Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to blame Tony Blair for the lack of skilled workforce?

493 replies

dunkaccino · 28/10/2021 15:57

In the 1980's only 15% of school leavers went into higher education leaving a good lot of people to become tradesmen/HGV drivers/butchers etc. Tony Blair decided in 1999 that 50% going to University was a great aim, which was finally achieved in 2019.

Now we have a lack of everyone useful - electricians, carpenters, fitters, engineers, butchers, drivers - coupled with a multitude of unskilled mickey mouse degree graduates who are of no practical use to anyone.

Covid & brexit have undeniably both played a part, but AIBU to think that Blairs idea was basically a bit shit and has left us lacking in the skilled workforce needed to run the country?

OP posts:
TractorAndHeadphones · 31/10/2021 18:34

@BurnedToast

I hate all this snobbishness. Most people end up with pretty normal jobs regardless of which university they went to, if at all.

DD is bright enough to do A levels, but has chosen to do an extended BTEC instead as it directly relates to an area she wants to work in. I have had some hilariously snobby comments about it.

Exactly. The issue is not that too many people are going to university it’s that many are going solely because DEGREES are held up as the gold standard.

I did accounting at uni and if i had been at a lower ranked uni teaching the same content as the professional exams it would have been a waste. Because the exams are an NVQ level 7 qualification equal to a Master’s. But because it’s not a degree it’s not considered as prestigious.

I’m not saying that people shouldn’t have some form of higher education but why all the fuss about full time degrees at the expense of everything else? When other qualifications are equivalent but looked down on just because they’re not degrees?

REDHERO · 31/10/2021 18:31

Perhaps more guidance to people whilst in education of what jobs are needed more. Then maybe people would train in those areas rather than on mass media degrees or on mass x y or z

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 31/10/2021 18:22

The polys were designed for technical degree subjects like art, design, some aspects of engineering. They were brilliant at that.

mids2019 · 31/10/2021 16:57

The point about ex polys was not that any of the students are in any way underachieving but I was making the point about what motivates students to achieve top grades (and in some cases their parents push for that) if there are not going to be improved career prospects at the end?

I think it's disingenuous to think as a whole Cambridge grads and new university grads will have those equal career chances. OK you will always get new university grads that earn millions in future and Cambridge grads that may enter relatively low paying professions but on average the picture is clear.

I think one of the considerations here is when to think university is not for me and it would be better on the whole to take on an apprenticeship or further education and these must be difficult decisions.

SpinsForGin · 31/10/2021 15:01

@woodhill

I wondered if they wouldn't be so long hence not so expensive?
The length of course doesn't really make a difference to cost from the university's perspective. Obviously it would be cheaper for the students if they are paying for a one year or two year course instead of a three or four year course but they wouldn't be cheaper to run.
DerTrotzkopf · 31/10/2021 14:53

@mids2019 bit of a underhand comment about Bolton uni. Not all their students are under achievers.

woodhill · 31/10/2021 14:53

I wondered if they wouldn't be so long hence not so expensive?

SpinsForGin · 31/10/2021 14:50

@woodhill

Yes you are right spin but perhaps they needn't be so costly
But they are expensive to run and someone needs to pay for it. We're in a situation where the £9250 tuition fee doesn't actually cover the cost of running an undergraduate degree course. This is why universities have a push on international students as their fees subsidise UK student fees .
woodhill · 31/10/2021 14:45

Yes you are right spin but perhaps they needn't be so costly

mids2019 · 31/10/2021 13:41

Whoops polys more vocational and unis more academic

mids2019 · 31/10/2021 13:40

I think the newer universities are great at offering specific vocational degrees offering aligned to industrial demand and I think the system worked to an extent. By differentiating university and polytechnic there was an awareness each sector offered something slightly different, the former more vocational the latter more academic.

By combining both types of university and placing all universities in direct competition to each other to an extent (e.g. using combined league tables) there often is a blurring of actual prestige of the universities and this may be to the detriment of the applicant. A league table may place an ex poly above an older university in some cases but in reality it may be worth having the degree from an older university.

An aside question would be why encourage children who are capable to become 'academic high flyers' if a batch of A star A levels and a Cambridge degree led to the same opportunities as going to the University of Bolton with 3 Cs. Do we want a level of education communism that equal opportunities for all graduates suggest?I

My view overall is that increasing the number of children going to university has not improved social mobility and efforts in this area should be concentrated on allowing disadvantaged students to get the best qualifications they are capable of by improving aspiration and combating any deficits in the state education sector. I don't think disadvantaged pupils are necessarily served well by attending universities where prospects aren't immediately apparent.

EvilPea · 31/10/2021 13:04

I live in a grammar area and fewer and fewer locals are putting their children in for it as they can’t afford / don’t want to tutor.
Tutoring in my area has become so intense that now children who should have and would have gone to grammar, the families feel “it’s not for them” which completely negates the whole premise

SpinsForGin · 31/10/2021 12:48

@woodhill

But wouldn't the diplomas and HNDs of before be suffice as oppose to saddling our youth with so much debt or is it another way for the government to make money out of loans or do they lose money?
These would still need to be funded from somewhere. Who would be responsible for funding these? The government decided that it should be the student who bears the financial responsibility of the cost of higher education.

I do agree that there should be a range of qualifications available and that a degree isn't always the right option.

woodhill · 31/10/2021 12:32

But wouldn't the diplomas and HNDs of before be suffice as oppose to saddling our youth with so much debt or is it another way for the government to make money out of loans or do they lose money?

SpinsForGin · 31/10/2021 12:07

I'm not denying that we have a hierarchical HE system. I'm fully aware of that.

What I take exception to is completely dismissing those newer universities. It's important that applicants are encouraged to look at the subject level information because the elite universities aren't brilliant at everything.

