Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked that 16 year old didn't know about apartheid

506 replies

biddlybop · 28/10/2021 09:12

Recently, I was having a conversation with a teen in the family and mentioned apartheid (think we were talking about films and books based on true events). They asked what apartheid was. I explained, and they had never heard of it.

I was genuinely shocked. We were taught about it in school - in both history, and English. I'm 30, so I wasn't educated decades ago.

Is this not in the curriculum anymore, or is it just her school? I think it's really important that young people are taught about these events, especially as racism is still such a problem.

OP posts:
2021namechanger · 29/10/2021 15:15

I’m not actually that surprised for a sixteen year old. If not taught at school it’s the sort of thing that would perhaps come up through watching a film or similar.

Would you expect a 16 to know about say, the Rwandan genocide, Chernobyl, or even the Falklands war. For anyone in their 30’s it’s fairly “new past” but for a 16 year old, even their parents would have been children when they happened.

mustlovegin · 29/10/2021 15:14

history is facts

Not necessarily, I think I've been clear in my post

Please tell us in your own words, exactly what you are afraid of???

Why is it than when someone disagrees it always has to be down to fear?

mustlovegin · 29/10/2021 15:11

Otherpeoples I've never said you have no right to be here, and I can appreciate that your family's history must have been very hard and complex. But you need to understand that if you blatantly say on a UK forum that most British are proud to be numerically illiterate you are likely to cause offence. Nobody is immune to that.

As for the wider point about anti-British propaganda, again let me tell you that one of the almost universal perceptions of the UK from outside the country is that we have never, really, come to terms with losing the Empire....understanding that, and therefore understanding Britain's place in the world today

That's the equivalent of asking Britain to 'know our place', and it's unacceptable. Why should our self worth or our decision on how to educate our children be based on 'a universal' outside view? Whose view is it anyway? Can't you see how contradictory and unreasonable that is?

XingMing · 29/10/2021 15:06

Fascinating family history @Otherpeoplesteens. Thank you. There would seem to be room for a big book on the winding down of the British Empire after 1947. Fragments of the story are told all over the place, but I've not come across one that takes the subject as a whole topic. Or have I just missed it?

HadEnoughofOtherThreads · 29/10/2021 15:02

@mustlovegin

mustlovegin
‘There's no need for the drama. The information is widely available and anyone can google it (specially16 year olds). The family can encourage it if they are interested (as the OP has done). But we shouldn't be financing the dissemination of anti-British propaganda in schools

And what's 'the truth'? Which news outlet tells 'the truth'? Who monopolises 'the truth'? 'The truth' will depend on what the teacher may want to focus on, what 'side' will be presented in a more favourable light, which nuances will be discussed, etc. And I'm not talking about apartheid here, but more about history in general.’

I agree with another PP about it’s only you that’s coming across as being melodramatic.

It’s not drama, history is facts.

‘But we shouldn't be financing the dissemination of anti-British propaganda in schools’
So you only want people to know about the good stuff?
You want to whitewash the rest of it so the great British people do not look bad!

You and people like you are the problem. Always have been and will continue to be with that ignorant mindset. It’s fear. Let’s get down to the nitty gritty of this. Please tell us in your own words, exactly what you are afraid of???

Otherpeoplesteens · 29/10/2021 14:49

@mustlovegin

So, you would like future generations to remain ignorant of the truth?

There's no need for the drama. The information is widely available and anyone can google it (specially16 year olds). The family can encourage it if they are interested (as the OP has done). But we shouldn't be financing the dissemination of anti-British propaganda in schools

And what's 'the truth'? Which news outlet tells 'the truth'? Who monopolises 'the truth'? 'The truth' will depend on what the teacher may want to focus on, what 'side' will be presented in a more favourable light, which nuances will be discussed, etc. And I'm not talking about apartheid here, but more about history in general.

The only one being melodramatic here is you, mustlovegin.

Anti-British propaganda? Yesterday I pointed out that levels of literacy and numeracy were poor in the UK and you said it was untrue and offensive. It is not 'anti-British propaganda' - it is fact. Here you go (the information is widely available and anyone can google it):

www.nationalnumeracy.org.uk/what-numeracy/what-issue

www.teacherboards.co.uk/community/adult-illiteracy-in-the-uk/

It should be widely understood that to fix something, you have to be aware that it's a problem. If you really think 49% of adults having the numeracy of a primary school leaver is acceptable, or that it is acceptable for 16% of adults to be functionally illiterate then it's obviously not a problem for you, but let me assure you it is for most people who care, or for people who think everyone should have better pay, or a multitude of others. Denying something appalling exists because to do so in your mind denigrates Britain, or the British education system, is actually part of the problem. That's you.

As for the wider point about anti-British propaganda, again let me tell you that one of the almost universal perceptions of the UK from outside the country is that we have never, really, come to terms with losing the Empire. Understanding all facets of this, how it influences the whole world today, and the legacy still being addressed in the Commonwealth and beyond is an important part of understanding that, and therefore understanding Britain's place in the world today.

Again, I know you'd rather not reference it but Brexit is instructive. When the Brexiters talk about 'Global Britain' they imagine UK as some great modern power. Most of the rest of the world laughs, they really do. When Gavin Williamson talks about sending Royal Navy aircraft carriers to the South China Sea to 'show China', the rest of the world laughs. When Boris signs an international treaty with a protocol on Northern Ireland with no intention of honouring it, the rest of the world looks on aghast. When Priti Patel threatens to starve the Republic of Ireland by preventing food shipments transiting Great Britain, the rest of the world looks on aghast. These are all current political and diplomatic decisions, based in the badly mistaken belief that the UK is still a world power because we're never come to terms with not being, and they cheapen us.

As for yesterday's line again about me "discrediting the British" but still "deciding to come and live here anyway" - seriously? You know absolutely nothing about my circumstances or my motivations, and yet still want to lecture us about 'the truth'? I have never felt the need to justify my circumstance on MN but I'll make an exception for you to help you down off your high horse. Here are my facts. My father arrived in Britain in 1939 on the Kindertransport. He was adopted by a couple in Yorkshire, and by the time he had finished his education word reached him of surviving members of his family in South Africa. He went to join them and ended up in Northern Rhodesia where, upon independence in October 1964, he was required to leave the place he called home. He and his fiancée (Portuguese, from Mozambique) went on to establish a life spread between Hong Kong and Macau, then British and Portuguese colonies respectively. I was born in the latter and did my early years education there, but my primary education in Hong Kong, in English, under the British system. I was sent to boarding school in the UK at age nine just after the agreement was reached to hand HK back to China; Macau would follow soon after. We knew enough about decolonisation that we didn't hang around to be required to leave, so started to build lives elsewhere. My parents retired to continental Portugal and I remained in Britain where I did all my secondary and tertiary education, and entered the workforce. I have been resident here for 36 years now, and like my parents before me was invited to leave the place I called home after the referendum because my passport had the wrong country on it. But by then I had already qualified for British citizenship, which I took up.

I have every right to be here, and I have every right to draw attention to things that aren't working well here, as well as talk about the inconveniences which have been heaped on my family by Britain's history. I have the advantage that I am not imprisoned by my lack of outside perspective, or by some Little Englander mentality. It is not 'anti-British' to do that. My only goal is to make things better for my children.

There are many truths, but all truth is based on facts. I really don't know why you are so afraid of them.

Lockheart · 29/10/2021 14:26

@mustlovegin

So, you would like future generations to remain ignorant of the truth?

There's no need for the drama. The information is widely available and anyone can google it (specially16 year olds). The family can encourage it if they are interested (as the OP has done). But we shouldn't be financing the dissemination of anti-British propaganda in schools

And what's 'the truth'? Which news outlet tells 'the truth'? Who monopolises 'the truth'? 'The truth' will depend on what the teacher may want to focus on, what 'side' will be presented in a more favourable light, which nuances will be discussed, etc. And I'm not talking about apartheid here, but more about history in general.

History is not "anti-British propaganda". It's history. It happened. The facts are as they are. It cannot be altered.

History should be taught warts and all. You can't only teach the nice bits because the bad makes you uncomfortable. Our history is myriad and we should not be afraid of it.

merrymouse · 29/10/2021 14:22

I think a lot of teachers try to make things relevant for the kids in front of them to "bring it to life", hence focusing on "what life was like for the average Brit". Most average Brits in the UK weren't out actively colonising, unless they were in a particular class, or in the armed forces - they were trying to put food on the table and a roof over their heads.

Agree. I think you probably only have 2 or 3 years to cover history in a political, academic way, as opposed to a hands on practical "What would it be like to live in an Anglo Saxon house or be an evacuee?" way before history becomes optional. Given the amount of time allocated to the subject in most curriculums, some things will be left out.

MadameMinimes · 29/10/2021 14:01

Wtf? What kind of person thinks teaching the history of Britain accurately is anti-British propaganda? It seems profoundly unpatriotic to suggest that learning the truth about British history will make children hate their country.

The Germans teach the holocaust without their children growing up to hate Germany and British children can learn about the slave trade without growing up to hate Britain. It is very strange to think that learning the history of your country would make you hate it. History just is. We can’t change it now or do anything about it, but we certainly shouldn’t shy away from teaching the less pleasant bits. It’s created the world as it is now and tells us illuminating and valuable things.

mustlovegin · 29/10/2021 13:20

So, you would like future generations to remain ignorant of the truth?

There's no need for the drama. The information is widely available and anyone can google it (specially16 year olds). The family can encourage it if they are interested (as the OP has done). But we shouldn't be financing the dissemination of anti-British propaganda in schools

And what's 'the truth'? Which news outlet tells 'the truth'? Who monopolises 'the truth'? 'The truth' will depend on what the teacher may want to focus on, what 'side' will be presented in a more favourable light, which nuances will be discussed, etc. And I'm not talking about apartheid here, but more about history in general.

DGRossetti · 29/10/2021 13:19

[quote julieca]@sashagabadon True. Lots of concepts like viral load were not understood by most of the population before the pandemic.[/quote]
Not so sure they are widely understood even now.

