Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think Taylor Swift is our century's answer to William Shakespeare

511 replies

beastlyslumber · 28/10/2021 16:01

She's such an incredible storyteller and lyricist (and her songs are ridiculously catchy. It's all about the hooks.) Listening to her album 'folkore' this afternoon - she wrote two whole albums in lockdown, you know. And they're both great, but 'folklore' is insanely good. As she moves away from autobiographical writing into character stories, her storytelling is getting even more emotionally direct, and even more fun. She's a total genius. Even on the rare occasions when her hooks and melodies don't grip you, her lyrics always get right to the heart of things.

If there's any justice in the world, Ms Swift will still be celebrated in 500 years for her original, moving, funny, perceptive and subversive writing.

YANBU = Obviously! She is the Bard of Pop
YABU = WTF? She's way better than Shakespeare

OP posts:
Biker47 · 30/10/2021 14:02

Are you the unhinged woman who created an entire Taylor Swift academic course and presented it to her prospective boyfriend, which included things like actual homework and exams?

WatchMyChops · 30/10/2021 14:00

Thank you. I needed a good laugh Xmas Grin

beastlyslumber · 30/10/2021 13:56

@wtaf37

Is there a vomit emoji?
Now we got problems, and I don't think we can solve them
OP posts:
CascadeOceanWaveBlues · 30/10/2021 13:40

@wtaf37

Is there a vomit emoji?
You need to calm down
TeaTime27 · 30/10/2021 13:17

@wtaf37

Is there a vomit emoji?
So casually cruel, in the name of being honest.
dresstokillmytime · 30/10/2021 12:58

@wtaf37

Is there a vomit emoji?
Why do you have to be so mean? Wink
wtaf37 · 30/10/2021 12:23

Is there a vomit emoji?

YellowBees234 · 29/10/2021 21:23

Agree OP. The lyrics to Marjorie are beautiful. They really portray the loss of a grandparent. Ivy is also a stunning portrayal of a love affair. And the demonstration of the different way in which the man and woman see the end of a relationship in Exile is so well articulated. She is insanely talented and Folklore is superb.

LumosSolem · 29/10/2021 19:49

Thanks for this thread @beastlyslumber it's been a great read.

I like TS, she's not my favourite lyricist though.

Mine is Alex Turner, he's the bard and to me, the best songwriter of his generation. Amy is right up there too. I've loved AT since arctic monkeys came out when I was 17/18 and if I could only listen to one band for the rest of my life it would be them.

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 29/10/2021 15:48

Yeah, good point. It's taken far fewer sales to get the No 1 spot in recent years. Just such a sad little trio occupying the top spot Grin

The injustice of those women each having more number 1 hits than Dusty Springfield.

AngeloMysterioso · 29/10/2021 15:36

I get what you're saying but on the other hand Jess Glynne, Geri Halliwell and Cheryl Cole are the most successful British female singers of all time (as in highest number of No.1 songs), so sales don't always indicate quality.

Number ones don’t always mean a successful career as so much stuff gets streamed or illegally downloaded now so actual sales a well below what they were in say the 90’s. I doubt there’s any metric that takes into account record sales, streams, radio airplay, tour and merch revenue and all the other income streams that would still put them above Adele. Plus, the Crazy Frog beat Speed of Sound to No.1, Robson & Jerome got the No.1 instead of Wonderwall, but nobody could say they were more successful than Coldplay or Oasis.

beastlyslumber · 29/10/2021 15:16

sales don't always indicate quality

That's true. And lack of sales don't indicate a lack of quality, either. But what I'm trying to say is "commercial" does not equal "low quality". Popular music being actually popular is kind of part of the deal Smile

Having said that, I'm a bit horrified by those people being the most successful female artists when we've produced Amy Winehouse, Kate Bush, Adele, Bat for Lashes...!!! So maybe I need to rethink my stance! I haven't actually listened to any of these women's records, and have only barely heard of them so maybe I'm just way too old being unfair.

OP posts:
StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 29/10/2021 14:32

It's like, this record has sold ten billion copies - what's more likely: that it's an amazing work of genius that has something to appeal to everyone? Or ten billion people are absolute idiots and I'm the only one with taste?

I get what you're saying but on the other hand Jess Glynne, Geri Halliwell and Cheryl Cole are the most successful British female singers of all time (as in highest number of No.1 songs), so sales don't always indicate quality.

beastlyslumber · 29/10/2021 14:26

Many of my friends are like this! To be honest, they wouldn't even care about being referred to as a music snob, as they genuinely believe their music taste to be superior as it isn't commercial so they would be like yes thanks, happy to be a music snob.

