Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find this behaviour utterly illogical?

106 replies

DrSeuss · 28/10/2021 16:16

Surely if you ban your child from having anything to do with Harry Potter to the extent that they can’t attend a Hogwarts themed birthday party and don’t allow them to celebrate Halloween at all, all on the grounds that the Bible forbids magic and witchcraft, you can’t then allow the child free access to “The Wizard of Oz” or hold a Peter Pan themed party or one with an Elsa from Frozen in costume? The book of Deuteronomy does indeed forbid magic according to Google. I find it firstly nonsensical and also a nightmare to navigate as the parent of such a child’s friend. Newest one is that David Walliams books are OK except for “The Demon Dentist “. I have no issue with people believing whatever makes them happy and would describe myself as having a Christian faith ( not very observant but still familiar with all the teachings of the C of E). The parents are C of E too but of a very different type to either my family or the Anglican school where I work, both being pretty accepting of all shades of belief. It’s quite tricky when my daughter and theirs want to spend time together. Something such as a simple cinema visit becomes so complicated when a film which has a suitable certificate for primary age children must still be pre approved in case it contains a forbidden theme. This is made even harder when Disney magic is deemed fine but others may not be.
Ideally, I would like someone with greater theological knowledge than me or who also believes that portrayals of magic in popular culture are wrong to help me understand and maybe give me some guidelines. I did once try asking why Disney was fine but Harry Potter wasn’t but the mother didn’t really answer me, just said that’s how it is. I asked the child as gently as possible if she was aware of why she can watch the witches in Oz but she said quite frankly that she didn’t know.

I am frustrated by the woolliness of their arguments and the arbitrary nature of decisions but this girl is a good friend of my daughter’s and is a pleasant child so I persevere.

I really hope someone can advise me.

OP posts:
DrSeuss · 28/10/2021 16:31

Right on, I work in SEN, exteme patience comes as standard! I also work with kids with ASD some of the time. the very fixed mindset and the idea that "it has to be that way because I want it like that" is sometimes a little familiar.

OP posts:
FauxPsychic · 28/10/2021 16:31

there is no way I am changing my values and lifestyle to accommodate anyone's religious nonsense
Think that's what they're doing too, except for them, it's 'non-religious nonsense'.

and hypocrisy.
Could you be the hypocritical one here? There are doing the same as you would do and somehow they're wrong? Just a thought.

I do agree that once it becomes such a drag, I'd end it. If not, then continue to work around it. I'm non-religious BTW. What I think could make one "better" than the other is how lighthearted one is and how gory or "dark", the other is. I'm just speculating.

RaraRachael · 28/10/2021 16:30

We had a very religious family in our school and the kids weren't allowed to use the computer or do anything to do with dinosaurs. The little boy said that the parents crossed out anything to do with dinosaurs as they didn't exist.

RightOnTheEdge · 28/10/2021 16:27

It sounds absolutely ridiculous.
You must have a lot of patience OP because I couldn't cope with the hypocrisy of them.

DrSeuss · 28/10/2021 16:25

Aquamarine, I would but she would be heartbroken as she gets very attached to people, just like her mum. The problem may cease to be at the end of the academic year when they are going to different secondary schools.

OP posts:
Aquamarine1029 · 28/10/2021 16:19

Sorry, but pandering to these ridiculous people is a fool's game. My daughter would have to find another friend because there is no way I am changing my values and lifestyle to accommodate anyone's religious nonsense and hypocrisy.