Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think Taylor Swift is our century's answer to William Shakespeare

511 replies

beastlyslumber · 28/10/2021 16:01

She's such an incredible storyteller and lyricist (and her songs are ridiculously catchy. It's all about the hooks.) Listening to her album 'folkore' this afternoon - she wrote two whole albums in lockdown, you know. And they're both great, but 'folklore' is insanely good. As she moves away from autobiographical writing into character stories, her storytelling is getting even more emotionally direct, and even more fun. She's a total genius. Even on the rare occasions when her hooks and melodies don't grip you, her lyrics always get right to the heart of things.

If there's any justice in the world, Ms Swift will still be celebrated in 500 years for her original, moving, funny, perceptive and subversive writing.

YANBU = Obviously! She is the Bard of Pop
YABU = WTF? She's way better than Shakespeare

OP posts:
User527294627 · 28/10/2021 17:25

The posters who think Shakespeare is unworthy of comparison with anyone as lowly as Taylor swift are the same people who had a sign at their wedding saying ‘when I saw you I fell in love, and you smiled because you knew: William Shakespeare’.

AICM · 28/10/2021 17:24

I have of late, (but wherefore I know not) lost all my mirth, forgone all custom of exercises; and indeed, it goes so heavily with my disposition; that this goodly frame the earth, seems to me a sterile promontory; this most excellent canopy the air, look you, this brave o'er hanging firmament, this majestical roof, fretted with golden fire: why, it appeareth no other thing to me, than a foul and pestilent congregation of vapours. What a piece of work is man, How noble in reason, how infinite in faculty, In form and moving how express and admirable, In action how like an Angel, In apprehension how like a god, The beauty of the world, The paragon of animals. And yet to me, what is this quintessence of dust?

SickAndTiredAgain · 28/10/2021 17:21

@WonderfulYou

YABU granted I haven’t heard much of her music but I don’t like her personality as she plays a character and is very two-faced.

So on her personality alone I voted YABU

Know her personally do you? A celebrity having a public persona is hardly shocking, and while anything about her being “very two-faced” may be true (I have absolutely no idea) I imagine you’re basing it off gossip articles and rumour?

It also, actually, isn’t relevant to her songwriting. Shakespeare is rumoured to have cheated on his wife but I rarely hear that used against him.

DaisyNGO · 28/10/2021 17:21

Genius thread OP
Now thinking of the lyrics to Kanye "no church in the wild"

I don't have to stan to appreciate good lyrics and storytelling 😀

Sparklingbrook · 28/10/2021 17:21

@DaisyNGO, it was a very long time ago but the more dissecting we did the more depressing the song got. It's weird I can still remember it.

That said, I just like to read a book for reading's sake, not making notes in the margins and writing huge chunks of it out and endlessly analysing every single word. So English Lit was not my favourite subject.

SirenSays · 28/10/2021 17:20

Standing in a white dress staring at the sunset and 22! Are the only lyrics of hers that I can remember off the top of my head 🤔

Namechangeforone · 28/10/2021 17:20

And just to add it's often the snobbiest who are the most stupid - unable to see a connection with how Shakespeare was viewed with how they're talking about contemporary writers here. Unable to see meaning where there is plenty instead quoting lyrics they have decided are vacuous filler. Does my nut in. They never look clever though - they seem incapable of thought and are missing out on discovering new things.

And yes to pp on Eminem. Another good one

DaisyNGO · 28/10/2021 17:18

Re Eminem

I don't know a lot of his work but ironically, Stan is genius

Also, the Real Slim Shady is bloody brilliant. I haven't seen 8 mile but I probably should.

DaisyNGO · 28/10/2021 17:16

@WonderfulYou

YABU granted I haven’t heard much of her music but I don’t like her personality as she plays a character and is very two-faced.

So on her personality alone I voted YABU

Who isn't playing a character?

Not sure you understood the voting options

To the PP who said Ryan Adams cover of Style was very good - yes, that's the best one I think. He managed to make Bad Blood sound like Wonderwall but that it's still quite good!

Namechangeforone · 28/10/2021 17:15

Gosh people are snobs aren't they.

I don't love her music but appreciate her cultural significance and yes she's a great song writer.

Jay Z has written some brilliant lyrics. As has Kanye. In fact a lot of hip hop is very clever if you dig down a bit - double and triple meanings often drawing on much older music or art or whatever, comments on politics presented in an entirely new way.

