Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sick of the expectation to work extra hours?

45 replies

Burnt0utMum · 28/10/2021 17:46

My job is a typical 9-5.30 Mon-Fri and WFH. I don't mind being a bit flexible sometimes but also I'm quite limited by my kids' schedules for clubs in the evenings and just generally being there to do dinner etc. and I'm studying part time too so time is limited. I log off on time but other people seem happy to stay hours extra. We've now been told that once a month we'll have to go on a rota to stay til 9pm. The time can then be taken back in the next working day. I said this is going to be really difficult for me to accommodate but was pretty much ignored. AIBU to say I don't mind staying an extra hour or so if it's paid as overtime but not something set in stone til 9pm? It'll be a different day of the week each month too and will definitely clash with my kids clubs.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mrbay · 28/10/2021 19:57

If they aren't willing to flex on this, you won't be the only one who cannot do this.

Put in a flex working request to have your hours officially made permanent. They will need to justify why they need you to cover to 9pm. Unless you have clients/customers requiring assistance until 9pm, I think that they may find it hard to reject your request.

Wishihadanalgorithm · 28/10/2021 19:47

I’d start looking for another job, OP. Why can’t they just employ someone to work the later hours on a permanent basis? Or, if not in the position to hire another person, why not ask if anyone wants to change their working hours?

Everyone working one late a month is fine if everyone has no other commitments but having children with no extra or easy childcare means it isn’t easy for you.

Like I said, look for another post. In the meantime, suck up the one late a month as this shows you are willing to be flexible and it won’t damage a potential reference.

woodhill · 28/10/2021 19:43

I think it's awful and yanbu.

It's hard enough with you working till 1730 and I don't blame you for wanting to leave in time

HamCob · 28/10/2021 19:38

Hmm I'm on the fence. I think for me it would depend on whether it's a well paid salaried job with otherwise good T&Cs. If so then I would probably just suck it up. Many professional jobs require you to do what needs doing to get the job done outside of the core hours. Me & DH often sit on our laptops of an evening when the kids are in bed but we have well paid jobs, good pensions etc so swings & roundabouts.
Minimum wage or a job with low hourly pay then I'd tell them to get stuffed!

LadySybilRamekin · 28/10/2021 19:36

I don't really think it's unreasonable for your husband to do one night a month - surely he can make up for it the other twenty nights? It may not be fair, but I don't think refusing will do you any favours in work - no matter hi unreasonable the request is.

IntermittentParps · 28/10/2021 19:33

Honestly, my colleagues seem more than happy to work extra on a regular basis and make a point of saying what time they worked til the night before
That sounds like a really toxic presenteeist work culture of the kind I loathe, and I do sympathise.
However, if they're otherwise quite flexible and good then I do think you need to suck this one up.
is it not at all possible for your DH to do it at least sometimes? Or for the kids to share lifts, as others have suggested?

middleager · 28/10/2021 19:29

I chose a part-time role, but regularly have to work over evenings and weekends, to the point I don't even want to go out Sat nights in case there is an early morning Sunday phonecall.

I am on an average UK salary. My colleagues are all on double my FT salary and on a higher grade, yet we are all treated the same in terms of expectations. They don't seem to mind working anti social hours though, but they don't have kids.

After eight years it grates. My personal time is not my own and if they doubled my salary too then maybe I wouldn't mind.

For one day a month though I could probably hack it.

themuttsnutts · 28/10/2021 19:27

From ACAS

Indirect discrimination
Indirect discrimination can happen when there are rules or arrangements that apply to a group of employees or job applicants, but in practice are less fair to a certain protected characteristic.

The employee or applicant must be able to prove both of the following about the rule or arrangement:

it's unfair to them and to others with the same protected characteristic, for example a woman believes she's experiencing sex discrimination against women
it's unfair compared with those who do not have the protected characteristic, for example, it's unfair to employees who are women, but not to men

Burnt0utMum · 28/10/2021 19:16

I could take the laptop with me but I doubt I'd get much done. Need to give them dinner before we leave and make sure they're ready. Then driving there and going in and the same on the way back all while trying to keep working without a break up to 9pm. I don't think I'd cope.

OP posts:
NoraEphronsNeck · 28/10/2021 19:14

Can you take your laptop with you and work while they're at their club?

Crazycrazylady · 28/10/2021 19:12

@girlmom21

All that will achieve is damage your relationship with your employers abs your colleagues who will be annoyed that you're not willing to do your share.

Alternatively, a large proportion of employees refuse and the business needs to reassess how to manage the additional workload.

