Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU re. Christmas and family visits?

460 replies

minervas1 · 28/10/2021 12:22

Just trying to sense check if I'm being U or if DH is...

Last Christmas we spent just us two (no kids yet!) and it was lovely, we had a perfect time. It had always been the plan to spend it like that after years of traipsing around between two families (usually 24th-26th with one, and then 27th-30th with another), but obviously Covid rules meant we couldn't visit anyone in the run up to Christmas or around NY as had been the plan.

This year I had presumed we would spend Xmas Eve, Day and Boxing Day alone but visit families before and after. I expressed this to DH, asking whether he wanted to see his Mum+Dad before or after Xmas, and he said he didn't want to do any of that. He said he didn't want to drive around on his annual leave and be guests in other people's houses, and just wanted to relax like last year. We both got a bit irritated with each other, and he eventually said he would do one trip if necessary to my Mum and Dad, but he was only going to do one. I think this is really cruel to his family who we're really close to, and I don't want to miss seeing mine in the festive season either.

Now, here's where I may be being Unreasonable... I don't drive. I can't drive, never had any interest in learning (not medical or trauma related or anything, just have never had to). Our families live quite far from us, so visiting does involve 4 hours of driving, although not difficult driving and mostly on motorway. DH says he finds that exhausting and it makes him tired for Christmas when he is "on holiday", and that travel days eat into festive time. He is happy to see family earlier in December and then just hunker down for the christmas period itself.

I don't know if he's just being a lazy dick here or not, tbh? Is it unreasonable to expect him to do the driving so we can make family happy and have some nice visits, especially as I already feel we're being a bit selfish by having Christmas just us two? Or is he fair enough? Is there a compromise here?

OP posts:
CSJobseeker · 28/10/2021 14:49

[quote julieca]@Thatsnotall no the couple where the man gets prioritised for any money on learning to increase his skills, but then controls both when he uses them, and his partners family coming to stay.
It is very common if money is limited for it to be spent on the mans skills rather than the woman.[/quote]
Except the OP says she "never had any interest in learning".

There is nothing at all to suggest that she is being prevented from learning, either by her DH or by her financial position.

LittleMysSister · 28/10/2021 14:49

[quote ImUninsultable]@AryaStarkWolf

She wants guests over christmas but she doesnt want to do the work of organising the house for it.

Sounds like she wants him to do hosting work if they visit or for him to do 16 hours of driving over the holiday so she can go on visits that he doesnt want to do.

It sounds a little like he has reached the end if his tether and is exhausted and just wants a break.

OP should absolutely be allowed to invite her family over. As long as he keeps the place as clean as he would usually do then that's fine. But she sounds like she wants more than that.[/quote]
In fairness, hosting guests at Christmas can be hard work and OP is also trying to consider her DH's family in all this. He has said they can visit hers but not his, she knows that will cause upset.

Tbh in OP's shoes, I'd also be conscious that it looks like it was me who put the restrictions on this year, since my family would still be getting a visit.

I don't think he's unfair not to want to drive since it all falls on him, but I do think he's unfair to say people can't come to their home at Christmas, knowing that it means OP either can't see her family or would need leave him sat at home alone over Christmas.

converseandjeans · 28/10/2021 14:49

OP do you work? He may be really looking forward to relaxing after a stressful few months. Possibly you do - in which case you should understand?

You need to learn to drive. On this occasion just get the train up & you don't need to worry about visiting his family. If he is happy to see them at another time then that's up to him.

If your Mum has just visited he obviously isn't saying no outright to visitors - more expressing a preference for chilling over Christmas with no travelling about?

CSJobseeker · 28/10/2021 14:47

@minervas1

I think what is so frustrating is he doesn’t control when my family visit at any other time - we actually just had my Mum down to stay with us for a mini-holiday, and his siblings often visit. He’s just got it into his head that it would be really hard work to have anyone over the Christmas holiday, whereas I would have multiple visits from both sides of our family happily.

I think possibly he is feeling incredibly drained after this year, which I do understand, it’s just annoying for me. Maybe I need to think more about the reasons he is saying this to me rather than just that it’s upsetting.

So you actually see family quite often, and he's normally totally fine about them visiting, and he's even compromised on driving you to your family at Xmas. This is not an example of someone being controlling.

It's just that he wants a quiet Xmas because "he is feeling incredibly drained after this year", whereas you want him to be your taxi driver and tidy the house in preparation for the guests that YOU want to invite (not him).

