Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to blame Tony Blair for the lack of skilled workforce?

493 replies

dunkaccino · 28/10/2021 15:57

In the 1980's only 15% of school leavers went into higher education leaving a good lot of people to become tradesmen/HGV drivers/butchers etc. Tony Blair decided in 1999 that 50% going to University was a great aim, which was finally achieved in 2019.

Now we have a lack of everyone useful - electricians, carpenters, fitters, engineers, butchers, drivers - coupled with a multitude of unskilled mickey mouse degree graduates who are of no practical use to anyone.

Covid & brexit have undeniably both played a part, but AIBU to think that Blairs idea was basically a bit shit and has left us lacking in the skilled workforce needed to run the country?

OP posts:
SpinsForGin · 30/10/2021 13:11

@woodhill

A lot of the universities were former polytechnics.
And?
MeredithGreyishblue · 30/10/2021 13:05

Does anyone really think that the person starting the (actually incredibly employable, modern day marketing) social media degree would be doing medicine, by choice, if the "mickey mouse media" degrees weren't offered?

woodhill · 30/10/2021 13:00

A lot of the universities were former polytechnics.

antsinyourpanta · 30/10/2021 12:51

I often wonder what is the value in the job market of a third class degree from,say, the University of Bedfordshire? Students come out with similar debt to higher ranked institutions. Makes me wonder about who is encouraging these poor choices, especially for families who may think that any degree is better than seeking a foothold in the job market.

My siblings were the first in my family to go to uni in the late 1990s. We had no idea what a red brick or Russell group university was, or whether some (other than Oxbridge) were thought of as better.
However even with a so-called "inferior" degree that you are inferring, surely that would open up more opportunities for jobs asking for a degree level education (even if that job is entirely suitable for school leavers)

Worldgonecrazy · 30/10/2021 12:34

I often wonder what is the value in the job market of a third class degree from,say, the University of Bedfordshire? Students come out with similar debt to higher ranked institutions. Makes me wonder about who is encouraging these poor choices, especially for families who may think that any degree is better than seeking a foothold in the job market.

Having worked at a University, the move from ‘students’ to ‘customers’ is leading to bad decisions on both sides.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 30/10/2021 12:17

But l WANT to go to university to study thenConfusedl do t want to do it online.

TheLastSpookyBakedBeanSaysBoo · 30/10/2021 11:54

I always see jobs which are either driving jobs in the first place or need you to have your own transport or driving license. But loads of people can't afford to learn to drive or keep a car on the road without the wages from the job they can't do without a license/car. I often wonder if we could do driving loans like student loans but for learning to drive.

UsedUpUsername · 30/10/2021 11:53

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

Spinsforgin.

It would appear so. I think all subjects have equal merit. That’s what makes for an interesting and diverse world. And people can study for the love of studying. If l had the cash, I’d do a different degree every 3 years. I like learning. Degrees l would choose would be

History, Sociology, Grsphic Design, Media Stidies, Politics, more history, more history.

I hate STEM subjects tbh. But don’t think they have any advantage or merit over any other degrees. Not keen on red brick snobbery either.

You don’t need to go to uni to study these subjects, there’s better resources online than in most British universities.
Namenic · 30/10/2021 11:07

Fetarabbit - absolutely - which is why I said SKILLS rather than degrees. Many IT jobs, finance, healthcare jobs do not necessarily need a full degree - at least for entry level roles.

I think the most useful training comes on the job. Academic study can complement vocational experience and I think a short 2 year course with additional later qualifications to build up to a degree would be helpful in many cases.

I’m not against a traditional 3 year academic degree. It will suit some people and help people who are considering research and academia to progress quickly. But I think there needs to be a diversity of courses.

Kpo58 · 30/10/2021 10:39

When I was at an all girl's school in the 90s academic people were pushed to go to college and university and non academic people did either Health and Social care or travel and tourism at college or hairdressing. There were no other options given.

Going into a trade wasn't even discussed. I wish that it was otherwise I wouldn't have ended stuck in a poorly paid office job.

SpinsForGin · 30/10/2021 10:34

I don't mean to be disrespectful, but if your role did not exist people would still make those choices without the need for all the meta-analysis. It's a bonus that it exists, but it's not essential.

Okay. You should remember this comment when people are complaining that young people don't get good enough careers advice and guidance in school. When government education policy completely ignores the benefit and value of a well funded, highly skills careers service because there isn't any evidence available because people like me aren't doing the research.

And when people are complaining that young people are making poor choices and are being herded into unsuitable university courses instead of being informed of all the choices available to them .... that's okay because what I do isn't important.

And all these comments about which skills are in demand and which sectors are crying out for workers .....who do you think gathers this data and makes sense of it?? Yep, that would be people like me.

