Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked that 16 year old didn't know about apartheid

506 replies

biddlybop · 28/10/2021 09:12

Recently, I was having a conversation with a teen in the family and mentioned apartheid (think we were talking about films and books based on true events). They asked what apartheid was. I explained, and they had never heard of it.

I was genuinely shocked. We were taught about it in school - in both history, and English. I'm 30, so I wasn't educated decades ago.

Is this not in the curriculum anymore, or is it just her school? I think it's really important that young people are taught about these events, especially as racism is still such a problem.

OP posts:
museumum · 28/10/2021 10:46

I learned about it in school in the 80/90s. we watched Cry Freedom about Steve Biko.
But there is limited room in the curriculum, today I might feel that the Transatlantic slave trade and the Windrush might be higher priority to cover in terms of treatment of Black people. And, as a previous poster said, partition of India is important to understand too in terms of our society here in the UK.

JaninaDuszejko · 28/10/2021 10:45

What exactly are the "rights" of apartheid ? I'd be curious to know. After all, balance and all that. There must have been some good ?

My grandfather thought putting Mandela in prison was absolutely the right thing because he was a communist and terrorist, the white minority were terrified of what would happen if apartheid was removed. And this is why it's important to teach about South Africa and Britain's part in its history, it's too easy to other people from the past who don't have 21st century values but if we don't understand why apartheid existed we can't stop it happening again.

thecatsthecats · 28/10/2021 10:44

If you're thirty, you were at school at least a decade ago. And at a time when Apartheid was a very recent issue for the staff, in the same way for staff now it would be 9/11.

As a history graduate, I have to say YABU. I get so annoyed when people expect me to know ALL history, because I studied a bit of it.

And though I do agree that we ought to learn from history, there's something to be said for forgetting some of it. History is hugely accessible, relatable and "present" via the Internet. I'm not sure that's entirely helpful to learning from it when so many seem eager to rehash it.

sashagabadon · 28/10/2021 10:44

Most of us in our 40’s lived through it, it wasn’t history exactly. I watched Nelson Mandela walk out of robin island live. I went to an amnesty concert at Wembley to help end apartheid. It was on the news regularly. It’s still quite recent “history” really so not a massive surprise it wasn’t immediately put on the national curriculum for history the moment it ended. 30 year olds are probably a bit too young to remember living through it.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 28/10/2021 10:43

This kind of thing is the sort of knowledge parents should be imparting to their own children. How on earth can a child get to 16 and NEVER have been made aware of the manifestations of inequality by his own parents? What the bloody hell do people talk about with their kids?

Just how much time do you actually think school have to teach history? You should also bear in mind that the history curriculum is heavily skewed towards British history and then the World Wars.

It's a lack of social and intellectual rigour within your own family. Not the school.

WhateverHappenedToMe · 28/10/2021 10:40

This is an example of what may well happen if society "cancels" people rather than allowing people to hear opposing views and discuss them.

nettie434 · 28/10/2021 10:40

@WhiskyXray

My KS2 child learnt about it. "Journey to Joburg" was a set text and a discussion of apartheid accompanied that. They have also learnt a lot about famous black people for Black History Month, albeit with a weirdly American focus- Rosa Parks, MLK, Michelle Obama and others.
I think that black history is often taught with a very American focus, unsurprising because of the consequences of slavery, but it does mean that it's easy to get a distorted view about what was happening in other countries too. I would have thought it came up in other contexts, like learning about Nelson Mandela.

I am so old that apartheid was still in existence when I was at school and it was often incorporated into the curriculum. However, the legacy of apartheid still exists today so it's wrong to see it as just being about history. The shock when the South African Quinton de Kock refused to take the knee at the cricket yesterday (although he has since apologised) is evidence of its ongoing effects.

ScaryHairyMcClary · 28/10/2021 10:40

I think schools and the curriculum need to avoid politicising the teaching of history as much as possible, i.e. there should be some objective criteria for choosing the topics. For example, black history might be really important to you, but for others the partition of India and Pakistan might be really important. Or the holocaust, or the oppression of women, or the Cold War... For you, black history in S Africa might be important but for others the UK involvement in slavery might be more relevant.

