Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask about the life experiences of unattractive women

210 replies

Iamnotattractive · 27/10/2021 22:02

Was impressed by the recent thread about pretty privilege, and stories there. Was so different to my experience, it sounded like a different planet.

So, I am an unattractive woman, and have been all my life. No obvious single disfigurement, I just look weird, overall badly put together.

I've been asked out only twice in my life (once at 17, once at 27) - had children with the second guy, despite having serious misgivings, but he was really the only option (it did not last). Men never notice I even exist - even the ones I work with for a year or so struggle to recall my name (I don't mean the immediate team members, but someone further out). I remember all the compliments I was given in my life, as the total number is under 10 Grin. If a guy offered to buy me a drink or offered to carry something heavy for me, my first thought would be that they have some criminal intentions - hypothetically, of course, it never happened in reality.

On the positive side, I have never experienced any inappropriate sexual attention or harassment. I don't also have to worry about losing my looks as I age - if nothing helped me at 16, nothing will help me at almost 40.

So wanted to ask other unattractive women, how does life look for you? Similar to mine?

OP posts:
Glitterblue · 27/10/2021 23:40

I'm horrified that some of you have been stopped in the street to be told how ugly you are 😥 People can be so cruel.

RicherThanYew · 27/10/2021 23:38

I prefer being ugly as it does lend me a certain amount of invisibility but that doesn't work so well around judgy people who love looking for flawed humans so they can feel better about themselves (It's true). My mum set me straight on the matter when I was little when she said "Richer, you'd be almost pretty if you just lost the weight" and I've been obese ever since. Unfortunately it really doesn't protect you from harassment or sexual assault!

Feduphairymclary · 27/10/2021 23:29

I have a very dear friend who is unusual in looks, she has always considered herself ugly (I think she is unique but she's not outwardly conventionally attractive I would agree). As a young woman she deliberately set out to break up the relationship of a man she fancied, who had flirted with her and made it clear he would be happy to have an affair. This was because he was the only man who had ever expressed an interest in her, she was successful in her plan and felt validated that she had "stolen" the man away from his pretty fiancee - in her opinion it meant that she wasn't too ugly to have a relationship. She married him and he cheated regularly, but she stayed with him because she has no confidence that she could attract anyone else.

I find it really sad, that her self worth is completely tied up with being married to someone with a conventionally attractive appearance, despite the fact he is a total shit. It is quite refreshing to read the accounts in this thread, of women who know that they are enough and are liberated enough to not tie themselves to bastards.

Iamnotattractive · 27/10/2021 23:26

@nettytree

I'm married to the the only bloke whose ever asked me out. I was 18 the first time he asked me, but because of low confidence I said no. Finally got together when I was 30. Been married 18 years now.
Almost the same story with me.

I am always amazed by when on MN threads posters advise to quit the relationship as there are hundreds of worthier men just around the corner. Not because I think that relationships have to be maintained at any cost, just surprised that it is so easy for so many people to just walk straight into a new one.

OP posts:
DancinOnTheCeiling · 27/10/2021 23:20

As someone who is ‘average’ looking I just wanted to post to say I’m so sorry to hear that people have been called ugly. Why oh why would anyone be so nasty? My heart breaks for people having to be at the receiving end of such abuse

nettytree · 27/10/2021 23:19

I'm married to the the only bloke whose ever asked me out. I was 18 the first time he asked me, but because of low confidence I said no. Finally got together when I was 30. Been married 18 years now.

TableFlowerss · 27/10/2021 23:18

I agree that being a plain Jane doesn’t mean someone won’t experience sexual harassment of any sort. In some ways it could make the situation worse, as if a guy gets rejected by a woman he deems not attractive, that could make him turn nasty and I guess that’s where the power comes. ‘How dare you not fancy me, I’ll show you etc…’

I do think overall though, being deemed particularly attractive will get more unwanted attention. I don’t mean by wearing make up etc… just some people have a naturally attractive faces

bluebell34567 · 27/10/2021 22:57

I went to the work Christmas party the year I lost all the weight in a size 10 dress and didn’t get a single compliment yet all the women around me were oohing and aahhing over each other’s dresses- I have to say I’ve never forgotten how shit I felt. I tried so hard to look nice for the first time in my new slim self and failed miserably.

they werent nice people.

villanova · 27/10/2021 22:51

Interestingly, I found a different experience with men. I'd say I'm of average appearance, but always been heavy so always the 'ignored friend', plus didn't have any confidence or self-esteem as a teen.

For a long time I've worked with a lot of male scientists, and I've found they're much more willing to talk to me, maybe as they're talking to me as a [person], not as an [attractive female]. I've also found similar in the hobbies I choose, which tend to be male dominated. It may help that I'm married, so it's obvious that I'm interested in the hobby or science, not potential partners, so we get straight to the interesting part of the conversation.
For colleagues in a more commercial role (who do tend to be more attractive & charming), yes the ignoring is more obvious.

