Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Absolutely livid with ML- what would you do ?

394 replies

fussytodd · 28/10/2021 12:32

So I'm staying with in laws for a couple of weeks.

I did some washing and accidentally put a wool jumper in with the general load at 40. It shrunk. I left it on the side in the laundry room to dry and then assess the damage.

Today mother in law comes up to me, holding just the jumper and goes:

' what happened here ?you must have washed this wrong. You need to wash it on a wool setting '

I reply :

' I know. I just didn't see it and put it in with other stuff at 30. That's a shame, oh well'

She says again : ' yeah but you can't wash it at 30, you can only wash it on a wool setting '. I again replied that I know that but I didn't see it and oh well.

To which she goes: ' well this is a hundred pound jumper '. It's her sons jumper, not hers...

So I just went, well what do you want me to do ?

Back story is that it has happened to me before that I've accidentally shrunk a jumper and it's come up as a joke in front of her before. Even so, am I right that I don't deserve to be scolded by her over this ? It's my money and my stuff. So what if I occasionally make a mistake.

I'm so angry, I can't look at her.

OP posts:
HesterShaw1 · 28/10/2021 14:24

@heather2908

Saying “oh well” to a shrunken £100 jumper really smacks of first world problems and entitlement.
Or it might smack of being so pissed off with the MIL and her criticising, she wanted to minimise it.

I do similar things when my mother gets hyper critical. I minimise them and pretend it's no big deal because I don't want to give her the satisfaction.

Is it me, or has AIBU got extra vicious the last few days?

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 28/10/2021 14:24

@Sickoffamilydrama

I kind of know what you mean OP my DH has to ascertain who is criminally responsible if something gets broken. After many years I think I've managed to get him to stop. It's frustrating enough when you do something without someone then making it into a drama.

My DMiL does the same if she comes round and something has been broken which isn't often she asks and asks DH until she has all the details to ascertain who is criminally responsible as well.

I do rather angrily want to scream it's a mug the handle snapped or it got knocked it's a fucking accident not a murder! But that's probably not the most function response.

I'd find this bloody irritating... My ex mother in law would do that...

It was if she was a prowling executioner waiting for one of us (me!) to slip up then wham! To tell us off to show us how utterly hopeless we were at life as a mug got broken... Grin.

In the end i started treating it as a joke...

Either.... Yes the culprits have been summarily exécutéd and we've buried the bodies...

Or
Oh my... Shocked look... Better cancel my day so we can find the culprit... And retrieve the 99p they now owe me for the mug...

Mostly I would just shrug my shoulders and change the subject...

Drove her maaaad though... That I wasn't as fascinated /obsessed with a chipped mug/plate etc.

smoko · 28/10/2021 14:24

I was taught to only wash clothes in cold water - never once had a shrinkage or colours staining!

To be fair if MIL has seen on 2 separate occasions you shrinking wool & this was $100 you look quite silly & wasteful.

ChargingBuck · 28/10/2021 14:24

@milkyaqua

I find it hard to understand how you could "accidentally" put a man's woollen jumper in the wash. It's not a g-string. How could you not notice something that size?
That's funny, I'm finding it hard to understand how you imagine OP's laundry skillz have any relevance to the issue?
Mummyoflittledragon · 28/10/2021 14:24

All these people telling you off. Ffs. No YANBU.

Well on the plus side it’ll be too big for your baby so you can keep it for them. Wouldn’t want your hard earned money to go to waste now would we?! Wink

milkyaqua · 28/10/2021 14:22

@MadameGazellee

I don't understand why you're angry with her?
Me, neither. I'd be asking her if she had any tips for de-shrinking the jumper.
JesusIsAnyNameFree · 28/10/2021 14:22

@heather2908

Saying “oh well” to a shrunken £100 jumper really smacks of first world problems and entitlement.
Sure. But it has nothing to do with anyone but the OP and her husband.
2Two · 28/10/2021 14:22

@ShinyHappyPoster

I think if you're someone who looks after your possessions then its difficult to relate to a mindset of saying 'oh well' when you shrink a £100 jumper. DH shrunk one of my dresses once. He apologised and bought me a replacement. Did someone else buy your DH the previous jumper that you shrunk? I'm wondering if MIL thinks you're being deliberately careless.

Also, and not peculiar to this thread, but I really hate this new trend for OPs to post conversations like they're an A level drama student. I don't think it adds anything and makes everything seem artificial.

OP has already explained that she bought the jumper.
sillysmiles · 28/10/2021 14:22

At the start I thought your anger was OTT but having read all these posts for people driving home how much of a terrible person you are, I'm right there beside the person who wanted to boil wash the other posters.

2Two · 28/10/2021 14:20

Maybe because you were behaving like a child? Why do you claim it was your jumper when it clearly wasn't?