Personally, I feel that history as taught in UK schools ought to focus on the UK and Europe. There is plenty of oppression to teach about here!

sashh · 28/10/2021 10:38

And I'm actually a person that quite likes history so watch a lot of films and documentary type shows to learn more. Does anyone know if there is a relevant one to learn more about apartheid?

Not a documentary but a book, "When she was white" by Judith Stone.

It's the true story of Sandra Lang, her parents were Apartheid supporting africanas, everything was fine until she went to school.

There her dark skin and afro hair was a problem, the school was whites only and they didn't believe she was white.

The book talks about her life but also the changes in SA law and how people were 'classified' so Sandra Lang in her life was classified as black, white and coloured at different times.

The book continues with the dismantling of apartheid and talks about the 'education' adults (particularly white) had to undergo in the work place. One white man was horrified that he would have to wash his hands in the same sink as a black man, the trainer asked who washed his sink at him and it was a black maid, it had not occurred to him that at home he washed his hands in a basin washed by a black person.

The different attempts to classify people and the tests applied would be laughable if the subject was not so serious.

If DNA testing had been available then apartheid could not have continued.

I think there's a big difference between WW2 which is still very much in your face and by definition was the whole world involved, and apartheid which was only one country.

Hmmm but SA history is quite intertwined with British history, concentration camps (segregated by race by the British) the Boer Wars, the restrictions on black people owning land imposed by Britain and the Netherlands, SA also played a part in WWII, well parts, different depending on skin colour.

daisypond · 28/10/2021 10:37

What exactly are the "rights" of apartheid ?

I phrased that badly. I meant the rights and wrongs of boycotting sport in South Africa. It was a massive, massive issue. Should the English cricket team play in South Africa? Etc. South Africa was a pariah country in much of the world. Similar as arguments today about should people trade with, go on holiday to or buy products from Myanmar or North Korea.

Plantstrees · 28/10/2021 10:35

I personally think a lot of responsibility for this sort of thing is down to parents. I taught my children about apartheid when they were quite young but then we had family connections to South Africa. I tackled a lot of difficult subjects by reading books and watching films with them and then critically thinking about and discussing the issues that arose. It was a good way of introducing them to different cultures and to the history of different regions of the world.

The school curriculum approach is to separate subjects, history from English literature for example, causing a disconnect that is difficult for some children to overcome. Reading a fiction book in an English lesson, often the children don't grasp how much of the background is real and what is fiction. Even if they do understand, often the English teacher is not in a good position to link it to the social and political history of the period whether due to either knowledge or time restrictions. Likewise, history classes do not delve into the literature that may provide a better insight to the social history, etc.

biddlybop · 28/10/2021 10:35

What exactly are the "rights" of apartheid ? I'd be curious to know. After all, balance and all that. There must have been some good ?

There wasn't any good

OP posts:
LucentBlade · 28/10/2021 10:34

My family lived in South Africa for almost a decade before I was born they moved there in the 1950’s. I’m in my fifties and a lot younger than my siblings, one of my sisters was born there. They left because of escalating violence in the very early sixties. My Mother was also worried that in a few years my brother would be drafted in to the army, he was around 15 when they left.

I have heard many tales over the years of how beautiful it was and their voyage there and back, of chameleons in the house to catch insects and how my Mother chopped a bird eating spider in half with a spade that got in the house. How baboons came down off the mountain one time to raid all the bins.

She also talked about the political situation and what happened to the family. There are many stories but these snippets are the ones that stick with me.

She helped take a man to hospital that was dumped on the side of the road that had both of his hands cut off. She was prosecuted for letting her maid sit in the front of her car. A girl was snatched and gang raped and left for dead in my sisters class who was about 11 at the time. Her car was surrounded in a protest once and she said my sister who was a toddler at the time was waving and smiling at the rioters and she thinks that saved them.

