Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU re. Christmas and family visits?

460 replies

minervas1 · 28/10/2021 12:22

Just trying to sense check if I'm being U or if DH is...

Last Christmas we spent just us two (no kids yet!) and it was lovely, we had a perfect time. It had always been the plan to spend it like that after years of traipsing around between two families (usually 24th-26th with one, and then 27th-30th with another), but obviously Covid rules meant we couldn't visit anyone in the run up to Christmas or around NY as had been the plan.

This year I had presumed we would spend Xmas Eve, Day and Boxing Day alone but visit families before and after. I expressed this to DH, asking whether he wanted to see his Mum+Dad before or after Xmas, and he said he didn't want to do any of that. He said he didn't want to drive around on his annual leave and be guests in other people's houses, and just wanted to relax like last year. We both got a bit irritated with each other, and he eventually said he would do one trip if necessary to my Mum and Dad, but he was only going to do one. I think this is really cruel to his family who we're really close to, and I don't want to miss seeing mine in the festive season either.

Now, here's where I may be being Unreasonable... I don't drive. I can't drive, never had any interest in learning (not medical or trauma related or anything, just have never had to). Our families live quite far from us, so visiting does involve 4 hours of driving, although not difficult driving and mostly on motorway. DH says he finds that exhausting and it makes him tired for Christmas when he is "on holiday", and that travel days eat into festive time. He is happy to see family earlier in December and then just hunker down for the christmas period itself.

I don't know if he's just being a lazy dick here or not, tbh? Is it unreasonable to expect him to do the driving so we can make family happy and have some nice visits, especially as I already feel we're being a bit selfish by having Christmas just us two? Or is he fair enough? Is there a compromise here?

OP posts:
minervas1 · 28/10/2021 14:09

I think what is so frustrating is he doesn’t control when my family visit at any other time - we actually just had my Mum down to stay with us for a mini-holiday, and his siblings often visit. He’s just got it into his head that it would be really hard work to have anyone over the Christmas holiday, whereas I would have multiple visits from both sides of our family happily.

I think possibly he is feeling incredibly drained after this year, which I do understand, it’s just annoying for me. Maybe I need to think more about the reasons he is saying this to me rather than just that it’s upsetting.

OP posts:
thing47 · 28/10/2021 14:09

You may ^want* to use the car OP, but as you're not qualified to do so, you can't. Not sure what you don't understand about that. Non-drivers don't get a say in how often or for how long a driver has to drive.

Your second point is, however, a valid one. The obvious compromise here is that people visit you, and in that you do get a say because you live in a joint property.

julieca · 28/10/2021 14:08

OP prioritise budget for you learning to drive. Your DP is being controlling. You need the independence.

InTheNightWeWillWish · 28/10/2021 14:07

[quote julieca]@Whatiswrongwithmyknee I am not looking down on anyone. But if an OP posted saying her DP finds it exhausting to hoover the whole house - that might be true, but it is really not a reason to say he shouldn't then hoover.[/quote]
I would find hoovering the whole house exhausting at the minute because I’m pregnant. The difference is I can hoover downstairs and say to DH that I’m tired and ask if he can take over and do upstairs. I can also do some rooms and leave some for later in the day or even the next day. Once I start hoovering I don’t have to hoover the whole house in one go, it would be ideal because then it’s done but its an activity that can be stopped part way through.

OP’s DH can’t say he’s tired and stop at a service station and ask her to take over because she can’t drive. No matter how bad the roads are, how bad the weather is, if he has a migraine or his back is hurting, they can’t swap drivers. They can’t just wait at the service station until the next day. Once he starts driving he needs to keep driving until he reaches the destination.

I would regularly drive 3 hours one way weekly for work (thankfully Covid stopped that). This isn’t that I’m a nervous driver or can’t drive long distances or on motorways. For such an experienced driver, surely you just realise that certain motorways are better than others? M25 90% of the time is a shit hole. M6 around Birmingham is usually much worse than the M6 around Preston.

