Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask about the life experiences of unattractive women

210 replies

Iamnotattractive · 27/10/2021 22:02

Was impressed by the recent thread about pretty privilege, and stories there. Was so different to my experience, it sounded like a different planet.

So, I am an unattractive woman, and have been all my life. No obvious single disfigurement, I just look weird, overall badly put together.

I've been asked out only twice in my life (once at 17, once at 27) - had children with the second guy, despite having serious misgivings, but he was really the only option (it did not last). Men never notice I even exist - even the ones I work with for a year or so struggle to recall my name (I don't mean the immediate team members, but someone further out). I remember all the compliments I was given in my life, as the total number is under 10 Grin. If a guy offered to buy me a drink or offered to carry something heavy for me, my first thought would be that they have some criminal intentions - hypothetically, of course, it never happened in reality.

On the positive side, I have never experienced any inappropriate sexual attention or harassment. I don't also have to worry about losing my looks as I age - if nothing helped me at 16, nothing will help me at almost 40.

So wanted to ask other unattractive women, how does life look for you? Similar to mine?

OP posts:
justanoldhack · 28/10/2021 11:59

I can relate. I used to resent the fact I was unattractive, but now I believe that it's protected me from a lot of BS and I wouldn't have wanted it any other way. The shallow men never bothered with me, or they actively bullied me. It weeded out those tossers right quick (who presumably went on to have relationships and children with other, prettier women. I wonder how that's going). I couldn't rely on my looks to get me anywhere, I had to develop other skills.

Not denying that sexual harassment is about power, but I haven't experienced it to the same levels as more attractive friends. Makes me feel like we are living on different planets. I don't doubt it happens to them, it just doesn't happen to me. I'm really grateful for it.

I have curly hair and wear it naturally. It's like an Instant Prick Shield. On days when I straighten my hair (very rarely as I can't be bothered) I notice how differently I'm treated by men. And it makes me laugh. The poor lambs.

I always remember what Zadie Smith she said to her daughter. It was something like, you can choose to spend an hour a day in front of the mirror if you want. But your brother was out of the house and hour ago, and so now he's already an hour ahead of you. She imposed a 15 minute mirror rule.

Catra · 28/10/2021 11:53

I've experienced both sides of this. As a teenager, I had terrible acne, awful glasses, and extremely crooked teeth which required a fixed brace. Boys at school used to come up to me and say, "God, you're ugly" and ask me why I bothered doing my hair as it wasn't going to make a difference to how hideous my face was.

Then I had about 15 years where men wouldn't stop pestering me. By this point, I had contact lenses, clear skin, and straight teeth. I also had a great figure and long, straight, glossy hair. Men would randomly ask me out in the street and pass me their phone number on the bus. On my first day in a new job, a male colleague said, "that's a nice dress but it would look better on my bedroom floor" in front in front of the entire office. Workmen would whistle at me, men in bars would offer to buy me drinks. On one occasion I even received a love letter from my boyfriend's housemate. I used to go out clubbing regularly because I loved to dance, but I'd always get men rubbing up against me on the dancefloor. As a musician, practically every single male I worked with tried it on with me. I was even hit on by an on-duty policeman who came to take my statement after I was mugged.

I'm now 43, 6 stone heavier, and utterly invisible. This suits me fine (the invisibility, not the weight gain) because I no longer get unwanted attention yet I'm married to a man who loves me unconditionally and is extremely attracted to me. Strangely enough, I have a lot more female friends now too, whereas I got the impression before that some women felt threatened by me .

Iamnotattractive · 28/10/2021 11:53

Ehhh... I don't think Claudia Winkleman qualifies as unattractive.

OP posts:
Jakarta · 28/10/2021 11:47

I've got to say I think a lot of attractiveness is down to self confidence.

I respectfully disagree, I do have self confidence still but it doesn’t change my appearance. I have managed to secure a job I was unqualified for with the help of confidence.
Funnily enough, I’m more confident than one of my attractive friends - what a coincidence they don’t get insulted on their appearance by strangers.

I have been out with some very unusual looking people that I wasn't remotely attracted to to start with but very often they won me over due to a great sense of humour, lovely personality etc.

