Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to buy the house but only with the land?

108 replies

Sp3849 · 28/10/2021 18:08

So we went to view a house we loved. A rural farmhouse with small parcel of land however on viewing realised it has another parcel to the side of it with caravan on. Asked the agent who it belonged to and they were vague. So before we made an offer I knocked the farm next door. To mainly discuss the access track that runs over thier land and they told us that small parcel of land next to the house with caravan was actually owned by the house In question. The grandchildren of lady who had lived thier (now deceased) frequently partied there. We then went and had a nose and there were beer bottles etc everywhere. I then referred this back to agent who then came back with that the family wanted to keep that part of the land to continue to stay in the caravan a few times a year and share the houses water supply (a well). We have gone back and said we would happily buy the house for the guide price and pay additional 15k for land which is approx 1/3 acre but won't consider buying it without it. My primary concern is that 1. Grandchildren could still party there and 2. What's stopping them renting caravan out etc? It is our responsibility to maintain track etc which they would also need to use to access caravan. Also where would they go to toilet etc. It is currently linked to house electrics which obviously it would be disconnected. I worry it could cause alot of issues. They are still yet to respond to our offer (made 8 days ago) they have had no other offers. Why are they taking so long to respond its driving me insane. Should I ring and put a deadline on the offer? Are we being unreasonable with concerns?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SinoohXaenaHide · 09/11/2021 23:22

Great update. Good luck with the new viewing.

They will probably sell successfully to someone less astute than you. Who will then regret it for decades to come.

billy1966 · 09/11/2021 22:30

Good call OP.

They sound duplicitous.

Best of luck with your next viewing.

scottishnames · 09/11/2021 19:52

unsync Err - no. As said upthread the owners of the caravan plot could possibly/probably claim rights to use the track based on long-term usage.

Also, no-one can just 'cut' access to someone else's water and electricity. Since the plot for sale and the caravan plot look to currently be in the same ownership, the current house/caravan plot owners will presumably have had legal title to both, for both sites. As others have said, unpicking/redistributing all that could be legally complicated - and impossible if the existing owners don't agree. To say nothing of the shared access track, as above.

I'm absolutely not defending the current owners, but I think they are being a lot more canny than some posters here give them credit for.

unsync · 09/11/2021 17:32

Of course if you buy the access road from the farmer and sever the electrics and water, they end up with a worthless piece of land with no access or services. (Just in case other house doesn't work out).

MaggieFS · 09/11/2021 16:44

@Platax

I Honestly wouldn't have known if I hadn't done a bit of digging around.

Yes, you would, because things like rights of way etc are exactly what the conveyancing process is designed to sort out.

There's nothing wrong with you asking (though it sounds as if you could be undervaluing the land), there is nothing wrong with them saying no. But overall you're probably better off continuing to search.

True, but it's frustrating that the OP could have agreed a price, had a survey done, started searches and incurred a fair whack of costs before finding out whereas has it been said from the outset it would have been more straightforward.
TopCatsTopHat · 09/11/2021 16:03

Please report back in the new option - sounds like a better prospect.
We had similar when we were searching for a self build option. Find a place that was great we were keen but it fell through, we were gutted. Then up popped a random alternative which was 1000x better! Now we're in that place and so so much happier as it had everything the other place did and more, for less money. Meant to be sometimes.

Pipsquiggle · 09/11/2021 15:05

Hi OP - you've definitely dodged a bullet there. Good luck with the new search

My prediction is that they will not sell the house as once the searches have taken place - the caravan and access will always come up and the vast majority of people will not find this acceptable.

It's always harder when there are multiple vendors - they rarely ever agree until it's been on the market for ages and then the penny drops

Platax · 09/11/2021 14:08

I Honestly wouldn't have known if I hadn't done a bit of digging around.

Yes, you would, because things like rights of way etc are exactly what the conveyancing process is designed to sort out.

There's nothing wrong with you asking (though it sounds as if you could be undervaluing the land), there is nothing wrong with them saying no. But overall you're probably better off continuing to search.

Thehop · 09/11/2021 13:58

New place sounds brilliant OP.

MRex · 09/11/2021 13:57

@Unsure33

Also - if your solicitor has not pointed this out to you and you had to work this out for yourself I would be worried about their competency as well ?

down load the title deeds and check carefully for covenants such as agricultural restrictions - that could open another can of worms .

Just been through that with a new house where we were assured agricultural restrictions on the land had been lifted - guess what, not true.

No offer was agreed, so unusual for the solicitors to have done any searches yet.
FreeBritnee · 09/11/2021 13:48

We’ve seen lots of old farmhouses with exactly the same set up. For sale with small parcel of land. The rest of the land set aside for good knows what. No thank you.

RobertsRadio · 09/11/2021 13:43

Sounds like the cheaper property could be a much better deal all round Op, hope the viewing goes well.

longtompot · 09/11/2021 13:35

Best of luck with your new viewing. Hope it's as good in person as it is on paper.

Years ago, when we started looking to buy our first home, my dh was chatting to an estate agents who he supports the IT for and they mentioned a gorgeous property which was on the market for much less than it should have been on for. The estate agent then said it was a divorcing couple and that the husband lived above the double garage that was in the back garden and that wouldn't be included in the sale as he would continue to be living there! Thankfully it was an area we weren't even considering, too far away, and was over our budget. I often wonder if it was ever sold and what the situation was like. The garages overlooked the back of the house and you'd feel constantly watched if you were in the garden.

PineappleWilson · 09/11/2021 13:25

Best of luck with your viewing OP. There's a house in our village like your first post, where the family want to keep the adjacent land (they run a business from it). Every few years the house goes up for sale, then is removed from sale when they get no offers because no-one wants a property with so many strings attached. You've dodged a headache.

Unsure33 · 09/11/2021 13:14

Also - if your solicitor has not pointed this out to you and you had to work this out for yourself I would be worried about their competency as well ?

down load the title deeds and check carefully for covenants such as agricultural restrictions - that could open another can of worms .

Just been through that with a new house where we were assured agricultural restrictions on the land had been lifted - guess what, not true.

HazeltonLane · 09/11/2021 13:01

@Marvellousmadness

I wouldn't buy it. You'd be up for a lifetime of potential misery
Agree 100% with this. We had a similar problem at my family home where the neighbouring property was used for extended family get-togethers. The noise was horrific and they were 1/2 mile away!
LakieLady · 09/11/2021 12:59

Disappointing for you, OP, but I think you may well have dodged a bullet there.

I hope everyone else interested is as thorough as you were.

Sp3849 · 09/11/2021 12:56

@Hexinthecity already done this. When they rang they were asking if I would consider it without. I explained to them that is was a definite no, given what I had been told and the evidence I had found myself that confirmed this. I would only buy that house with the land. If they had a price in mind to let me know. She said that they were pretty firm on not selling it. Conversation ended with estate agents saying they would get in touch if the family changed thier minds. But on another note a much cheaper house has come up in much better condition with around the same amount of land and even better with different agent, so of to view that one tomorrow!

OP posts:
JumperandJacket · 09/11/2021 12:53

Dodged a bullet there, OP. I think sellers generally underestimate how off-putting this is for buyers- I remember talking to one seller who tried to reassure me by saying, "I'll just be at the bottom of the garden- you'll hardly notice me!" and that was just one chap, not a party caravan!

Hexinthecity · 09/11/2021 12:45

Their loss @Sp3849. You may we’ll find though that they come back to you in a few months when no other offers come their way, how long has it been on the market? I’d tell the EA that you’re still interested but only if the land is part of the deal and they can contact you when the family realise it’s a deal breaker for any interested parties.

harriethoyle · 09/11/2021 12:43

I think you've definitely dodged a bullet on this one OP... whole thing could have been a nightmare!

elbea · 09/11/2021 12:41

1/3 of an acre is a building plot, you are going to have to pay way more than amenity land value for it.

Sp3849 · 09/11/2021 12:41

@Still1nLove I was thinking the same but a good solicitors should uncover this. Hopefully they wouldn't have forked to much out in costs before they find out!

OP posts:
Still1nLove · 09/11/2021 12:37

I feel sorry for the buyer if they don’t find out about the party caravan

Sp3849 · 09/11/2021 12:34

Well update. Finally! They do not want to sell the land. They have been advised to take our offer by agents but he family cannot reach a unanimous agreement. NO offer will persuade them! so back to houshunting for us.

OP posts: