Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked that 16 year old didn't know about apartheid

506 replies

biddlybop · 28/10/2021 09:12

Recently, I was having a conversation with a teen in the family and mentioned apartheid (think we were talking about films and books based on true events). They asked what apartheid was. I explained, and they had never heard of it.

I was genuinely shocked. We were taught about it in school - in both history, and English. I'm 30, so I wasn't educated decades ago.

Is this not in the curriculum anymore, or is it just her school? I think it's really important that young people are taught about these events, especially as racism is still such a problem.

OP posts:
mustlovegin · 30/10/2021 00:11

Surely an understanding of history as inherently subjective shows you that nationalism is a construct

'construct' these days seems to stand for any aspect of reality that a minority of people don't like and want to eradicate by trying (and failing) to convince others that it doesn't exist. Let's not go there...

me109f · 29/10/2021 23:58

Last gasp of british colonialism. Best forgotten about.

I spent some time in Oklahoma in 1985 and South Africa was more in the news than the rest of the World put together, the USA news featured it every day, and I think it was to offset the racial troubles in the US at the time.
In 1988 I visited SA for a couple of weeks, spending time in a couple of townships as well as Johannesburg and Cape Town and a trip to Kruger National Park on a quick safari (very few tourists). It was still in apartheit but I never saw any troubles in my travels. I had never ever seen a country with less police presence, and saw no army presence at all. I make no excuses for the apartheit system, but I freely wandered everwhere and loved the place. Best food I have had in any country, it was wonderfully peaceful and the best agriculture and infrastructure in Africa.
At school, history only went up to 1914 for me. There was a policy not to teach politics wars or recent history so as not to politically influence or bias pupils. This sort of thing can easily be learnt from TV, books and newspapers.

feelingsareweird · 29/10/2021 23:55

I have a PhD in history and have never been formally taught about apartheid. But I was a teenager in the 90s and was reasonably exposed to current affairs so i knew about it as a teen for sure, probably from newsround!

@mustlovegin you’re quite right that history is not just facts but interpretation. But why would anyone who has even a vague understanding of that need or want ‘a deep sense of belonging or loyalty to their land’?! Surely an understanding of history as inherently subjective shows you that nationalism is a construct and has no real meaning or value? What we need to be teaching students is that being ‘British’ has and always has had a host of different meanings, some good, many bad. And all intimately tied up with the rest of the world.

MadameMinimes · 29/10/2021 23:41

Also the number of people killed in witch hunts in Britain was tiny. Likely around 1,000 over a period of well over 200 years and definitely no more than 2,000. Elsewhere in Europe there were pockets of witch hunting but the grand total estimate for the whole of Europe from the late 1400s to the late 1700s is usually put somewhere in the region of 50,000. For comparison, that is fewer than the estimated number of people being murdered by the Nazis every 4 days at the peak of the holocaust in the Autumn of 1942.

Otherpeoplesteens · 29/10/2021 23:36

@mustlovegin

[O]ther nations do not have to act in our best interests. Why should we take their views as gospel? What you seem to be suggesting is that we had better toe the line or else.

Not at all. But the UK is a weak nation no matter how you skin this particular cat, and the only way to increase its influence is to build alliances with like-minded nations, through shared sovereignty or at the very least through shared interests - be that a common enemy or a common goal. If Dunkirk didn't wipe away the last vestiges of belief that Britain could go it alone, then I imagine Suez did.

We're never going to achieve that without understanding our would-be allies' interests or goals. If the UK cannot or will not do that, then toeing the line is the best that we can hope for.

Your and others' similar posts (as I don't mean to put you on the spot) relay a feeling of detachment. Very rarely someone with any deep sense of belonging or loyalty to their land and fellow countrymen would express opinions in this way.

Once again, your interpretation of fact results in your version of truth which is bollocks. I have a Portuguese first name and a Silesian family name, and I speak fluent Cantonese, but if you met me in the street you'd mistake me for being related to Jacob Rees-Mogg long before you'd think I was related to Cristiano Ronaldo. I am foreign, but I am also British. I have nevertheless spent my life since the age of nine justifying my presence in Britain and I'm getting rather sick of it. I am amazed that anybody could interpret my life as displaying detachment when I have spent it consciously putting down roots here.

I refuse to show wilful blindness to the UK's many problems simply out of a sense of loyalty or belonging, because that does not achieve anything. I express dissatisfaction with life in the UK precisely because I have a deep sense of loyalty to it, and with that comes both a desire and a duty to improve it. I have spent much of my life around born-and-bred
Brits who have lived overseas and - with the benefit of that experience - think the same as me. It's nothing to do with detachment, everything to do with the fact that we are not blinkered by blind faith in British or English exceptionalism.

[D]o you not think it's rather tone deaf and disingenuous to suggest that we need to encourage negativity and self-flagellation for the sake of it and start to focus on events that didn't even take place here like apartheid?

You are the only one who has described understanding the facts of history as "negativity" or "self-flagellation." I'll give you an example of why something like apartheid, in a far off land, has consequences for totally disconnected people today, and how understanding it makes people's lives easier, if not necessarily better.

I mentioned previously that my mother was Portuguese, from Mozambique. In the run up to Mozambican independence in 1975 my parents were among the quarter of a million or so who were ordered to leave. Mine went to Macau, many went back to Portugal with nothing but the clothes on their backs, and the rest generally went penniless to South Africa. Those who settled in SA often took up skilled trades - carpentry, plumbing, electrician work - which white South Africans didn't want to do, but for which the training and education wasn't available to blacks. They settled and integrated. Some even set up international businesses like Nando's. But come the end of apartheid all those skilled trade jobs became accessible to black South Africans. All well and good.

The Portuguese in SA found themselves priced out of the jobs they'd been doing for 20 years, and most of them didn't have the skills to go on to the professional classes where, if they did, they were also competing with post-apartheid blacks. Many tens of thousands of Portuguese citizens - and their children, who had been born and raised in South Africa and often spoke English or Afrikaans as a first language - went back to continental Portugal and had to be absorbed there.

Now, if you are a British retiree or holiday home owner in the Algarve, and you never learned a word of Portuguese (i.e. most of them) you'll seek out businesses where people speak English. If you're a British holidaymaker and need to go into a bank you'll ask if anyone speaks English. A huge number of the people you'll encounter are Portuguese retornados from South Africa.

None of this is a problem, really. But every so often, if you hang around them long and often enough, you'll hear one refer to "the Dutch," and it's usually not complementary. Given the number of people from Amsterdam, Eindhoven or Nijmegen who have also settled in the Algarve you'd be forgiven for thinking that these Portuguese-Saffas had an issue with folk from the Netherlands. You'd be wrong. They had simply lived under an apartheid pecking-order which as well as discriminating against people of colour (unlike what they had in Mozambique or Angola) also differentiated between white Portuguese, whites of British origin, and Afrikaaners - the "Dutch" to whom they are actually referring.

Those who don't understand the history behind it jump in feet first at drinks parties in southern Portugal - which had literally nothing to do with apartheid - at their peril.

MadameMinimes · 29/10/2021 23:25

@Ibelieveinghosts

I think it’s important to point out that the whole “Stalin killed more people than Hitler” thing is old Cold War propaganda. The fact is that around 90% or more of the people who went into the gulag survived and the best estimates for the number that died in the gulags is somewhere in the region of 1.5 million over a period of 20 or so years. The nazis killed 6 million Jews and a total of around 11 million civilians, with most of those deaths happening between 1941-1945. Stalin was an awful leader, and his crimes are horrific enough, but during the Cold War the number of people he killed was dramatically overestimated for ideological reasons.

We should not be teaching children that Stalin killed more people than Hitler because it isn’t true. Even if you add the famine deaths to his “toll”, which is a fundamentally different thing to systematically gassing people to death IMO, the numbers still don’t stack up.