You seem like a lovely person, but my very real life experiences tell me that not everyone thinks like this.
Also, it seems women are much more likely to think like this as we see men as well rounded people, and value them for other things than just looks. Whereas, men are less likely to think like this and sadly many still determine a woman’s worth firstly through her looks. Everything else is a nice addition (e.g., there was even an academic study which showed men don’t see more educated woman as more desirable unless they were physically attractive)

Neuropsy112 · 28/10/2021 11:44

I am definitely on the lower than average end of the scale looks wise (slightly weasely face, and once someone said I looked like all my features are scrunched into one small part of my face), but I am vivacious as all heck, punch well above my looks weight dating and spouse wise, and would say I've done well in terms of work progress and close group of lovely friends. I don't mind getting older as I'm not known for my beauty. I also have experienced plenty unwanted attention. Hope this is helpful to you in any way x

Ladyraven0483 · 28/10/2021 11:42

I was always called the ugly child when I was a kid by family members especially my dad, my sister was always the beautiful one, in my teens and early 20s I think I got ugly duckling syndrome because I started getting attention/compliments, early 30s now and I can’t still work out whether or not I’m ugly. I’ve been told I’m pretty, been told a few times very pretty but other times I’ve been called ugly ok looking so I’m baffled

DeJaDont · 28/10/2021 11:40

The content of its a misogyny thing could be right. I'm far from special but what I ABSOLUTELY am is assertive. People (men) treat me with respect as I make it clear I will certainly call out anybody that's treats me or anybody else in a rude or derogatory manner.

Interestingly, a great deal of the men that have been interested in me have wanted me to be incredibly subservient in the bedroom. So it's like the only reason they wanted to get me into bed was for the challenge of being able to dominate the gobby bird that wrong foots them and unbalances their world view of them being king.

number87inthequeue · 28/10/2021 11:39

In my younger days, I often felt that I lived in a different world from that of my more attractive friends. They frequently told me how lovely/friendly/welcoming/open/funny certain individuals or groups were. Yet when I met them invariably I was either ignored or on some occasions mocked/talked down to.

I have found that age has been a great leveller. Partly because the men I meet now are mainly old and married (so less interested in whether I am worth considering as a potential girlfriend) and partly because I've found that most of the other women of my age also look quite plain.

godmum56 · 28/10/2021 11:37

@DeJaDont

I've got to say I think a lot of attractiveness is down to self confidence.

I have been out with some very unusual looking people that I wasn't remotely attracted to to start with but very often they won me over due to a great sense of humour, lovely personality etc.

Myself, I'm not typically beautiful by a country mile. My teeth are incredibly crooked and my mouth is full of fillings due to a terrible child hood diet. I've always been a bit overweight but very firmly obese since mid twenties. I'm ginger with lots of freckles (and not the gentle sprinkle, the extra bold tsunami that l looks like I'm more freckles than pasty white skin).

But I was raised to be fiercely independent, taught electronics and engineering and I rode horses and did gymnastics. My dad pretty much raised me as a typical boy but with access to girls activities as well as well. And whatever I did I did pretty well. My confidence and resilience was through the roof. I was raised talking to adults like equals and asking questions so I can often come across as arrogant. Plus I have a huge bank of trivia stored in my brain. This meant that I would insert myself into situations, correct teachers when they were wrong, talk with people that would never normally have entertained a mere teenage woman who had just started an entry level job etc. some people absolutely hated me and that's fine.... but men? I was never ever short of male attention. I have had dozens of proposals from the laughable to the one I actually accepted.

Im certainly not overly attractive but I DO have presence and that comes from having the self assurance of walking into a room and knowing that even if I'm out of my depth I can take it till you make it. And people either love or loathe me. Not really any in betweens🤷🏼‍♀️.

I am so glad that i am not the only one. I am not for one moment disagreeing with or denigrating anybody's lived experience but i do wonder how much of people's experience is either down to judging themselves and/or accepting the judgement of others?

And yes I am absolutely with Claudia Winkelman. Iris Apfel is also another good example

jobleaver · 28/10/2021 11:37

*genuinely not generally

DeJaDont · 28/10/2021 11:36

@IntermittentParps

I absolutely agree with Claudia Winkleman then!

I know I'm unusual in a sense.... I'm a woman with a man's confidence and I treat absolutely everybody as equals and with the same amount of respect. People in higher up positions of power can often accept me in a conversation as an equal despite my looks/contrary clothing presentation - but then you would be surprised by how they react when they see me treating people lower than them with the same respect. It's a very complex and divisive thing. If I had to define myself I'd say I'm super strong marmite and that's absolutely fine with me.

