Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate bloody book bags?

105 replies

Rainallnight · 27/10/2021 19:40

Why are book bags a thing? They are annoying, uncomfortable to carry and can’t sensibly hold anything else. Which means I end up carrying them plus whatever other bag is needed for DCs’ bits and pieces.

Why can’t reading books be put in an ordinary backpack? Is there something I’m missing?

OP posts:
Whereismumhiding3 · 28/10/2021 06:07

Ah I see, you're school had COVID rules in about backpacks atm

That doesn't stop you bringing backpacks for DCs. You can get out and they carry if you're walking . Or you shove them all into yours in your back or under the buggie if you have little ones.

Rules will change back in time as DCs need a bag to take other stuff for school 1. Gloves scarves hats raincoats in for gold weather 2. Packed lunch and water bottles 3. It Helps to have separate book bags (to fit in bigger bag) to keep those books etc together

Whereismumhiding3 · 28/10/2021 06:03

Get a rucksack big enough to put your DCs book bag into as well.

It's just a way to keep school library books and reading books parents sign & make notes in (and any spelling cards etc) together so they don't get lost. And they fit into trays at school as these books are read with teacher or TA at school too. It's just a flexible folder really with a handle.

ThirdElephant · 28/10/2021 05:47

@Heyiam

Genuine question.. those that are claiming there’s not enough space for backpacks if yr 4 or younger, surely there is a chair for each child that the backpack could be hung on? Also if a school has the room the host a p.e bag all the time bar half term when they are sent home to be washed it would be a fair presumption going by responses on this thread that parents would rather go in with a rucksack everyday and use the p.e hook than negotiate the school run with book bag lunch bag water bottle plus w.e else separately. For all the teachers / ta’s saying book bags are easier, there’s plenty of things that would make my job easier unfortunately I still have to do it the hard way. Suck it up. Putting 30 books in 30 rucksacks isn’t worth getting worked up about surely?
Space for a backpack on the back of a chair? Madness.

Several reasons:

  1. They'd forever be falling off, causing a trip hazard on the floor.
  2. When kids change seats for different lessons, they'd have to faff around with their bag.
  3. They'd find excuses to faff around with their bag just seated at the table
  4. I've got as many kids as humanly possible crammed into my classroom. If all of them had a bulky backpack on the back of their chairs, there'd be no space to walk between them.
ThirdElephant · 28/10/2021 05:44

There's a couple of solid reasons behind the madness. In my school, if every kid brought a rucksack there'd be no place for them. They have one peg each, in a zigzag orientation, on which to hang their coats and rucksacks could only go there. If there were 30 rucksacks the coats would forever be sliding onto the floor, plus children would then have to rummage around near the pegs and bags to retrieve their book, which takes much longer than simply popping them in their assigned tray for easy access during the day.

CallMeRisley · 28/10/2021 05:44

@Heyiam

Genuine question.. those that are claiming there’s not enough space for backpacks if yr 4 or younger, surely there is a chair for each child that the backpack could be hung on? Also if a school has the room the host a p.e bag all the time bar half term when they are sent home to be washed it would be a fair presumption going by responses on this thread that parents would rather go in with a rucksack everyday and use the p.e hook than negotiate the school run with book bag lunch bag water bottle plus w.e else separately. For all the teachers / ta’s saying book bags are easier, there’s plenty of things that would make my job easier unfortunately I still have to do it the hard way. Suck it up. Putting 30 books in 30 rucksacks isn’t worth getting worked up about surely?
In primary school children often don’t sit in the same seat all day long. They might have one seat for English and a different seat for maths depending on their grouping/ability, then a third seat for mixed ability work or other subjects. Primary aged pupils moving around the classroom are likely to knock rucksacks off the back of chairs. It’s really not practical for young children to keep rucksacks on the back of chairs in the classroom.

Book bags are flat and rectangular so they all stack into one container, for the teacher, TA or other helper to easily go through them all at once, putting in letters or pulling out books to change them.

I appreciate there are things that are difficult about your job. For school staff, a lot is about saving time. It’s not that it’s “difficult” to put letters in 30 rucksacks or change reading books in 30 rucksacks in the cloakroom, it’s that it takes double the time or more, which is time taken away from that adult being with the children. In a primary school classroom there is literally not a minute to spare, not a minute unaccounted for.

Heyiam · 28/10/2021 05:26

Genuine question.. those that are claiming there’s not enough space for backpacks if yr 4 or younger, surely there is a chair for each child that the backpack could be hung on? Also if a school has the room the host a p.e bag all the time bar half term when they are sent home to be washed it would be a fair presumption going by responses on this thread that parents would rather go in with a rucksack everyday and use the p.e hook than negotiate the school run with book bag lunch bag water bottle plus w.e else separately. For all the teachers / ta’s saying book bags are easier, there’s plenty of things that would make my job easier unfortunately I still have to do it the hard way. Suck it up. Putting 30 books in 30 rucksacks isn’t worth getting worked up about surely?