This isn't a man being lazy and controlling. He's just expressing his wishes about how he wants to spend his free time.

YOU want to spend your Xmas being taxied around to people's houses and having multiple visits from guests. He has compromised to a degree, but he isn't on this earth to facilitate what you want and he has a right to say no.

itsallgoingpearshaped · 28/10/2021 14:46

Your update just makes it clear that it's now your turn to learn to drive and he should be helping fund the effort, like you did for him.

icedcoffees · 28/10/2021 14:46

He doesn’t drive for himself, he drives for our household, in the same way when I put on washing I do it for both of us

What a bizarre thing to say Hmm

Putting washing on takes two seconds - it's not like you're taking it down to a river and banging it on a rock! It's hardly a comparison to driving which requires your 100% concentration the entire time in order to be safe. I mean, when you do the laundry, you don't sit and stare at the machine for 4 hours while it washes and dries your clothes Grin

If you want to go and see your family over the Christmas break, why can't you just...go alone? I don't see why DH needs to either chauffeur you there or accompany you on the train. Just go on your own.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 28/10/2021 14:46

*I do think he is being rather selfish actually.

He won't drive (fair enough).
He won't compromise and get a train.
He won't allow any visitors.*

Or OP is being selfish and expecting him to like it or lump it

She expects him to drive whenever she wants
He offered to visit one set of family at Xmas and the other earlier in Dec but OP won't compromise
He appears to have not vetoed family visiting over Xmas despite that not being his preference but OP won't spend time (less time than he would have to drive) getting the house ready for visitors.
He would be happy for OP to visit her family separately by train if she wanted but OP won't compromise.

Method · 28/10/2021 14:45

@Morgan12

I do think he is being rather selfish actually.

He won't drive (fair enough).
He won't compromise and get a train.
He won't allow any visitors.

Seems like he's doing what he wants and you've to like it or lump it.

I'd leave him all alone and go spend Christmas with my family.

^^ this absolutely.
MrsR87 · 28/10/2021 14:41

I say this as someone who was with DH for five years before I learnt to drive five years ago (he’s always driven) … you cannot compare four hour driving trips to doing the laundry!
I can understand you’re disappointed, especially if you enjoy seeing family and friends during the festive period but you really can’t call him a lazy dick. If you are so eager to see them, get the train yourself.
I’d be more disappointed at him not wanting family over but again I can see where he’s coming from…we regularly entertain over Christmas and it can be very draining!

PurpleBananaSmoothie · 28/10/2021 14:41

@julieca

OP I would ignore this MN thread. So many people calling you names who haven't even read the thread and are talking out their arse. Put yourself first from now on. He is controlling.
How the fuck is he controlling?

He’s willing to drive OP to her parents early December. He’s happy to have OP’s family visit but wants his own space over Christmas. He’s not cutting her off from anyone. He usually takes her wherever she wants and drives each time. He’s saying he’ll visit her family over his family in December. OP contributed to the cost of him learning to drive and the maintenance of the car because it benefits her. Until now, when he’s said he wants a break over Christmas, which includes not travelling and just having his own space for the Christmas break.

julieca · 28/10/2021 14:40

@Thatsnotall no the couple where the man gets prioritised for any money on learning to increase his skills, but then controls both when he uses them, and his partners family coming to stay.
It is very common if money is limited for it to be spent on the mans skills rather than the woman.

Wizzbangfizz · 28/10/2021 14:39

Learn to drive and share the load! If he won't facilitate visiting his own family leave him to it and get him to tell them why!

Thatsnotall · 28/10/2021 14:37

@julieca

OP I would ignore this MN thread. So many people calling you names who haven't even read the thread and are talking out their arse. Put yourself first from now on. He is controlling.
So the bloke who drives his wife round anywhere she wants for 351 days of the year because she can’t drive the car she owns, and who has now said he’d like not to do anything other than chill at home with his wife for a fortnight at Christmas for the first time, is controlling? Hmm
Morgan12 · 28/10/2021 14:36

I do think he is being rather selfish actually.

He won't drive (fair enough).
He won't compromise and get a train.
He won't allow any visitors.

Seems like he's doing what he wants and you've to like it or lump it.

I'd leave him all alone and go spend Christmas with my family.

TeeTotaller1 · 28/10/2021 14:35

4 hours driving v staying at home?