Lily Allen good too. Lots of good writers about.

WonderfulYou · 28/10/2021 17:14

YABU granted I haven’t heard much of her music but I don’t like her personality as she plays a character and is very two-faced.

So on her personality alone I voted YABU

DaisyNGO · 28/10/2021 17:13

@Sparklingbrook

I had to dissect Eleanor Rigby for GCSE English. Sometimes it's best not to look into lyrics too deeply maybe.
Oh I LOVE that!
HereForThis · 28/10/2021 17:12

I haven't even voted yet

Lucky you. I did just before I read the meanings.Halloween Blush

Sparklingbrook · 28/10/2021 17:11

@HereForThis

Spark, either way the vote goes, it works to the OP's favour. There's no "unreasonable" and I'm sure many haven't realised it. Grin
I haven't even voted yet. Grin
JustAddBakedBeans · 28/10/2021 17:11

@User527294627

People are deliberately pulling out Taylor Swift lyrics which they think are vacuous, but (setting aside the fact that it’s pointless to consider lyrics in isolation from the accompanying music since the interplay between those things is virtually the point of pop music), I won’t sit here and be told that ‘Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day? Thou art more lovely and more temperate’ is profound, genre-defining lyricism, worthy of a place on the poetic pantheon, but that ‘take the words for what they are: a dwindling mercurial high, a drug that only worked the first few hundred times’ is just an inane pop song, unworthy of the praise of a few mumnetters who have substituted bland and mindless hero-worship of Shakespeare for thinking critically about the cultural impact of contemporary artists working in the genres that today have the same kind of impact and public engagement as theatre had in Shakespeare’s time.
Well said.
HereForThis · 28/10/2021 17:10

Spark, either way the vote goes, it works to the OP's favour. There's no "unreasonable" and I'm sure many haven't realised it. Grin

MrsColon · 28/10/2021 17:09

I've just had a read of the lyrics to Folklore - they're OK, better than many, but she's definitely no literary genius!

Sparklingbrook · 28/10/2021 17:08

The vote is very close with the OP being 53% unreasonable.

BetsyBigNose · 28/10/2021 17:07

Yep, I'm totally with you OP. Each time I hear this lyric, my soul sheds a small tear and it forces me to contemplate my raison d'être:

"To the fella over there with the hella good hair, why don't you come on over baby and we can shake, shake, shake..."

HereForThis · 28/10/2021 17:07

Sorry, @Smoko not Spoko.

Apologies Spoko, whomever you are.

Sparklingbrook · 28/10/2021 17:07

Great writing is everywhere - doesn't have to be old to be wonderful and important

I would agree with that. There was a thread on here not long ago with people quoting their favourite lyrics from songs. Loads of different 'ages'.

HereForThis · 28/10/2021 17:06

Personally enjoying @Sparklingbrook and @Spoko's lyric posts. Grin Makes me feel better for not being able to unclick the rigged vote. Neither is true for me and I'm not a fan of Shakespeare either.

Pedalpushers · 28/10/2021 17:04

@littlegwyneth I had to stop myself just posting All Too Well in its entirety Grin

Not all of her songs are good, but when she's good she's phenomenal.

User527294627 · 28/10/2021 17:04

People are deliberately pulling out Taylor Swift lyrics which they think are vacuous, but (setting aside the fact that it’s pointless to consider lyrics in isolation from the accompanying music since the interplay between those things is virtually the point of pop music), I won’t sit here and be told that ‘Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day? Thou art more lovely and more temperate’ is profound, genre-defining lyricism, worthy of a place on the poetic pantheon, but that ‘take the words for what they are: a dwindling mercurial high, a drug that only worked the first few hundred times’ is just an inane pop song, unworthy of the praise of a few mumnetters who have substituted bland and mindless hero-worship of Shakespeare for thinking critically about the cultural impact of contemporary artists working in the genres that today have the same kind of impact and public engagement as theatre had in Shakespeare’s time.

LittleGwyneth · 28/10/2021 17:03

@sparklingbrook sure, but TS has some lyrics which absolutely do stand up to scrutiny. I think Eleanor Rigby does too - and I'm pretty sure I had that as a past GCSE paper when I was doing mine. Great writing is everywhere - doesn't have to be old to be wonderful and important.