Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Where does everyone stand?

432 replies

pumkinbump · 27/10/2021 23:48

Posting here for traffic.

Married 7 years.

1 child age 6yrs.

Her - forever unemployed by choice. Cheated throughout marriage. DNA test needed on baby as didn't know who the father was. Left 8 months ago with be with someone else which was likely going on before the split. On benefits. Child is autistic so gets a mobility car which she has.

Him - full time worker. Paid for deposit on house. Paid every bill and mortgage payment for the duration of the relationship. Has their son 4/5 nights out of 7 as she doesn't want to. Pays her £100 a month despite this, plus extra for shoes, clothes etc.

He is terrified that she's going to claim half of the house in divorce.

Does anyone have any advice where he would stand on this?

Thanks in advance.

OP posts:
PegasusReturns · 28/10/2021 08:02

I think you’ve posted about this before? You’re the girlfriend no?

2 things:

• starting point on divorce is 50/50 split the ex will almost certainly get at least half of the house

• be aware of a man who bitches about his “awful” ex wife. It’s a huge red flag to be so disrespectful of the mother of your child.

itsgettingwierd · 28/10/2021 07:59

What needs to be presented is facts.

As well as financial settlement they need to get a child arrangement order sorted. This can be applied for from each parent about how much they wish to care for child. Usually it's 50/50.

If it's currently 70:30 he can ask for that to be formalised and the financial settlement re childcare will come from that.

Unfortunately what someone has done with regards aduktary etc doesn't count in a settlement.

Artie30 · 28/10/2021 07:56

I have no advice but whoever you are sounds really judgmental of the mother. I have an autistic son, I do not get a mobility - most parents of autistic children do not! I do not work because it's really hard to find work around children with sen!

HestersSamplerofCarrots · 28/10/2021 07:56

What she claims isn’t necessarily the same as what is classed as a marital asset, or what could be agreed through mediation or awarded by a judge.

FatCatThinCat · 28/10/2021 07:41

Who does the school run if dad is working fulltime? Bet mum does. But he wants to take the mobility car off her? And the house? What a charmer.

londonrach · 28/10/2021 07:37

Get legal advice.

However house be 50:50 usually as you married and partnership one working one looking after child. Affairs don't count. Get legal advice

honkytonkheroe · 28/10/2021 07:36

The starting point is 50/50 split. It’s unlikely to change much from that to be honest but it is anyone’s guess on the day if it went to court. Ignore the infidelity as it’s a red herring. Basically she looked after the child and he worked. If he was on his own he would have presumably had to pay some child care. It would take quite a lot to move from a 50/50 split. It depends how much the deposit was as to whether that has an impact.

RudestLittleMadam · 28/10/2021 07:34

@Morph2lcfc

if hes working full time who is looking after child before and after school hours? I know from experience it’s pretty much impossible to work full time and care for an Sen child as there just aren’t the same options with childminders/ after school clubs you get with an nt child. The post is making out dad has child all the time but how is this even possible if he works full time
I wondered that. But then the OP doesn’t seem to know who did the majority of care while the parents were still together when it was most likely the mum by default because the dad was at work. Unless they were lucky enough to have found suitable childcare.
RudestLittleMadam · 28/10/2021 07:30

Ignoring most of it, the DLA is for the child, not their parents, as is the car. Therefore whoever has the child most should be claiming the DLA. As far as I know, you can’t split it.

I’m interested that the father is a friend of yours Hmm but you don’t know who did the lion’s share of caring for a child with presumably complex needs and quite severe autism. I’m assuming severe autism because they have a mobility car. They don’t just give those out, you have to be in receipt of higher rate mobility element of DLA. If mum was at home she wasn’t “refusing to work” she presumably claimed carers allowance, for good reason.

3peassuit · 28/10/2021 07:26

It doesn’t matter where Mumsnet stands, your friend should see a solicitor.

Pandaly · 28/10/2021 07:23

I'd get the maintenance and contact pattern formalised

Pandaly · 28/10/2021 07:23

Thing is presumably he was happy to be the main earner for that long and pay the bills and stuff while she didn't work and looked after their child. So I'm not sure how the court will look at it now he's decided he wasn't happy. I think your view is very biased towards him.

fourminutestosavetheworld · 28/10/2021 07:17

OP, the fact that she cheated during the marriage, needed a DNA test to confirm paternity of her child and ultimately left for another man will have no bearing whatsoever on how the finances are legally divided.

They were married and had a child so the starting point is 50/50 on everything.

The courts will not see her as unemployed but as a SAHM for their child. Her contribution to the marriage will be seen as equal to that of her husband who provided financially.