Hothammock · 30/10/2021 10:32

@mustlovegin actually I stand by saying it will take generations to change. This is because there is a big difference between funneling people through degrees, and spending the time to build specific skills and practical experience. To be able to teach real skills you also need a teaching workforce with sufficient experience and expertise. We really don't even have that and it will take time to develop it for many vocations. You can't magic up this kind of capacity. It literally takes generations.

woodhill · 30/10/2021 10:27

Language degrees are useful

The government hasn't helped by withdrawing the funding for support for NHS courses especially when the students are working in the hospitals and the courses are long hours

jgw1 · 30/10/2021 10:09

I think there is broad agreement that the is a shortage of skilled workers in the UK.
I missed some of the budget, but am sure someone can enlighten me as to what steps were announced to address this problem?

mustlovegin · 30/10/2021 10:08

Interestingly, the theories I teach relate to how people make career choices

I don't mean to be disrespectful, but if your role did not exist people would still make those choices without the need for all the meta-analysis. It's a bonus that it exists, but it's not essential.

However, without doctors people would die, without engineers we wouldn't have roads, without farmers we wouldn't be able to eat, etc, etc. It's pretty easy to see what we should be prioritising at a time of scarcity

mustlovegin · 30/10/2021 10:05

It will take generations to change this

Not necessarily. Perceptions can be changed relatively quickly (see what happened since 2016). As can bureaucracy.

Capacity issues as mentioned in relation to doctors and midwives will take a bit more, but it's not an unsurmountable issue, and we need to act fast

SpinsForGin · 30/10/2021 09:50

Interestingly, the theories I teach relate to how people make career choices and I'm specifically interested In how and why people choose university.
They can't be that pointless given we're all commenting on this thread!

Hothammock · 30/10/2021 09:49

When a generation were pushed into uni rather than the vocations, we had access to a European skills market. We have now severed ourselves from that skills market.
It will take generations to change this and we will be a nation of bodge for a while yet.

Fetarabbit · 30/10/2021 09:48

@Namenic

The point is that shortage of certain types of skills hampers our economy. So those should be subsidized more than degrees which we have a glut of graduates.
Its a bigger issue than that though. Healthcare courses for example are competitive and always more applicants than places- but they can't increase numbers until there's a training infrastructure expanded in hospitals and other settings. Midwives for example, there is a huge shortage and to get onto the course is highly, highly competitive; but there aren't the staff/placements available on placement to facilitate more students. The biggest issue (and with teaching) is also people leaving within the first few years in high numbers; training more doesn't solve the issue of retention etc its only part of a puzzle.

Subjects like IT are fast moving and vast. A degree is absolutely useful and the majority will go on to have successful careers, but it's not always the most suitable route- I think higher paying apprenticeships etc are better. Again, the shortage isn't necessarily down to degrees, and increasing or encouraging degrees in certain subjects isn't necessarily the answer.

SpinsForGin · 30/10/2021 09:45

This is ridiculous. If you are going to spend 3+ years of your life studying something, it had better be something useful, not made-up, bogus, pointless theories

Made up, bogus, pointless theories....... really? I don't think you understand the purpose of universities.

Theories are important. They help us understand the world around us, they help us predict events and can help us challenge and change things for the better.
Everything we do is underpinned by theory. Theories that have been tested over and over again.

Namenic · 30/10/2021 09:41

The point is that shortage of certain types of skills hampers our economy. So those should be subsidized more than degrees which we have a glut of graduates.

Fetarabbit · 30/10/2021 09:39

@mustlovegin

with some degrees the skills you acquire are just as valuable and useful as the content itself

This is ridiculous. If you are going to spend 3+ years of your life studying something, it had better be something useful, not made-up, bogus, pointless theories

Hmm

Perhaps if you had studied something along those lines your critical thinking would be at a higher level.

mustlovegin · 30/10/2021 09:36

with some degrees the skills you acquire are just as valuable and useful as the content itself

This is ridiculous. If you are going to spend 3+ years of your life studying something, it had better be something useful, not made-up, bogus, pointless theories

malificent7 · 30/10/2021 09:31

Tbh myideal job would be pottering about at home but sadly it's not very well paid!

SpinsForGin · 30/10/2021 09:20

@malificent7

Most trades people earn more than me with my 2 degrees. Wish i'd trained as a plumber tbh.
Do you want be a plumber? Is that a job you'd enjoy? My friend is a plumber and earns more than me (I'm a university academic) but I wouldn't trade jobs.

Although, there has been a trend in schools to push university as the best option but that is changing slowly. Schools now have a legal duty to ensure all options are presented equally.

One of the things the government could do is make degree apprenticeships less bureaucratic. I'd love to offer my course as a degree apprenticeship but I just can't make it work financially due to all the bureaucratic hoops we have to jump through.