I used to think that "commercial" was an insult! That if something was commercial then it must be of low quality. But then I stopped being a teenager... Really I think it's quite a patronising view, isn't it? Insulting, really. It's like, this record has sold ten billion copies - what's more likely: that it's an amazing work of genius that has something to appeal to everyone? Or ten billion people are absolute idiots and I'm the only one with taste?

I always piss people off though, because I do listen to classical music, including modern music which can be quite obscure, and I listen to indie stuff, death metal, prog rock, hip hop, and pop, and probably every single genre of music there is. People who think I'm simple-minded because I like TS are a bit simple-minded themselves, to believe that we must all fit ourselves and our tastes into little boxes that represent our intellect and status. It doesn't work that way!

OP posts:
beastlyslumber · 29/10/2021 14:19

Even as a fan, it took me a few listens to Evermore before anything stood out to me. Evermore feels a bit more personal, however the story telling in Folklore had me hooked instantly! Likely due to the timing, mid pandemic, easy listening was just what I needed!

The timing of Folklore was so perfect. I remember a friend messaging me saying, hey do you know TS has put an album out? and it was like a little light went on in my life. It was in that dark time of lockdown where nothing was happening, and it felt like people were just quietly isolated and scared. I don't know, it was just perfect timing. And the album is so great. The 1 as an opener - immediately got into my head.

Really love that album because it has such a coherent feeling and atmosphere. Like I was saying before about Blood on the Tracks or Rumours, it's an album that has a whole unique world of its own.

OP posts:
beastlyslumber · 29/10/2021 14:14

It’s rare to like every song or lyric that an artist puts out there even if a massive fan. Depending on where you are in your life songs can speak to you or leave you cold too.

Totally agree. I don't like everything TS has put out by any means. But what I do like, I LOVE and consider to be superb works of art. I do think she's a genius.

OP posts:
DaisyNGO · 29/10/2021 12:08

@StrychnineInTheSandwiches

I've listened to the Evermore album off the back of this thread. It was okay but I found it a bit samey. I expected more since it seems to be the one she's getting critical acclaim for. It sounds like more of what she's always done, songs that are very reminiscent of 90s singers like Sarah McLachlan and Heather Nova.

I have nothing against her though and like when people are passionate about music and artists.

I'm sure Swift will be kicking around for a long time to come.

It's interesting isn't it

I find it very different to her usual work
As a whole, I found it samey too

I really don't know what gets more critical acclaim as I pay no attention to that. But there's so many things at play with critical acclaim, sadly.

I will make my own pointless criticism. I don't feel I am being kept up to date with Taylor's cats 😂 They're probably busy. Or Benjamin grew up and isn't cute any more ...

TeaTime27 · 29/10/2021 12:07

@StrychnineInTheSandwiches

I've listened to the Evermore album off the back of this thread. It was okay but I found it a bit samey. I expected more since it seems to be the one she's getting critical acclaim for. It sounds like more of what she's always done, songs that are very reminiscent of 90s singers like Sarah McLachlan and Heather Nova.

I have nothing against her though and like when people are passionate about music and artists.

I'm sure Swift will be kicking around for a long time to come.

Even as a fan, it took me a few listens to Evermore before anything stood out to me. Evermore feels a bit more personal, however the story telling in Folklore had me hooked instantly! Likely due to the timing, mid pandemic, easy listening was just what I needed!
StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 29/10/2021 11:59

I've listened to the Evermore album off the back of this thread. It was okay but I found it a bit samey. I expected more since it seems to be the one she's getting critical acclaim for. It sounds like more of what she's always done, songs that are very reminiscent of 90s singers like Sarah McLachlan and Heather Nova.

I have nothing against her though and like when people are passionate about music and artists.

I'm sure Swift will be kicking around for a long time to come.

TeaTime27 · 29/10/2021 11:59

@ClinkeyMonkey

I think posters who call others music snobs are saying more about themselves than the people who, after all, are only engaging with the OP's claim that Taylor Swift is the modern Shakespeare. If you call someone a music snob for disagreeing with or being critical of your preferences, then it seems to me that you have a chip on your shoulder and that you don't quite have the courage of your convictions. Why aren't YOU the music snob for loving Taylor Swift I wonder?