Huh, @JudgeJ? Where has OP claimed that it was her jumper? And where on earth do you get the evidence that OP was behaving like a child? At the point that her MIL came up bearing the jumper all ready to interrogate OP, there is no suggesting that OP was doing anything other than inoffensively minding her own business.

heather2908 · 28/10/2021 14:20

Saying “oh well” to a shrunken £100 jumper really smacks of first world problems and entitlement.

Yogawankonobi · 28/10/2021 14:19

Half of the people replying on here sound like they could be op’s MIL Grin

Your anger is slightly ott but I’m guessing that you have a lot more going on with her!

milkyaqua · 28/10/2021 14:17

I find it hard to understand how you could "accidentally" put a man's woollen jumper in the wash. It's not a g-string. How could you not notice something that size?

Milkshake54 · 28/10/2021 14:17
Flowers

I know how hard (some) MIL’s can be and to add on top pregnancy, hormones and HG ❤️.

Ragtag1999 · 28/10/2021 14:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

2Two · 28/10/2021 14:16

@ittakes2

I think you are blowing this up out of proportion. She is not scolding you like a child she is trying to explain to you what you need to do differently with wool. If this is the 2nd time its happened she prob assumes you don't know - not everyone does. I think if she is older too she might not be as aware as your generation that she needs to check her tone when speaking to adults. I am guessing she speaks to others like this too - unless you are telling us its just you than this is a different story.
Why on earth would she assume that, given that OP acknowledged that she'd accidentally let the jumper get in with the wrong wash? It's not like OP was standing there gormlessly wondering how on earth the thing had got shrunk, she had demonstrated that she knew why and she also knew what she should have done to avoid it.

And please pack in the casual ageism. Older people are just as capable as younger ones of knowing how to check their tone.

EnidFrighten · 28/10/2021 14:15

Incidentally, you can make lots of things from felted jumpers. Make MIL a nice hot water bottle cover out of it for Christmas!

AmDillDandin · 28/10/2021 14:14

@Ragtag1999

Christ.. sorry masterbating
Too try hard. Name change and have another go, but with less ... desperation
2Two · 28/10/2021 14:14

@HeartsAndClubs

Absolutely none of MIL's business though if in future your child’s partner were to ruin something expensive of theirs and then just shrug it off with a “oh well,” wouldn’t you as their mother, be concerned about what kind of relationship it was?
Nope. Especially when my child didn't pay for the item in question. I hope I would have the sense to work out that accidents happen and no-one's perfect.
Ragtag1999 · 28/10/2021 14:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

2Two · 28/10/2021 14:13

@HeartsAndClubs

I can just imagine if a woman posted here that her DH/mil/other person had washed her £100 jumper and ruined it and then said “oh well.”

While maybe your mil shouldn’t have said anything, it’s a bit of a casual attitude to have towards ruining something which isn’t even yours, even if you did pay for it.

If my partner ruined something of mine like that I would be fuming. And if he brushed it off like that I would potentially be rethinking the relationship, on the assumption this probably wasn’t the first time.

Your “oh well,” attitude clearly shows you have little respect for your DH and his stuff, to the point that you ruined something of his and then just shrugged it off.

As his mother it might be that she sees this.

But do you not get the point that OP wasn't saying "Oh well" to her husband? She wasn't brushing him off. She was saying it to someone who had chosen to stick her nose in where it had absolutely no business to be. Given the background circumstances, MIL is pretty lucky she wasn't told to fuck right off.
Ragtag1999 · 28/10/2021 14:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

User527294627 · 28/10/2021 14:12

I think she was rude, but I don’t think it warrants you being so angry. Clearly though there is a big backstory so I expect this is a cumulative effect issue!

Glad you’re getting away soon. It’s shit being pregnant and ill and not in your own home.

iwannascream · 28/10/2021 14:11

I'd have been tempted to tell her you had shrunk it on purpose to fit the baby Grin

2Two · 28/10/2021 14:09

@Hothammock

I'm not sure why you think it's unreasonable for someone to point out you need to take more care when sorting your laundry but you don't see it's unreasonable to say oh well about shrinking a £100 wool jumper... If you care so little for possessions why not donate their value to food banks instead of your careless laundry practices. Your reaction is totally disproportionate.
Why does anyone have to point out to OP that she needs to take care when sorting? Does anyone seriously think she couldn't work that out without her MIL explaining it to her? Would you seriously take it on yourself to make a fuss with a relative about an accident with their own possessions?

And equally there is absolutely nothing unreasonable about saying "Oh well" when talking to someone about something that is none of their business. Had it been MIL's jumper or one she'd given to her son, yes, something more might have been required, but OP really doesn't have to abase herself about a simple accident which has harmed no-one but herself and her husband.