Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to blame Tony Blair for the lack of skilled workforce?

493 replies

dunkaccino · 28/10/2021 15:57

In the 1980's only 15% of school leavers went into higher education leaving a good lot of people to become tradesmen/HGV drivers/butchers etc. Tony Blair decided in 1999 that 50% going to University was a great aim, which was finally achieved in 2019.

Now we have a lack of everyone useful - electricians, carpenters, fitters, engineers, butchers, drivers - coupled with a multitude of unskilled mickey mouse degree graduates who are of no practical use to anyone.

Covid & brexit have undeniably both played a part, but AIBU to think that Blairs idea was basically a bit shit and has left us lacking in the skilled workforce needed to run the country?

OP posts:
NowEvenBetter · 29/10/2021 00:41

OP never bothered coming back to the thread??

Tealightsandd · 29/10/2021 00:36

may be mistaken, but did Tony Blair write yesterday's budget?
Was there anything in the budget other than 3p off a pint of draught beer, to make you think that anything is going to change soon?
What about for the past 10 years? Could anyone have been trained in a skill in that time?

@jgw1 Yes definitely. The heirs to Blair absolutely could and should have moved away from his failed policies.

nancybotwinbloom · 28/10/2021 23:16

[quote Rivermonsters]@nancybotwinbloom do you need to be good at maths for that? Sounds interesting however my maths skills are awful[/quote]
To be a gas fitter. No I don't think so. Just thorough. Understand the gas process. How meters work. You should at least enquire about it.

He didn't go to uni for it. Think he may he an apprenticeship. But you should look into it.

Look at energy assets, sms, National grid, stark, they are the biggest ones to ask first. Good luck 🤞

UsedUpUsername · 28/10/2021 22:53

[quote Simonjt]@UsedUpUsername You don’t seem to understand, he was only able to create his business because his degree has enabled him to gain five years of experience as an employee in a company that develops social media platforms. Without the degree he wouldn’t have the experience, knowledge, or vital business contracts.[/quote]
No I do understand. I know someone who started running social media accounts of small F&B businesses and went on to bigger things from there. No one cares about the lack of degree.

Now I can see that the office job was the precursor in yr example but developers often don’t need to have degrees if they have the relevant skillset. And if they have a strong portfolio—that’s what clients actually care about. No reason he couldn’t develop those skills outside of uni, in fact in his case sounds like the degree was a waste of time and just a box ticking exercise for HR

KrispyKale · 28/10/2021 22:45

Medicine turns away highly qualified students every year. It's a different issue to the mass exoansion of lower tarrif courses.

sst1234 · 28/10/2021 22:41

Blair is the same economically illiterate idiot who created a low pay labor market by subsidizing low pay with tax credits. Something that is now so deeply embedded within our economy that it suppressed skills growth further.

Rivermonsters · 28/10/2021 22:34

@nancybotwinbloom do you need to be good at maths for that? Sounds interesting however my maths skills are awful

Mammyofonlyone · 28/10/2021 22:25

@FOJN

So if everyone just knew their place everything would have been fine.

That single sentence reveals the general lack of respect for skilled jobs. Becoming a plumber is "knowing your place" which is beneath those with a university education?

Why would you encourage people who may not be academically inclined to get into loads of debt to gain a qualification which has become so ubiquitous it won't necessarily give you an advantage in the job market. We need skilled workers as well as educated ones.

Exactly
Kendodd · 28/10/2021 22:25

Except, we are also massively short of university educated professionals as well, example, doctors.

nancybotwinbloom · 28/10/2021 22:23

@RussianSpy101

Totally agree.

RussianSpy101 · 28/10/2021 22:22

@VivienScott I agree. They also earn better in most cases.

nancybotwinbloom · 28/10/2021 22:21

Maybe don't get a degree. Train as a gas fitter. My DSS earns over £40k. He's 23.

RussianSpy101 · 28/10/2021 22:21

DH owns a construction company. There’s no shortage of 18/19yos qualifying in trades and by 21 many of them out earn university leavers of the same age starting their first job.
Unless you’ve done law or medical, a good plumber, bricklayer & scaffolder earns much more than a teacher and a nurse. I’m just using industry specific degree examples here.

Morgoth · 28/10/2021 22:17

@MargaretThursday

I remember TB saying he wanted 75% of the school leavers to be above average.

It is possible he meant the mode (most common)form of average, but that would be pretty silly.
Median= middle so by definition can't be 75% above average.
Mean (traditional average) you could get that-but only if the bottom 25% sank really low, and I doubt he was aiming for that.

Conclusion: he liked sound bites and didn't care whether they made sense or not.

