Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think Taylor Swift is our century's answer to William Shakespeare

511 replies

beastlyslumber · 28/10/2021 16:01

She's such an incredible storyteller and lyricist (and her songs are ridiculously catchy. It's all about the hooks.) Listening to her album 'folkore' this afternoon - she wrote two whole albums in lockdown, you know. And they're both great, but 'folklore' is insanely good. As she moves away from autobiographical writing into character stories, her storytelling is getting even more emotionally direct, and even more fun. She's a total genius. Even on the rare occasions when her hooks and melodies don't grip you, her lyrics always get right to the heart of things.

If there's any justice in the world, Ms Swift will still be celebrated in 500 years for her original, moving, funny, perceptive and subversive writing.

YANBU = Obviously! She is the Bard of Pop
YABU = WTF? She's way better than Shakespeare

OP posts:
Ifyoudontlikeitdosomethingelse · 29/10/2021 09:27

@User527294627 Yes, without a doubt.

User527294627 · 29/10/2021 09:19

@Ifyoudontlikeitdosomethingelse

Shake it off is not a great song... How are our brains so different? What are you hearing that I'm not?! I think I'm not attuned to pop music or something. I just don't understand. It's like eating McDonald's or watching eastenders or reading take a break. It's feels like it's for the simple minded.
There might actually be something in this, because I have four first class / with distinction degrees, two in English literature, but the feedback on my masters dissertation did say ‘While we loved the writer’s novel approach and superb writing skills, we are unable to shake off the creeping suspicion that she is simple minded.’

I always wondered why. Maybe they heard me humming Shake It Off when I handed it in?

GlitterOnTheFloor · 29/10/2021 09:12

I took my daughter to see her Reputation tour. I wasn't that fussed beforehand but she was amazing. Managed to make you feel like she was talking to a small group of people when there were thousands there.
I feel sorry for her that when she stood up for herself she was made to look like a bitch and now people have an opinion of her based on what the media wanted her to be portrayed as. Obvs I don't know her and am basing my own options on the Netflix doc and the stuff she posts with her mum. (I cannot listen to 'Soon you'll get better' as we lost a family member just before the album was released and it's too painful)
My daughter can't wait for her to release the next 'Taylor's version' album as she hates that the guy who bought her albums gets the royalties for Taylor's work.

SummaLuvin · 29/10/2021 09:02

Or that not everyone is familiar with every single song Taylor Swift has ever written?
Name any artist and people will have a song that springs to mind based on what they've heard from them on the radio etc.

I agree with this, some people are only aware of a handful of songs which will inform their opinion. But also, people are coming on this thread which is about her excellent song-writing and quoting the one song they know as "evidence" that she isn't a good song writer. I wouldn't go on a thread about Adele's upbeat music and claim she only ever writes miserable songs because that's what I have heard on the radio, I would be aware that she has loads of songs I haven't heard because I have never listened to a whole album. I wouldn't presume I know better than people actually familiar with her body of work.

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 29/10/2021 08:58

I must be missing something as I find her songs boring and extremely overrated.

SummaLuvin · 29/10/2021 08:56

I haven't seen Ronan mentioned. It's a beautiful, gut-wrenching song, I challenge people to listen/watch her performance of it and not well up.

Sparklingbrook · 29/10/2021 08:29

@AngeloMysterioso

I don't get why everyone is banging on about shake it off? She's released so many songs!

Because lyrically it’s her “weak spot” I guess, and they’d rather just point to that and use it an an example of her not being any good and consider it case closed, than embrace the possibility that Pop Princess Taylor Swift might actually have a song or two that appeal to even their highbrow tastes…

Basically it’s just snobbery.

Or that not everyone is familiar with every single song Taylor Swift has ever written? Name any artist and people will have a song that springs to mind based on what they've heard from them on the radio etc.
AngeloMysterioso · 29/10/2021 08:24

I don't get why everyone is banging on about shake it off? She's released so many songs!

Because lyrically it’s her “weak spot” I guess, and they’d rather just point to that and use it an an example of her not being any good and consider it case closed, than embrace the possibility that Pop Princess Taylor Swift might actually have a song or two that appeal to even their highbrow tastes…

Basically it’s just snobbery.

Sparklingbrook · 29/10/2021 07:59

@AlphabetAerobics

She also did her civic duty and did dury duty. Not many of her status would.
It looks as if she didn't actually have to do it in the end. She was excused because of her own court case at the time.

www.theguardian.com/music/2016/aug/30/taylor-swift-excused-jury-duty-nashville

AlphabetAerobics · 29/10/2021 07:32

She also did her civic duty and did dury duty. Not many of her status would.

SickAndTiredAgain · 29/10/2021 07:02

@smoko

Taylor swift has received criticism for being anti feminist FYI

it’s no coincidence that the “evil” girls in her clips are always dark brunettes. She really seems to dislike brunette women!

Does she have a chip on her shoulder that she isn’t exotic?

She isn’t about girl power, she arguably tears other women down by painting herself as the “not like the other girls”

I don’t know all her videos but isn’t the brunette thing just because it’s the opposite to her? For example in you belong with me, in the video she plays both characters, so the easiest way to distinguish is to change clothes and put a brunette wig on. A brunette singer would have put a blonde wig on.