But the op has said her colleagues appear happy to do it so that's not the case here??
ejhhhhh · 28/10/2021 19:10

I’d go back with a compromise. You can do one evening every two months or so, but explain it means your kids missing their clubs so it’s very inconvenient (and I’d find missing 1 out of every 4 club sessions unacceptable). Or just say no, or look for another job. I do think they’re being unreasonable, despite what other posters think!

Burnt0utMum · 28/10/2021 19:09

They are a flexible employer in general but I was reassured of this when I interviewed for the job and I emphasised how important it was to me and I wouldn't have accepted the offer otherwise. Honestly, my colleagues seem more than happy to work extra on a regular basis and make a point of saying what time they worked til the night before. It makes me feel like I'm slacking by logging off on time even though I've worked hard all day. I have done extra in the mornings or evenings here and there but only when it suits me to do it without other aspects of my life suffering. I'd never stay til 9pm even without considering clubs. I'm in bed by 10pm every night exhausted anyway.

OP posts:
jay55 · 28/10/2021 19:02

Can you not share lifts with someone else at the clubs?

girlmom21 · 28/10/2021 19:01

All that will achieve is damage your relationship with your employers abs your colleagues who will be annoyed that you're not willing to do your share.

Alternatively, a large proportion of employees refuse and the business needs to reassess how to manage the additional workload.

Crazycrazylady · 28/10/2021 18:59

I absolutely know that it's not ideal but your contract allows for them to do this so you can absolutely go to war on this if you want but it sounds to me that you'll lose.
All that will achieve is damage your relationship with your employers abs your colleagues who will be annoyed that you're not willing to do your share.
It also sounds that your work are being semi flexible by allowing you schedule lunch around your school pick up time. You also didn't mention childcare so are your children at home in the afternoon which I know not all employers allow.
I just think pick your battles here and if it's one you can't win, there is no point in damaging relationships all over the place.Confused

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 28/10/2021 18:59

I would just look for a other job.
First it's once a month then it'll be once a week.

Chloemol · 28/10/2021 18:59

It’s in your contract. So yes the6 can do this

It’s one day a month, and you get the hours back the next day

If you can’t do then speak to them. Although it’s one day a month s9 8 dont see why your dh can’t help out

Namenic · 28/10/2021 18:58

Sounds like a rubbish company. But I guess if you’re not willing to do the 1 day a month, then sounds like it is better to look for another job?

MilkCereal · 28/10/2021 18:56

It's a pain but I would do it. Kids miss club or dh does it that day. I'm a teacher, we have parents evening 2 nights a years, school plays, twilight meetings etc. If I know the dates we move or miss kids clubs.

Burnt0utMum · 28/10/2021 18:54

Glad some people are seeing my point. I've chosen this sort of job because the hours fit around my life. Even if DH could take the kids to their clubs, is it so bad that I actually want to do it? I enjoy that time watching them do their activities. I want that time in the evenings to be with them instead of working, or I would've chosen a different job with different hours. Clubs are also paid for in advance so whether they miss them or DH leaves work early, we'd be out of pocket. The late stays are only because some people in the business can't get their act together to be done on time so insist we stay open that late. It's entirely possible to finish on time if the culture would allow it.

OP posts:
HouseOfFire · 28/10/2021 18:46

@Burnt0utMum

DH would have to leave work early to accommodate it and would mean we lose money so no way are we doing that.
1 day a month?
OnlyGin · 28/10/2021 18:45

@girlmom21

Why are people acting as though OP is being unreasonable here? Presumably she picked a 9-5 because that's what suits her family.

What happens when people call in sick on their late finishes and OP is expected to cover last minute or when one day a month becomes one day a week?

Stick to your guns here OP.

I agree. All the questioning about why OP can't do X Y or X... Because that's not how they have arranged their family life, which they are perfectly entitled to do however best suits them. If it doesn't suit their family for her husband to leave work early why should they?
girlmom21 · 28/10/2021 18:43

Why are people acting as though OP is being unreasonable here? Presumably she picked a 9-5 because that's what suits her family.

What happens when people call in sick on their late finishes and OP is expected to cover last minute or when one day a month becomes one day a week?

Stick to your guns here OP.

OnlyGin · 28/10/2021 18:43

You are being asked to work one “late” night a month with compensatory time off the next day. This means it’s not extra hours, just working your standard hours at a different time.

It may not be extra hours but it is an inconvenience, especially to people with a young family. Starting 3 hours late the next day is of no use to OP.

People should be allowed to plan their family life around their standard working hours. Is everyone just supposed to scramble to rearrange things now whenever their employer says you have to work 3 hours longer in the evening? What if like a PP said, they decide they need this once every fortnight or once a week etc...

OP could go to bagpipe lessons at 6pm every night after work if she wanted to, she should be allowed to plan her life outside of her normal working hours however she sees fit.

Swipe left for the next trending thread