Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to blame Tony Blair for the lack of skilled workforce?

493 replies

dunkaccino · 28/10/2021 15:57

In the 1980's only 15% of school leavers went into higher education leaving a good lot of people to become tradesmen/HGV drivers/butchers etc. Tony Blair decided in 1999 that 50% going to University was a great aim, which was finally achieved in 2019.

Now we have a lack of everyone useful - electricians, carpenters, fitters, engineers, butchers, drivers - coupled with a multitude of unskilled mickey mouse degree graduates who are of no practical use to anyone.

Covid & brexit have undeniably both played a part, but AIBU to think that Blairs idea was basically a bit shit and has left us lacking in the skilled workforce needed to run the country?

OP posts:
SpinsForGin · 31/10/2021 10:13

[quote MerryChristmasToYou]**@SpinsForGin, @antsinyourpanta, I just used Shittown as a made up name. I could have used Unremarkabletown Perfectlyoktown.

I'm sure your college is wonderful and a centre of excellence to you, but anyone disagreeing with you is 'ridiculous'.[/quote]
People who disagree with me aren't ridiculous. I enjoy having a debate and hearing other perspectives.

I found the term 'shittown' ridiculous and insulting. It was clear what point you were making and it was unnecessary.

UsedUpUsername · 31/10/2021 08:19

@londonmummy1966

Used up - looking at the formulaic way DD is expected to write an A level history essay I very much doubt that the skills needed to write a report are taught at school. Also, the three years I spent learning to read by myself, form my own opinions and conclusions and then argue the toss with my tutor were not structured in a way that could really be taught in school in a class where the ability was quite mixed. There is also no way that I could have been trained to do this in the professional environment in which I worked. When you have to charge your time to clients in 6 minute blocks there really is no time to teach someone how to read and process at speed and write properly - you need arts graduates who have already learnt that skill.
Honestly we have to train graduates out of writing like they are drafting an academic essay.

That said, I don’t see why this sort of training has to necessarily happen at uni, it could be in the office as you gain experience or with additional coursework completed on your own time. And we need to push companies to start hiring based on portfolios and/or experience instead of summarily requiring degrees as a box ticking exercise.

MerryChristmasToYou · 31/10/2021 07:58

@SpinsForGin, @antsinyourpanta, I just used Shittown as a made up name. I could have used Unremarkabletown Perfectlyoktown.

I'm sure your college is wonderful and a centre of excellence to you, but anyone disagreeing with you is 'ridiculous'.

Peggytheredhen · 30/10/2021 19:32

The lack of skills in industry isn't because everyone decided to spend 3 years studying a BA in Navel gazing studies, it's because of the lack of funding in apprenticeships and general post GCSE support

This.

The number of children leaving school without five GCSEs is truly shocking. That has nothing to do with people choosing to go to university.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 30/10/2021 19:24

Used up - looking at the formulaic way DD is expected to write an A level history essay I very much doubt that the skills needed to write a report are taught at school

25 years a secondary teacher and l totally agree. They can’t absorb vast amounts of knowledge like degree level work. That ability comes with repeated practice.

They don’t have the spohistication or understanding at 17 or 18.

londonmummy1966 · 30/10/2021 18:33

Used up - looking at the formulaic way DD is expected to write an A level history essay I very much doubt that the skills needed to write a report are taught at school. Also, the three years I spent learning to read by myself, form my own opinions and conclusions and then argue the toss with my tutor were not structured in a way that could really be taught in school in a class where the ability was quite mixed. There is also no way that I could have been trained to do this in the professional environment in which I worked. When you have to charge your time to clients in 6 minute blocks there really is no time to teach someone how to read and process at speed and write properly - you need arts graduates who have already learnt that skill.

UsedUpUsername · 30/10/2021 18:14

my History degree I received specific training in how to read manuscripts and inscriptions - not very useful in the outside world. However I also learnt how to digest vast amounts of text and information at speed and then produce a document summarising it, drawing out the main arguments, balancing them and making a case - at university it was called an essay, at work it was called a report but it was basically the same skill set. My classical languages taught me how to approach a sentance with grammatical rigour - very useful when ploughing through the tax legislation

Pretty sure you would have already been showing the aptitude for this in secondary, I don’t see how you couldn’t have built upon this in the workplace, perhaps taking individual coursework as needed.