My brother who has now sadly died and my eldest sister spoke quite good Afrikaans and used to sing nursery rhymes to me in it as a small child.

Mother would never buy anything South African and berated the local grocer for stocking Cape grapes once.

Megan2018 · 28/10/2021 10:33

I'm 43 and wasn't taught about apartheid at school that I can recall - but I knew about it as it was heavily in the news when I was young as it was in the lead up to it ending.
We did cover slavery though in Eng Lit.

RedMarauder · 28/10/2021 10:32

I'm in my 40s.

We couldn't study apartheid in history as it was still in place while we were at school so it was current affairs. The theories behind it were covered in other subject areas plus we had a few exiled South Africans, both teachers and pupils, in school.

Also didn't study the holocaust or the World Wars at secondary school. Though everyone was aware of it and those of us who did one History GCSE syllabus studied Germany from 1919 to 1939, The Russian Revolution covering Russia up until 1939, The Cold War and the break up for the British Empire from 1946 to 1960.

daisypond · 28/10/2021 10:32

I’ve just asked my 22-year-old if she knows what apartheid is. She said of course she does, and gave me a potted account. She didn’t do history GCSE at school. The popular Nought and Crosses trilogy books for teens would surely have brought the issue to life as well for younger people.

TomPinch · 28/10/2021 10:28

@SerendipityJane

Families were divided over the rights and wrongs of it.

What exactly are the "rights" of apartheid ? I'd be curious to know. After all, balance and all that. There must have been some good ?

There wasn't any 'right' about it. However, lots of South African whites acquiesced out of fear of being massacred, and the government strongly encouraged this belief in them.

It's a shame that memory of apartheid is fading in the UK, and also what South Africans achieved in moving on from it without civil war: it was a phenomenal achievement.

QueenofLouisiana · 28/10/2021 10:28

@TheMarzipanDildo the current curriculum was introduced in 2014. The narrow focus explain why we often teach other aspects through English (ie. immigration, apartheid, slavery are all things I’ve taught through the selection of texts in English).

Kuachui · 28/10/2021 10:27

im 28 and have no idea what you are talking about

Meloncurse · 28/10/2021 10:26

I'm 40 so aware of apartheid through the news, but I'm not sure it was something that ever came up in school so don't find it surprising that younger people who weren't born in the 90s aren't aware

Our English set text was Talking in Whispers so that dealt with Pinochet in South America

SorrelForbes · 28/10/2021 10:23

I'm 51 and the only time Apartheid was mentioned in school was during an RE lesson.

We did Ag and Ind revolution and a tiny bit about suffragettes. For O levels we covered WWI and (a month before the exams because someone fucked up and didn't realise it was on the syllabus) WWII. For A level it was the cold war, Chinese revolution and the Japanese industrial revolution.

I love history and consider myself to have a fairly broad spread of knowledge but it's been predominantly gained through my own reading.

MumsTheWordFact · 28/10/2021 10:23

I wasn't taught about apartheid at school but then it was in the news anyway since it was ending in my first year of Secondary School.

History is a massive subject and people can't know everything. I find it odd that when the transatlantic slave trade is taught/talked about they forget to mention Black slaves were sold to Europeans by the Black Africans themselves for the most part. I also find it odd almost no one has heard about the Barbary slave trade where millions of White Europeans were taken as slaves by Africans, but there you go, its all political isn't it?

Seasonschange · 28/10/2021 10:22

I’m similar age to you and didn’t learn about it in school. My parents mentioned it in the context of them protesting about it.

CaMePlaitPas · 28/10/2021 10:22

I'm in my 30s and never learnt about apartheid at school. As usual, it was left to black students to shoulder the burden of educating the rest of us on black heritage and history, warts and all. History class was about the war and public health in the 19th century.

Nottheduchess · 28/10/2021 10:22

I’m 40 and wasn’t taught about it in school, I know about it now of course but 16yo me wouldn’t have. Not the whole thing anyway, I mean I knew about slavery and such but wouldn’t have known the word apartheid.