MadameMinimes · 29/10/2021 23:00

XingMing

Slavery was abolished in Britain and the empire in 1833, not 1807. That is earlier than most slaving European powers except, I think, Spain. In 1807 we banned the trading of slaves, which is not the same as ending slavery. I think we were second only to Portugal on banning the trading of slaves. We were at the earlier end of both but weren’t first in either. The 1833 Act was part of a wave of abolition legislation sweeping across European powers in the early to mid nineteenth century. The Dutch, Spanish, Portuguese and French were implementing similar measures at the time, some slightly earlier than us and some slightly later.

treblechoc · 29/10/2021 22:59

My kids' school's key stage 3 history curriculum has a module on the Civil Rights movement which compares and contrasts events in UK and US history. Apartheid is mentioned as a topic to research for an optional extension task. They also do a module on genocide, covering Rwanda, Cambodia, as well as the Holocaust. They can't cover everything, but do encourage them to read widely. If teenagers have gaps in their knowledge it is as much their parents' (and their own) responsibility to fill them as their teachers'.

JaninaDuszejko · 29/10/2021 22:53

@MrsFirth2006

I’m 49 and learnt nothing about this at school in history either GCSE or A -Level. Not sure if my daughters have either.
It wasn't history when you were at school. Apartheid in South Africa didn't end until 1994.
MrsFirth2006 · 29/10/2021 22:44

I’m 49 and learnt nothing about this at school in history either GCSE or A -Level. Not sure if my daughters have either.

XenoBitch · 29/10/2021 22:40

Early 40s, and I was never taught about it in school.

Cheeseplantboots · 29/10/2021 22:39

I just asked my two. My 14 year old knew what it was but my 15 year old didn’t. Both say they’ve never learned it in school.

grey12 · 29/10/2021 22:31

Apartheid was definitely not part of my curriculum. Personally I think history is a terrible subject at school. It should be general world history instead of what day month year was a king born!!! Confused

Ibelieveinghosts · 29/10/2021 22:29

I’m not sure history lessons are really the place to focus on this. History lessons are seemingly becoming increasingly politicised. I think history in the U.K. should focus largely on British history, in a neutral, non-judgemental way. Skills such as critical thinking, not being anachronistic, learning to formulate clear balanced arguments, analysing both the good and bad, how things were viewed from different perspectives etc should be the skill focus. Pupils should be taught how a wide variety of past events have shaped today. The rise and fall of empires. It’s impossible to teach all of history so it’s importyto equip students with the skills to actively understand the boys of the past most relevant to them themselves.

History is so wide, apartheid is a minuscule event in history, yes it might be important to certain groups, and fit in with current focuses, but in shaping the U.K. and wider world fairly small. There are 100s of other historical events which are ignored which actually were very important. Tell people there was crusades in what is now southern France Christians v Christian not Muslim people are confused. Explain about the history of expulsion of Jews which went on for centuries in Europe and they might understand both the holocaust and the Israel issue a little bit more. Tell them on sheer numbers Stalin was probably worse than Hitler, explain about the true nature of the Reformation and witch hunts we would probably learn a lot more about the dangers of current society. History as a subject has been increasingly sidelined for the importance of STEM subjects, but without understanding our past we can’t understand our present and shape our future.

mustlovegin · 29/10/2021 22:28

Perhaps the selection process for the curriculum should be framed in a different way so that the focus is more on the injustices rather than the victories

Who in their right mind would want to do that? It will not lead to more 'empathy' and 'kindness', it will encourage further division and hold us back

JaninaDuszejko · 29/10/2021 22:26

Slavery was prohibited in England after 1807. I don't think many countries banned it earlier

The slave trade was banned in the British Empire in 1807 but slavery wasn't outlawed in the Empire until 1834, and there was then a transition period, and reparations to the slave owners that was only paid off in the 21st century. Denmark was the first European country to abolish the slave trade in 1792, the last country in the world to ban slavery was Mauritania in 1981.

