottles etc everywhere. I then referred this back to agent who then came back with that the family wanted to keep that part of the land to continue to stay in the caravan a few times a year and share the houses water supply (a well). We have gone back and said we would happily buy the house for the guide price and pay additional 15k for land which is approx 1/3 acre but won't consider buying it without it. My primary concern is that 1. Grandchildren could still party there and 2. What's stopping them renting caravan out etc? It is our responsibility to maintain track etc which they would also need to use to access caravan. Also where would they go to toilet etc. It is currently linked to house electrics which obviously it would be disconnected. I worry it could cause alot of issues. They are still yet to respond to our offer (made 8 days ago) they have had no other offers. Why are they taking so long to respond its driving me insane. Should I ring and put a deadline on the offer? Are we being unreasonable with concerns?

OP posts:
Disfordarkchocolate · 09/11/2021 10:32

That would put me off too.

TopCatsTopHat · 09/11/2021 10:30

For the EA to assume/fail to mention their caravan would just carry on sharing your water!!!! wtaf. Imagine if you had a row over their noise and they decided to pee in it before they left. Envy

TopCatsTopHat · 09/11/2021 10:26

We bought a rural property where the private access road to it is shared with the neighbour. The other owner owns the track and we have documented legal rights to access to it which comes with a duty to share maintenance.
As it happens the neighbour and we have always been very fair about joint maintenance and our legal rights give us protection from funny business. But I am still conscious that if the house next door changed hands and we got a pain in the rear for a neighbour it might get less simple.
I think that even apart from all the potential for cheekyfuckery if the parcel of land stays in their possesion you would at least want their access and joint maintenance of it written into the legal documents but even that wouldn't protect you from them flipping you the bird (which they have form for) and ignoring, all it would do is allow you to serve lawsuits to try to force them to be reasonable... Urgh!
They will feel they have legacy rights to carry on exactly as before and I would fully expect them to have zero consideration for you.

Don't touch it unless they sell the land.

Pipsquiggle · 09/11/2021 10:21

Lots of red flags OP. There would be no way I would buy the property without the land. Imagine buying your forever home with a party caravan next door - horrendous.

I think this sale is salvageable though. You are in a very strong position and if they have a good estate agent, they should be advised to sell the land.

*You are cash buyers
*You are flexible on moving
*They haven't had any other offers - how long has it been on the market?
*Although you found out about the caravan from a neighbour, it should have been discovered by a good solicitor in the searches, so any other future potential buyers will probably have had the same concerns.

I would carry on looking for property. They may need to confer with the rest of the family which is why it is taking time.

I think it is perfectly reasonable to set out a deadline on this but don't give them a really tight deadline - ask the EA how many households are involved in this sale - the more households, the longer it will probably take.

As previously stated, you are in a really strong position - you need to spell this out to the EA and they need to make this clear to the sellers, particularly if they have been trying to sell it for a while.

If this sale progresses, make sure you get a very good solicitor and also keep in touch with the farm next door.

timeisnotaline · 09/11/2021 10:18

@BorryMum

I don't see what is cheeky about it, they want to keep a piece of the land for future use. They aren't going to be teenagers for ever and maybe want the land as they have nice memories of the place. However I wouldn't purchase it unless the land was included purely because it could cause you future problems. It's not cheeky to pick and choose what they want to sell though, it belongs to them and they can sell it how they like.
It’s cheeky to try to hide it. The op didn’t realise that patch of land was on the title but not being sold but would continue to rely on shared water and access. Depending on the caravan type I wonder what their plans were for sewage also, probably not something they had to think about in the past.
Eddielzzard · 09/11/2021 10:17

That caravan sounds like a total nightmare and I wouldn't touch the house without that extra land and checking all restrictions and rights. If they can't even clean up around the caravan while people are viewing the house, it doesn't bode well for how they'll be if you were living there. They clearly couldn't give a shit.

scottishnames · 09/11/2021 10:10

As a PPfrom Cornwall has said, plots of land with (or likely to get) planning permission are selling for silly money in scenic areas, especially if there is water/electricity on site.
I'd think an offer of £15,000 was 'cheeky'; the going rate for 1/3 acre with shared access in scenic parts of Scotland would be many times that, for eg:
www.fiuran.co.uk/oban/properties/plot-2-airdeny-mill-taynuilt-argyll-pa35-1hy/

But quite apart from that, you surely would not want to be living next door to a party caravan - especially a party caravan owned by people who did not clear their rubbish (bottles) away, and who have past form for not getting on with other neighbours?

You can buy Land Registry documents for any house, so it would be an idea, if you are still interested, to buy those for all the adjacent properties. Money well spent, IMHO.

As a different PP has said, shared road access need not be an issue; it's quite common in rural areas. And - though this is not the easiest thing to do - if the owners of the bit of land with the caravan had used the roadway for a certain number of years, they might be able to claim that they'd established a right to do so. Also, as PP said, it would be almost impossible to stop them if they really wanted to.