This exactly. They give out the same meaningless logic and sound bites in secondary school education too - “everyone must achieve the average grade or above!”. As with anything in life, a national distribution bell curve will always exist. There always has to be 50% of the population below average and 50% above average in anything - intelligence, attractiveness, physical ability, cooking ability, whatever. The curve can shift position along the x axis if the population as a whole gets smarter or dumber or the curve can expand or narrow if the population develops either more or less extremes each end, but the same distribution curve cannot change and the average of any given cohort will always be the same - 50% above it and 50% below it.
Menofsteel · 28/10/2021 22:14

I’m glad I’m a bus driver. Mortgage free at 39, studying for a degree and my employer is throwing all kinds of money at us to work extra hours right now (as usual but the cash bonuses have gone WAY up since the shortage bit) I think getting people in jobs like plumber, HGV driver, carpenter to talk in schools rather than just the aspirational degree people about the realities of these jobs and skills, would be beneficial. We haven’t failed. None of my colleagues are struggling. I bet plumbers and carpenters are doing even better. Like a PP said, get the respect back for people doing jobs that aren’t in an office.

KrispyKale · 28/10/2021 22:12

I suspect he either didn't do A level maths OR yes, he just didn't care really!

MargaretThursday · 28/10/2021 22:05

I remember TB saying he wanted 75% of the school leavers to be above average.

It is possible he meant the mode (most common)form of average, but that would be pretty silly.
Median= middle so by definition can't be 75% above average.
Mean (traditional average) you could get that-but only if the bottom 25% sank really low, and I doubt he was aiming for that.

Conclusion: he liked sound bites and didn't care whether they made sense or not.

elp30 · 28/10/2021 21:49

@mustlovegin

It always amazes me that people think electricians/heating engineers/plumbers are not academically inclined, you need maths, physics, you have to sit yearly written exams and do practical tests to keep your qualifications up to the latest requirements and be able to run your own business on top of all that

I agree. They are much more valuable than someone learning social studies or some other obscure subject which serves no purpose really

My father emigrated to the USA from Mexico and his actual job in Mexico was "professional musician". However, he learned, on the job, how to be a tradesperson on building sites (he also worked as a professional musician part-time too). He only went to school until age eight (yes, age eight, not year eight), so knew how to read and write, in Spanish, and basic mathematics. He had to learn English and more advanced skills for the two different trades.

He later owned his own two businesses: carpentry & owned his own musical group. He owned his own home, raised his family and lived a comfortable life. He HIRED people who had degrees in business, accountancy, law, construction management and degreed musicians and singers from esteemed music schools.

He may not have had experience or education himself but he was smart enough to outsource those who did.

VivienScott · 28/10/2021 21:47

The trouble is, as a country, we have an obsession with academia. We need to re-educate society that trades people etc are just well qualified and intelligent and valuable as anyone with a degree, and sometimes more so.

Morgoth · 28/10/2021 21:45

@KrispyKale

Yes the Blair sin business is a rather bitter pill.

@Morgoth your post about the lower achieving graduate now taking up the roles formerly taken by the 16+ : I think in many cases they are the same type of candidate separated by 30 years.
That's the con. Don't get me started on the whole paying for your own trainjng element of this change in the jobs market!

Yep. Bang on @KrispyKale. This is what I was trying to articulate but not as well as you. Exactly the same sort of person in relation to ability and competency, just separated by time. Those that would normally have been the ones to go into such industries are now the low-tier grads who like you said, 30 years ago, would be the ones filling these positions instead of the polytechnic uni places they are nowadays.
Simonjt · 28/10/2021 21:39

@UsedUpUsername You don’t seem to understand, he was only able to create his business because his degree has enabled him to gain five years of experience as an employee in a company that develops social media platforms. Without the degree he wouldn’t have the experience, knowledge, or vital business contracts.

TheNestedIf · 28/10/2021 21:38

I did an impractical, arty degree.

I have gone on to do a highly technical job, which many people on this website rely on. The degree got me a foot in the door as being someone who was willing to learn and was capable of doing so.

I am interested in butchery, but never tried for a career in it, because it's badly paid compared to what I do. That's the problem, right there. Taking employees for granted.

UsedUpUsername · 28/10/2021 21:34

[quote Simonjt]@UsedUpUsername He couldn’t, as he couldn’t have gained employment in managing social media himself, without that employment he couldn’t upskill himself enough to then be able to open his own business and gain clients from links he had made.[/quote]
It’s not necessary. You successfully manage social media accounts for businesses, you don’t need a degree to do it and it’s often done on a freelance or contract basis.

Fizbosshoes · 28/10/2021 21:20

I think this all goes back to the grammar school system, where it was seen as desirable to go to the grammar school and therefore the academic route. From then on anything practical looks like second best.

Way back in the 1950s when my dad was at school his parents didnt want their kids to go to a grammar (and wouldn't let them sit the 11+)
because they wanted them to leave school earlier and learn a trade....

woodhill · 28/10/2021 21:18

@sst1234

To many people with Mickey Mouse degrees promoting a culture a mediocrity, when what we needed was engineers and bricklayers. Blair’s poliovirus dumbed down an entire generation
Then we were told we had a skill shortage