ButtonLoon · 27/10/2021 22:44

I don't know if I'm unattractive, but I'm stocky and square jawed and Roman nosed and would certainly never be called pretty. I seem to be invisible to street harrasers (why I don't know) but also have been glad to not have too much attention from men. I think I attracted boyfriends in my youth with my manic pixie attitude.

Iamnotattractive · 27/10/2021 22:40

@clatterclatter

Sometimes I feel like when I make an effort I look worse, I look like me but also with an extra layer of looking crap. Make up never seems to look right and neither does my hair. I do enjoy fashion but don’t have the wages to spend much on it.
I could have written that word by word Grin Makeup seems to make other women prettier, for me it is just a different, more colourful version of ugly. And I used some quite talented make up artists too, not all diy!
OP posts:
Iamnotattractive · 27/10/2021 22:38

Has anyone else on this thread noticed that sometimes men, specifically at work treat you differently if they don’t find you attractive? Bare minimum communication, like you aren’t worth speaking to?
Yes, this is the feeling I was trying to describe. I don't even think that they do it consciously, to be honest. Those famous first seven seconds, which are often mentioned in "make the right first impression" business trainings... I think (heterosexual) men spend five of them estimating whether you are attractive or not. If not, you just don't register with them anymore as a person at all, as if you just don't exist.

OP posts:
clatterclatter · 27/10/2021 22:36

Sometimes I feel like when I make an effort I look worse, I look like me but also with an extra layer of looking crap. Make up never seems to look right and neither does my hair. I do enjoy fashion but don’t have the wages to spend much on it.

BoarOnTheFloor · 27/10/2021 22:36

I’m quite confident and secure in myself and people are often surprised by that - I think a lot of women get a chunk of confidence from how they look/the attention they get from men so don’t understand why I am confident despite not getting that.

I remember a barman flirting with me once (never happens which is why I remember!) and my friend being a bit put out, as she was much prettier than me and so didn’t expect it that way round.

JaceLancs · 27/10/2021 22:34

Just reading other responses
I dress well (to suit me)
Manage female friendships ok
Am seen positively on the whole
Just don’t attract the opposite sex

clatterclatter · 27/10/2021 22:33

I’m here for this thread OP. I’m a plain Jane and I was tubby in my teenage years and early 20s. Never got chatted up, never had a boyfriend, wasn’t kissed until I was 19. In a bit of a crap marriage now with no affection. Even now I’m slimmer I’ve not found it makes much difference.

Has anyone else on this thread noticed that sometimes men, specifically at work treat you differently if they don’t find you attractive? Bare minimum communication, like you aren’t worth speaking to?

JaceLancs · 27/10/2021 22:32

I’ve never felt pretty or thin enough etc
Sadly hasn’t stopped me being sexually abused as a child or hit on as an adult
I have managed relationships and marriage/children but am now long term single and have zero confidence to even consider a relationship or even casual sex despite being confident in my career etc

Iamnotattractive · 27/10/2021 22:32

@DDUW

Never been asked out, never been on a date.

Have any of you been ridiculed for trying to make an effort with your appearance? I used to try to wear nice clothes but I was humiliated by people finding it funny so I stopped.

Yes, mainly by other women tbf. I don't think men noticed anyway.
OP posts:
Iamnotattractive · 27/10/2021 22:31

@Ahhbiscuits

Do you have a link to the other thread OP please? I’ve not seen it but as a person that feels like they wear a cloak of invisibility, I’d be really interested to read others experiences on being attractive and the differences it brings!
Here it is

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4384603-Pretty-privilege-do-you-have-it

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 27/10/2021 22:31

@DDUW

Never been asked out, never been on a date.

Have any of you been ridiculed for trying to make an effort with your appearance? I used to try to wear nice clothes but I was humiliated by people finding it funny so I stopped.

Yes, I have. The nasty comments were from other women.
MushMonster · 27/10/2021 22:30

DDUW, you were surrounded by the wrong people.
Try again!
Wear things that make you feel well and happy.

Ahhbiscuits · 27/10/2021 22:29

Do you have a link to the other thread OP please? I’ve not seen it but as a person that feels like they wear a cloak of invisibility, I’d be really interested to read others experiences on being attractive and the differences it brings!

DDUW · 27/10/2021 22:27

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

MushMonster · 27/10/2021 22:26

I am not sure I would prefer to be pretty to be honest. Few attentions thrown my way, but almost 100% success! I am on my second marriage, and very happy.
Harrassment, yes, unfortunatelly it happens.
At work, and life in general, I was picked on when I was young, but once I got my confidence and stood my ground, I found that I would get help when needed, and be treated quite the same, at work, queues, venues. I never had a drink bought by an stranger, but I would never ever want that. And I do not like chatting to strangers, though I am getting better at it with age, that used to be the definition of torture for my young self.
In all, being unattractive or plain is not that bad. What you really need is confidence being yourself, and being comfortable in your shoes. That is what does the trick.

Iamnotattractive · 27/10/2021 22:26

And yes, as a couple of PPs I also had people on the street telling me how ugly I am. Mainly groups of young men. I could never understand what they get out of it.

OP posts: