Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked that 16 year old didn't know about apartheid

506 replies

biddlybop · 28/10/2021 09:12

Recently, I was having a conversation with a teen in the family and mentioned apartheid (think we were talking about films and books based on true events). They asked what apartheid was. I explained, and they had never heard of it.

I was genuinely shocked. We were taught about it in school - in both history, and English. I'm 30, so I wasn't educated decades ago.

Is this not in the curriculum anymore, or is it just her school? I think it's really important that young people are taught about these events, especially as racism is still such a problem.

OP posts:
WhiskyXray · 30/10/2021 18:18

God, don't get me started on values. My child is at a "values based school" [sic] and every month has to do a perfectly moronic collage about a new "value."

How is "hope" a value, though? Are the hopeless then people lacking in moral fibre, or...?

feelingsareweird · 30/10/2021 18:12

@Twelveshoes

‘Romans, tudors, wwii, Wwi, maybe wwii again.’

Neither me nor my kids did the Romans at school. DD and DS went to different schools. DD didn’t do WW1. I only did WW1 because I took GCSE modern world history, which was 30 people in a massive school.

DD did WW2 at GCSE and it was all about life in Germany. It didn’t cover the U.K. at all.

Politicians go on about history, English and PSE because it allows them to make nonsense speeches to the public which have nothing to do with reality and don’t involve them having to do anything.

We do the Tudors because the English reformation is really important. It isn’t anything to be proud of in particular unless you are very into some kind of religious sectarian group or like smashing up statues.

Obviously the exact modules differ but I’d be v surprised if many kids are finishing school having had no lessons ever about at least one of wwii home front, d-day, Wwi (especially since 2014) or the tudors!! The reformation is indeed important in understanding why Britain has developed as it has. Also in depicting Britain (England?!) as independent of Europe, able to branch out on its own. English exceptionalism. Plus the Spanish Armada - plucky Britain against the odds again!

Ask teachers if those speeches don’t involve anyone having to do anything - in my experience teachers have had to rewrite their curriculum materials several times in recent years as a result!

Twelveshoes · 30/10/2021 18:12

In what way are the British values nonsense?

They are democracy, rule of law, liberty and so on aren’t they?

They are not particularly delivered through history. Aren’t they taught through activities like school elections?

MadameMinimes · 30/10/2021 18:09

@feelingsareweird Gove’s ideological obsession was a lot less to do with assembling a new national “narrative” in history and a lot more to do with support for a “knowledge rich” curriculum and a move away from the pedagogy of “discovery learning”. There is still significant flexibility for history departments around the country to choose what to teach within their history classrooms and academisation (I know not a Gove invention) meant huge numbers of schools where history departments were totally free to set their own curriculum for key stage 3. There is not a national narrative that schools are expected to teach. The English school system has typically given schools enormous flexibility in history, even at GCSE and A Level with a huge amount of optionality.

I’m not a Gove fan but I can’t say I’m sorry to see the back of smug, overly smiley trainers at INSET days wanging on about how I should be a “guide on the side” rather than a “sage on a stage”.

Twelveshoes · 30/10/2021 18:07

‘Of course, I agree with everything you’ve said, maybe I didn’t articulate it very well. But none of that comes under patriotism, surely?’

Yes, I think that is what patriotism is for most people. They care about the country they are part of and want to make it better.

Some people will therefore be cautious about viewing the past of a country too negatively because it makes people despondent about their society and not want to contribute to it.

Part of the reason why the narrative of how much ordinary British people have fought for their rights is promoted throughout society (and not through a few lessons) is so that left wing people can participate in patriotism. That’s part of why we commemorated Peterloo and the suffragettes.

feelingsareweird · 30/10/2021 18:05

[quote RedMarauder]@feelingsareweird if you point out to children other Empires that existed at the time e.g. French with the troubles that have stemmed from it and other Empires in history e g. Roman then how can children be turned against Britain?

The statement is illogical.[/quote]
Yes that’s my whole point, it’s illogical to get upset about teaching colonialism. But just look at the headlines and see all the frothing about decolonising the curriculum, museums etc!!

feelingsareweird · 30/10/2021 18:02

@RedMarauder

So why did Gove make such a fuss about reorganising the curriculum to foreground ‘British values’ and tell teachers to stop showing blackadder?

Political grand standing.

I remember doing an essay question on what are British values for a university course. There aren't one set of British values it depends on your individual background, where you live and the people around you.

Yes that’s the point. And the curriculum now has to include these nonsense British values as defined by the Tory party. Because school history curriculums all over the world are a direct reflection of political agendas.
RedMarauder · 30/10/2021 18:02

@feelingsareweird if you point out to children other Empires that existed at the time e.g. French with the troubles that have stemmed from it and other Empires in history e g. Roman then how can children be turned against Britain?