SaveWaterDrinkGin · 28/10/2021 03:37

I agree they’re a ballache, especially if you walk to school. My DD is year one and takes a backpack which she brings home full of shit every day like conkers and wet play colouring pictures

user64323 · 28/10/2021 02:51

I agree. I got one for my son as requested, and then they handed out those big clear plastic book bags for the reading books. So I have to carry the plastic bag, the boom bag, a water bottle separately. Then on forest school days there is another bag with wellies and waterproofs to carry too. We get the bus or walk over a mile so it is a total PITA for me because they are awkward to carry, especially when my 4 year old wants to keep holding my hand, swapping hands, have help balancing on walls etc. I think I might rebel and buy the rucksack meant for year 3's up.

Italiandreams · 28/10/2021 02:38

@Rainallnight because when they are older they are more independent so when you hand them a letter they are more likely to independently put it in their bag and ensure it gets home. Same for reading books, in key stage one we can encourage independently changing books and then putting them away but they often need help. It’s much easier to help if you can just put them in a drawer in a classroom rather than go through bags in the corridor.

rainraim · 28/10/2021 00:43

@Theunamedcat so did ours, they even sent a letter before school started in September saying no book bags or backpacks. So I didn't buy either. Except when school started I saw majority of the children with book bags and back packs and so now my children have been bugging me about a bag. The school annoys me, if you have a rule you bloody need to enforce it.

Mammyloveswine · 28/10/2021 00:30

It's one bag.. per child., fits a4 stuff in.. carries in a hand...

Not really an inconvenience... my two are 3 and 5 and carry their own.. pack their own.. check their own fir letters and homework.,

Igneo · 28/10/2021 00:17

I carry my child’s book bag because they scoot home. I would love a book bag with a cross body / shoulder strap, but until then I’m afraid you’ll have to curse me as Balancing is much easier without a book bag hanging off the handle.

Stevenage689 · 27/10/2021 23:35

I always thought of book bags as just mini briefcases. Which is funny now, as I've not seen a briefcase in years.

But the principal is the same. Protect the books and the paper. Letters in book bags are less likely to end up a soggy mess than those in book bags, both because they are water resistant and because they're too small to shove a big water bottle into.

IdLoveToButCantBeArsed · 27/10/2021 23:28

I really can't stress enough how much faster it is to change 30 children's reading books if I can just go down their book bag trays, pull 10 out at once, easily find the books and put them back as opposed to trying to carry 10 rucksacks, go through various pockets to find the books, try and work out which bag belongs to each child to put it back again. Same goes for putting newsletters etc. to send home. We really do have more important things to be doing, like spending time with the children.

Firesidefox · 27/10/2021 23:25

@Theunamedcat

Our school stopped back packs due to covid

Book bags are supposed to fit in trays

So did ours but reinstated now. At least we've learnt SOME ways you are highly unlikely to catch Covid and sense is beginning to prevail.
IdLoveToButCantBeArsed · 27/10/2021 23:23

@Rainallnight

So if it’s the case that there isn’t enough room at school for backpacks, how come it seems that it’s ok in the older years?
At our school the older years have lockers. Also by that age they are more than capable of taking their own work, books, letters etc. out of their drawers and putting them in their rucksacks. They also normally change their own reading books by that age so a staff member isn't spending hours routing through rucksacks in a cloakroom to find reading books.
WaterBottle123 · 27/10/2021 23:16

@Theunamedcat

Our school stopped back packs due to covid

Book bags are supposed to fit in trays

@Theunamedcat

Are you also at our school? With the mad headmistress that thinks back packs carry Covid but book bags definitely don't?

Rainallnight · 27/10/2021 23:13

So if it’s the case that there isn’t enough room at school for backpacks, how come it seems that it’s ok in the older years?

OP posts:
HelpIcantfindaname · 27/10/2021 23:03

In my school the book bags do fit in the trays. Coat hooks are in the classroom & are far too close together to hang backpacks on. We don't allow backpacks as there just isn't space to store them safely.

StripyHorse · 27/10/2021 22:48

@DeepaBeesKit

My son easily fits a small flat snack pot, reading journal, reading book, library book & jumper in his book bag. All UK infant children are offered school lunch, if parents choose not to take this up and send a lunch bag that's their choice.
Infant school children in Wales don't.

Don't presume that because something is a rule in England it applies to the whole of the UK.

Mummyme87 · 27/10/2021 21:09

Not enough space for 30 odd backpacks in a classroom

ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 27/10/2021 21:09

16 fucking years of that during infants, for about a 3rd of it we had 2 bookbags (y2 + reception).
I despised them.

My youngest is in y3 now and oh what a joy it is that he has a backpack now as well.

3scape · 27/10/2021 21:07

I have a pannier bag for the bike about the size of a messenger bag that everything fits inside of.

Unfortunately a lunch box is completely necessary for my child as there is no way he would eat the food on offer at school.

DeepaBeesKit · 27/10/2021 21:05

My son easily fits a small flat snack pot, reading journal, reading book, library book & jumper in his book bag. All UK infant children are offered school lunch, if parents choose not to take this up and send a lunch bag that's their choice.

Seashor · 27/10/2021 21:00

Rucksacks are bulky. We don’t have room for 30 rucksacks in class. Spare clothes are in draw string bags and books in book bags which are lovely and slim. It’s the only way that it all fits on a peg.
Coats are obviously flung on the floor! Only kidding!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread