Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU re. Christmas and family visits?

460 replies

minervas1 · 28/10/2021 12:22

Just trying to sense check if I'm being U or if DH is...

Last Christmas we spent just us two (no kids yet!) and it was lovely, we had a perfect time. It had always been the plan to spend it like that after years of traipsing around between two families (usually 24th-26th with one, and then 27th-30th with another), but obviously Covid rules meant we couldn't visit anyone in the run up to Christmas or around NY as had been the plan.

This year I had presumed we would spend Xmas Eve, Day and Boxing Day alone but visit families before and after. I expressed this to DH, asking whether he wanted to see his Mum+Dad before or after Xmas, and he said he didn't want to do any of that. He said he didn't want to drive around on his annual leave and be guests in other people's houses, and just wanted to relax like last year. We both got a bit irritated with each other, and he eventually said he would do one trip if necessary to my Mum and Dad, but he was only going to do one. I think this is really cruel to his family who we're really close to, and I don't want to miss seeing mine in the festive season either.

Now, here's where I may be being Unreasonable... I don't drive. I can't drive, never had any interest in learning (not medical or trauma related or anything, just have never had to). Our families live quite far from us, so visiting does involve 4 hours of driving, although not difficult driving and mostly on motorway. DH says he finds that exhausting and it makes him tired for Christmas when he is "on holiday", and that travel days eat into festive time. He is happy to see family earlier in December and then just hunker down for the christmas period itself.

I don't know if he's just being a lazy dick here or not, tbh? Is it unreasonable to expect him to do the driving so we can make family happy and have some nice visits, especially as I already feel we're being a bit selfish by having Christmas just us two? Or is he fair enough? Is there a compromise here?

OP posts:
CSJobseeker · 28/10/2021 14:27

@Bargoed

Honestly you don't drive and have no empathy just how bloody exhausting it is!
This.

*so visiting does involve 4 hours of driving, although not difficult driving and mostly on motorway"

As a non-driver, you are in no position whatsoever to comment on the relative difficulty of a driving journey, and 4 hours is a lot of driving so will be tiring no matter kind of roads it's on.

Your options are:

  • learn to drive
  • get some form of public transport
  • persuade your family to visit you instead

But you can't expect your DH to facilitate your wish to take long journeys when you don't contribute to the driving at all.

MeredithGreyishblue · 28/10/2021 14:25

He doesn't have to be sitting next to you while you do the laundry though!

You're both entitled to a Christmas you're happy with. Find a compromise or a good public transport link.

ImUninsultable · 28/10/2021 14:25

@AryaStarkWolf

She wants guests over christmas but she doesnt want to do the work of organising the house for it.

Sounds like she wants him to do hosting work if they visit or for him to do 16 hours of driving over the holiday so she can go on visits that he doesnt want to do.

It sounds a little like he has reached the end if his tether and is exhausted and just wants a break.

OP should absolutely be allowed to invite her family over. As long as he keeps the place as clean as he would usually do then that's fine. But she sounds like she wants more than that.

StormyTeacups · 28/10/2021 14:25

He sounds quite intransigent.

But, it is his family that is missing out I guess. And no, him telling you that you can't have guests is not on

InTheNightWeWillWish · 28/10/2021 14:24

@minervas1

So I take on board a lot of what everyone is saying and obviously everyone thinks I’m in the wrong so fine, I will quietly think it’s unfair rather than continuing to complain to him, but I would like to point out two things.
  1. My DH couldn’t drive when we met. When we first left university neither of us could afford it, and then a few years after that he really wanted to learn so we could stop taking the train and we knew it would massively enhance our quality of life. We both paid for him to learn, the car was given to us by my Mum (her old car), we both pay for the upkeep and costs associated. He doesn’t drive for himself, he drives for our household, in the same way when I put on washing I do it for both of us. I think it’s super weird that everyone thinks I’m getting “lifts” everywhere - he may physically do the driving but I’m just as entitled to want to use the car, within reason. He’s not my Dad giving me a lift to the cinema to meet up with my mates for gods sake.
  1. I’m surprised so many people think it’s ok to tell your spouse they can’t have guests at Christmas. I wonder how many of you would like it if your husband said that?
1) my DH couldn’t drive when we met either and he learnt shortly after we graduated. ‘Our’ first car was my car. I bought it, I insured it. We paid for the maintenance on it and he gave me some money towards his share of the insurance. DH would still give me a lift to the train station in the morning. It was in my car that I bought but he still gave me a lift. Now partly this was because he was wanting to drive himself to work later (I caught the first train) but he was still giving me a lift. It gave me 5 extra minutes in the morning because I didn’t need to defrost the car. It meant I could eat my breakfast on the way to the station rather than driving. We still share a car now and jointly contribute to costs. If he wants the car when I have plans, he has to give me a lift. He has to organise his plans around where I want to be. Or vice versa. I don’t need him to give me a lift to meet my friends. You do. You have to make sure he’s free to drive you or to ask your friends to pick you up. If you’re meeting your friends for dinner and the cinema, how is it any different than your dad driving you there? Other than you’re contributing to the cost of the maintenance of the car which you weren’t doing at 15.
  1. we ask each other before we have guests to our house. There is a compromise usually in that we would manage how long someone stays. It doesn’t sound like you’re open to compromise though, so maybe a hard no is the only option? We’ve also had one of his friends outstay his welcome (technically his ex gf) over the Christmas period. I told DH when they finally left that they weren’t coming over again. Fortunately he agreed. I’m expecting our first child and expecting to be inundated with visitors in early December. We are agreeing the boundaries between us and realise there’s compromise needed on both sides - me how long I spend with his parents and him how long he spends with mine. That’s a discussion to be had between you. Neither of us live near family either, so yes that compromise takes into account how far they’ve travelled to see us. If he’s never allowing visitors, that’s a different story but he’s saying he doesn’t want to endlessly host over Christmas. He’s not saying they can’t turn up at other times. Neither of us would agree to endlessly host family over Christmas as it’s a time for us to relax.
DaisyNGO · 28/10/2021 14:24

[quote julieca]@InTheNightWeWillWish if Driving is really so bloody exhausting for him, just stop for a coffee.
I think OP was wrong to use income for DP to learn to drive. Because this kind of control by men is so common.[/quote]
I'd hate to do 4 hours WITH a coffee break. I didn't really think OP was suggesting 4 hours non stop.

The money she paid benefits her as he mostly drives her. She says she doesn't want to drive.

Driving a long way with someone who can't drive is a pain, if anything goes wrong, they can't help out. Especially in winter when you might suddenly get a bug...dare I say, even more likely at the mo.

TrickOrTreat21x · 28/10/2021 14:23

Your being the lazy dick not learning to drive and expecting to be driven around. YABU.

RampantIvy · 28/10/2021 14:23

@episcomama

And it's a four-hour round trip? I thought you meant 4 hours each way? So two hours each way is enough to induce an attack if the vapours in your DH? Fuck me, unless he has ME or CFS I'd wonder what was wrong with him.
Or maybe he just doesn't want to?
starfishmummy · 28/10/2021 14:22

Learn to drive and then come back and say 4 hours on a motorway is "not difficult driving"

tiggerwhocamefortea · 28/10/2021 14:22

although not difficult driving and mostly on motorway.

Well you wouldn't know would you....since you don't drive

don't know if he's just being a lazy dick here or not, tbh?

Well One of you is the lazy dick but it isn't your husband in this scenario

NailsNeedDoing · 28/10/2021 14:21

I will quietly think it’s unfair rather than continuing to complain to him

Which bit do you think is unfair? From what you have said, it seems perfectly fair, so I’m genuinely asking.

You want to make two trips, he wants to make none, so the compromise is that you do one trip. That way you both get half of what you want and half of what you don’t want. How is it unfair?

friendlycat · 28/10/2021 14:21

Your last comment is crazy sorry. It’s far easier to put clothes in the washing machine and press a button than it is to drive 4 hours on an “easy” motorway!

People who don’t drive always think it’s easy and usually are unrealistic just as you are. I loved the thread about a non driver previously saying that “it’s only drivers getting panicked about the petrol crisis and you don’t find non drivers getting themselves riled”. Eer no that’s because they don’t drive and need petrol!

He’s offered various solutions ie one visit over Christmas and another in the run up early December. Seems a good solution so that everyone is happy. But you don’t seem keen.