Ellen2shoes · 29/10/2021 22:12

Perhaps the selection process for the curriculum should be framed in a different way so that the focus is more on the injustices rather than the victories. There as so many facts - it is about the selection of facts taught. Many posters on here have talked about genocides throughout history. Apartheid and the Holocaust in my British, Western view are the seminal 20th century lenses through which other injustices could be understood or taught. Maybe that way our children would grow up having more empathy and kindness? Not knocking this generation - they are super aware of environmental issues and can teach us a thing or two, but sometimes I wonder if the reason that woke culture is accused of being shallow and self righteous is because of this lack? They can be so mean too!

XingMing · 29/10/2021 22:02

@EllenTwoShoes, I think there's a very fine line to be trodden here, in between acknowledging inward migration as mainly desired and desirable, and remembering that the UK has been at the leading edge of progressive thought since about 1700. Without denying that the UK has often got things wrong (often important ones), it has IMO more often got them almost right rather than mostly wrong.

merrymouse · 29/10/2021 21:56

It's impossible to study everything in history, which is why the history syllabus is as much about how to analyse and understand history, and hopefully inspire an interest in history, as it is about learning facts.

There just isn't enough time to cram everything in in the time available. However, there is no reason why people shouldn't carry on learning about history in the decades after they leave school. It's not as though there aren't hundreds of tv and radio programmes, podcasts, films and books to learn from.

XingMing · 29/10/2021 21:48

Slavery was prohibited in England after 1807. I don't think many countries banned it earlier (but could be wrong); NZ had barely been discovered and was not fully explored then. The past was a much harder, nastier place than most of us can imagine now, and the rules we hold dear today just didn't apply.

NovemberWitch · 29/10/2021 21:42

Don’t you lot talk to your children about important stuff; history, current affairs, environmental issues, human rights and politics?
Or do you rely on schools for everything from toilet training to safe sex instruction?

Only so many hours in the school day, and every month there’s another thing that ‘Ought to be taught in schools’
Parents need to step up more.

Dnaltocs · 29/10/2021 21:31

Some things we have to teach at home.
We’re not taught about the Highland Clearances or the then ban on speaking Gaelic, the Irish Potato Famine. Or the British troops coming to Glasgow to remove the Scottish troops to barracks. The English - British groups, were then told by Winston Churchill to fire at the hungriest of Glasgow residents who were starving.
Some Irish were sold as slaves, sectarianism etc.
Do we hear of this in British history - no!
Lots we are not taught.

msgreen · 29/10/2021 21:30

Read this thread and asked my 18 year old ,who is well read well educated ,I am always amazed at the stuff he knows ,until now
he had no idea... but knows of Nelson Mandela ,and De Kirk
how is that possible

JaninaDuszejko · 29/10/2021 21:26

My kids school shared a list of books they were going to read in form. The only women were black Americans and the only black people were American women. I do worry that it's too easy to use American literature to tick the 'black' or 'women' token box when actually it would make more sense to cover British colonialism in India or Africa. The only black kids at our school (in a very white part of the UK) have come from Africa, not from the US and there are far more people of Indian extraction. Our involvement in apartheid would make more sense to study than segregation in the US. Why have I only learnt about the Biafran War in my 50s (thanks to Chimamanda Adichie Ngozi) but learnt about black slaves in the US at 6 (thanks to Roots which of course suggests the UK still had slavery in the 1850s)?

I do think that the varied experiences of colonialism (rather than segregation in the southern states) should be covered more than it is in the English and Scottish history curriculums. I did history Higher in Scotland in the 1980s and while half the course was European history we learnt nothing about British colonialism apart from the Glaswegian Tobacco Lords and the Glasgow cotton trade a century later - no mention of slavery in either case.

lucybluebella26 · 29/10/2021 21:22

@Lockheart

I'm in my 30s and I don't recall being taught about apartheid or slavery.

We were mostly taught about WW1 and 2, and the Russian Revolution.

This ⬆️⬆️⬆️ We were also only taught these things at A level. If you didn't take History as a gcse subject your education basically ended at Queen Victoria.