50/50 is the starting point but the priority will be to ensure that the child's needs are met. Often the main carer is able to remain in the house for an agreed amount of time for this reason, and the split slides 60/40 or 70/30 in favour of the main carer. But will he really be the main carer, permanently, if he works ft and mum doesn't work at all?

Morph2lcfc · 28/10/2021 07:16

if hes working full time who is looking after child before and after school hours? I know from experience it’s pretty much impossible to work full time and care for an Sen child as there just aren’t the same options with childminders/ after school clubs you get with an nt child. The post is making out dad has child all the time but how is this even possible if he works full time

Fetarabbit · 28/10/2021 07:04

OP you should have reversed the roles in this scenario. Realistically you’re never going to get a genuine response when the man is the one who has been wronged, because according to MN women are always in the right, even if they shirk responsibility for their children the man is usually to blame.

A tale as old as time.

Of course this is only one, biased side of the story, but assuming what has been posted is the truth, she's the one that left for another man and only has the child a few nights a week, if that was a man of course people would be scathing. Especially if she worked and he didn't.

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 28/10/2021 06:57

@Coyoacan

Who looks after the child while our hero is working fulltime and the evil mother is off galavanting with one of her many lovers?
Presumably the woman with the baby due soon? The pumpkinbump OP. Who sounds like she's living in the house the wicked mother owns half of.

He will do the same to you.

MoveAhoy · 28/10/2021 06:46

@lljkk and @HeartsAndClubs

If you would have seen this post as anything but a one sided story based on anger because of the assumed sexes of the proponents then that's your bias to deal with.

Don't tar all of MN with your own insecurities.

Terfydactyl · 28/10/2021 06:45

@lljkk

If the sexes were reverse then MNers would be exasperating lots about cock-lodgers.
Do cock lodgers mostly look after a disabled child? Not the ones I've heard about.
lljkk · 28/10/2021 06:38

If the sexes were reverse then MNers would be exasperating lots about cock-lodgers.

HeartsAndClubs · 28/10/2021 06:37

OP you should have reversed the roles in this scenario. Realistically you’re never going to get a genuine response when the man is the one who has been wronged, because according to MN women are always in the right, even if they shirk responsibility for their children the man is usually to blame.

Realistically the house may be split 50/50 but he would be better off applying for full residency on the basis the child spends most nights with him. He would likely still have to buy her out, but what you need to look at there is the equity not the full mortgage value. Assuming he’s the one who pays the mortgage anyway, if he can aford to pay her half of the equity he will be able to remain in the family home. Even more so if it is proven that the child spends the majority of time with him anyway.

The rights and wrongs of how the marriage ended and who did what and paid for what will not be taken into account here.

Divorce is essentially the ending of a financial contract in the same way that marriage is a financial contract. The emotional bit isn’t something the courts are interested in, and neither should they be, as everyone is going to have their own version of events and if the emotional side were taken into account nobody would ever agree and the process would take significantly longer while they played a game of “he said/she said.”

Frankii · 28/10/2021 06:34

"The facts:

Her: a fucking evil witch. Oh the stories I could tell!

Him: a hero, an innocent poet, a knight in shining armour, a veritable Adonis of our time.

The question: how can said hero fuck her over as much as possible?"

MsTSwift · 28/10/2021 06:33

I used to do some divorce work years ago and would feel all sorry and aggrieved for my client then the particulars from the other side would arrive…

onelittlefrog · 28/10/2021 06:29

It will most likely be split 50/50. Adultery doesn't normally affect anything, particularly if it's been more than 6 months. And obviously her contribution to the household will be considered - childcare and housekeeping. She's not really "unemployed" if she is looking after a disabled child.

The only thing that could potentially affect it is the domestic violence you mentioned. However, there would have to be proof that it happened, and usually only if it is serious trauma.

He needs to talk to a lawyer, basically. But the court will likely come down 50/50, particularly as there is a disabled child involved that needs providing for.

Whereismumhiding3 · 28/10/2021 06:26

*Does not 'dies' Hmm and 'for' not 'fit'

Whereismumhiding3 · 28/10/2021 06:25

He can apply for residency. He already has majority of childcare/ child nights. She is NRP so he can claim child benefit and DLA for child- benefits fit children go with who claims CB although if he earns too much may want to leave things as they are.

I wouldn't make life difficult fit the mum if I were him. But if he genuinely dies most of childcare and is the resident parent the house will go mostly to him, as whilst it is a shared marital asset, if he has care of child then judges favour that & she may get a small %