Nocutenamesleft · 28/10/2021 14:07

@minervas1

So I take on board a lot of what everyone is saying and obviously everyone thinks I’m in the wrong so fine, I will quietly think it’s unfair rather than continuing to complain to him, but I would like to point out two things.
  1. My DH couldn’t drive when we met. When we first left university neither of us could afford it, and then a few years after that he really wanted to learn so we could stop taking the train and we knew it would massively enhance our quality of life. We both paid for him to learn, the car was given to us by my Mum (her old car), we both pay for the upkeep and costs associated. He doesn’t drive for himself, he drives for our household, in the same way when I put on washing I do it for both of us. I think it’s super weird that everyone thinks I’m getting “lifts” everywhere - he may physically do the driving but I’m just as entitled to want to use the car, within reason. He’s not my Dad giving me a lift to the cinema to meet up with my mates for gods sake.
  1. I’m surprised so many people think it’s ok to tell your spouse they can’t have guests at Christmas. I wonder how many of you would like it if your husband said that?
You’re not driving. The car belongs to a household. But your husband isn’t your slave is he? He is by all means allowed to say. No I don’t want to drive. Xmas is known for how hard it is and so busy. Which requires a lot more concentration. Motorway driving then adds to that on TOP.

You’re being so unreasonable!

ancientgran · 28/10/2021 14:07

[quote julieca]@ancientgran except she isnt leaching lifts as you so delightfully put it.[/quote]
I was actually agreeing with the poster I quoted when she commented on the audacity of someone who can't be bothered to learn to drive calling someone a lazy dick. Calling someone a lazy dick is delightful, did you comment on that?

MargosKaftan · 28/10/2021 14:06

Gosh it says something that as a household you needed one driver, so even though the car would be a gift from your mum, as a couple it would be him that got the budget for lessons and acquired a skill that is useful for many jobs and gives him control over where you go and when.

If he doesn't drive regularly, then driving 2 hours will be tiring. It would be better long term if you could share that or in cases like this where only you want to go, he can duck out. If he's less sociable than you, this could be an ongoing issue.

I couldn't live with a man who would refuse to have my family visit at all. And controlled when I could go see them. You have been together since Uni, so have you spent the bulk of your adult life with him? Think about if this is actually how you want to live.

Viviennemary · 28/10/2021 14:05

If he doesnt want to drive then you either go by public transport or stay at home. I don't think he should be obliged to ferry you around if he would rather stay at home.

DaisyNGO · 28/10/2021 14:04

OP "I think it’s super weird that everyone thinks I’m getting “lifts” everywhere - he may physically do the driving but I’m just as entitled to want to use the car, within reason"

Not a valid comparison

If DH does your laundry, he can use the machine to do it.

In this case, you can't use the machine. And it sounds like you have no idea why it might be hard work.

Jointly paying for the item doesn't mean you can demand someone else's labour.

StCharlotte · 28/10/2021 14:04

Perhaps this is your DH's way of getting you to learn to drive...

And yes YABU.

Nocutenamesleft · 28/10/2021 14:03

Ooh. Motorway driving. In winter

4 hrs. Is completely exhausting!

userxx · 28/10/2021 14:03

He doesn’t drive for himself, he drives for our household

So chauffeuring is one of his "jobs" ?

Still think you should learn to drive. I'd hate to rely on someone to drive me places.

ancientgran · 28/10/2021 14:01

@minervas1

So I take on board a lot of what everyone is saying and obviously everyone thinks I’m in the wrong so fine, I will quietly think it’s unfair rather than continuing to complain to him, but I would like to point out two things.
  1. My DH couldn’t drive when we met. When we first left university neither of us could afford it, and then a few years after that he really wanted to learn so we could stop taking the train and we knew it would massively enhance our quality of life. We both paid for him to learn, the car was given to us by my Mum (her old car), we both pay for the upkeep and costs associated. He doesn’t drive for himself, he drives for our household, in the same way when I put on washing I do it for both of us. I think it’s super weird that everyone thinks I’m getting “lifts” everywhere - he may physically do the driving but I’m just as entitled to want to use the car, within reason. He’s not my Dad giving me a lift to the cinema to meet up with my mates for gods sake.
  1. I’m surprised so many people think it’s ok to tell your spouse they can’t have guests at Christmas. I wonder how many of you would like it if your husband said that?
So you're not getting a lift? Is he your chauffeur or something. You can't just demand that people do things. Driving isn't relaxing, maybe have some lessons and find out.
Thatsnotall · 28/10/2021 14:01

@episcomama

And it's a four-hour round trip? I thought you meant 4 hours each way? So two hours each way is enough to induce an attack if the vapours in your DH? Fuck me, unless he has ME or CFS I'd wonder what was wrong with him.
Give over. Everyone is different. Driving IS tiring in different ways for different people (hence the ‘take breaks’ campaigns) - just because it doesn’t ‘give you the vapours’ Hmm (which, incidentally, OP hasn’t stated it does her DH either, but it’s an interesting non-sequitur) doesn’t mean it isn’t the case for others.
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 28/10/2021 14:01

I think it’s super weird that everyone thinks I’m getting “lifts” everywhere - he may physically do the driving but I’m just as entitled to want to use the car, within reason.

Yes but I think people are saying this is not within reason.

I’m surprised so many people think it’s ok to tell your spouse they can’t have guests at Christmas. I wonder how many of you would like it if your husband said that?

I wouldn't at all. I may have misread it though, but it sounded like your OH was expressing his preference rather than thinking he had a right to put his foot down and veto this possibility?

julieca · 28/10/2021 14:00

@ancientgran except she isnt leaching lifts as you so delightfully put it.

Outnumbered99 · 28/10/2021 14:00

With your drip feeds im more on the fence. is there a rift with his family that you don't know about? Is there something wrong with his health mental or physical, that he doesn't want them to see? Something doesn't sound right here and its about more than driving.

Ditto other posters- get driving lessons for Christmas! (I say that as the only driver in my household too).

ancientgran · 28/10/2021 14:00

@1FootInTheRave

I can't believe you have the audacity to call him a lazy dick.

You're the lazy one who never learned to drive.

Stop leeching lifts and sort yourself out.

I was going to say the same. The bloody cheek of her.
julieca · 28/10/2021 13:59

@ImUninsultable MN is crawling with MRAs. So I am not surprised.

ImUninsultable · 28/10/2021 13:58

Learn to drive. That is a lot of driving and it is tiring. Help him out.

Flipflopblowout · 28/10/2021 13:58

2 hours there and 2 hours back is a breeze, don't understand the problem other than he doesn't want to go. The solutions for next year have already been highlighted.

minervas1 · 28/10/2021 13:56

So I take on board a lot of what everyone is saying and obviously everyone thinks I’m in the wrong so fine, I will quietly think it’s unfair rather than continuing to complain to him, but I would like to point out two things.

  1. My DH couldn’t drive when we met. When we first left university neither of us could afford it, and then a few years after that he really wanted to learn so we could stop taking the train and we knew it would massively enhance our quality of life. We both paid for him to learn, the car was given to us by my Mum (her old car), we both pay for the upkeep and costs associated. He doesn’t drive for himself, he drives for our household, in the same way when I put on washing I do it for both of us. I think it’s super weird that everyone thinks I’m getting “lifts” everywhere - he may physically do the driving but I’m just as entitled to want to use the car, within reason. He’s not my Dad giving me a lift to the cinema to meet up with my mates for gods sake.
  1. I’m surprised so many people think it’s ok to tell your spouse they can’t have guests at Christmas. I wonder how many of you would like it if your husband said that?
OP posts:
CheddarGorgeous · 28/10/2021 13:56

Neither of you are unreasonable. You want to spend Christmas with family. He wants to spend it alone. He's at least compromising and saying he'll do one trip.

Are you incompatible in other ways?

Also, learn to drive. It's much fairer on your husband.

LookItsMeAgain · 28/10/2021 13:55

My advice is to not visit family and extend an invite to them for them to visit you. They don't have to stay with you, if there is an AirBnB nearby for example and your DH is precious about sharing or welcoming family into your (as in yours and his) home.

The compromise here is that it's time for you to learn to drive. Whether you want to or think you don't need to learn, it's a life skill and will help in the future. Then at Christmas you can share the driving to and from relatives and he may be more amenable to doing the visiting.

Bookworm20 · 28/10/2021 13:55

I don't drive. I can't drive, never had any interest in learning

Why not? So other people can drive you around everywhere and then you moan about them being lazy? Bloody hell. That is the most entitled thing I've read today.

Sorry but YABVU. I'm with your DH on this. How about you get yourself bothered to learn to drive and then you can do that easy 4 hour drive in winter and then he can't moan about visiting family can he?

And as for getting the house ready for guests 'on your own'? Do you live in a mansion or something? Its really not that hard!

Do you always expect other people to do everything for you?