I'd be doing the latter, sod that

Learn to drive then in a years time I'll bet you'll be saying you don't want to schlep up and down the motorway when it's your annual leave

NorthSouthcatlady · 28/10/2021 14:34

I can see where he is coming from. Those dash around and have to visit lots of people type Christmas’s tire me out

YABU for calling him lazy as he won’t drive you. Driving is tiring and you can’t demand people do stuff you won’t do yourself. A friend of mine can’t and won’t drive, difference is she doesn’t expect people to drive on her behalf. She either walks, gets a taxi or uses public transport

wasthataburp · 28/10/2021 14:31

Why can't they visit you?

Thatsnotall · 28/10/2021 14:31

@minervas1

I think what is so frustrating is he doesn’t control when my family visit at any other time - we actually just had my Mum down to stay with us for a mini-holiday, and his siblings often visit. He’s just got it into his head that it would be really hard work to have anyone over the Christmas holiday, whereas I would have multiple visits from both sides of our family happily.

I think possibly he is feeling incredibly drained after this year, which I do understand, it’s just annoying for me. Maybe I need to think more about the reasons he is saying this to me rather than just that it’s upsetting.

I think you’re totally missing the point. We had Christmas year before last just us, no family, and I can’t tell you how amazing it was. I now look at the ‘family-visiting’ of Christmas with absolute dread (be it going to them or them coming to us). He’s simply found Christmas to be more enjoyable when it’s just the two of you - I think you’re being very very unreasonable to dismiss that on the need to ‘make family happy’ as per your OP. Why is making your wider-family happy more important than what your DH wants? That’s not to say what you want doesn’t matter, of course it does, but what you want can only happen with him doing all the things he said he doesn’t want to. The compromise he has offered is to see your family earlier in the month which IS a compromise if he doesn’t want to travel anywhere at all over the Christmas period and he HAS to be the one to take you because you can’t drive …. I can’t see why this is so awful?

So yes, you’re being enormously unreasonable. And the washing comparison of previous post is also a bit odd. Presumably DH can use it? And if you asked him to put a load on, he could? And it would have very limited impact on anyone’s time? Owning a vehicle may be a shared household asset but using it is not. It feels like, if he drives you around everywhere all year long, to say no, once a year, is more than reasonable.

Really struggling to see how you’re not understanding this. Hope you work it out.

CSJobseeker · 28/10/2021 14:31

Jointly paying for the item doesn't mean you can demand someone else's labour.

And I agree with this!

I assume your DH jointly bought the appliances in your house. If there was a shared appliance which he refused to learn how to use, would he have the right to dictate to you when he required you to use it? Hell no!

You want to use the car? Learn how to drive it and get a licence.

senorafridgidaire · 28/10/2021 14:31

Team DH here. If he's always been happy to do The Visits in previous years, cut the poor chap some slack this year - let him stay home and chill for a fortnight, and let him deal with the fallout if he doesn't want to visit his own family, if there even is any fallout. I can't imagine anything worse that a forced 'we WILL see both families between the dates of X and Y because CHRISTMAS'. Doesn't stop you getting on a train to go and visit whoever you like, and you've said he's happy to see everyone earlier in Dec, so no big deal surely?

And yes, learn to drive.

AryaStarkWolf · 28/10/2021 14:30

[quote ImUninsultable]@AryaStarkWolf

She wants guests over christmas but she doesnt want to do the work of organising the house for it.

Sounds like she wants him to do hosting work if they visit or for him to do 16 hours of driving over the holiday so she can go on visits that he doesnt want to do.

It sounds a little like he has reached the end if his tether and is exhausted and just wants a break.

OP should absolutely be allowed to invite her family over. As long as he keeps the place as clean as he would usually do then that's fine. But she sounds like she wants more than that.[/quote]
ahh OK, I missed that bit, bloody hell

julieca · 28/10/2021 14:30

OP I would ignore this MN thread. So many people calling you names who haven't even read the thread and are talking out their arse.
Put yourself first from now on. He is controlling.

Notonthestairs · 28/10/2021 14:30

You sound like you think you've invested in a long term on call taxi driver. Learn to drive.

Guests staying has to be a joint decision and compromises worked through.

Bonniegirlie · 28/10/2021 14:28

Driving is tiring! You're so out of order never learning and leaving it all to him. Sheesh. And you're calling him lazy? Wow, just wow

CSJobseeker · 28/10/2021 14:28

(bold fail)

Swipe left for the next trending thread