My old nan used to say that it's absolutely none of your business what other people think of you. The only thing that matters is what YOU think of you. And if you would be embarrassed by your own behaviour being splashed across the tabloids then it's a sign you are doing something wrong and need to reassess. Both of those have certainly shaped my self identity since a small child. Add in my ability to talk about really vast and unusually varied subjects (thanks bipolar special interests in random things like breeding exotics, cultivating orchids, silversmithing, learning python, cake decorating, Saxon history, Vikings, anthropology, linguistics,Green keeping etc etc) and I know absolutely it's my knowledge and approach to talking to people that makes me attractive to other people. I'm an absolute mine of random stuff and can join in most conversations easily. I'm not invited, I see a chance and I take it. I think people that are typically walk flowers take much less risk and so by default get much less in way of rewards?

Plus when I'm hypomanic people are drawn to me like flies, I must give off hormones or something?

jobleaver · 28/10/2021 11:36

Sometimes I feel like when I make an effort I look worse, I look like me but also with an extra layer of looking crap. Make up never seems to look right and neither does my hair.

Same here. I never like to make it obvious that I’ve put lots of effort in my appearance because I still look bad. When you’re generally unattractive, makeup can’t help that much it feels like putting lipstick on a pig.
I still wear makeup because I do look slightly better with concealer and neutral makeup but avoid bright colours and shimmer as don’t want to draw more attention which will invite even more hurtful comments. My ultimate wish is to blend more into the crowd

I also dress very “neutral” (I follow fashion trends etc, dress well but will never wear anything daring because it looks silly on me)

Jakarta · 28/10/2021 11:25

Can relate to a lot of your own experiences, OP. I’m in shape but have a below average face.

I think one slightly frustrating thing is that when attractive women talk about their struggles (which I’m not invalidating, it’s heartbreaking hearing how sexual assault is a regular occurrence - similar to you OP I don’t really experience it) some may presume us ‘invisible’ women have an easier life, but I feel like they’re thinking about plain/average rather than below average/unattractive women (I fit in this category).

When you’re actually unattractive, people do treat you horribly too but in different ways. I can get on fine with most women as I’m never seen as a threat, whereas it is very rare men will like me. I’ve also noticed generally women are less judgemental when befriending unattractive people (men or women).

Now I’m not complaining about men not seeing me as attractive or being uninterested romantically but what many people don’t realise is men (even the politically correct, happily married guys at work) don’t even want to respect or befriend me. Whereas they’ll befriend other attractive women even if they’re loyal to their partner… as pp rightfully said sometimes men, specifically at work treat you differently if they don’t find you attractive? Bare minimum communication, like you aren’t worth speaking to?

The worst is public insults and bullying about my appearance, which has funnily enough nearly always been by men (at school, work, or in public by grown men who were strangers). Now I know some women will read this and say “not all men are like this” but I feel like one benefit of being an unattractive woman I see which men are genuinely nice or which are good at faking it if that makes sense. Some of my more attractive friends will say “Steve is such a funny/lovely guy” whereas the same Steve guy will have mocked my appearance.

NotPersephone · 28/10/2021 11:24

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

NotPersephone · 28/10/2021 11:19

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Tooshytoshine · 28/10/2021 11:11

I think there is a difference between being conventionally good looking and attractive.

I am not the former but have been led to believe I am the latter - but have never tested it out as met my other half two decades ago at 24! Over the years, the (innocent) crushes I have formed have always been on women with asymmetrical faces, idiosyncratic looks and cracking personalities. When people are pretty they can sometimes just look generic to me...

As for the feeling worse when you make an effort, do you think it is because you look less authentically you. When I wear very feminine clothes it feels drag, when I wear clothes that make me feel like the best version of myself then I feel more confident and visible

SeaInelegans · 28/10/2021 11:08

I am an obese woman. I have always struggled with my weight. When I was younger I always assumed this would insulate me somewhat against sexual harassment. Maybe I would experience more if I were conventionally attractive, but experience has taught me I’m not immune and I agree with previous posters who say it is about power.

I also occasionally receive abuse in the street from complete strangers (generally men) because my appearance is so abhorrent to them. I have a theory that these are the same men who harass attractive or normal looking women. They see women as objects and so instead are angry that I don’t fit their ideals of what a woman should look like.

Only last night cycling home from work I had McDonalds rubbish thrown at me from a passenger in an overtaking car. It could have been because I’m a cyclist, or a fat woman, or perhaps a combination of the two but either way it made me feel like shit.

IntermittentParps · 28/10/2021 11:02

@DeJaDont

I've got to say I think a lot of attractiveness is down to self confidence.

I have been out with some very unusual looking people that I wasn't remotely attracted to to start with but very often they won me over due to a great sense of humour, lovely personality etc.

Myself, I'm not typically beautiful by a country mile. My teeth are incredibly crooked and my mouth is full of fillings due to a terrible child hood diet. I've always been a bit overweight but very firmly obese since mid twenties. I'm ginger with lots of freckles (and not the gentle sprinkle, the extra bold tsunami that l looks like I'm more freckles than pasty white skin).

But I was raised to be fiercely independent, taught electronics and engineering and I rode horses and did gymnastics. My dad pretty much raised me as a typical boy but with access to girls activities as well as well. And whatever I did I did pretty well. My confidence and resilience was through the roof. I was raised talking to adults like equals and asking questions so I can often come across as arrogant. Plus I have a huge bank of trivia stored in my brain. This meant that I would insert myself into situations, correct teachers when they were wrong, talk with people that would never normally have entertained a mere teenage woman who had just started an entry level job etc. some people absolutely hated me and that's fine.... but men? I was never ever short of male attention. I have had dozens of proposals from the laughable to the one I actually accepted.

Im certainly not overly attractive but I DO have presence and that comes from having the self assurance of walking into a room and knowing that even if I'm out of my depth I can take it till you make it. And people either love or loathe me. Not really any in betweens🤷🏼‍♀️.

This made me think of a recent interview with Claudia Winkleman where she talks about her upbringing: 'I learned that what you look like is the least interesting thing about you'.
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 28/10/2021 10:59

@NotPersephone

What an awful experience. You may yet find someone mature enough to be worthy of being your partner though.

NotPersephone · 28/10/2021 10:53

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

HyacynthBucket · 28/10/2021 10:52

A lot of these experiences are heartbreaking. Particularly total strangers feeling the need to tell someone they think they are ugly. To act so appallingly is all to do with them and their own insecurities, the same as other bullying. It is an expression of power, used to make themselves feel stronger, in exactly the same way that sexual harassment or assault is about power, not sexual attraction, So unkind, but not about the ones who suffer it. Everyone has something to be glad of/proud of to give self-worth. If we can find those things we will carry ourselves with more confidence, and perhaps be less prone to bullying. Bullies pick on those they sense are vulnerable, but responsibility is always with the bully, never the bullied. Flowers to all who have had to put up with this.

KnobblyWand · 28/10/2021 10:23

I don't like to think of myself as unattractive or ugly, there's nothing repellent about me - or you, I'd wager.

I'm just plain-looking. I have a husband who thinks I'm beautiful and tells me so all the time and that's nice, but once I reached the age where grown men didn't try to groom and abuse me anymore (around 16?), I've been quite left alone, and I much prefer it to the alternative.

Iamnotattractive · 28/10/2021 10:22

I've always considered myself to have a very stereotypical Male life experience in that I just exist in my body and do what I want with very little tedious appearance upkeep admin (although the middle-aged beard is a little upsetting now!), I simply can't imagine giving up hours of my day choosing an outfit or doing makeup.
Yes, same. I started reading some things from the manosphere / red-pill areas of the internet (not the toxic stuff) and was surprised as to how much it had resonated with my life.

OP posts:
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 28/10/2021 10:18

"My face is asymmetrical, and I have had total strangers in the street feel the need to tell me how ugly I am"

That is awful. So sorry you had to experience that abuse.

DeJaDont · 28/10/2021 10:18

@StormTreader

I've never been told by even a boyfriend that I'm pretty - I once flat-out asked my then-boyfriend if he thought I was pretty and his reply was an awkward pause and then a careful "why do you ask?".

It is hard seeing attractive people dance into relationships as soon as they want them, have people rush to do them favours and give them presents etc, but on the flipside I am never harassed in the street or prevented from doing something I want to because its not "feminine".

I've always considered myself to have a very stereotypical Male life experience in that I just exist in my body and do what I want with very little tedious appearance upkeep admin (although the middle-aged beard is a little upsetting now!), I simply can't imagine giving up hours of my day choosing an outfit or doing makeup.

I don't do overly feminine either unless it's a formal event and then I may concede to put on a dress. But I've never struggled for sexual or romantic attention despite looking like a more ginger version of Karen Mathews on a bad day. Unless my hair is going through a short cropped phase then I'm more Ed Sheran without the musical talent 😂