Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked that 16 year old didn't know about apartheid

506 replies

biddlybop · 28/10/2021 09:12

Recently, I was having a conversation with a teen in the family and mentioned apartheid (think we were talking about films and books based on true events). They asked what apartheid was. I explained, and they had never heard of it.

I was genuinely shocked. We were taught about it in school - in both history, and English. I'm 30, so I wasn't educated decades ago.

Is this not in the curriculum anymore, or is it just her school? I think it's really important that young people are taught about these events, especially as racism is still such a problem.

OP posts:
XingMing · 29/10/2021 21:21

Oddly, because I live in a very "White" area of the UK... that is extremely rural... where most people have families that have lived locally for several generations, it's not an issue. People from cities visit on holiday, shudder slightly at the idea of living without Deliveroo, and go home again. A few come and stay and get stuck in with the rest of us peasants. They are welcomed.

Ellen2shoes · 29/10/2021 20:56

YANBU. Had a conversation with my son about this when he about 14 - he didn't know. I did find it strange given that it was so recent and the significance of race/colour in the present is so highlighted by BLM. Wouldn't apartheid be central to education about this? I think that the historical canon should be reviewed, just as the English one should. Of course there are endless facts and possibilities about what could be taught at schools but more emphasis should be placed on the events that have an impact on our relationships in the present, as well as our economies. Postcolonial history is sidelined as ideological, but isn't history all ideological, including how we select what is taught.

XingMing · 29/10/2021 20:51

There's not enough time in all the years of education to teach everything that's considered important IMO. By the time we've agreed all DC need to read and write competently (a benchmark that is too often missed IMO) the Dc are older and starting to be critical.

I can never forget the afternoon I took DS to Waterloo, and the diorama of the battle (which was only won by Wellington thanks to the arrival of German reinforcements -- Blucher, IIRC) was represented as Napoleon's triumph. The political lens does odd things to history.

Nobody recalls that Stalin murdered at least 12 million small-holder farmers (the kulaks), and killed Russia's ability to feed its population for 40 years. People have forgotten that Mao ordered the civil service onto the land to dig during the Cultural Revolution to equalise society. Or that Pol Pot and the Khmer Rouge violently dismembered the Vietnamese social order. None achieved an equal society, which I remember being the avowed intent.

DaisyStiener · 29/10/2021 20:18

Ha haaa another one for only Russian history!?

  • but I do know about apartheid
mustlovegin · 29/10/2021 20:04

Again, in the Brexit debate almost everyone outside the UK believes that the UK's position is weak, and that it strengthened the UK's hand to surrender some sovereignty in return for a say in the direction of a much larger, more powerful, entity

Otherpeoples I'm not saying that one has to ignore feedback or opinions from outside the UK, but other nations do not have to act in our best interests. Why should we take their views as gospel? What you seem to be suggesting is that we had better toe the line or else.

Your and others' similar posts (as I don't mean to put you on the spot) relay a feeling of detachment. Very rarely someone with any deep sense of belonging or loyalty to their land and fellow countrymen would express opinions in this way.

If we want our country to successfully navigate the challenges ahead, do you not think it's rather tone deaf and disingenuous to suggest that we need to encourage negativity and self-flagellation for the sake of it and start to focus on events that didn't even take place here like apartheid? How is that a good idea?

The OP has made a good job of fuelling division on a forum, do you think replicating this IRL and amongst our children will help us move forward in any way? We don't need this now. The information on any historic event is available for anyone who cares to look for it, we have more important tasks to attend to now.

Mesoavocado · 29/10/2021 20:00

Late 30s. Never taught it at school though have vague recollection of Mandela release on tv

My parents taught me

School did ww1 and ww2

mustlovegin · 29/10/2021 19:40

History has facts - there is no doubt that the Battle of Bosworth was in 1485

reluctantbrit you must know full well that in the current climate a history lesson is not going to be limited to dates

mustlovegin · 29/10/2021 19:35

What are you scared of?

What do you think I should be scared of? Because whatever it is, you should be scared too

FortVictoria · 29/10/2021 19:35

@Charles11

My Dc have been taught about apartheid. They’re 16 and under. I remember ds1 was very confused and appalled by it when he learnt about it in primary school and said ‘there was a party and black people weren’t allowed to sit next to white people!’ I got to the bottom of his confusion, figured out what he was learning and then helped him to understand what was going on.
OMG. Not a funny subject at all, but this post did make me smile Smile
Agoddessonamountaintop · 29/10/2021 19:27

I knew someone a few years ago, 19y/old then, she’d be 25 now, who didn’t know about the Holocaust. I’m in my late 50s and apartheid was never mentioned in school even though it was very much in the news at the time. Later on we gaily danced to Free Nelson Mandela; I always assumed everyone knew who he was but maybe not.

stopblowingyournose · 29/10/2021 19:23

It's just occurred to me both my dds who are 8 and 12 know a lot about segregation, race riots and civil rights movement in USA due to of all things - working on hairspray the musical. Apartheid wouldn't exactly surprise them.

merrymouse · 29/10/2021 19:18

Nelson Mandela died 8 years ago.

Many under 10s aren’t very aware of current affairs, and there is nothing particularly wrong with that.

It would be odd for a 16 year old to unaware of issues around racism now, but they might not relate that particularly to South Africa. It’s not as though there aren’t loads of other examples.

Blueseasky · 29/10/2021 19:08

YANBU - Mine are 9 and 16 year old , they know a lot about apartheid and racism, various forms of discrimination intentional and unintentional.

stopblowingyournose · 29/10/2021 19:00

@cricketmum84

I've just asked my 12YO DD and she didn't have a clue
My dd is 12 I highly doubt she knows about it and she's at a grammar and is v widely read.
Choccyhobnob · 29/10/2021 18:58

Mid 30s here and never learnt about it at school. Hadn't heard about it until my mid twenties when I had to ask my DH about it as I'd heard the term but didn't know anything about it. Dh is only 3 years older but from a different area and learnt about it at his school. We did ww1, ww2, American slavery, prohibition, Russian revolution, peasants revolt, magna carta etc etc e

cricketmum84 · 29/10/2021 18:42

Saying that -as soon as I explained it to her she knew exactly what I meant but just hadn't recognised the word.

cricketmum84 · 29/10/2021 18:41

I've just asked my 12YO DD and she didn't have a clue

Angie1403 · 29/10/2021 17:55

I live in Scotland and it wasn’t until I was in my mid 20’s that I realised I knew nothing about my own history. Almost nothing in the curriculum, all focussed on the world wars and the empire and the closest we came to Scottish historical events was learning about the monarchy. I’m genuinely ashamed of my education whilst remaining proud of my homeland.

stopblowingyournose · 29/10/2021 17:48

I know what apartheid is. I'm 42. I can recall the free nelson Mandela concert being on tv. Ive seen the film the power of one. I know about trade sanctions and sun city but mostly I know about it because 1. It was in the media when I was a child and 2. My dad was relentless about these kinds of issues.
I don't recall it coming up much at school and I went to state and independent schools.

Jack80 · 29/10/2021 17:36

I knew what it was just not that working Im 40 not sure if I was taught about it.

Angelil · 29/10/2021 17:32

LOL. I’m an English teacher and have taught international school students (so…in the top 1% of privilege) aged 17-18 who didn’t know what it was…

CreamFirstThenJamOnTop · 29/10/2021 17:18

I’m in my 40s and was never taught about it at school. I was aware of it as a child / teen via my parents and the news but never through school.
Same with many issues and historic events.
People are gobsmacked that I was never taught about WW1 or WW2 at school but I didn’t - everything I know is through learning from parents, self-taught or museums and documentaries etc.

reluctantbrit · 29/10/2021 17:08

@mustlovegin

I studied British colonialism in India as part of my history A-level in Germany. If you would see the bookshelves in my house you would find tons of books related to British history (among other countries). History is more than facts about which king ruled when or that Britain won a war.

History has facts - there is no doubt that the Battle of Bosworth was in 1485. You can argue (and lots of historians have) that Henry VII shouldn't have automatically been crowned King of England based on a dubious blood link to the throne. So are tons of other historical events, always open to interpretation and the view is changing depending on the time a study/book/documentary is done.

When DD was in Y7 I asked her history teacher what will be covered in KS3. She mentioned imperialism and also said very confidently that she will be very critical on that subject as there is nothing worse than repeating the same old slogans prior to WWII when the world and views on subjects have changed so much.

Otherwise the Germans would still think they are a military strong empire with a Kaiser declared in Versaille after winning a battle over the French.

There is no point in just teaching the glorious side of things, that's so one-sided, you can forget about giving children a well rounded education.

Otherpeoplesteens · 29/10/2021 16:35

That's the equivalent of asking Britain to 'know our place', and it's unacceptable. Why should our self worth or our decision on how to educate our children be based on 'a universal' outside view?

Well, for starters, because self-awareness on how others perceive us is usually a fairly important influence on our own behaviour in our personal lives - although I'm beginning to wonder with you - and it would be fairly logical to carry this through to a nation-state level when acting in a regional or global environment. If you are fed back at work that all your staff think you are impulsive, or dishonest, or inconsistent, if you had any sense you'd address that.

Apart from recklessness, the only reason you wouldn't do that as a country would be if you were so powerful it didn't matter, or so weak it didn't matter. And for that you'd need an honest understanding of your place in the world. And that is not "unacceptable" - it's just how international politics works whether you like it or not. It influences so many things.

Again, in the Brexit debate almost everyone outside the UK believes that the UK's position is weak, and that it strengthened the UK's hand to surrender some sovereignty in return for a say in the direction of a much larger, more powerful, entity.

China now knows that it can put tanks on the streets of Hong Kong in direct violation of the 1984 Sino-British Joint Declaration, because not only are they economically and militarily far, far superior to us, but also because the UK has made it clear that it does not regard international treaties as binding. If Boris can rip up the Northern Ireland protocol on the basis he never intended to honour it, why wouldn't Beijing throw that back in our faces? The UK made itself much weaker than it had to be.

The UK wants to lead the global fight against climate change through COP26. And yet on Wednesday the duty on domestic flights was cut in the budget. The rest of the world sees UK making a point of not walking the talk, so why should they? UK leadership fatally undermined before the conference starts.

Britain needs to know its place in the world if it wants any influence at all in it, and it needs to understand how people perceive it if it wants to further its own agenda.

HadEnoughofOtherThreads · 29/10/2021 15:47

@mustlovegin

Facts are the ‘real’ and ‘complete’ history.
You’re basically saying you don’t want others to know the real truth and are happy to continue to stick your fingers in your ears. Most probably because hiding the bad history does not have a direct negative impact on you and how you are perceived in by others in society, i.e., racism, your mother tongue and/ or the colour of your skin.

‘Why is it than when someone disagrees it always has to be down to fear?’

Because it usually is. What are you scared of them? What’s ‘your’ problem?