LittleMysSister · 28/10/2021 14:21

@minervas1

So I take on board a lot of what everyone is saying and obviously everyone thinks I’m in the wrong so fine, I will quietly think it’s unfair rather than continuing to complain to him, but I would like to point out two things.
  1. My DH couldn’t drive when we met. When we first left university neither of us could afford it, and then a few years after that he really wanted to learn so we could stop taking the train and we knew it would massively enhance our quality of life. We both paid for him to learn, the car was given to us by my Mum (her old car), we both pay for the upkeep and costs associated. He doesn’t drive for himself, he drives for our household, in the same way when I put on washing I do it for both of us. I think it’s super weird that everyone thinks I’m getting “lifts” everywhere - he may physically do the driving but I’m just as entitled to want to use the car, within reason. He’s not my Dad giving me a lift to the cinema to meet up with my mates for gods sake.
  1. I’m surprised so many people think it’s ok to tell your spouse they can’t have guests at Christmas. I wonder how many of you would like it if your husband said that?
I don't think it's OK for him to tell you you can't have guests at Christmas but I read your post saying you wouldn't invite people over when you know he doesn't want them there, so I guess there isn't much you can do about that?

Quite honestly if my DP told me I couldn't have my family over for Christmas I'd go to them without him on the train, in your shoes.

I don't agree with you about driving though, it's not really the same as doing the laundry, which you could both do if needed. And ultimately you might not be in this position if you drove as maybe he wouldn't feel so rubbish about having to drive so much over Christmas and you would also have the capability of driving yourself, even if he doesn't join.

I'd have a chat with him and see whether if you were able to share the drive would he be more willing to travel over Christmas. If yes, that's maybe something you can do next year.

thing47 · 28/10/2021 14:20

She could go and sit in it for 4 hrs, she's entitled to

Grin
mbosnz · 28/10/2021 14:19

You're fully entitled to use the car. So, go drive yourself. Oh. Wait. . .

He's open to family visits at other times, he's feeling bloody knackered, clearly and really doesn't want to host, or be hosted. If you don't like that, you can leave him to it, travel by public transport (or drive yourself, you are after all, fully entitled to use the car), and go and have family Christmas with your family or your inlaws. I do seem to remember that one of your objections to hosting was that you'd have to do all the grunt work for that. But you're the one that wants it. . .

AryaStarkWolf · 28/10/2021 14:18

Even though I definitely think you're BU, I don't think you're BU about having people visit over Christmas, it's your home too and he needs to compromise with you there i think

LookItsMeAgain · 28/10/2021 14:16

The thing is though @minervas1 - he learned how to drive and you still haven't. All the rest is smoke and mirrors.
Stop quietly thinking it's unfair - it isn't.
Stop continuing to complain to him - he doesn't deserve this.

You are being unreasonable.

As for not wanting people to stay in your house, I can respect that. I would see that in a similar light as not wanting family or friends to join you on your holidays.

Artie30 · 28/10/2021 14:14

I don't blame your partner tbh. Driving around visiting family at Christmas is tiring and time consuming IMO. He sounds like he just wants to chill out on his time off and last year covid was the eye opener for that!

ancientgran · 28/10/2021 14:12

@thing47

You may ^want* to use the car OP, but as you're not qualified to do so, you can't. Not sure what you don't understand about that. Non-drivers don't get a say in how often or for how long a driver has to drive.

Your second point is, however, a valid one. The obvious compromise here is that people visit you, and in that you do get a say because you live in a joint property.

She could go and sit in it for 4 hrs, she's entitled to. Of course she isn't entitled to say he has to drive it while she's sat there calling other people lazy dicks.
Goblina · 28/10/2021 14:12

Are you planning to learn to drive op?

LadyTiredWinterBottom2 · 28/10/2021 14:12

Yeah we never visit anyone over Christmas. I prefer to drink and my lovely DH doesn't want to spend his time driving. So they can come to us or not see us. I am sure there will be pearl clutching over this and accusations of selfishness but we are comfortable with our decision.

julieca · 28/10/2021 14:11

@LittleDandelionClock Grin

LittleDandelionClock · 28/10/2021 14:10

@julieca

The only thing I don't like is driving rain and thick patches of fog. Apart from that I don't care. Traffic jams - put music on and sing along.
Whoop de do for you. Hmm
julieca · 28/10/2021 14:10

@InTheNightWeWillWish if Driving is really so bloody exhausting for him, just stop for a coffee.
I think OP was wrong to use income for DP to learn to drive. Because this kind of control by men is so common.

Temple29 · 28/10/2021 14:09

“I think it’s super weird that everyone thinks I’m getting “lifts” everywhere - he may physically do the driving but I’m just as entitled to want to use the car, within reason.”

Not true at all. If you used the car without him in it you would just be sitting in the driveway.

I agree with others that you should learn to drive but to answer your question YABU. He has suggested visiting everyone earlier in December, I would do that. And if you still want to visit your own family closer to actual Christmas then make your own way there.

Swipe left for the next trending thread