Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to blame Tony Blair for the lack of skilled workforce?

493 replies

dunkaccino · 28/10/2021 15:57

In the 1980's only 15% of school leavers went into higher education leaving a good lot of people to become tradesmen/HGV drivers/butchers etc. Tony Blair decided in 1999 that 50% going to University was a great aim, which was finally achieved in 2019.

Now we have a lack of everyone useful - electricians, carpenters, fitters, engineers, butchers, drivers - coupled with a multitude of unskilled mickey mouse degree graduates who are of no practical use to anyone.

Covid & brexit have undeniably both played a part, but AIBU to think that Blairs idea was basically a bit shit and has left us lacking in the skilled workforce needed to run the country?

OP posts:
Dobermansdinner · 04/11/2021 18:02

@jgw1

What I want to know is if it is Tony Blair or Gordon Brown's fault that the Parliamentary standard rules don't allow Tory MPs to always get away with being corrupt sleazebugs.
Do you mean that Tories do get away with being sleeze bags or don’t get away with it?
jgw1 · 04/11/2021 17:55

What I want to know is if it is Tony Blair or Gordon Brown's fault that the Parliamentary standard rules don't allow Tory MPs to always get away with being corrupt sleazebugs.

Dobermansdinner · 04/11/2021 17:53

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

Dobermansanddinner, it’s not incorrect.

I live in the North. She destroyed all the northern cities main manufacturing bases. She closed the mines, because she wanted a service economy, it’s absolutely true.

She closed the mines because it was a hell of a lot cheaper to buy coal abroad because the wage bill for the miners (which was really really good money at the time) was so expensive. Plus, she didn’t want the unions running the country - which was basically what Arthur scargill did - told the government what to do. And she didn’t want the national union of coal boards telling the conservatives what to do. Only reason I know all this is because watched documentary on it the other week.
user1497207191 · 01/11/2021 19:13

@ColinTheKoala if kids are being tutored to get into grammar schools doesn't that mean they struggle once there or does the tutoring continue?

Not necessarily. By passing, they’re demonstrating good numeracy and literacy, and ability to work under pressure, exam technique, etc. That is a really good grounding for secondary, and after all, they’re doing the same GCSEs as comps etc., so the actual work isn’t harder, they,ve just got a solid head start.

user1497207191 · 01/11/2021 19:09

@MeredithGreyishblue

One of my friends seems to think there's some kind of Central Pot where people claim expenses for their own business.

She can't understand why her self employed husband stays in moderate/ cheap hotels and not nice spa ones when he travels for his own business as he can "just claim it back". From where??

I’m an accountant and it’s pretty common for new clients to think the costs they incur come off their tax bill pound for pound, I.e. they think that if their tax bill is £1,000, all they have to do is spend £1,000 on a laptop or stationery and pay no tax! There’s a lot of misinformation about s/e tax.
ColinTheKoala · 01/11/2021 18:29

@REDHERO

Perhaps more guidance to people whilst in education of what jobs are needed more. Then maybe people would train in those areas rather than on mass media degrees or on mass x y or z
Well they might if they have an aptitude for those areas. The government (and a lot of MNers) seem to think that everyone could study science/engineering if they just would. They can't. I couldn't have done. I did humanities and languages, did a law and language degree and have worked among other thing as a lawyer.

Had I done science A levels I would not have got very good grades, had I passed at all, I would have ended up at a second rate poly or university and got a third rate degree. I doubt I would have got a decent job and I wouldn't have had a STEM career.

We should be steering kids in the direction of their interests and talents, not making everything about STEM. In life you are better making the most of your strengths.

If kids are being tutored to get into grammar schools doesn't that mean they struggle once there or does the tutoring continue?

KirstenBlest · 01/11/2021 18:01

You can't claim hotel costs but you can put it through as expenses.
I usually try to stay somewhere as cheap as possible that is just about ok.

Sometimes you end up somewhere that is reasonable and pleasant. Often, staying somewhere not that close to where you are working makes it less expensive, and you can claim back the mileage.

CatsArePeople · 01/11/2021 17:57

There is a lot of middle class protectionism in my opinion in that high status professionals do not envisage their children going into overly manual careers.

Nepotism, or so called "networking".
And then there's supply and demand.

MeredithGreyishblue · 01/11/2021 17:27

One of my friends seems to think there's some kind of Central Pot where people claim expenses for their own business.

She can't understand why her self employed husband stays in moderate/ cheap hotels and not nice spa ones when he travels for his own business as he can "just claim it back". From where??

mids2019 · 01/11/2021 17:24

There is a lot of middle class protectionism in my opinion in that high status professionals do not envisage their children going into overly manual careers. The children of graduates on the whole will take on similar roles as their parents and there is a vested interest to maintain this status quo.

Perhaps this is why we have systems that in the past have favoured wealthier families and social mobility has been hard to come by in some instances.

There needs to be more skilled trades people but how many parents will actively encourage their children to aspire to their jobs?

TractorAndHeadphones · 01/11/2021 11:38

[quote user1497207191]**@TractorAndHeadphones* Also if you work for yourself you don’t have holidays sick pay etc but you get to claim a decent amount as business expenses*

Not sure what you mean. Self employed can claim expenses they incur because of their self employment, i.e. travel, equipment, materials etc., in just the same way that if someone is employed, then it's their employer who pays those costs of operating. Being s/e isn't some magic where you can claim private things. S/e spend money to be able to do their trade and it's right that they can offset those costs against the income they generate.[/quote]
Where did I say it was wrong? Do you get all of your exercise from jumping to conclusions?

Many people not in the know consider a wage superior to self-employment because of the perceived stability. And the fact that the self-employed bear all of the risk.

However a lot of supposed ‘stable’ office jobs don’t pay very well and people are at risk of redundancy. Employees pay for a lot of things out of their own pocket. Some places don’t even provide laptops. Commutes and WFH expenses aren’t reimbursed.

By comparison if you earn a good revenue from being self-employed you get to keep more of the money. An example being expensing (which even then isn’t free money, you get to claim tax relief not the entire cost). There is risk - but if you’re in a trade it’s more lucrative than a generic office job. Therefore not sure why people look down on this

user1497207191 · 01/11/2021 11:05

@Ticksallboxes

I haven't RTFT but I agree with you!

I always remember a conversation I had with a head of year secondary school teacher in the late 90s, who was very frustrated that she had to push for all students in their final year
to go to university.

She said so many (usually boys) clearly were not academic and would have thrived in a trade, and she felt she was thwarting their chances by recommending they apply to university instead.

Also a friend of mine lives in one of the most expensive areas in our city and has said most of her neighbours are in trades.

Another big problem is the way that "practical" skills like woodwork, metalwork, etc is taught in schools. It seems commonplace that the teachers don't have "trades" experience/background so aren't really in the best position to teach and encourage practical skills at all.

I certainly remember my school days where the wood/metal work teachers weren't remotely interested and just watched on as we spent weeks/months making a wooden fish or a metal trowel. My woodwork teacher was an ex-maths teacher who'd had a nervous breakdown and returned to work as a woodwork teacher as it was less marking/stressful etc.

It certainly seemed like the only ones good at the wood/metal work were the pupils who had a father/uncle with their own workshop in their shed/garage, as they would knock out their fantastic 3d wooden fish in a couple of weeks so were clearly learning skills etc somewhere other than the classroom! I also remember doing GCSE Design where one lad just messed around in class all the time, not obviously doing much, but then at the end of the course, miraculously appeared with a metal framed go-cart - it was blatantly obviously he'd made it somewhere else (or someone had made it for him), because he'd certainly not made it in the classroom!

user1497207191 · 01/11/2021 10:58

@TractorAndHeadphones Also if you work for yourself you don’t have holidays sick pay etc but you get to claim a decent amount as business expenses

Not sure what you mean. Self employed can claim expenses they incur because of their self employment, i.e. travel, equipment, materials etc., in just the same way that if someone is employed, then it's their employer who pays those costs of operating. Being s/e isn't some magic where you can claim private things. S/e spend money to be able to do their trade and it's right that they can offset those costs against the income they generate.

TractorAndHeadphones · 01/11/2021 10:39

@Ticksallboxes

I haven't RTFT but I agree with you!

I always remember a conversation I had with a head of year secondary school teacher in the late 90s, who was very frustrated that she had to push for all students in their final year
to go to university.

She said so many (usually boys) clearly were not academic and would have thrived in a trade, and she felt she was thwarting their chances by recommending they apply to university instead.

Also a friend of mine lives in one of the most expensive areas in our city and has said most of her neighbours are in trades.

This! A degree merely demonstrates academic skills to a certain level. Not having a degree doesn’t mean you aren’t capable of critical thinking, or anything like that. In face if that piece of paper was sooo important include a degree element in trade apprenticeships problem solved.

I know that anecdata isn’t really relevant but so many people make a good living in the trades and more importantly are inclined towards it. Not just men! But if you’re not ‘in’ the trades you don’t know how good it can be and schools etc dont encourage these options.

Also if you work for yourself you don’t have holidays sick pay etc but you get to claim a decent amount as business expenses…

EvilPea · 01/11/2021 10:31

@TheHateIsNotGood

When I went to an ex-Poly Uni as a mature student in 2000 (Social Policy) I was 'taught' that the Grammar School system benefitted the better off as they could afford the specific tuition.

I said "but I wasn't tutored, I was an ex-pat kid newly returned from the California state-school system, read a few test-papers, took the test at County Hall (Surrey) and passed".

The Uni Tutor's response was "You must have been very bright". Er, yes, I probably was, but wasn't that the idea of Grammars?

And then there's the people I know who passed the 11+, but their Dads said "No - you're not going to school with a bunch of snobs"; and yes, those kids were "very bright" too.

Not offering any answers here, just some facts to dispel some fastly held 'myths'.

The bright untutored children are not passing now. The past 3-5 years has seen a real shift in my area. Tutoring has become the norm which pushes the pass rate up and the ones grammar was meant for out. Tutoring is also happening younger and younger, it’s now normal all through juniors.

That’s before you look at private schools being able to tutor and state not.

Grammars vs comps are not the way to get more people into trades and vocations.

Ticksallboxes · 01/11/2021 06:41

I haven't RTFT but I agree with you!

I always remember a conversation I had with a head of year secondary school teacher in the late 90s, who was very frustrated that she had to push for all students in their final year
to go to university.

She said so many (usually boys) clearly were not academic and would have thrived in a trade, and she felt she was thwarting their chances by recommending they apply to university instead.

Also a friend of mine lives in one of the most expensive areas in our city and has said most of her neighbours are in trades.

Yusanaim · 01/11/2021 06:31

I think the class system is the real reason our education system falls behind other countries. The tradition was that posh pupils went to Eton or some other private schools, studied the Classics, then went to Oxbridge to study something, anything. Then went out into the world to run the City or Banking or wherever the money is.
What they didn't do was study engineering - Engineers in Germany were/are Herr Doctor - prestigious title for a prestigious job.
AS can be seen by our politicians this still remains. In fact it still remains in everything, ex public school pupils excel at sport (Olympic competitors), in the arts (many of our comedians ). We produce a good number of entrepreneurs but that doesn't seem to be thanks to their innovative and technical education. More often because they dropped out of school.
We need scientists, engineers, mathematicians, software experts.
We should provide a higher salary for teachers of these subjects. Sadly the best mainly go into industry.

pointythings · 31/10/2021 20:31

The personal experience of a single person is not data.

TheHateIsNotGood · 31/10/2021 19:33

Ah yes pointy, nothing like describing actual data (eg: ethnograhic) as anecdotal or "anecdata" instead of actual data; which from a Social Research perspective Is Data.

