Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Where does everyone stand?

432 replies

pumkinbump · 27/10/2021 23:48

Posting here for traffic.

Married 7 years.

1 child age 6yrs.

Her - forever unemployed by choice. Cheated throughout marriage. DNA test needed on baby as didn't know who the father was. Left 8 months ago with be with someone else which was likely going on before the split. On benefits. Child is autistic so gets a mobility car which she has.

Him - full time worker. Paid for deposit on house. Paid every bill and mortgage payment for the duration of the relationship. Has their son 4/5 nights out of 7 as she doesn't want to. Pays her £100 a month despite this, plus extra for shoes, clothes etc.

He is terrified that she's going to claim half of the house in divorce.

Does anyone have any advice where he would stand on this?

Thanks in advance.

OP posts:
Mothership4two · 28/10/2021 09:46

What happened during the relationship (unemployed, cheating, DNA test, affair) has no bearing on the legalities of the divorce. He needs professional legal advice and maintenance/custody balance needs addressing.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 28/10/2021 09:34

But if the man walked out and went to live with another woman and left the mother to cope alone and he kept the disability car no one would say he deserved 50% and round of applause.

There is plenty of defending of men on MN too even if it is over-shadowed by those who feel a woman is always in the right. People do make assumptions in these situations - based perhaps on their experiences which are of women doing 90+% of the childcare and home management etc. Some people find it harder to consider whether that is always the case and to accept that some men are doing what women have traditionally done. But it's not right to say "no-one" would. I have defended men who have been primary carers and who are still expected to contribute financially or be happy with any tiny amounts of money they are allowed access to. There is bias against men but that does not make the man in this situation right.

@BillMasen it's hard to say whether the man does more care without more detail. Yes he has the child for most nights, but we don't know who looks after the child after school. The man works FT, after school care until about 4:30 happens 2 days a week. So who does the rest of the care? It is possible that the man has adapted hours of work and really does do the full care on the nights he has the child though that still leaves the question of who is looking after the child on the 5 days on which the child sleeps at dad's in the holidays. It's very possible that the mother is actually still doing a lot albeit not at night. You may be right but we need more of those facts before we can judge.

PegasusReturns · 28/10/2021 09:32

I see lots of posts where the “facts” are accepted and advised upon, and in this case they are not being

This OP has posted repeatedly on this matter. She’s the girlfriend and the “facts” are that she’s being misled appallingly by the father in this situation.

Anyone who claims to pay for everything (presumably by way of a job) and also do all the childcare is going to be challenged especially when that child has significant additional needs. Because it cannot be true.

Clocktopus · 28/10/2021 09:28

Would you say a mother with a job can't look after her child? School/child care, lots of us manage or have managed to work fulltime and be the primary care giver

The child in question has disabilities and has had a carer (his mother) rather than going to childcare. There is a severe lack of childcare for children with additional needs, especially wrap-around and school holiday care, so how is the father here continuing to work FT while also caring for a child with complex needs? Is the mother providing the wrap-around care?

BillMasen · 28/10/2021 09:24

@knittingaddict it would change the advice on benefits, cars, cms, potential split of house.

You are ignoring the op stating the man has more care. Surely who has the more care impacts things?

DameMaureen · 28/10/2021 09:24

Sadly bad behaviour does not count towards what is legal when it comes to divorces . Start the process.

ancientgran · 28/10/2021 09:19

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee

I think there is bias against men here. But the issue is that, when men are the SAHP or main carer, their contribution is dismissed. So the response the man in this situation is the response the woman should get if the roles were reversed. The inequity does not mean that the way the man is being talked about here is wrong.
But if the man walked out and went to live with another woman and left the mother to cope alone and he kept the disability car no one would say he deserved 50% and round of applause.
ancientgran · 28/10/2021 09:17

@justustwoandmoo

OP you will never EVER get a fair and balanced view on this from the women of Mumsnet. All men are evil....you should know that!!

Delete the thread and reword it to change the roles (sexes) around and you might get somewhere xx

Very true, no one would say a woman can't be the carer for her child and have a job, no one would say the father should have the mobility car if he only has the child two nights a week and school nights at that.
knittingaddict · 28/10/2021 09:17

@justustwoandmoo

OP you will never EVER get a fair and balanced view on this from the women of Mumsnet. All men are evil....you should know that!!

Delete the thread and reword it to change the roles (sexes) around and you might get somewhere xx

Because that will totally change the financial settlement going forward. Confused
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 28/10/2021 09:16

I think there is bias against men here. But the issue is that, when men are the SAHP or main carer, their contribution is dismissed. So the response the man in this situation is the response the woman should get if the roles were reversed. The inequity does not mean that the way the man is being talked about here is wrong.

ancientgran · 28/10/2021 09:15

@Bythemillpond

I don’t think it matters who did what, when or where.

If 2 people are married, have a child, then the starting point is 50/50.

It doesn’t matter if one person has had no job or slept around the courts aren’t interested.

You say the Dh now has his child for the majority of the time.

I am presuming he has given up his job otherwise how can he look after his child and go out to work at the same time. Or does he only do nights and not days.

Would you say a mother with a job can't look after her child? School/child care, lots of us manage or have managed to work fulltime and be the primary care giver.
BillMasen · 28/10/2021 09:14

@knittingaddict

Take away all the moral indignation and irrelevant detail. So what if she's on benefits and has the mobility car. So what if he pays her money (ever heard of child maintenance). I could go on and on about how much of your post was pointless stuff that makes her look bad and him a saint.