The statement is illogical.

Twelveshoes · 30/10/2021 18:00

‘Romans, tudors, wwii, Wwi, maybe wwii again.’

Neither me nor my kids did the Romans at school. DD and DS went to different schools. DD didn’t do WW1. I only did WW1 because I took GCSE modern world history, which was 30 people in a massive school.

DD did WW2 at GCSE and it was all about life in Germany. It didn’t cover the U.K. at all.

Politicians go on about history, English and PSE because it allows them to make nonsense speeches to the public which have nothing to do with reality and don’t involve them having to do anything.

We do the Tudors because the English reformation is really important. It isn’t anything to be proud of in particular unless you are very into some kind of religious sectarian group or like smashing up statues.

RedMarauder · 30/10/2021 18:00

So why did Gove make such a fuss about reorganising the curriculum to foreground ‘British values’ and tell teachers to stop showing blackadder?

Political grand standing.

I remember doing an essay question on what are British values for a university course. There aren't one set of British values it depends on your individual background, where you live and the people around you.

feelingsareweird · 30/10/2021 17:58

@Twelveshoes

‘I think there’s a difference between a sense of social responsibility, even feeling glad to have been born into and able to contribute towards a democratic society, and feeling love and pride towards the political boundaries I was born into by chance.’

Not sure what this has got to do with what I said. We can have a sense of social responsibility towards people all over the world.

But our social contract is between us and the rest of the people we are part of a democracy with now. We are consenting to be part of that democracy together and we maintain that democracy.

It isn’t about whether or not you are born into it. It is about contributing to that democracy so that it continues to exist. If you don’t actually care about it anymore than you care about, say, Iraq or Peru, why even bother worrying about the British schooling system in particular?

Of course, I agree with everything you’ve said, maybe I didn’t articulate it very well. But none of that comes under patriotism, surely? I care about British education because it’s the education system I have experienced, that my taxes pay for, that my kids will go through, that I have a small hope of changing for the better through my vote and my work. Not because of some abstract love/pride for Britain, which is what PP seems to be referring to with arguments that we shouldn’t ‘turn children against Britain’ by teaching them about colonialism.
feelingsareweird · 30/10/2021 17:52

@Twelveshoes

‘School history plays a big role in imparting our national narrative to the population, as determined by whoever is in power at the time.’

It really doesn’t. We study very little history at school and there is a great deal of variation between schools.

You can’t make a national narrative out of it.

So why did Gove make such a fuss about reorganising the curriculum to foreground ‘British values’ and tell teachers to stop showing blackadder? Why would he care? There is very little variation in the key topics - Romans, tudors, wwii, Wwi, maybe wwii again. Specifically, the bits of those periods that depict Britain in a certain way (plucky Britain standing firm against huge odds) and encourage us to participate in those rituals of the national story - Poppy wearing, Remembrance Sunday…
SpeedRunParent · 30/10/2021 17:45

There is an absolute chasm of difference in the knowledge teens have, people too come to mention it. Some people grow up in households where history and current affairs are discussed all the time, some don't.

Twelveshoes · 30/10/2021 17:43

‘I think there’s a difference between a sense of social responsibility, even feeling glad to have been born into and able to contribute towards a democratic society, and feeling love and pride towards the political boundaries I was born into by chance.’

Not sure what this has got to do with what I said. We can have a sense of social responsibility towards people all over the world.

But our social contract is between us and the rest of the people we are part of a democracy with now. We are consenting to be part of that democracy together and we maintain that democracy.

It isn’t about whether or not you are born into it. It is about contributing to that democracy so that it continues to exist. If you don’t actually care about it anymore than you care about, say, Iraq or Peru, why even bother worrying about the British schooling system in particular?

Twelveshoes · 30/10/2021 17:36

‘School history plays a big role in imparting our national narrative to the population, as determined by whoever is in power at the time.’

It really doesn’t. We study very little history at school and there is a great deal of variation between schools.

You can’t make a national narrative out of it.

feelingsareweird · 30/10/2021 16:35

@Twelveshoes

‘…so if, as you’ve implied, you feel this personal connection specifically to Britain, it must be to a political construct. Which is why I find patriotism very strange, tbh.’

Why would this be odd? We have agreed to be a nation state and live under the same laws and government. We have a social contract with each other to come to decisions together, to provide each other with healthcare, social care, an income to meet our basic needs, to protect our shared environment, to provide support if one of us is forced abroad or threatened by a foreign state while abroad.

If we don’t feel a sense of personal connection and responsibility to the rest of the nation our society won’t hold together.