Kuachui · 09/11/2021 10:10

to be fair i would walk because owning the land means shit, they can still party there as doesnt seem like they will care

RubyViolet · 09/11/2021 10:06

Give them a week to consider your offer.
If it’s a no then go back with your best and final offer and a 48 hour deadline.
If it’s still no just walk away, l have experience of a land dispute over access and utilities, it was not something l would want to go through ever again.

Yuledo · 09/11/2021 09:44

Big reg flags waving in the wind.

MapleMay11 · 09/11/2021 09:40

From what you've said, the land was never for sale and they don't want to sell. You're not in a position to make demands so walk away.

BorryMum · 09/11/2021 09:39

I don't see what is cheeky about it, they want to keep a piece of the land for future use. They aren't going to be teenagers for ever and maybe want the land as they have nice memories of the place. However I wouldn't purchase it unless the land was included purely because it could cause you future problems. It's not cheeky to pick and choose what they want to sell though, it belongs to them and they can sell it how they like.

godmum56 · 09/11/2021 09:36

Yanbu and I would do the same

HoikingUpMyBigGirlPantss · 09/11/2021 09:35

Chase up the EA and check online with Land registry (only a couple of £) ... but a "secret" party caravan with shared utilities/access, and previous neighbour issues, that would be a no from me too.

BackInBlackAgain · 09/11/2021 09:17

@LakieLady

I think the vendors were hoping to keep this quiet and therefore I wouldn't trust them as far as I could throw them.

Although it has occurred to me that if the track is built on land belonging to the farmer, and use by others is only permitted to access the house you're thinking of buying, it might be that once they've sold the house, they have no right to access the party field.

Which would amuse me no end, and mean that their party field was of no use to them whatsoever.

With them being CF already i honestly think it wouldnt bother them at all if they didnt have permission to use the lane to get to the land, they would still use it. Unfortunately this would be a civil matter so OP couldnt even ring the police to stop them using the lane.
Tulipomania · 09/11/2021 09:04

They will be planning to develop the plot of land with the caravan and probably hope to build a house on it.

The caravan will be used as precedence for residential accommodation.

You are right to be cautious and insist on buying the additional land too, or walk away.

ChalfontPark · 09/11/2021 08:55

You sound overinvested already. If they want to keep the piece of land for their own use, they are perfectly entitled to do so.

Obviously if they do sell the house, a lawyer will have to make arrangements to formalise access rights and they will need to sort out independent services (electricity / sewerage).

You don't have to buy the house from them if what they're offering doesn't work for you!

pasturesgreen · 09/11/2021 08:54

I wouldn't touch it with a barge pole unless they accept your offer. You'll have no end of trouble if the previous owner's grandchildren still have access to the land and caravan.

Chimley · 09/11/2021 08:54

You're right to be hesitant about what else they're hiding but downloading the LR details (£6 for deeds and map together) should put your mind at rest re ownership of all the land. If it's all under one title still then your solicitor would have pointed this out anyway at some point. Some people really are oblivious when trying to hide stuff.

LakieLady · 09/11/2021 08:49

I think the vendors were hoping to keep this quiet and therefore I wouldn't trust them as far as I could throw them.

Although it has occurred to me that if the track is built on land belonging to the farmer, and use by others is only permitted to access the house you're thinking of buying, it might be that once they've sold the house, they have no right to access the party field.

Which would amuse me no end, and mean that their party field was of no use to them whatsoever.

HeronLanyon · 09/11/2021 08:47

Absolutely no way would I consider this. Even with the small parcel of land aren’t they going to be rather close anyway ? Now you know they’ve been slightly problematic neighbours and knowing they would simply relocate their party caravan ?
I’ve walked away from dream home after estate agent described field nearby as ‘mixed’ when I asked about it. Mix of old caravans, small livestock enclosure, rotting cars etc. Still think of that house (with unbelievable views and land at front) then I remember that field at the back ! Estate agent really didn’t want me walking the land so I wouldn’t see it.

Dontcryformeallegra · 09/11/2021 08:39

Of course do not proceed unless they accept your offer.

Bargoed · 09/11/2021 08:35

Waves from Wales x The fact this was concealed is what worries me - you could have spent alot of money before this came to light! So they are therfore either naive and think they can just carry on as is or were hoping you got too far into the purchase before this came to light.

TyrannosaurusRights · 09/11/2021 08:34

I’d leave the offer another week but start searching again.

And I’d make sure if that EA had anything even remotely worth seeing I prioritised doing so - a deadline helps but a house with only one offer on it. The EA will definitely push the family (for their commission) once you’re obviously looking elsewhere

JumperandJacket · 09/11/2021 08:27

When we were looking for a rural house we saw a few where the seller planned to keep a bit of land close to the house for camping etc. It was a complete deal-breaker for us each time- the last thing we would have wanted is the seller hanging about like a bad smell. In your case where there’s a caravan etc I would not even consider buying, I’m afraid.

Swipe left for the next trending thread