She’s been vocal about sexual assault, stated she’s “obviously pro choice”, and when she came out in support of the democrat candidate in her state, listed the republican woman’s track record on domestic violence (and LGBT equality) as reasons.
(She’s also pro gun control which I know isn’t a feminist issue but I mention it just because I think it’s the other big political issue she has come down on one side of)

I’m not saying that therefore she’s an amazing feminist by the way, and you can definitely critique some of her earlier songs as being a bit “I’m not like other girls” as you’ve said (although I think the fact she’s now in her early thirties and some of the songs were written when she was 15/16/17 is relevant).

FrankButchersDickieBow · 29/10/2021 00:14

Nrtft and I'm sure it has been said by many. But Amy winehouse is the bard. Love is a losing game, is the most sublime song ever.

Over futile odds
And laughed at by the gods
And now the final frame
Love is a losing game

Makes me cry every time I hear it ❤

CascadeOceanWaveBlues · 29/10/2021 00:05

Phil Collins actually commented on that cover saying "Such a beautiful voice, she absolutely nails it. Lovely to hear it." which is pretty impressive imo!

CascadeOceanWaveBlues · 29/10/2021 00:03

I don't think I was a very good feminist in my late teens/early 20's either. She's early 30's now and you can see how much she has grown and changed, I think she definitely seems to be more about building women up these days.

DaisyNGO · 29/10/2021 00:02

Dress - sorry!

When I listen to 1989, .I often skip it.

I never skip Out of the Woods. Like, ever! 🤗

Smoko - no idea what that means. So who am I offending now?

Loved this thread. The pp who linked to the Phil Collins cover, I have a contact who said she disliked TS massively till she heard that. I hadn't heard the original.

I remembered, I didn't have the Exile boyfriend but I did have the Mean ine. "I can see you years from now in a bar, talking over a football game, with that same big loud opinion but....nobody's listening..."

He said that would be me, after failing in my career 🤷🏻‍♀️

I got rid as soon as he said it.

Good Night, Swifties.
Good night, non Swifties.

thecombineharvester · 29/10/2021 00:01

I like a lot of TS, but didn't love folklore, though I'm going to give it another go... At the moment though I can't stop listening to Dirty Computer by Janelle Monae, it's just incredible! Not as recent (2018) but every single song on there is brilliant.

dresstokillmytime · 28/10/2021 23:58

@smoko

Taylor swift has received criticism for being anti feminist FYI

it’s no coincidence that the “evil” girls in her clips are always dark brunettes. She really seems to dislike brunette women!

Does she have a chip on her shoulder that she isn’t exotic?

She isn’t about girl power, she arguably tears other women down by painting herself as the “not like the other girls”

She had an early track called Better Than Revenge that was really not nice and derogatory. She's apologised for it since and I do think she has learned and grown as a woman and as a feminist.
dresstokillmytime · 28/10/2021 23:56

@DaisyNGO

Love Gorillaz

Taylor was originally country and may be classified as folk in some ways. If Haim are folk....Shake It Off is not representative of her huge discography. When I listen to Reputation, I often skip it.

It was on 1989.
smoko · 28/10/2021 23:56

Taylor swift has received criticism for being anti feminist FYI

it’s no coincidence that the “evil” girls in her clips are always dark brunettes. She really seems to dislike brunette women!

Does she have a chip on her shoulder that she isn’t exotic?

She isn’t about girl power, she arguably tears other women down by painting herself as the “not like the other girls”

CascadeOceanWaveBlues · 28/10/2021 23:52

Sure, but even when other songs had been recommended people were still quoting SIO as if it's her only song. I think that I wouldn't post on a thread slating an artist as being shit if I only vaguely remembered the chorus to one song released 7 years ago.

Sparklingbrook · 28/10/2021 23:49

Shake it Off was the first song that came to mind. Other than that one the only TS song I could think of was Blank Space.
You can’t expect everyone to be familiar with every artist’s complete back catalogue unless they are huge fans.
A question was asked and posters answered with the knowledge of TS they had I think.

smoko · 28/10/2021 23:48

To the person who criticised Eminem for writing a song about killing his girlfriend - you know who else wrote about murder a fair bit?

Shakespeare!

It’s a clever, confronting commentary on the fine line between love & hate

Also lyrically the song “Kim” has a lot more hidden meanings, messaging & references than you might expect if you aren’t familiar with his artistry as a whole

It’s a song which makes you uncomfortable, has elements of humour, rage, retaliation…

It’s the dark side of being brokenhearted

It’s too early here for me to intellectualise it much more, but this track has been discussed & dissected a lot.

ChristmasPlanning · 28/10/2021 23:46

[quote CascadeOceanWaveBlues]I don't get why everyone is banging on about shake it off? She's released so many songs!

These are three of my favourite live performances, a cover of Can't Stop Loving You

And this version of The Archer

& Soon You'll Get Better

[/quote] Thanks for these
CascadeOceanWaveBlues · 28/10/2021 23:26

I don't get why everyone is banging on about shake it off? She's released so many songs!

These are three of my favourite live performances, a cover of Can't Stop Loving You

And this version of The Archer

& Soon You'll Get Better

Pedalpushers · 28/10/2021 23:14

For clarification for many posters who don't seem to understand, Taylor Swift has released 9 albums, all with upwards of 12 songs on them, and only one of those is Shake it Off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread