Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to blame Tony Blair for the lack of skilled workforce?

493 replies

dunkaccino · 28/10/2021 15:57

In the 1980's only 15% of school leavers went into higher education leaving a good lot of people to become tradesmen/HGV drivers/butchers etc. Tony Blair decided in 1999 that 50% going to University was a great aim, which was finally achieved in 2019.

Now we have a lack of everyone useful - electricians, carpenters, fitters, engineers, butchers, drivers - coupled with a multitude of unskilled mickey mouse degree graduates who are of no practical use to anyone.

Covid & brexit have undeniably both played a part, but AIBU to think that Blairs idea was basically a bit shit and has left us lacking in the skilled workforce needed to run the country?

OP posts:
IntermittentParps · 29/10/2021 17:22

@MerryChristmasToYou

Mickey Mouse degrees are ones that do not lead to a job. They might be in subjects like Media Studies, Communication, Philosophy ...

If I was recruiting I would look at the degree, the university, and experience.

I work in a niche area and there is a degree and masters degree for the work but the grads I've worked with were clueless.

Any degree is valuable. I loathe this attitude about 'useless' degrees just because they're not obviously vocational.
CatsArePeople · 29/10/2021 17:20

Mickey Mouse degrees are ones that do not lead to a job. They might be in subjects like Media Studies, Communication, Philosophy ...

I wouldn't slag particular degrees, but there are subjects for which there is very little marketability (history), or the market is way too competititve (arts).

woodhill · 29/10/2021 17:20

Isn't Media studies good for journalism or tv jobs though

MerryChristmasToYou · 29/10/2021 16:54

Mickey Mouse degrees are ones that do not lead to a job. They might be in subjects like Media Studies, Communication, Philosophy ...

If I was recruiting I would look at the degree, the university, and experience.

I work in a niche area and there is a degree and masters degree for the work but the grads I've worked with were clueless.

DGRossetti · 29/10/2021 16:32

Granted he spent some days dealing with busted soil pipes

DF used to say "The job may be dirty, but the money is clean".

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 29/10/2021 16:09

Yes, what is a Mickey Mouse degree?

Because our design graduates are recognised as the best in the world. They are frequently ‘exported’ abroad.But maybe only to Disneyland eh?🙄

Fetarabbit · 29/10/2021 16:03

@SpinsForGin

unskilled mickey mouse degree graduates who are of no practical use to anyone.

Could you define a Mickey Mouse degree please?

Yes this intriges me too. I'm assuming people think of art related subjects or perhaps media studies, but there is a big market for these professions and networking at university alongside the degree is very useful. People can can go on to do grad schemes, PGCEs and all sorts of postgraduate courses with them. Everything we look at has been designed and created by someone after all, the media is a huge industry, and many people go on to have successful and fulfilling careers.
SpinsForGin · 29/10/2021 15:51

unskilled mickey mouse degree graduates who are of no practical use to anyone.

Could you define a Mickey Mouse degree please?

RickJames · 29/10/2021 15:36

You're not wrong but I think its a cultural thing too. Trades and lorry driving have been valued less than officey, smart suit type jobs for too long.

I remember having a great sales job, nice clothes and business trips and my friend (double qualified, plumber and electrician) thought my job was amazing. One night we compared wages and he did less hours and got the same wage, plus he did cash in hand on the side - he was so much better off than I was. Granted he spent some days dealing with busted soil pipes but he also spent a lot of time running electrics through newly built warehouses etc. and he took a lot less crap from clients. He had a few sets of overalls, company van and car, could easily afford to eat lunch out everyday. Didn't have to live in a city centre with expensive housing. He realised actually my job was a bit bollocks and I wished I'd got into plumbing or electrical!

I'd never encourage my DS to see Uni as a goal within itself. Fair enough if he has a clear plan but otherwise I'm going to be encouraging an apprenticeship. He can get paid by his firm to do a degree if he needs one.

I teach apprentices and University students. I often see uni kids that have happily done apprenticeships and are sponsored to do a degree or even packed in their job to do a degree. They are streets ahead of the kids that have no work experience. I never see an apprentice that I think 'this isn't for you, you should be at uni doing philosophy!'

DGRossetti · 29/10/2021 15:13

The root of the problem has been the commodification of education*. It's now something which has to be sold so all the middlemen can extract the value out of it before it finally gets delivered to the student.

*and, in wider society, the commodification of everything

woodhill · 29/10/2021 15:05

@bogeythefungusman

User1497207191 your post at 11.20 is absolutely on the money - when less than 10% of people went to university, there were still many intelligent, focused, motivated young people who went into trades, got jobs in banks, insurance and accounting firms who learned 'on the job' with perhaps day release to college to gain qualifications. Not any more.
Yes so much better but TB turned the universities into businesses with a bums on seats approach
Fizbosshoes · 29/10/2021 14:53

Yes we do get ‘the uni experience’ and whilst it is fun it also gives us life experience. At 21 I had graduated uni and had lived away from home for 4 years. At 21 my brother who did an apprenticeship still stays at home and has only just become aware that council tax is a thing.

I would take an educated society over an uneducated society any day. Unfortunately there is a huge element of snobbery from people who regard a tradesman as uneducated. For what it’s what it’s worth my partner has a masters degree and earns over 50k, and he can’t even put a shelf up. More practical skills in the curriculum wouldn’t go amiss!

Its possible to get life experience without going to uni. I didn't go but most of my peers did. I did an apprenticeship (and had a pt job) and moved out of home when I was 22, just after most of my friends who went to uni , had moved back in with their parents. That was over 20 years ago but a work colleagues DD started an apprenticeship straight from school and was living in a shared house at 17.

A lot of skills are talents and aptitudes for things rather than "learning ". My DH is about the least academic person you could meet. He left school with minimal o levels. He is artistic and practical but hopeless at reading instructions or filling in forms. He can lay a floor, or fix a leaking tap or put up shelves - arguably just as useful as some more "professional" jobs (although he doesn't do any of that for a living)

ILoveShula · 29/10/2021 14:44

@EerieSilence, some of Boris Johnson's children are now adults, and some are girls, so won't be or weren't at Eton. No idea about JR-M's children.

Strictly1 · 29/10/2021 14:37

@VladmirsPoutine

So if everyone just knew their place everything would have been fine. It seems to me the multiples of people with either a PPE or Classics degree from Oxford haven't exactly done a sterling job of running the country.
It's society's perception of success that needs to change. It saddens me that we only seem to value academia in this country.

You can be incredibly talented and knowledgeable without a degree. University does not suit everyone's learning ability - this does make them less in anyway and shame on those who think it does. Just like I've met many degree educated people who have lacked other skills.

We can all valuably contribute to the society we live in.

onlychildhamster · 29/10/2021 14:34

From a Guardian article:

Ross Hemsworth is an HGV1 driver and musician, and said that while there was some help for the haulage industry in the budget, there was not a lot for individual drivers like him.

Hemsworth, 64, a married father-of-four, operates as a driver for hire – he has his own limited company which he has had since 2018. Based in Somerset, he has been an HGV1 driver since the early 1990s and wanted more money spent on “levelling up” in the south-west, particularly when it came to public transport.

Asked how he was managing financially, he said: “Scraping by is probably the best term. We’re keeping the bills paid, but we’re not in the position we could be in or should be in.”

Hemsworth said that while there had been reports about the big bonuses that some companies were offering lorry drivers, these were “usually tied into a lot of small print” that did not get reported – for example, an individual might have to work for the company for at least a year or they claw it back, or the bonuses can be withdrawn under various scenarios.

For HGV1 work, “you’d be lucky to get £10 to £12 an hour in Somerset … Most drivers I know down here are taking home, after deductions, £450 to £550 a week, which for many people isn’t enough to live on. This is another reason why drivers are leaving the business.”

I can imagine its similar for a lot of tradesmen (esp given that you have to pay for materials) and you are essentially running your own small business. There is a lot of press about the successful plumber who earns £200k but not much about the fine print. In a normal job, the pay may not look great but you will not incur any expenses from it other than the usual commuting/clothes/lunch and you will get redundancy/sick leave. I don't blame young people for choosing a 'safe' salaried job given that we are the generation that came of age during the '08 recession and have been profiled to be more risk averse.

NotPersephone · 29/10/2021 14:32

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

pointythings · 29/10/2021 14:31

Cancunot raises a good point about the way in which a university education equips you with skills that stay with you for life. My degree isn't related to the job I do right now, but it has equipped me with skills I can use in any field - and I have done just that.

We are also rather drifting away from the central question: why are we holding Tony Blair personally responsible for our current situation when we have had a government of a different colour for almost 11 years now - and they've done nothing to address it? It's getting old.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 29/10/2021 14:30

One of the major problems is that training and funding training has not developed to match the realities of the job market now.

It needs to be easier and less risky for people to retrain.

The job for life isn't really a thing anymore. If someone finds themselves in an oversaturated industry or with out of date qualifications or unable to physically do the job they originally trained for it is really difficult for them to retrain into these shortage areas.

Someone on the dole is not in a position to spend thousands training to become a lorry driver. Funding is not available for adults to do many vocational qualifications. Once in full time education your entitlement to benefits changes but people have homes and families to support.

Make it easier for those with appropriate skills and aptitude to retrain into shortage areas rather than having people only able to do unskilled work.

EerieSilence · 29/10/2021 14:24

@dunkaccino - that's complete bollocks.
I believe that education and the possibility of higher education should be available to everybody.
That doesn't make the trade and people working in trade less intelligent or below people with higher education. But I'm not blind to the Tory brainwashing going on here.
I can't imagine Boris Johnson's or Reese-Mogg's children starting an apprenticeship as a plumber or HGV driver - can you? Do you think this will end up with children of peers and Tory elite going for trade to be an example? I would like to see that.
No, this will end up with higher education being once again available to those who can afford it. BJ's kids will go to Eton and study classical studies or something completely useless, only to rise through the ranks of the Tory Party based on their family name while the plumber's son will not be able to study medicine or nuclear physics even if they wanted to.
Please, let's see through the demagogy of the Daily Mail's articles on how Blair etc. are to blame for the lack of tradesmen because they let rubble study whatever they wanted. They don't really believe plumbers are their equal. They believe that they people shouldn't cross the limitations of their own class.

dunkaccino · 29/10/2021 14:09

[quote EerieSilence]@dunkaccino - you're right. It's about time the UK went back to the old good system, where people knew their place and didn't try to rise above their station.[/quote]
And this perfectly illustrates (again) the problem. You seem to think that a degree is somehow 'above' a trade, you are the problem.

OP posts:
sst1234 · 29/10/2021 14:08

[quote Simonjt]@sst1234 You are choosing to purposely misunderstand. So without his degree, how do you propose he would have gained a job that required a degree? Without said job he wouldn’t have been able to gain skills in his area of employment, he also wouldn’t have been able to gain contacts or business links, the links who switched over to his business very quickly enabling him to employ over 100 people in the first year of his business.[/quote]
And I think you are conflating correlation with causation.

sst1234 · 29/10/2021 14:06

@pointythings

We live in a world where the media have immense power and where the use of communication intersecting with technology drives so much of what is going on. Anyone who thinks studying these phenomena is doing a Mickey Mouse degree is frankly a Muppet. Media and communication is one of the powers in the age we live in.
What’s that got to do with getting a degree in media studies? You can make up degrees for almost anything. Doesn’t mean it’s needed to be successful.
Canunot · 29/10/2021 13:53

The problem is what a lot of people are considering as Mickey Mouse degrees such as media studies are actually far more useful than the likes of classics (unless you are rich and have connections, then it may just land you a job in Downing Street).

Years ago you wouldn’t see a degree in HR for example, but plenty of people who had for example studied English would go after jobs in this field. Now people are getting degrees in this so they are obviously getting the jobs, so where do people who studied English go? Does this mean we should stop letting people study English at Uni?

I have a degree in Politics and History. At uni i was not able to do unpaid/low paid internships in the summer, I had to work to get as much money as possible. So when I left a lot of jobs were unavailable to me as I did not have experience. After 3 horrible sales jobs, I got an apprenticeship in telecommunications. I worked alongside people with different backgrounds, barely anyone has a degree. However, it has stood in me in good stead. I have progressed faster than a lot of my colleagues due to skills i learned in my degree.

Another thing is people don’t seem to realise how hard it is to get into a trade, a lot of people I know have got an apprenticeship due to family or friends. So unless you have those connections it is extremely hard to get an apprenticeship as some are much more competitive than uni courses.

Yes we do get ‘the uni experience’ and whilst it is fun it also gives us life experience. At 21 I had graduated uni and had lived away from home for 4 years. At 21 my brother who did an apprenticeship still stays at home and has only just become aware that council tax is a thing.

I would take an educated society over an uneducated society any day. Unfortunately there is a huge element of snobbery from people who regard a tradesman as uneducated. For what it’s what it’s worth my partner has a masters degree and earns over 50k, and he can’t even put a shelf up. More practical skills in the curriculum wouldn’t go amiss!

Rugsofhonour · 29/10/2021 13:50

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

EerieSilence · 29/10/2021 13:39

@mustlovegin ATP? TMR.