For instance, I was always shocked that older journalists I met never had degrees—it wasn’t seen necessary then I guess—but they still had tremendous writing and research skills regardless.

AlecTrevelyan006 · 30/10/2021 18:12

Blair was right to stress 'education, education, education' but unfortunately that morphed into 'university, university, university'

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 30/10/2021 18:11

People can go to uni and then learn a trade if that's where the money is. It's not one or the other.

UsedUpUsername · 30/10/2021 18:07

@jgw1

Ok but don’t expect taxpayers to subsidize what is essentially your hobby

The tax payer seems to be perfectly happy to subsidize Boris' hobby of pretending to be in charge of the government.

Umm … what?

If we could cut his funding I’d be all for that too 😏

UsedUpUsername · 30/10/2021 18:06

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

Burnedtoast absolutely. I’d hate to be a child of a STEM obsessed red brick university parent.

‘No you can’t do a degree in Politics. It’s not worthwhile’

It’s not though 😂
kesstrel · 30/10/2021 16:19

Tradespeople don't want to take on apprentices because they get nothing out of it. It used to be that if you took on the bother of training an apprentice up, you would hope to keep him on working for you and expand your business. But if a tradesman's turnover goes above £85,000 per year, they have to start charging VAT to their customers, meaning their quotes increase by 25%, meaning they are no longer competitive. It's been that way for ages now, I think from before Blair was elected.

job-prices.co.uk/vat/

woodhill · 30/10/2021 16:19

@madisonbridges

I worked in HE and the efforts that were made to nurse people through obtaining their degree or foundation degree was huge. It's money orientated. The more students you can enrol, the more money you get, the more lecturers you can employ. If students leave mid course, the govt remove the funding for that student and you can't enrol another student. If you lose a few students, you're looking at running the course at a loss so it will be cancelled for the following year. No hours means laying off lecturers. So there's huge pressure in getting students to stay and achieve. Some students come out with foundation degrees, even maybe degrees, being unable to construct complex sentences even. And all this is because the more quals people get, the more quals employers demand. So then people need to get higher quals. Jobs that once were carried out quite proficiently by a basic education and on job training, now need degrees. The whole system needs overhauling. Remember Tony Blaur didn't introduce this aim to create a higher skilled workforce. It was done to get youth unemployment figures down.
Totally agree and I understand what you mean about the standards and students leaving and funding cut
jgw1 · 30/10/2021 16:00

Ok but don’t expect taxpayers to subsidize what is essentially your hobby

The tax payer seems to be perfectly happy to subsidize Boris' hobby of pretending to be in charge of the government.

BiBabbles · 30/10/2021 15:54

But that is separate from training and job opportunities. Most of which don't really need a degree.

Whether they do or don't depends on employers. On the job training is notoriously cut to the bone in many sectors while also complaining colleges and unis aren't doing enough. As previously mentioned, there have always been employers who like young people/apprentices because they're cheap and others who prefer not to do any training which has now mostly been leaned on further and higher education. More apprenticeships doesn't automatically solve this issue.

Many of the supposed graduate jobs of today are no more skilled than they were 30 years ago - when the same roles were advertised to 16 or 18 year old school leavers.

And those same jobs were often mocked as "unskilled" as part of keeping wages down.

Now we've the same, but the blame is on 'too many mickey mouse degrees' instead. Same tune, different lyrics.

But if would be good if it was fairer - if everyone had access to the most important needs. Starting with housing.

But the OP was asking if Blair is responsible for the lack of tradespeople/HGV drivers/butchers etc. While the cost of housing plays a role because university becomes one of the most well sign posted ways for people to leave home younger and leaves those seeking vocational training often limited to what is available in their own area, discussing housing doesn't answer whether the goal to get 50% of kids to uni caused a skill shortage in some areas. It's a piece, but not the only one.