I think there’s a difference between a sense of social responsibility, even feeling glad to have been born into and able to contribute towards a democratic society, and feeling love and pride towards the political boundaries I was born into by chance. I find it odd that people feel so much love and pride for that political entity that they are uncomfortable discussing things people who happened to be born in the same nation state did in the past, to the point they’d try to censor those things.

And all history is about political goals. ESPECIALLY the school curriculum!! Why do you think people get so frothy about it if it’s just about source analysis skills?! School history plays a big role in imparting our national narrative to the population, as determined by whoever is in power at the time. Hence the point of this thread in the first place - what should be part of that narrative is always going to be contested.

Shasha17 · 30/10/2021 15:43

I wasnt taught about it until I took history A Level voluntarily.

MadameMinimes · 30/10/2021 15:36

@WhiskyXray Grin

dotoallasyouwouldbedoneby · 30/10/2021 15:35

@ThinWomansBrain

I was at school in the 60's - 70's - aware of it through current affairs in the 70's, but can still recall being shocked to learn a bit about it in later years at primary school; we had these colour coded learning and comprehension cards, and I distinctly remember one about the death of Martin Luther King - but other than that, no formal teaching about it. (Does anyone else remember those SRA reading cards, I used to love them!) Equally, although I knew bits about the war, there was little formal teaching about it - I didn't learn about the holocaust or the occupation of France until mid teens, when on a french exchange stay. Most history featured on Romans, Tudors & Stuarts - with little joining of the gaps in between!
www.mheducation.com.au/schools/literacy/reading-laboratory

Yes I remember the SRA Laboratory Reading Comprehension cards. Encountered them late Junior School as I moved to a new area. I found them quite Americanised.

WhiskyXray · 30/10/2021 15:33

You'll be telling us Solzhenitsyn isn't to be taken uncriticially as 100% accurate gospel next. /s

HippeePrincess · 30/10/2021 15:31

YABU, I'm in my 30's and I have no idea what it is.

MadameMinimes · 30/10/2021 15:16

@Ibelieveinghosts

I mean, you could probably scrape together a number higher than 11 million by adding in all of the deaths from Gulags, famines and all of the combat deaths in the Cold War but the question is why would you? The original estimates of 15 or 20 million deaths in Gulags and through dekulakisation were never based on any figures at all. They came from guesstimates by defectors who based their numbers on hearsay and anecdote.

More importantly, if you use that measure to judge Stalin, then you have to apply the same to Hitler and hold him responsible for all of the 75 million or so people who died in World War Two.

I do teach students to look at numbers objectively. That why I may seem a bit nit-picky over figures that were once accepted as “accurate”. Whether Hitler of Stalin killed more people is not a matter of “which figures you look at”. It is objectively the case that Hitler killed more people than Stalin. You may have been taught differently at school, but the historians then were mistaken. Some things are up for discussion and open to debate, but barring some fundamental new evidence, which of those two leaders killed more people is not one of them. The figures are conclusive.

Ibelieveinghosts · 30/10/2021 14:32

[quote MadameMinimes]@Ibelieveinghosts

I think it’s important to point out that the whole “Stalin killed more people than Hitler” thing is old Cold War propaganda. The fact is that around 90% or more of the people who went into the gulag survived and the best estimates for the number that died in the gulags is somewhere in the region of 1.5 million over a period of 20 or so years. The nazis killed 6 million Jews and a total of around 11 million civilians, with most of those deaths happening between 1941-1945. Stalin was an awful leader, and his crimes are horrific enough, but during the Cold War the number of people he killed was dramatically overestimated for ideological reasons.

We should not be teaching children that Stalin killed more people than Hitler because it isn’t true. Even if you add the famine deaths to his “toll”, which is a fundamentally different thing to systematically gassing people to death IMO, the numbers still don’t stack up.[/quote]
Well it depends which figures you look at I suppose and what you count as culpable deaths -do you count combat deaths? Deaths arising out of the Cold War era etc? and obviously factor in the different er record keeping systems. The Germans were probably a lot more efficient in this. I suppose we could also compare with Mao. Maybe the important thing to teach Kids is look at all numbers objectively.

Re witch hunts, it’s not about numbers it’s about the way people who could be classed as different are treated. Very relevant to today.

Lies, damn lies and statistics eh?

Twelveshoes · 30/10/2021 14:31

Merrymouse, yes, I think you have summed all that up perfectly.

History lessons aren’t there to meet people’s political goals.

merrymouse · 30/10/2021 12:39

History lessons teach people to analyse source material, understand different view points and think about the influences (geographical, political, beliefs, culture) that led to a particular event.

It's not about teaching children that a particular event was good or bad (although there are times when this will be blindingly obvious).

You don't learn about victories and injustices as victories and injustices, you learn about how to make an argument to back up your conclusions using historical data.

A personal sense of patriotism, or lack of it, is rather beside the point.