Lots of the newer universities are excellent for vocational subjects and often have links with employers which translates into jobs.

The hypocrisy on this thread is interesting. On one hand people are complaining that young people don't have skills and are studying subjects at university that don't train them for anything but then they're dismissing universities which actually do offer vocational courses and train students to do specific jobs! We can't win really 🤷🏼‍♀️

mids2019 · 31/10/2021 11:59

I think we have to be honest about the fact that degrees from more prestigious universities (e.g. Oxbridge) are held in higher esteem by a lot of employers and it will always be thus.

Looking at the most competitive elite professions e.g. national journalism, law, elements of academia, banking, upper civil service they are flooded with Oxbridge grads (and some others).

If we have a hierarchical HE system employers are always going to look first at the high flyers from the best inistitutions....It makes sense to do so.

In order to get into elite institutions though a good academic profile is requisite hence the concern many parents have on these boards regarding quality of secondary education.

The problem with the newer universities is not the offering vocation specific subjects tailored to specific industries but offering academic subjects that are not going to be rated by employers e.g. law, history, economics etc. For instance we have too many law grads for lawyer positions and this gives false hope for those degrees from the lower reputation institutions.

Completely agree with students not being allowed to fail at uni. 2.2s and thirds are a rarity now because of students being customers.

SpinsForGin · 31/10/2021 11:21

@DGRossetti

The introduction of the grammar school system was meant to give bright young people from disadvantaged backgrounds an opportunity to get a better education and go on to university. In an individual level this worked for some people but on a societal level it just perpetrated inequalities as grammar schools weren't evenly distributed across the country.

We all went to the local Comp. Harrow didn't have a grammar school system.

Like I said, there were examples of people from disadvantaged backgrounds attending university. Im not saying that didn't happen! However, the data does show that you were far more likely to go to university if you were from an elite background.

It was the exception rather than the rule.

DGRossetti · 31/10/2021 11:11

The introduction of the grammar school system was meant to give bright young people from disadvantaged backgrounds an opportunity to get a better education and go on to university. In an individual level this worked for some people but on a societal level it just perpetrated inequalities as grammar schools weren't evenly distributed across the country.

We all went to the local Comp. Harrow didn't have a grammar school system.

SpinsForGin · 31/10/2021 11:05

@DGRossetti

If we're to go back to a system where only 6% of the population go to university do you think that will help social mobility? Because guess which 6% of the population would end up accessing HE? Definitely not those from disadvantaged backgrounds

My DF is an immigrant whose schooling stopped at 14. DM was a SAHM who was able to re-sew cloths so that they could be passed down to my 2 DBs.

Thanks to the old system we all went to Uni and got degrees (the first on both sides of the family). With one DB getting a PhD (he's American now).

Just for balance.

Yes of course there were some people from disadvantaged backgrounds who made it to university but the data shows is that these were very much the exception rather than the rule.

The introduction of the grammar school system was meant to give bright young people from disadvantaged backgrounds an opportunity to get a better education and go on to university. In an individual level this worked for some people but on a societal level it just perpetrated inequalities as grammar schools weren't evenly distributed across the country.

So yes, there are examples like this but we need to be aware that this wasn't the experience for all young people from disadvantaged backgrounds.

SpinsForGin · 31/10/2021 11:00

[quote MerryChristmasToYou]@SpinsForGin, I've already explained that I just said 'shittown' as a made up name for a town.

You seem to have a chip on your shoulder about working in a former tech.[/quote]
No. I'm incredibly proud of the university I work for. I've worked for other universities and actively chose to come and work at this one because it has an excellent reputation. In fact, I was head of student recruitment here before moving into academia so my job was to tell the world how wonderful the university is!

It would be easier to believe you chose that name at random if all your posts about these types of universities wasn't heavily inferring their inferiority.

I do find it a shame that these attitudes still exist especially as it is nearly 30 years since polytechnics were granted university status. A lot can happen in 30 years and if people took the time to look they'd find some examples of academic excellence alongside some strong, well respected vocational courses.

DGRossetti · 31/10/2021 10:54

If we're to go back to a system where only 6% of the population go to university do you think that will help social mobility? Because guess which 6% of the population would end up accessing HE? Definitely not those from disadvantaged backgrounds

My DF is an immigrant whose schooling stopped at 14. DM was a SAHM who was able to re-sew cloths so that they could be passed down to my 2 DBs.

Thanks to the old system we all went to Uni and got degrees (the first on both sides of the family). With one DB getting a PhD (he's American now).

Just for balance.

MerryChristmasToYou · 31/10/2021 10:47

@SpinsForGin, I've already explained that I just said 'shittown' as a made up name for a town.

You seem to have a chip on your shoulder about working in a former tech.

SpinsForGin · 31/10/2021 10:40

They won’t get a place at the college n a trades course nor an apprenticeship because they’re too old and don’t qualify for funded training places.

The apprenticeship grant for employers is for 16-24 year olds but there is no age limit on apprenticeships and no age limit on the apprenticeships levy which is used to fund most apprenticeships now.

user1497207191 · 31/10/2021 10:35

@IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves

People can go to uni and then learn a trade if that's where the money is. It's not one or the other.
They won’t get a place at the college n a trades course nor an apprenticeship because they’re too old and don’t qualify for funded training places.
SpinsForGin · 31/10/2021 10:22

I'm sure your college is wonderful and a centre of excellence to you,

My university is a recognised centre of excellence for my particular subject. I didn't just decide to call it that...... it's the result of years and years of work and research by people who are leaders in the field. It is possible for non RG and red brick universities to gain this status, which is the point me and other posters have been making.

Referring to a whole group of universities as 'shittown' just feeds into the snobbish attitudes which are rife on MN.