Anyway, when I was younger I'd have made the same claim about Kate Bush or Tori Amos (except I'd have been rightGrin)

I disagree. The people I would refer to as music snobs, would be someone likely to scoff "taylor swift? Ha!" type of thing, without ever having actually listened to Taylor Swift. To me, I'd classify that as looking down your nose at something. Hence the music snob term.

Many of my friends are like this! To be honest, they wouldn't even care about being referred to as a music snob, as they genuinely believe their music taste to be superior as it isn't commercial so they would be like yes thanks, happy to be a music snob.

I'm a Taylor Swift fan (can you tell?) and there are some of her songs that I dislike, or think are a bit rubbish. Her music isn't for everyone, I 100% agree with that. It's the attitude of people who dismiss her purely based on 1 song, or even just her reputation. She's too popular or whatever. Or young kids like her music, so therefore cannot be taken seriously.

There are a million and one artists I don't know, or listen to. But I'd never feel the need to make fun of someone's music tastes because they like someone I don't. It's that attitude that I don't understand.

AngeloMysterioso · 29/10/2021 11:56

I think posters who call others music snobs are saying more about themselves than the people who, after all, are only engaging with the OP's claim that Taylor Swift is the modern Shakespeare. If you call someone a music snob for disagreeing with or being critical of your preferences, then it seems to me that you have a chip on your shoulder and that you don't quite have the courage of your convictions. Why aren't YOU the music snob for loving Taylor Swift I wonder?

It’s one thing to disagree, it’s another thing entirely to pick one song from the god knows how many she’s written and use it as evidence that she’s rubbish, without bothering to listen to anything else.

Or indeed, to call people who enjoy her music simple minded, which is just an insult.

I don’t like all her songs and I’m not sure about the Shakespeare comparison, but even if I hated her music I’d still be able to acknowledge that she’s extremely talented.

ClinkeyMonkey · 29/10/2021 11:45

I think posters who call others music snobs are saying more about themselves than the people who, after all, are only engaging with the OP's claim that Taylor Swift is the modern Shakespeare. If you call someone a music snob for disagreeing with or being critical of your preferences, then it seems to me that you have a chip on your shoulder and that you don't quite have the courage of your convictions. Why aren't YOU the music snob for loving Taylor Swift I wonder?

Anyway, when I was younger I'd have made the same claim about Kate Bush or Tori Amos (except I'd have been rightGrin)

Sparklingbrook · 29/10/2021 11:30

Zayn Malik wasn’t he One Direction but did a Robbie Williams? Gigi Hadid-model?

This isn't to say that no-one can criticise her, or has to like her music, by it's nature it is subjective

I think that’s the thing. It’s rare to like every song or lyric that an artist puts out there even if a massive fan.

Depending on where you are in your life songs can speak to you or leave you cold too.

DaisyNGO · 29/10/2021 11:24

"They are the same as the individuals on twitter right now, claiming they have never heard of Zayn Malik and GiGi Hadid after their recent split . Come off it. Nobody believes you."

I believe them. I only know who Zayn Malik is because...Taylor Swift made a record with him.

I often get comments from friends who can't believe I don't know xyz person.

I find the world very overwhelming so believe it or not, I hide from media as much as I can.

I'm only on here all day yesterday and today because I took some annual leave and we are waiting to hear back on a flat.

So "like, who is Taylor Swift anyway?" 😂 actually is believable to me.

I don't understand slating a band, actor, writer etc when you know very little of their work.

LittleDandelionClock · 29/10/2021 11:17

[quote TeaTime27]@LittleDandelionClock oh don't get me started on people who feel the need to reply to things on Twitter etc with "can't be that famous, I've never heard of them" or "must be slow news day. I've never heard of them", well good for you! Every time I see someone write it I assume that of course they know who the person is and they're just being obnoxious. Surely if you seen an article about a famous person who you genuinely never heard of, you wouldn't waste your time writing anything, you'd just scroll on past. [/quote]
Exactly! It's like these individuals who go on to fan pages to slate the celebrity. I dislike a few celebrities, but I don't go onto their fan pages berating them (and their fans!) Nor do I go on twitter - or mumsnet - to blather on about how I don't even know this person. And as IF someone has never heard of Taylor Swift. As I said, no-one believes you!!! Wink

As you said, it's just a way to say 'I do not KNOW this really famous person, therefore I am much better than you, for I do not follow modern and popular trends...'

Swipe left for the next trending thread