Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU re. Christmas and family visits?

460 replies

minervas1 · 28/10/2021 12:22

Just trying to sense check if I'm being U or if DH is...

Last Christmas we spent just us two (no kids yet!) and it was lovely, we had a perfect time. It had always been the plan to spend it like that after years of traipsing around between two families (usually 24th-26th with one, and then 27th-30th with another), but obviously Covid rules meant we couldn't visit anyone in the run up to Christmas or around NY as had been the plan.

This year I had presumed we would spend Xmas Eve, Day and Boxing Day alone but visit families before and after. I expressed this to DH, asking whether he wanted to see his Mum+Dad before or after Xmas, and he said he didn't want to do any of that. He said he didn't want to drive around on his annual leave and be guests in other people's houses, and just wanted to relax like last year. We both got a bit irritated with each other, and he eventually said he would do one trip if necessary to my Mum and Dad, but he was only going to do one. I think this is really cruel to his family who we're really close to, and I don't want to miss seeing mine in the festive season either.

Now, here's where I may be being Unreasonable... I don't drive. I can't drive, never had any interest in learning (not medical or trauma related or anything, just have never had to). Our families live quite far from us, so visiting does involve 4 hours of driving, although not difficult driving and mostly on motorway. DH says he finds that exhausting and it makes him tired for Christmas when he is "on holiday", and that travel days eat into festive time. He is happy to see family earlier in December and then just hunker down for the christmas period itself.

I don't know if he's just being a lazy dick here or not, tbh? Is it unreasonable to expect him to do the driving so we can make family happy and have some nice visits, especially as I already feel we're being a bit selfish by having Christmas just us two? Or is he fair enough? Is there a compromise here?

OP posts:
thing47 · 28/10/2021 15:36

Not driving = perfectly reasonable
Not driving but expecting someone else to ferry you wherever and whenever you want to go or they're a 'lazy dick' = totally unreasonable

HTH

LaetitiaASD · 28/10/2021 15:35

@Ohwhatfunwehad

Non drivers have no idea how annoying it is for drivers to play taxi.

Get the train, learn to drive and listen to your DH. This will only become more problematic if you have children

Yeah but non-drivers are environmental saints - they never buy petrol unlike those disgusting, petrol buying, climate changing drivers that ferry them around!
thing47 · 28/10/2021 15:29

I think you've made up a whole back story that doesn't exist actually

This. Julieca is clearly projecting some (unresolved?) issues in her own life as her posts bear no resemblance to those being raised in this thread.

For those of you who are hard of reading, the DH is quite happy to take OP to see her own family; it is his family they won't be seeing. Not quite sure what aspect of his behaviour is in any way unreasonable.

AryaStarkWolf · 28/10/2021 15:27

And someone driving thier spouse on a journey they are both taking anyway is not doing them a favour

It is a favour if the driver didn't actually want to go in the first place!

julieca · 28/10/2021 15:26

@MalagaNights I agree. I am convinced on any MN thread you only have to put the sentence - I cant drive - for most people to tell you you are wrong, whatever the situation.

RampantIvy · 28/10/2021 15:26

I think possibly he is feeling incredibly drained after this year,

Probably due to all the driving he has to do Grin

It depends on where you live on how difficult and tiring you find driving. M25, M6 round Birmingham, M62 - no thanks.

Semi rural Yorkshire where I live is fine most of the time.

Some people enjoy driving. Some people (DH) loathe it. I neither like nor dislike driving. It is just something I have to do.

DampSquidGames · 28/10/2021 15:25

Why can’t you take the train or coach to visit your parents?

MalagaNights · 28/10/2021 15:24

God this thread is weird.
It's like the crowd smelled the blood with 'you don't drive' and are revelling in the frenzy of beating you to a pulp with this.

It's like driving is some special greulling challenge, whihc you can never possibly understand.

A 4 hour journey is tiring whether you're the passenger or the driver.

The question is really whether you want to make the trip.

It's evidently not about the driving as everyone is gleefully seizing on, as he also won't get the train and doesn't want people to stay.

The issue is: he wants a quiet realxing Christmas, you want to see both families.

You both need to work out how you are going to organise your time over Christmas so there isn't resentment either way and so you don't need to have this row every year.

And you don't need to drive just so you can share the drive at Christmas. Ignore the frothing.

And someone driving thier spouse on a journey they are both taking anyway is not doing them a favour Grin!

julieca · 28/10/2021 15:24

Of course she wants him to contribute to housework aka getting the house ready.

bluebeck · 28/10/2021 15:24

YABU

I think you should just get the train to see your family on your own.

Hillary17 · 28/10/2021 15:24

I can’t drive and we honestly have this every year. We now flip it - so we host everyone at a bit of a nibbles and drinks event on Boxing Day. Then we still family but husband doesn’t moan none stop about the drive. Sorry! I’m convinced we’ll argue about this until our death beds.

EssexLioness · 28/10/2021 15:22

I think you are being unreasonable here OP, but maybe because you just haven’t considered his point of view before. 4 hours driving is exhausting and I am a confident driver. I have family over 4 hours away, mostly motorway driving and it is a real chore tbh. Motorway driving is actually more draining in my view, which you may not realise as a non driver: it is boring and monotonous and requires a lot of concentration to avoid your mind wandering. All of this is worse in grey, miserable weather and things like torrential rain are stressful as your visibility is so poor and there are a lot of idiots on the road. It can also be potentially deadly, and I have seen so many near misses (often involving HGVs).
I think he is being very fair to offer to drive to your family, and his family plans aren’t your business to worry about. Leave that up to him.
Also you say you don’t want to get the house ready on your own, yet he doesn’t want the guests so I think that’s fair. You accuse him of being lazy because he doesn’t want to do all that driving yet it is much easier and quicker for you to get the house guest ready (unless you live in a huge mansion), so by your logic then it is you that is being the lazy one.

AryaStarkWolf · 28/10/2021 15:21

@julieca

She said she wasnt bothered. Women commonly do this when resources are scarce and let the man gain the skills.
These are her words :

I don't drive. I can't drive, never had any interest in learning (not medical or trauma related or anything, just have never had to).

icedcoffees · 28/10/2021 15:19

He's said he take her, just isn't prepared to visit both families. I think he's been fair offering to take her to her parents. OP asks if there is a compromise but he's already offered the compromise but that isn't enough.

Exactly, which makes OP seem even more irrational to me, lol.

AryaStarkWolf · 28/10/2021 15:19

@julieca

She said she wasnt bothered. Women commonly do this when resources are scarce and let the man gain the skills.
I think you've made up a whole back story that doesn't exist actually
Goblina · 28/10/2021 15:17

@Morgan12

I do think he is being rather selfish actually.

He won't drive (fair enough).
He won't compromise and get a train.
He won't allow any visitors.

Seems like he's doing what he wants and you've to like it or lump it.

I'd leave him all alone and go spend Christmas with my family.

He has compromised by suggesting doing the visit earlier in December. Just not Christmas week.
julieca · 28/10/2021 15:15

She said she wasnt bothered. Women commonly do this when resources are scarce and let the man gain the skills.

DampSquidGames · 28/10/2021 15:15

I think your DH is being very reasonable, he said he would like a quiet Christmas and has offered to drive you to see your parents.

verymiddleaged · 28/10/2021 15:15

I’m just as entitled to want to use the car, within reason.

OP you are perfectly entitled to use the car but as you haven't learned how to drive unless you hire a chauffeur you can't.

To be able to use the car you need to be able to get behind the wheel and drive it.
Learning to do this if you are ever thinking of having dc would be best done sooner rather than later.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 28/10/2021 15:14

@minervas1

I think what is so frustrating is he doesn’t control when my family visit at any other time - we actually just had my Mum down to stay with us for a mini-holiday, and his siblings often visit. He’s just got it into his head that it would be really hard work to have anyone over the Christmas holiday, whereas I would have multiple visits from both sides of our family happily.

I think possibly he is feeling incredibly drained after this year, which I do understand, it’s just annoying for me. Maybe I need to think more about the reasons he is saying this to me rather than just that it’s upsetting.

I think you may have hit on something in your first post about how nice a quiet Christmas was for him (and loads of others) last year. I'm dreading 3 day trips in 4 days this year if we go back to normal. Utterly exhausting and sometimes unfair on younger ones I think as they don't always get chance to enjoy gifts fully until they get home.

Also given he's generally happy for your mum to come I think it's fine to want some time as just a couple over Christmas.

(I think everyone else has covered the driving bit of this!)

AryaStarkWolf · 28/10/2021 15:12

[quote julieca]@Thatsnotall no the couple where the man gets prioritised for any money on learning to increase his skills, but then controls both when he uses them, and his partners family coming to stay.
It is very common if money is limited for it to be spent on the mans skills rather than the woman.[/quote]
The OP has said herself she has no interest in learning to drive though

anon12345678901 · 28/10/2021 15:11

@knightsinwhitesatin

I am surprised so many people think driving is such a hardship, especially when it’s to do a nice thing like see family over holidays. I do nearly all the driving in our household and I don’t mind it, I look forward to the drive up to see family for Christmas, get the radio on, snacks in the car and a KFC pit stop! I don’t think you’re being unfair OP, but I guess if your DH really doesn’t like driving then fair enough. But it’s still nice to see family at Christmas, in my opinion, so maybe the train with a tin of gin is a compromise. Good luck!
I enjoy driving, but I do it every day and have driven for over 20 years now. It looses its appeal, especially longer journeys. Sometimes it's nice to not drive or be driven. OP maybe it's time you started lessons for yourself?
ineedaholidayandwine · 28/10/2021 15:11

He's fair enough in this one, i don't drive either, same as you just never had to, don't want to.
I'd never expect my husband to drive me to my family, i know he finds long drives exhausting so if he says he's not up for it either I'll get the train or they come to us.

fitsandgiggles · 28/10/2021 15:11

Unreasonable. There's nothing worse than using your free time to chauffeur people around. And 4 hours driving will be tiring. It's not like when you are passenger and can relax, have a look on your phone etc. Why not get the train or see if family can visit you?

AryaStarkWolf · 28/10/2021 15:10

He's prepared to do one visit so why don't you get public transport to visit your family and then see his family with him or send him by himself if you fancy a quite day.

Send him by himself to go visiting when he doesn't even want to go? wtf?