The fact you're comparing yachts - a flashy consumable - to education is another part of the problem. Higher education has been turned into a consumable as have many areas of society - including housing. Those who manage any housing project will need trained - the question comes down to by who? That's an answer that keeps shifting around and as others mentioned, the funding models at colleges and universities for vocational or academic courses is creating far more of a mess than any student picking to study media.

SpinsForGin · 30/10/2021 15:52

@Tealightsandd

So are you happy with only the very rich and elite having access to university? I'm not.

Only the rich and elite have private yachts. We're never going to have a completely equal society. But if would be good if it was fairer - if everyone had access to the most important needs. Starting with housing.

So we're comparing higher education to yachts now?
londonmummy1966 · 30/10/2021 15:50

I have to say that this is a depressing thread - a lot of snobbery and a lot of posters who seem to know the price of everything and the value of nothing. Few seem to grasp that there is a difference between education and training. Training is teaching people how to do something specific that is useful to your circumstances. Education is meant to be enlightening people and developing them. Both are important but they are very different especially economically. Whilst it is easy enough to put an economic value on training, it is much harder to do that for education in its purest sense. When Blair was looking to southern Asia and talking about a more educated society, when posters here argue that only STEM subjects should be taught, they are actually talking about training and not education. Some degrees are basically training (eg medicine) others are largely education eg Philosophy. Some are a combination of both. All are valuable as is the training others receive via a non-academic route. Some training is more useful than others eg in my History degree I received specific training in how to read manuscripts and inscriptions - not very useful in the outside world. However I also learnt how to digest vast amounts of text and information at speed and then produce a document summarising it, drawing out the main arguments, balancing them and making a case - at university it was called an essay, at work it was called a report but it was basically the same skill set. My classical languages taught me how to approach a sentance with grammatical rigour - very useful when ploughing through the tax legislation. My STEM educated colleague struggled with all of that but she was really good at crunching numbers and pulling spreadsheets out of thin air. Fortunately for us, the big accountancy firms thought both our degrees were useful, and actually her knowledge of chemical reactions was probably no more useful to our employer than my knowledge of ancient Rome.

madisonbridges · 30/10/2021 15:50

I worked in HE and the efforts that were made to nurse people through obtaining their degree or foundation degree was huge. It's money orientated. The more students you can enrol, the more money you get, the more lecturers you can employ. If students leave mid course, the govt remove the funding for that student and you can't enrol another student. If you lose a few students, you're looking at running the course at a loss so it will be cancelled for the following year. No hours means laying off lecturers. So there's huge pressure in getting students to stay and achieve. Some students come out with foundation degrees, even maybe degrees, being unable to construct complex sentences even. And all this is because the more quals people get, the more quals employers demand. So then people need to get higher quals. Jobs that once were carried out quite proficiently by a basic education and on job training, now need degrees. The whole system needs overhauling. Remember Tony Blaur didn't introduce this aim to create a higher skilled workforce. It was done to get youth unemployment figures down.

Tealightsandd · 30/10/2021 15:39

So are you happy with only the very rich and elite having access to university? I'm not.

Only the rich and elite have private yachts. We're never going to have a completely equal society. But if would be good if it was fairer - if everyone had access to the most important needs. Starting with housing.

woodhill · 30/10/2021 15:37

@Tealightsandd

What social mobility?

The inequality divide is widening.

People today are doing the same sort of jobs now that they would have done 30 or 40 years ago. The only difference is they now have huge debt (as does the taxpayer).

In fact things are worse now for many. The public health housing emergency is affecting more and more people including graduates. And wages have gone down whilst working conditions have got worse.

Sorting the public health housing emergency would do a lot more for social mobility than a degree.

Throw in better funded social services, mental and physical health care, infrastructure, and access to adult education evening, part-time, and weekends, and we're getting there. We could pay for these essential quality of life services with the money currently used to help students into decades of debt...

Good point
Tealightsandd · 30/10/2021 15:36

Of course we need to actually provide decent training and apprenticeship opportunities. That some were/are crap doesn't mean they shouldn't be available. They just need be done properly.

Many of the supposed graduate jobs of today are no more skilled than they were 30 years ago - when the same roles were advertised to 16 or 18 year old school leavers.