I completely agree, the current access to Grammar Schools is very limited now - many locations don't have them now, since most were closed down in the 1970s, including the one I went to which has since been a 6th Form College.

Nowadays, what are called Grammars today are nothing like they were - hardly anywhere has one nearby, so that cancels out many "very bright" students and there's so few now the 'myths' of 2000 have now become the reality of today.

Using FSM as an indicator/factor is a very blunt instrument that hardly illustrates the full picture, although it does speak in the language of current understanding.

pointythings · 31/10/2021 18:55

@TheHateIsNotGood

When I went to an ex-Poly Uni as a mature student in 2000 (Social Policy) I was 'taught' that the Grammar School system benefitted the better off as they could afford the specific tuition.

I said "but I wasn't tutored, I was an ex-pat kid newly returned from the California state-school system, read a few test-papers, took the test at County Hall (Surrey) and passed".

The Uni Tutor's response was "You must have been very bright". Er, yes, I probably was, but wasn't that the idea of Grammars?

And then there's the people I know who passed the 11+, but their Dads said "No - you're not going to school with a bunch of snobs"; and yes, those kids were "very bright" too.

Not offering any answers here, just some facts to dispel some fastly held 'myths'.

What you've provided is anecdata. If you use eligibility for free school meals as an indicator of economic deprivation, you will learn that grammar schools have a far lower % of pupils eligible for free school meals than comprehensives in the same area. Which would suggest that poor bright pupils are not getting access to grammar schools in the way that they should be if it was genuinely about ability. In 2000 it may have been different, but we are 20+ years on and these days, money buys tuition and that buys access to grammar schools.
TractorAndHeadphones · 31/10/2021 18:48

Also to add this is not just me making things up. I review CV’s for a charity and the amount of young peoples’ CV’s I get with even Master’s degrees but nothing except for retail/low-level admin jobs for 5 years is disheartening. Why? Because they can’t afford to do unpaid projects!
Media companies will talk rubbish about diversity and social mobility and ‘widening participation’ but they won’t actually take a young person who has worked hard in every other aspect. Just in paid work. They don’t want to put in the effort to bloody train people. It makes me so angry. There are a few who break through workinf days, nights etc but that’s like saying a few kids in deprived areas manage to get to Cambridge so it’s all good.

TractorAndHeadphones · 31/10/2021 18:41

Also to add more degrees make things harder.
You don’t just need a degree to compete. You need that plus relevant work experience for some fields.

Whom does this benefit? Wealthy kids whose parents can pay while they take on relevant ‘unpaid internships’ and projects for their portfolios. While the poorer students who manage to get degrees have to work for actual money. Many don’t get full maintainance either because parental income is too high but they have multiple kids.

TheHateIsNotGood · 31/10/2021 18:38

When I went to an ex-Poly Uni as a mature student in 2000 (Social Policy) I was 'taught' that the Grammar School system benefitted the better off as they could afford the specific tuition.

I said "but I wasn't tutored, I was an ex-pat kid newly returned from the California state-school system, read a few test-papers, took the test at County Hall (Surrey) and passed".

The Uni Tutor's response was "You must have been very bright". Er, yes, I probably was, but wasn't that the idea of Grammars?

And then there's the people I know who passed the 11+, but their Dads said "No - you're not going to school with a bunch of snobs"; and yes, those kids were "very bright" too.

Not offering any answers here, just some facts to dispel some fastly held 'myths'.

REDHERO · 31/10/2021 18:37

"Exactly.
The issue is not that too many people are going to university it’s that many are going solely because DEGREES are held up as the gold standard."

I agree with this. However, some quickly find out that a degree alone is not enough to make it and end up doing the jobs that others look down on with university debt to pay back (assuming they ever earn enough).

TractorAndHeadphones · 31/10/2021 18:37

@AlecTrevelyan006

Blair was right to stress 'education, education, education' but unfortunately that morphed into 'university, university, university'
Yes!