The facts are that they are married and she will receive child maintenance and will get at least 50% of the equity in the house. Presumed faults by the wife will not change anything, thank god.

There is so much more I could say about your op, but it's not worth the energy required.

The facts are that the resident parent is likely to get more than 50% and cms. We don’t know who will be the resident parent, it could be the father based on the op

And if he’s got the kids more, then of course it matters if he’s also paying and she’s also claiming benefits and keeping the car. A man doing that while having the kids less wouldn’t be defended.

knittingaddict · 28/10/2021 09:13

@TractorAndHeadphones

Hahahah if this was a woman talking about her DH there’s be lots of advice on their rights how to get the house etc. No ‘there are several sides to every story’

But since it’s the other way around.. nah we just can’t believe that a man could be screwed over by a fannylodger.

It's not about anyone screwing anyone over. It's simple facts. Child maintenance doesn't care one iota about who slept with who or who did or didn't do the washing up. Same for financial settlements on divorce. They don't make moral judgments.

The op can put as much biased (and it is obviously biased) stuff in her op as she likes, but facts are facts.

DifferentHair · 28/10/2021 09:10

Also her sexual history, particularly that little nugget you put in about the child having a DNA test isn't relevant. If your 'friend' raised that in court he would be identifying himself as a dickhead and doing his ex a great service in terms of the outcome.

Judges hate that shit.

What a disrespectful way to describe the child's mother.

DifferentHair · 28/10/2021 09:07

OP,

You're doing this family no favours by weighing in with your judgment.

She's clearly been a career of a disabled child. That is a significant contribution, and you'll help everyone in this family if you can bring yourself to see it in this light.

The best outcome for the child is for all the adults in his life to show each other kindness and respect.

Clocktopus · 28/10/2021 09:06

"The facts:

Her: a fucking evil witch. Oh the stories I could tell!

Him: a hero, an innocent poet, a knight in shining armour, a veritable Adonis of our time.

The question: how can said hero fuck her over as much as possible?"

Grin

When my parents split up, DF tried so hard to control that narrative. From his side of things you'd think he single-handedly raised us all those years while holding down a FT job. His account of DM was that she was off having numerous affairs, she was abusive to him, she was keeping dark secrets from us all, she was sponging off him and refused to get a proper job, and so on. The reality of it was that he was the one having affairs, between raising four DC including one with additional needs and working two PT jobs (not considered "proper" jobs, of course) as well as running the house DM didn't have the time or energy for an affair. He was the one who was abusive. He was the one keeping secrets.

He was also under the impression that the sadder the tale he could spin for the judge, the bigger the share of the house and assets he would get. The judge very quickly disabused him of that idea and refused to read his laminated file of alleged transgressions by DM.

justustwoandmoo · 28/10/2021 09:05

OP you will never EVER get a fair and balanced view on this from the women of Mumsnet. All men are evil....you should know that!!

Delete the thread and reword it to change the roles (sexes) around and you might get somewhere xx

Oftenithinkaboutit · 28/10/2021 09:04

@BillMasen

Not surprising no, but I’d like to think people would be capable of dealing with each post on its own merits and not assuming/disbelieving based on what happened to them

The op has posted on AIBU

Of course people are going to bring their own experiences to the table. That is what drives their viewpoint.

Has she posted in the legal section - then a more objective response would be more reasonable to expect

knittingaddict · 28/10/2021 09:02

Take away all the moral indignation and irrelevant detail. So what if she's on benefits and has the mobility car. So what if he pays her money (ever heard of child maintenance). I could go on and on about how much of your post was pointless stuff that makes her look bad and him a saint.

The facts are that they are married and she will receive child maintenance and will get at least 50% of the equity in the house. Presumed faults by the wife will not change anything, thank god.

There is so much more I could say about your op, but it's not worth the energy required.

Quartz2208 · 28/10/2021 09:01

The fact that he paid the mortgage and bill on the house whilst married doesnt matter (otherwise can you imagine what would happen). The deposit could if he had ringfenced it at the time but I suspect he did not.

But it is a marital asset

bibliomania · 28/10/2021 08:59

Why do you care what people think? The division of the marital assets is not going to be put to the public vote. It will either be agreed by the parties or decided by a judge if they can't agree, based on law, not your view of the morality.

3WildOnes · 28/10/2021 08:57

It is incredibly difficult to work when your have a child with special needs, unless you are in a job that pays enough for you to be able to afford a highly experienced special needs nanny. Very few jobs offer school hours term time only and even then you would have to factor in all of the appointments the child needs to attend.
He did not pay the bills and mortgage, they both did out of joint family money. You are clearly very biased in your writing.
If she was the full time parent and if she continues to be then she will likely get more than 50%.

Grizzlydog · 28/10/2021 08:57

What is happening to this child before and after school on 4 or 5 days dad has them and is working? Who has him in the school holidays?
50/50 is a fair starting point.
Are the assets enough for both to buy another property of they are divided 50/50?
It's irrelevant who has done what now tbh and all about what is in the best interests of the child.

TatianaBis · 28/10/2021 08:56

Of course division of assets will start at 50:50. She will certainly have a claim on the house, whether it’s exactly half will depend on the settlement.

A friend of mine is getting divorced and has to split the house that she paid for entirely. That’s how it works.

CatJumperTwat · 28/10/2021 08:55

Good luck having a baby with this prince, OP. Great decision there.