HadEnoughofOtherThreads · 29/10/2021 12:38

@mustlovegin

‘Why should our taxes be used to indoctrinate our kids against us? Genuine question’

😯
So, you would like future generations to remain ignorant of the truth?

JaninaDuszejko · 29/10/2021 12:24

It's implausible that the majority of the British people would like to have our kids indoctrinated against us

Speak for yourself. My DC have ancestors on all sides that have benefitted from colonialism, e.g. one was involved in the Virginia Company, another was a Conquistador and several benefitted from 20th century colonialism in Africa. Our parents generation either deny or gloss over the family's involvement in racism but I remember the generation above who lived the ex-pat life in South Africa and Rhodesia and had very dismissive attitudes to the local black people and it's important our children understand where their white middle class privilege comes from.

YippieKayakOtherBuckets · 29/10/2021 12:11

We cover the social impact of the Industrial Revolution in detail when teaching A Christmas Carol as a GCSE text. You can’t understand Dickens’s purpose in writing the novel without that contextual knowledge.

reluctantbrit · 29/10/2021 12:06

@mustlovegin

I think the positive aspects of the industrial revolution are well known and normally covered. DD did it in primary and then in Y8.

But how many do understand the social injustice of it leading to the chartist movement, right to vote, labour political movement, the right to strike, social security and several post WWI revolutions.

I am German.

ThanksItHasPockets · 29/10/2021 11:55

@KatherineofGaunt

At GCSE we did the History of Medicine, the Wild West and Northern Ireland. I was heavily into history and only started learning about apartheid after watching a film based on a book called 'The Power of One'.

As a primary teacher, only at one school have I seen any history from Africa, where they compared Elizabeth I with a Queen from an African country alive at the same time (I think, its a long time ago). Even Black History Month tends to either celebrate black people in history or focuses on slavery in the US.

I've worked in several schools and never heard apartheid mentioned. These days, schools have more flexibility to choose units to meet the National Curriculum, but you still have many teachers in class who used the same old QCA units and will still have resources, planning etc. That's why I don't think many primary schools have branched out into other areas of history yet.

It is also important to remember that many primary schools will not have a History specialist on the staff, and it’s very likely that the overworked History lead who doesn’t get a TLR for co-ordinating the subject is not themselves a history graduate. Even smaller secondary schools will have at least one history specialist on the staff body.
wednesday32 · 29/10/2021 11:35

Sadly there are far too many events to have occurred, to be able to cover all themes during school. If at the age of sixteen this is the first time the conversation has come up between you both, so when else would they have discussed the topic? I am 35 and never discussed the apartheid or slavery during school. The themes I studied in secondary school were WW1,WW2, The industrial revolution, crime and punished ie witchcraft and the trials at eth tower of London. In primary school the historical themes were the romans, Vikings and the Royal Family dating back to the war of the roses. Different schools may use different reference book sand also depends on the individual teachers what the also bring to the discussions in class as well as how the syllabus is navigated.

ColinTheKoala · 29/10/2021 11:34

@Grumpyoldpersonwithcats

Pleased to report that when I asked DS2 (18) this morning if he knew what apartheid was, he looked at me with contempt and replied 'of course I do', followed by a brief accurate description. He gave up history pre GCSEs.
Pleased to report that when I asked DS2 (18) this morning if he knew what apartheid was, he looked at me with contempt and replied 'of course I do', followed by a brief accurate description. He gave up history pre GCSEs

Knowledge moves in interesting ways too. My son knew about it because of his interest in sport and athletics in particular - and the fact that Zola Budd ran for the British athletics team and why. Being interested in one thing leads to another - there is no "right" knowledge despite the sneering by some posters on here.

ColinTheKoala · 29/10/2021 11:32

I raised my eyebrows though when they had to write a mini biography of a prominent black person, and the two choices were Rosa Parks or Marcus bloody Rashford

Could have just as easily picked Kelly Holmes! She has had a very interesting life and done a lot for women in sport via her charity.

As for other things we should cover in school history lessons - the Spanish Civil War might be a good topic too. And Oswald Mosley - we tend to gloss over him and things like the battle of Cable Street.

RedMarauder · 29/10/2021 11:31

@mustlovegin

who is "us"?

It's implausible that the majority of the British people would like to have our kids indoctrinated against us

You still have clarified who "us" is.

You just gone on some rant ignoring the fact that the people in the UK aren't one homogenous mass and good teachers, regardless of their subject, point that out.

Unhomme · 29/10/2021 11:25

The problem with teaching history is that there's a lot of it and more is discovered all the time.

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 29/10/2021 11:22

Pleased to report that when I asked DS2 (18) this morning if he knew what apartheid was, he looked at me with contempt and replied 'of course I do', followed by a brief accurate description. He gave up history pre GCSEs.

mustlovegin · 29/10/2021 11:15

who is "us"?

It's implausible that the majority of the British people would like to have our kids indoctrinated against us

RedMarauder · 29/10/2021 11:10

@mustlovegin who is "us"?

mustlovegin · 29/10/2021 11:02

The main issue is the background of the teachers choosing topics to study. I know from family and friends the "history" they cover in black history month is a joke.

Why should our taxes be used to indoctrinate our kids against us? Genuine question