Namenic · 30/10/2021 15:36

The point is not whether people who get degrees get good jobs. The point is whether the govt should subsidize a whole bunch of degrees which aren’t needed (as people could do them straight from school).

As they progress in their career they could be needed - so they could do part-time work-study. But in an area that they know will be useful.

Right now many do a degree then work a bit and realise that they want to work in a different field, so do a 2nd degree or masters. I mean, fine if you want to do that, but the govt should not subsidise these things in preference to things where there is a skills shortage.

I suspect that there has been qualification inflation. Employers want to filter out ‘the best’ and they use uni as a filtering point even if the actual job doesn’t require degree level skills.

SpinsForGin · 30/10/2021 15:34

It's profoundly depressing that there appears to be more focus and concern on trying to get everyone into university than there is for ensuring access to affordable secure housing.

There isn't a push to get everyone to go to university. 50% of school leavers go.... that's clearly not everyone

Higher Education is a nice want. Decent affordable housing is an essential need. The former is more accessible than the latter. Everyone does not need to go to university. They do all need good housing. We need to rethink our priorities.

More educated societies have lower crime, better mental and physical health, have fewest people accessing benefits. How can that be a bad thing?

If only 6% (or whatever figure) went to university, so what?
So are you happy with only the very rich and elite having access to university? I'm not.

People need access to good job and training opportunities (blue or white collar, doesn't matter which) with decent pay and working conditions, good public services and infrastructure, and - crucially - affordable secure housing. They don't need HE to have these things.

I agree. Nobody has said HE is the ONLY way, it's isn't and shouldn't be promoted as such.

Tealightsandd · 30/10/2021 15:31

Obviously, because enjoyment of life is pretty much essential for mental and physical health, (and a cohesive less divided society) we should provide opportunities for people to broaden the mind and/or pursue an interest or hobby. Well funded part-time/weekend/evening adult education are to be valued in an advanced and civilised society. Good public services and facilities are always important including recreational - whether parks, playgrounds, or FE courses.

But that is separate from training and job opportunities. Most of which don't really need a degree.

BiBabbles · 30/10/2021 15:28

Blair is one of many in power who while having done some things beneficial also had a knock on effect that caused many issues in education and retraining (and housing and many other areas). There are so many things that could be changed, but part of the barrier to that is the rose-tinted glasses I'm seeing.

As already said, things like apprenticeships weren't entirely that kind to people well before Blair was in power and there are many issues now with getting apprenticeships of all levels up to degree apprenticeships working well in a broad range of subjects many are discussing as 'don't need degrees'. Going away to university has a lot of support in many ways that isn't there for vocational courses - it's largely what you have in your area. Not everywhere has them and those looking at options are going to look at what's available.

I've recently been working with a new school that is building a career programme from scratch with the goal of 'raising aspirations'. This school is part of a multi-county initiative, and the "best" is utterly disheartening - just having a career specialist is rare, those having their own cupboard size office to run 1:1 career guidance is rarer still, and as more resources move solely online, we're hitting barriers in engagement (paperless is an admirable environmental goal, but is the bane of trying to get engagement compared to being able to hand something over). That having a stable, consistent career programme is viewed as a goal/benchmark even for well established schools and the most used career programmes still use Myers-Briggs as a way to measure how much someone will like a job shows how much this is a neglected area.

Maybe it's because I'm in an area called mickey mouse, hobby, better to be learned online (as much as I complain about the problems academia, the internet handles the social sciences even worse), but I think the problem being viewed as 'too many media studies degrees' is over simplistic. Higher education in general like much of the rest of society has socially shifted into something to consume, an ~experience~ to have. This conflicts with the other social ideal that degrees - particularly subsidized by taxpayers - should be value for money and lead to high paying careers. Things like the cap in training or the issues in making vocational courses or the many barriers face in trying to retrain or shite work conditions in essential fields or any other systemic problem into 'kids just need go into trades'. As much as I want better vocational training, it's a one of many parts involved in the issues we're facing - part of which isn't helped by using what someone in their 70s did decades ago against all odds when most others didn't that has very little meaning on how we improve the labour market today - much of which is skilled - much as a lot of work denegrated as 'unskilled' often is - it's just not the skills that some value.